4 ms·
> Citing that no one officially lodged a criminal complaint isn't a counterpoint. Most sexual assault isn't pursued. Serial creeps are plying their trade right
by lelanthran 5y ago
> Citing that no one officially lodged a criminal complaint isn't a counterpoint. Most sexual assault isn't pursued. Serial creeps are plying their trade right now.
Actually it is a counterpoint. If someone accuses me of a crime, then refuses to pursue any prosecution of that crime, and then expects me to suffer consequences for that crime, that's a gross injustice.
That's why we have a justice system.
- verifex 5y agoThe problem is that there is no justice system for things that are not illegal, but are ethically or morally bad. Society in the US and in much of the western world has agreed that the only official punishments due for anything are when laws are broken. No law broken, no punishment. This is actually a weakness of our society when the lawmaking bodies choose to sit on the sidelines when the ethical or moral values of the society change, but the laws do not. This is not to say that I endorse lots of new laws to accommodate punishments for people that break moral or ethical values that our society holds, but that without a system that can handle these problems in any capacity, society picks up the slack using whatever tools necessary. As of right now, our society has picked up and run with the idea of ostracism. Trying to guide how our society treats people who break moral or ethical values is a right we have mostly all agreed that lawmaking bodies are in charge of. Unfortunately, most lawmaking bodies in the US, and maybe other parts of the world, are too concerned with outrage-farming for trying to win re-election. I wish I had a good answer here, but honestly, our society has a lot of social problems we are dealing with poorly right now, and this seems like a low-priority one, unfortunately.
- lelanthran 5y ago> The problem is that there is no justice system for things that are not illegal, but are ethically or morally bad. That's not a problem, that's a feature! After all, do you want to be punished for breaking someone else's moral code? Whether you like it or not, the legal system and the sets of laws is the only moral and ethical yardstick we have gotten society to agree on. If you want your particular set of morals to have a punishment then work within the guidelines to get it made into a law. If you can't garner enough support for your moral position to be made into law then maybe it's not as moral as you think.
- avs733 5y agoHow far do you want to take this argument? Warning people about someone's creepy behavior isn't a punishment, it's a warning that they might violate my moral code and I should probably avoid them. Is me avoiding them punishment? Should I then be punished? not punished? Define punishment...
- lelanthran 5y ago> Warning people about someone's creepy behavior isn't a punishment, Until someone goes around warning other people that they think that you act creepy around children? How do you define creepy? It's completely subjective. That's why the courts are objective. Making the argument for mobbing and witch-hunts almost never ends well.
- avs733 5y agoit's telling that you think courts are objective...
- lelanthran 5y ago> it's telling that you think courts are objective... So, if you think that the court system, with it's experts, and centuries of experience, with fallbacks and checks and balances, with emphasis on applying the law with regard to precedent and societal input, with appeals and formal processes that must be followed ... is unable to be objective, what makes you think that random people with an actual specified bias is more objective? I dunno about you, but I'll take my chances in court over someone who literally shouts their bias to the world any day. All the arguments for mob justice that you are attempting to make are the same arguments the KKK made for their justice.
- Jcowell 5y agoThere’s a difference between able to be objective and being objective. Anyone who believe that’s American Courts, or rather, courts are objective is someone I hope has a really good lawyer if they ever go to court.
- tptacek 5y agoIn fact, it is not the purpose of a justice system to ensure that you retain all your clients when you're accused of misconduct. In our justice system, it's rather the opposite: most of the function of the justice system we have is to ensure that people retain the freedom not to associate with people, with only very narrow exceptions. You can lose jobs, friends, and clients simply for being a jerk. There's nothing illegal about being an asshole, but plenty of people refuse to work with assholes.
- lelanthran 5y ago> You can lose jobs, friends, and clients simply for being a jerk. There's nothing illegal about being an asshole, but plenty of people refuse to work with assholes. Sure, but the current cancel culture results in people refusing to associate with the accused out of fear, not because they think he or she is a jerk. I heartily support freedom of association. I don't support a mob of people, completely unrelated to either the victim or the accused, exacting punishments for any third party who exercises their own freedom of association. Made all the more worse when the mob then moves on in a coordinated fashion to the next "accused". I cannot see a future where I ever support mobbing and witch-hunts, even if I happen to believe their accusation.
- tptacek 5y agoI guess I think you can coherently believe that without somehow implicating the justice system. People have different thresholds for this stuff.
- lelanthran 5y ago> I guess I think you can coherently believe that without somehow implicating the justice system. People have different thresholds for this stuff. So why are their thresholds more important than others'? This is literally why we have a justice system - people have different ideas about what is wrong and what is right. The justice system, with its set of laws, is the final arbiter o right and wrong. If you cannot get enough support for adding in your personal moral code to the set of laws, then perhaps it's not as universally moral as you seem to think it is.
- orwin 5y agoOkay, counterpoint. Say you were 50yo a restaurant owner, and launched a party for the arrival of your new cook. At the end of the party, you proposed to the 19yo apprentice to drive her home while she was waiting at the bus stop. As she live outside town and don't really want to wait an hour for the night bus, she accept. In the car, you managed to rape her, then throw her out. Devastated, she go home to her then boyfriend, who drunk, said something like "with how you dress, i wouldn't be surprised". Oh, also, this "boyfriend" work in your friend's restaurant. She managed to get herself up three day later (two and a half), but it is too late to take a sample, and since you threathened her, no bruising was found. Even if a sample was recolted right after the act btw, it would not have been a clear evidence of a rape, as she could have given her consentment (after all, she was in your car). So you can sleep easily, nothing to fear. Well, until somehow, people keep shouting "rapist" when then pass in front of your restaurant, and tell your client to call the cooking institute and ask them about which restaurant in town their female apprentice to avoid. Oh, and the girl you raped shared her story on facebook with your 18 yo daughter, who is not estranged to you. All that, that's gross injustice, too?
- lelanthran 5y ago> All that, that's gross injustice, too? Hold on, in your little narrative, how are the accusers sure that there was a rape? No, seriously, that's the point of the justice system - determine if the crime happened. So, if anyone ever calls you a rapist, then you are one? Or are you arguing that these rules are only for other people, not for you?
- tptacek 5y agoI someone calls you an asshole, and people listen, you have no recourse to the justice system to recover your reputation and retain your professional connections.