8 ms·
When I worked at Google I had the chance to interact with many of the leadership including the founders and CEOs, as well as many SVPs. I have to say, both Larr
by dekhn 5y ago
When I worked at Google I had the chance to interact with many of the leadership including the founders and CEOs, as well as many SVPs. I have to say, both Larry and Sundar have the personality and motivational skills of limp noodles. When I met Eric Schmidt, he immediately quizzed me about every detail about my product and product plans and further goals and was encouraging, like an actual leader. It was a wonderful discussion and I left the room feeling like I had actually been listened to by a leader who wanted the company to grow in new directions (like cloud and machine learning for health research).
I also got to meet people like Urs Hoezle and Luiz Barroso who are responsible for Google's technical position in computing today; they were both also great leaders who really deserve to have their own sub-company to run (TI and Core).
I was truly lucky to be able to have coffee with Jeff Dean and Sanjay Ghemawat almost every morning for a year, which led to some great research collaborations. I was extremely disappointed to see Jeff defend Megan Kacholia's firing of Timnit (yes, I read the paper) and call it a resignation. That pretty much killed the reputation of Google Research's leader.
- rejectedandsad 5y ago….how did you manage to get into this position? Were you a senior principal engineer?
- dekhn 5y agoI have a long history. I started out as a Biophysics PhD doing MD simulations and applying machine learning to biology (search for 'David Konerding' in Google Scholar). Since Google is very much like academia, my research training prepared me to be successful inside. Getting inside was the hardest part! When I joined google, the only way I could get hired was as a test engineer on an SRE team, which I then converted into an SRE via mission control and wrote docs and shared them internally with folks until the principal engineers read them, and then they gave me infinite resources (Google Exacycle) to do everything I described above. I used that to get promoted to Staff SWE, and used that to launch a product (Google Cloud Genomics) and do some interesting machine learning for drug discovery (BTW, at this point mny career was effectively complete- I had set out to do everything I wanted, and was interested in what to do next). The above happened because (beyond a wide range of boosts provided by parents and country) I have an intense drive, wanted to work at Google more than anything, and exploited the internal structure of the company to maximize my power. I kept networking to meet more and more people, and by meeting those people I got more access and support. I helped build up a team- Google Accelerated Sciences- which does basically what I thought Google should be doing all along. unfortunately, at that point Google politics and personalities intervened and I was kicked out of the cool kid's club.
- Aperocky 5y ago> I have an intense drive, wanted to work at Google more than anything, and exploited the internal structure of the company to maximize my power > at that point Google politics and personalities intervened and I was kicked out of the cool kid's club. It sounds like a power struggle gone the other way from reading this. And it certainly doesn't seem like either of the sides are more noble than the other. But props for you for doing what you loved best, if only one day any of these can be decoupled from politics.
- alisonkisk 5y agoThere's a difference from politicking into a club and politicking others out of a club.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rejectedandsad 5y agoWow, very impressive! Turns out I've followed your work for a while and never knew your HN username. Makes me wish I had the innate ability to be able to achieve even a fraction of this or have a scrap of the prestige - instead, I'm stuck on a lower rung for good (I blame heritability of intelligence via my parents).
- dekhn 5y agoHuh, OK, I didn't know anybody followed my work! Note that I am not particularly intelligent- I always struggled in school, and had a ton of imposter syndrome. I tried and failed to become a successful scientist and instead pivoted to what I'm actually good at (scientific computing). Most of my drive came from fear of not being able to make enough money to live in the bay area, or from being thought unintelligent. Never underestimate the power of imposter syndrome!
- selimthegrim 5y agoWhere would you go now if you wanted to do such things? I have people in UW CS tell me a physics PhD in CMT is no proof I can learn how to analyze RNASeq data quickly enough for them and they want a postdoc with the experience already to teach DL to (I would have thought the other way around would be easier)
- codingwageslave 5y agoClassic name dropping from a Google employee. This is why the companies products are mediocre, the employees care more about the fact that they work at Google. No mention of product possibilities, innovation, or anything. Just prestige.
- QuercusMax 5y agoBased on what I read of dekhn's internal Google+ posts when he was at Google, that couldn't be further from the truth. This is someone who cares greatly about both good engineering and making a positive impact on the world.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoStrangely enough it feels like you’re proving OPs point here?
- QuercusMax 5y agoI'd love for you to explain how. I've never met him personally. Reading internal blogposts is a very common thing that people do.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoIt feels like a second order name drop (perhaps a prestige drop?) by immediately indicating your access to internal posts and identification of him by his username. I've been aware of him before but not enough to know his HN or common username!
- QuercusMax 5y agoMust be exhausting to be that cynical.
- rejectedandsad 5y ago
- choppaface 5y agoDo you think Jeff Dean defended the firing because he really understood the circumstances and the consequences of taking the position, or do you think he was naive? Was Jeff involved in the firing of people like Michael Church?
- spoonjim 5y agoUnderstanding the circumstances and consequences of taking a position, and not being naive, is almost definitionally the job of a leader. Technical wizards who are clueless n00bs should be individual contributors, not the head of Google Brain.
- choppaface 5y agoAnd I actually mean the question seriously and thoughtfully, although the downvote barrage wants to take it as flame bait. Jeff’s calibration towards firings is unquestionably different than the rest of industry, but how different? And how much training / preparation did he really have? Important questions for any org head. The thing here is a lot of current and past Googlers seem to agree Jeff messed up. I’d like to understand why through the lens of evaluating what bar we set for the people-managing skills for engineering leaders industry-wide.
- spoonjim 5y agoIn 2020 if you can't figure out that a white man firing a black woman for something related to race and AI is going to be a big problem for you as the head of AI for perhaps the world's most potent AI juggernaut facing increasing calls for regulatory scrutiny you really have no fucking clue what you are doing. Overall the entire situation needed to be handled far more carefully even if the outcomes were the same. He thought that because he was the boss he could do whatever the hell he wanted to, and the fact of the matter is that there are forces more powerful than him.
- nostromo 5y ago> Larry and Sundar have the personality and motivational skills of limp noodles And yet they were still more motivating than Sundar, who is so flat he sounds like he's bored to death, even when he's talking about super cool tech like AI and quantum computing. Page wasn't polished, but he could energize teams about building the future in a way Sundar hasn't been able to.
- dekhn 5y agoI think you misread- Sergey has lots of personality and motivational skill (he's a brilliant natural leader with an amazing sense of humor). The main problem with Sergey (told to me by several SVPs) is that he's so smart (but not wise) , 10 minutes into your well-prepared presentation he'll ask "well, why didn't you do it this other way? It's faster and simpler?". This will cause your presentation to halt, you have to waste a bunch of time epxlaning why that is a cool academic idea that won't actually work in the real world, and then everybody on the team is amotivated.
- actuator 5y ago> Jeff defend Megan Kacholia's firing of Timnit (yes, I read the paper) and call it a resignation. From what has been put outside, don't you think Timnit's mail to employees as a manager was out of line for someone in her role. Even to me who doesn't have intimate knowledge of the whole thing, that didn't look appropriate.
- GVIrish 5y agoI think the email can be inappropriate and Dean's response can be problematic at the same time.
- dekhn 5y agoYes, Timnit definitely pushed the boundaries of what is considered acceptable discourse at work. But, speaking both as an ex-manager, and an engineer who worked there (and resigned twice), it definitely wasn't a resignation. To resign at Google you tell your manager you're resigning and then fill out a form (that's the process that makes it an official resignation). What Megan did to Timnit was immediate termination, combined with an advanced exit date, which only happens if you're truly and deeply violating Google rules or your country's laws. When I brought up the Timnit firing situation my VP literally said: "It takes me a year and a half to fire a bad employee, I don't know how Megan did it so fast".
- Judgmentality 5y ago> It takes me a year and a half to fire a bad employee What? I could understand 6 months, but how the hell do you add a year to that?
- neaanopri 5y ago"Performance Improvement Plan"
- Judgmentality 5y agoI've seen lots of those before, but never anything that could remotely approach 18 months (I typically see them last only 1 month). I cannot imagine the frustrating bureaucracy that is Google.
- andyxor 5y agoTimnit was a bully, the definition of 'toxic employee', so glad Google had the balls to let her go, PR hit be damned, it means they still have true leaders
- dekhn 5y agomy complaint is merely that they continue to insist she resigned. She didn't- she was terminated without cause. I personally think Timnit shouldn't have been hired in the first place, but if they were going to fire her, they needed to follow the path, which takes about 1-2 years, of establishing that she was not a good employee for Google.
- mchusma 5y agoThank you for following up with some nuance. I did read her email, and do disagree with your stance that she did not quit, and presumably Googles legal team did as well. But I appreciate your thoughts.
- ksd482 5y agoWhy shouldn't Timnit have been hired according to you?
- dekhn 5y agoAccording to her, she was recruited by Jeff at a conference specifically to work on improving Google's machine learning equity. As part of hiring somebody, I don't just meet them at a conference and read their papers. I interact with their prior employment network and read their social media. I think if Jeff had paid any attention to her tweets before she was hired, he would have thought twice about bringing her on.
- Apocryphon 5y agoI wonder if anyone's compared Timnit's firing to Apple's firing of Antonio García Martínez. It sounds like both are politically opposite versions of the same mishire situation.
- 1024core 5y ago> I was extremely disappointed to see Jeff defend Megan Kacholia's firing of Timnit Jeff had 2 options: pick a safe leader, or a corrosive person. Timnit has shown incredible tone-deafness and arrogance; just view her Twitter exchange with Yann LeCun. She was clearly out of her league, and doubling down every day with newer and newer antics. She needed to go.
- dekhn 5y agoI didn't say that Timnit shouldn't be fired.
- thu2111 5y agoAre you objecting to Google's refusal to let her "unresign" then? Btw plenty of us ex Googlers think Jeff Dean's reputation was enhanced still further by that move. Gebru was acting in crazy ways, she really should have been fired much earlier, but taking the opportunity when she so helpfully presented it seems like a no brainer. Sad that the rest of Google lacks that approach.
- dekhn 5y agoI don't think Google should unresign her. I think it should admit it fired her (technically speaking), and pay her a bunch of money (to make up for the bad handling of the firing). I agree, she should have been fired earlier. However, she was just promoted, which meant she must have had several quarters of excellent perf. I think one thing that would be truly excellent, but won't happen, would be to have Megan Kacholia defend herself by explaining her actions to the wider Google community. In particular: Why was Megan, a person with effectively no research experience, a VP in Google Research and making decisions about research papers being withdrawn? Her lack of experience in the area seems to have led to an exacerbation of tensions. Why did Megan convert an offer to have a discussion about a resignation into an interpretation that Timnit resigned voluntarily, coupled with an accelerated departure (immediate, with termination of all Google services)? Why was Megan pushing so hard to have the paper withdrawn, given that the paper wouldn't be that impactful on Google's reputation, made some useful (if obvious and a bit overstated) points, and wasn't being published in a prominent venue? To Jeff and Megan: to what extent did Jeff support Megan's decision to fire Timnit over a refusal to withdraw a paper, or did his support come after learning Megan had fired Timnit? To what extent did Timnit's previous tweets calling out her employees and mentioning confidential Google Research activities play a role in her firing? Was her discouraging email really a reasonable justification for accelerating her termination? My guess about all of this is that Megan and Jeff decided to fire timnit when timnit posted several negative tweets attacking Jeff and google Research, and used the paper and the email (and vague offer to resign) to justify the firing and they didn't think through the implications of firing a twitterati like Timnit in a roughshod manner. This seems most consistent with all the evidence I've seen.