9 ms·
You are going to have a very hard time to re-conciliate eating food without causing pain (and yes, trees/plants probably also feel some kind of pain, while not
by ekianjo 5y ago
You are going to have a very hard time to re-conciliate eating food without causing pain (and yes, trees/plants probably also feel some kind of pain, while not the same as in the animal realm).
Animals in the wild don't give a s** about the pain they cause to other species when they eat themselves alive, and eating a prey alive is the normal standard in nature.
This being said, I'm all for minimizing suffering of anything involved in the food chain as much as possible. I consider that avoiding wasting food is just as important as reducing the pain we cause to animals.
- syops 5y agoThe person you responded to didn’t say anything about eating food without causing pain. Your first two paragraphs aren’t an appropriate response.
- justinclift 5y ago> Your first two paragraphs aren’t an appropriate response. Er... why not? They seem fairly reasonable to me.
- syops 5y agoIt would have been a reasonable response had OP mentioned anything about eating food without causing pain. As it is the response makes no sense because it addresses a point not raised by OP.
- justinclift 5y agoIsn't this bit about causing pain in food? > ... boil them alive is one of the cruelest forms of torture I've seen.
- syops 5y agoYou've changed things a bit now. The phrase in question is: eating food without causing pain The OP doesn't say this is what should be done. OP says that we should respect our food and talks about the living conditions of animals we eat and how they are killed. OP doesn't say or imply that we should eat food without causing pain.
- bjornjajayaja 5y agoThere’s a huge difference: in the animal kingdom all species play their part and live freely—yes there is predators and prey, and the wilderness can be a violent place. But humans breed animals in cesspools, and humans rip mother cows from its children to mass produce milk and beef—much of which is tossed in the dump in the name of “food safety.” Animals will catch what they eat, and catch no more than necessary. Humans will over-fish and dump shit all over the place killing marine life and filling oceans with oil. I could go on and on. But you know, we’re all fucked from this behavior. In the name of money we will all perish at the hands of our fellow cheek-turners.
- tux1968 5y ago> Animals will catch what they eat, and catch no more than necessary. I don't think that's true. Have seen many a cat catch mice to "play" with until they're dead and not eat even a nibble.
- kalium-xyz 5y agoWolves are known to just kill a dozen sheep, either to train the young or because they can. Most predators are known to have behavior which involves killIng and/or maiming inefficiently and for reasons other than food. Even worse is that you have plenty of prey animals that will also go ahead and kill or maim each-other for social reason (elk, zebras).
- nsonha 5y agoSo there are evolutionary reasons baked in such behaviors? Regardless, it's not quite the same as building factory for the sole purpose or killing, and esentially kill for pleasure. The equivalence would be an ongoing massacre which is not seen in nature to my knowledge.
- liaukovv 5y agoNature is ongoing massacre.
- cranekam 5y agoJust because other animals don’t consider the suffering of their prey isn’t an excuse for humans to do the same. Animals do what is instinctive. Humans (should) have empathy for others, including animals, and are able to make choices about their behaviour. Just because “in nature” animals are eaten alive doesn’t mean we shouldn’t strive to do better.
- kalium-xyz 5y agoWhat about animals that are known to have emphatic behavior and are fully capable of making non instinctual choices yet will gladly be very cruel (e.g. wolves, dolphins)?
- uh_uh 5y agoNo contradictions here. You don't even have to go to the animal realm. There are some humans who are capable of empathy towards some people but happily inflict pain on other people. This however should not be an argument for the rest of us to behave in a cruel manner towards anybody.
- hdnkdksms 5y ago-Some- humans? Have some humility. Everyone shows empathy towards some and aggression towards others. Not everyone deserves empathy, either.
- amanaplanacanal 5y ago> Not everyone deserves empathy, either. Could you expand on that? I’m always curious to understand how other people think about these issues. If I see people that are with causing folks around them pain, of whatever type, my usual suspicion is that they suffered some sort of massive pain or trauma themselves that they never found a healthy way to deal with.
- Dracophoenix 5y ago
- moeris 5y ago> yes, trees/plants probably also feel some kind of pain Are you kidding? How do you suppose one can feel pain without a nervous system? Magic?
- kalium-xyz 5y agoIts purely chemical and much slower than a nervous system. Really just signaling and arguably we dont even know if animals feel/expirience pain like we do either. Kinda begs the question what is actually capable of suffering
- f6v 5y agoA worm or a fruit fly has a nervous system. Does it feel pain? How do you quantify it?
- toshk 5y agoIt’s not unreasonable to assume that if a nervous system is present and similar pain signals are send, similar suffering is experienced by animals as humans. Simply because suffering is a motivation to take action. There might be a difference in that most animals, like baby’s, wont be able to seperate themselves from their suffering/pain. I am suffering vs suffering is all there is. If thats the case, pain for animals might even be worse then humans. That might be backed up by the fact that most animals are very pain avoidant (makes them really scared), where some humans seek it out, and most of us are able to accept a bit of pain to get something better. (There seems to be some indication that other animals have a sense of self, like dolphins, certain birds, elephants etc) (Also seems that pain for animals, same as with humans, is not felt when they are filled with adrenaline and in fight mode)
- saiojd 5y agoHow can you be so convinced that plants feel nothing given that we have absolutely 0 understanding of what consciousness is?
- ekianjo 5y agoYou'd be surprised how much we thought the world was magic just a few hundred years ago. In 100 years from now people will look down at us like complete ignorants just like we look down at our ancestors.
- dalbasal 5y agoNote that OP did not say "without causing pain." He/She said "respect" which is descriptive of both of your positions. There is a tendency, in animal welfare discussions, to ratchet. As the conversation tips forward and back, meanings are interpreted a little more strictly each time. Backyard chickens is a respectful way to have eggs and meat. Battery raising is disrespectful. Wasting meat is also disrespectful.
- f6v 5y ago> Battery raising is disrespectful. Towards chicken? Maybe. But chicken isn't the only variable in the equation. I agree it'd be much less wasteful to grow meat in bioreactor without even wasting energy on growing feathers, organs and whatnot. But we're not there yet, and we might have a hard time feeding people without chicken factories.
- dnautics 5y agoSo while I agree with what you're saying, you'd better be able to come up with a legal standard of "respectful". I don't know what that is. If you don't you'll wind up with something like "killing a chicken by slitting its throat" [and facing mecca] is disrespectful.
- cheese_goddess 5y agoYou can kill a chicken by thrusting a knife into its open beak to pierce its brain (chickens actually have brains). You hold the bird by the feet, upside down and thrust. The bird will squawk once and go limp. Then you can cut its throat and let the blood out. The problem is that people don't know this and (even professional poultry growers) think that the only sensible way to kill a bird is to cut its throat. Same for crabs. So far in the last two years I've seen crabs cooked alive twice right before my eyes, once roasted and the other boiled. I tried to intervene but was laughed away or told there was no time. In the second case, the lady who boiled the crabs alive didn't want to hear about their agony while eating them later (of course I had to twist the knife in). I thought all this is just stupidity and ignorance. All it takes is five minutes to think, five minutes to go online and ask a question of a dumb search engine, and another five seconds for the chicken and a bit longer for the crabs. How hard is it? I mean, come on. Btw, I eat meat and I'll be vegetarian when hell freezes over but you kill an animal to eat it, at least don't torture the poor beast. Just get it over with quickly.
- goodoldneon 5y agoMonkeys throw their feces. Should humans do the same because, you know, wild animals do it?