10 ms·
Seeing live lobsters semi-frozen on ice so they can stay alive until you can take them home and then boil them alive is one of the cruelest forms of torture I'v
by stavros 5y ago
Seeing live lobsters semi-frozen on ice so they can stay alive until you can take them home and then boil them alive is one of the cruelest forms of torture I've seen. Same with keeping chickens and pigs in cages the size of their bodies.
This is all disgraceful, and if we can't at least respect the animals we eat, we probably don't deserve to eat them.
- extropy 5y agoHow about lettuce, carrots, eggs, etc? Just because their reaction times are slower does not mean they are not suffering? The truth is humans are wired to gauge the level of environmental danger by looking for personably relatable aggression events. And there is a practical limit how low we should go. Also with living more dense, humans are gotten way better at handling various aggressive stimuli, like noise, air pollution, constant close interaction. We have stopped treating them as aggression, but it still is for the rest of life on this rock.
- mdiesel 5y agoThe difference in intelligence between an egg and a chicken aren't just reaction times. Basic cellular life might respond to stimuli in a way we can call "pain", but they'll never understand it the same way. The difference is like us touching a hot stove and pulling away as an automatic response, versus the various forms of torture we've invented. That doesn't mean it's right, just that there is a difference and we'll all draw a line somewhere. A bit like how people see eating cats and dogs as somehow different from chickens and cows.
- ekianjo 5y agoYou are going to have a very hard time to re-conciliate eating food without causing pain (and yes, trees/plants probably also feel some kind of pain, while not the same as in the animal realm). Animals in the wild don't give a s** about the pain they cause to other species when they eat themselves alive, and eating a prey alive is the normal standard in nature. This being said, I'm all for minimizing suffering of anything involved in the food chain as much as possible. I consider that avoiding wasting food is just as important as reducing the pain we cause to animals.
- syops 5y agoThe person you responded to didn’t say anything about eating food without causing pain. Your first two paragraphs aren’t an appropriate response.
- justinclift 5y ago> Your first two paragraphs aren’t an appropriate response. Er... why not? They seem fairly reasonable to me.
- syops 5y agoIt would have been a reasonable response had OP mentioned anything about eating food without causing pain. As it is the response makes no sense because it addresses a point not raised by OP.
- justinclift 5y agoIsn't this bit about causing pain in food? > ... boil them alive is one of the cruelest forms of torture I've seen.
- syops 5y agoYou've changed things a bit now. The phrase in question is: eating food without causing pain The OP doesn't say this is what should be done. OP says that we should respect our food and talks about the living conditions of animals we eat and how they are killed. OP doesn't say or imply that we should eat food without causing pain.
- bjornjajayaja 5y agoThere’s a huge difference: in the animal kingdom all species play their part and live freely—yes there is predators and prey, and the wilderness can be a violent place. But humans breed animals in cesspools, and humans rip mother cows from its children to mass produce milk and beef—much of which is tossed in the dump in the name of “food safety.” Animals will catch what they eat, and catch no more than necessary. Humans will over-fish and dump shit all over the place killing marine life and filling oceans with oil. I could go on and on. But you know, we’re all fucked from this behavior. In the name of money we will all perish at the hands of our fellow cheek-turners.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xwolfi 5y agoThis is a feeling you have in time of fat cows, where food is everywhere and you probably should eat a bit less even. In times or places where this abundance is not as shockingly unnatural, the feeling of the food we consume takes less importance. And, as others said, it's not just animal. Killing a plant, often in way more atrocious manners, is just as bad. We'll probably have to murder and massacre our food for a bit longer. Live with it and work on synthetic food, this will resolve the problem you have with life-sourced food. Well except we'll probably still have to kill millions of animal and plants for population control. Heh. You know we also kill, without asking their opinion or respecting them much, other more exotic life-forms, like virii or bacterias, that are as innocent as the rabbit you had in your last civet. All they did was follow their instincts, and they didn't have a choice contaminating you; but you had a choice killing them.
- sinsterizme 5y agoI find it a bit strange that you seem to be assigning moral equivalence to animals, plants, viruses and bacteria. Animals should be of top priority because they are the most likely to feel the highest amount of pain by our actions, and we can feasibly take measures to prevent it
- justinclift 5y ago> they are the most likely to feel the highest amount of pain Is that just guesswork?
- sinsterizme 5y agoThere’s plenty of empirical studies done on animals where we observe they respond to painful stimuli similarly to humans and avoid similar situations thereafter. We can’t ask them so this is the best we have.
- justinclift 5y agoYes... and what about the others?
- helloplanets 5y agoThis reminds me that everyone should read Consider The Lobster by DFW. [1] It's such a straightforward, yet well written think piece about this exact subject. [1]: http://www.columbia.edu/~col8/lobsterarticle.pdf http://www.columbia.edu/~col8/lobsterarticle.pdf
- wastholm 5y agoI got a 404 at that address but this seems to be the same article (I had to override a TLS certificate warning to get it): https://www.theessayexperiencefall2013.qwriting.qc.cuny.edu/files/2013/11/Consider-the-Lobster_david-foster-wallace.pdf https://www.theessayexperiencefall2013.qwriting.qc.cuny.edu/...
- sharkweek 5y agoAlso available here as an audio recording, read by Wallace himself - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fZOl7C_vDI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fZOl7C_vDI
- f6v 5y agoOut of interest, how do we decide if something is a torture? Imagine a machine that’s broken, does it feel pain? Say, you drop your iPhone with Siri on the floor. Is it cruel? Isn’t a lobster the same kind of machine, just a biological one?
- StavrosK 5y agoIndeed, how do we decide anything that's on a gradient?
- f6v 5y agoEthics aren’t universal.
- StavrosK 5y agoAre you arguing against deciding?
- f6v 5y agoI'm arguing that the decision might not be the same for everyone. > This is all disgraceful, and if we can't at least respect the animals we eat, we probably don't deserve to eat them. This will sound completely bananas to someone who doesn't live by the same principles as you do.
- StavrosK 5y agoI agree.
- uh_uh 5y agoWe can't decide because we don't have a machine that objectively measures consciousness. But it's safer to err on the side of mercy than to accidentally create hell on Earth.
- 5y ago
- pfortuny 5y agoDo you honestly think lions “respect” their food, and fungi, and viruses, and mantises?
- stavros 5y agoDo you honestly hold yourself to the same ethical standards as lions?
- recov 5y agoI think humans are a bit more civilized than lions, and can comprehend what we're doing.
- uh_uh 5y agoWhy do people think that the cruel behaviour of other creatures should give humans any pass in their own cruel behaviour? People don't seem to apply this logic when it comes to rape and murder (both very common in the animal kingdom) but when it comes to torturing other animals, suddenly it's all good for some reason.
- EvilEy3 5y agoBecause food doesn't fit in the same good/bad area. You can live without tape and murder, you can't live without food. And no, I don't want to eat fake plant based surrogate.
- 5y ago
- darkerside 5y agoFreezing then boiling live lobsters seems much less inhumane than factory farming mammals.
- AlexandrB 5y agoI agree. Even assuming that lobster suffer when they are boiled - that's an event that lasts but a minute or two. Many factory farmed animals spend their entire lives in various states of stress and suffering.
- AlexandrB 5y agoI think it's important to approach this topic with some nuance. There is a wide variety of intelligence in the animal kingdom - ranging from primates down to bivalves, which lack a distinct "brain" at all. In terms of intelligence, a lobster is closer to some insects, which we seem to have no problem killing en-masse with chemical agents if they enter our home or threaten our crops. I'm not sure it's totally knowable whether lobsters have the capacity to suffer, but moral consistency on this issue would require sacrifices far above just "not eating meat".
- causality0 5y agoBeing semi-frozen isn't torture. From reports of human beings who nearly died by it, freezing to death is a very pleasant, dreamy sensation.
- willhamina 5y agoMmmmm! Sounds tasty! Think I'll order fresh fried lobster at my favorite Chinese restaurant for lunch today!