4 ms·
Bitcoin Beach: What Happened When an El Salvador Surf Town Went Full Crypto
- imtringued 5y agoI actually doubt that it's going to work out the way they hoped. My prediction: People send $1000 worth of Bitcoin (0.028 BTC) as remittance to El Salvador. The people in El Salvador spend half of if (0.014 BTC left) Bitcoin goes up 2x or whatever and they have $1000 again. As they keep accumulating Bitcoin they will simply earn money from doing nothing. Building an entire economy around this is troublesome. I'm assuming all businesses and individuals use Bitcoin. People come up with the idea that unemployment stimulus competes with private employment [0]. Guess what. Holding Bitcoin competes with private businesses. Running a business is an inherently risky endeavor. If you predict that your future income is going down because of demographic factors (old people just don't spend as much nor do they take on loans) then the inherently risky act of running a business is not viable anymore. When there is mild deflation or extremely low inflation then holding onto USD is far less risky. With Bitcoin the problem gets even worse. As the price of Bitcoin goes up, the risk of running a business no longer makes any sense whatsoever. You still have volatility risk but those only matter within the first 5 years. When you buy in at $35k and the price goes up to $70k you don't care about 50% crashes anymore. What people get wrong about the USD is not that it is losing it's value very quickly. It's the exact opposite. It's way too stable to the point that it drowns out productive work forcing the central bank to engage in constant interventions to keep the ship from sinking. That stability is just an illusion. If people stop working and businesses stop investing your paper bills (any fiat currency) or Bitcoin become worthless. The inflation induced by the pandemic is shattering that illusion and that is a good thing. [0] Gaining $x amount of dollars from welfare eliminates earning $x from a job, if you spend the $x you shifted the burden of working onto the working part of the population. What happens is that at some point there is so much work the working population cannot fulfill all of it. Workers get to choose which jobs they want to work at. The increased bargaining power lets them work jobs that pay higher wages. It becomes easier to find a job for those who are still unemployed and the attractiveness of unemployment benefits goes down as jobs pay more than unemployment benefits. This only works if unemployment benefits aren't adjusted with inflation though. Considering that the $300/week bonus is temporary it is hard to argue that benefits are rising with inflation.
- jl2718 5y agoYou’re stuck in a dollar mindset. Bitcoin doesn’t deflate against Bitcoin. Nobody’s making any more land, and yet there are farmers and developers, not just hodlers. The alternative is an inflationary economy where these people get driven out by leveraged real estate investment projects that don’t actually make any money. Static supply enforces cash flow reality.
- errantmind 5y agoBased on this article it seems the BTC experiment mostly worked. Many unbanked El Salvadorans were able to save and send BTC. Some were payed in BTC. The main downside is exchange rate volatility, which is to be expected. I see this issue tapering off over time. As BTC matures its volatility should decrease while maintaining a deflationary appreciation in value, encouraging saving. Yes, deflation as a feature goes against some economic theories but I unironically see it as environmentally friendly. Reducing consumerism and frivolous spending, in the end, may be exactly what we need.
- FabHK 5y agoM-Pesa has delivered digital currency on the mobile phone to the unbanked (and banked) in Kenya since 2007, successfully, without exchange rate volatility, and without burning 15 GW as BTC (for comparison, each of the 4 Chernobyl reactors produced just 1GW).
- mgh2 5y agoI have read a lot of crypto articles recently, and yet the community cannot answer this: How do you account for the global population growth (and consequently GDP growth) that is constantly in need for a relatively stable exchange medium for value of goods produced? Cycle: More people > more production > more money Money is a tool to fuel production. Controlled inflation/devaluation fuels growth, as long as it is backed by actual production (tied to economic output). Counter this with popular examples given: Germany (WWI), Venezuela, Greece, Argentina, Lebanon, etc. dramatically devalued their currency without an increase in production. The problem with any limited supply is that it benefits and incentivizes hoarders and non-producers, having nonbeneficial effects for society as a whole. Beware: The poor & needy are always the most vulnerable victims for manipulation by the rich. For all we know, the "crypto helping the unbanked poor" narrative might just be another marketing stunt by speculators. Please provide a nonpaywall version (I bypass w/ Pocket app) and more information to answer this question. I am still researching, trying to approach this without bias Note: I have inquired about this before (with more context) without answers https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27498190 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27498190
- jl2718 5y agoSo glad you asked... > Controlled inflation/devaluation fuels growth Sure - if you measure 'growth' in terms of the inflated asset. However, well, just look at this chart: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=ERzc https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=ERzc Take a good look. That's what total failure of an economic theory looks like. Edit: I do think you are way off on your points, but I am actually a believer in 'controlled inflation' for totally different reasons. But how to distribute new money creation? Here's a terrible idea: let the most powerful decide (fed/govt). Better idea: allow anybody to work for it (Bitcoin).
- mgh2 5y agoSince one of the article's protagonists leveraged the Evangelical church's influence: "...people are left with little choice but to flee their homeland, resorting to crime and violence". I wonder if it is not the other way around. That the lack of specific religious foundational values causes crime. Take the simple example of the rule: "do not lie or steal"...from the average joe all the to the president. Printing money to fake (vs. fuel) production and steal from people’s labor: a simple but devastating lie if scaled nationwide. https://m-g-h.medium.com/in-data-we-trust-2978dacc8c22 https://m-g-h.medium.com/in-data-we-trust-2978dacc8c22