6 ms·
This is good for USDC right? Because it's $262 million that they don't have to pay back? >EDIT: I’ve since learned that the developer(s?) behind this are alrea
by gruez 5y ago
This is good for USDC right? Because it's $262 million that they don't have to pay back?
>EDIT: I’ve since learned that the developer(s?) behind this are already the laughing stock of the DeFi community, having wrecked each of their 3 previous projects (now 4) — though this might be their biggest hit yet
And people poured $262 million into this?
- onepointsixC 5y agoThey poured 1.33 X $262M at the very least as the stuck USDC was 75% of the collateral that still remains. But apparently a lot more than that even was poured in, in the first place.
- neither_color 5y agoWait so USDC is linked to existing USD in a bank somewhere, so what's stopping coinbase from just nulling the locked usdc and minting 262MM new ones? Sorry if it's a dumb question Im not sure how stablecoins work.
- rawtxapp 5y agoBecause those tokens are fungible, they can "blacklist" certain addresses and refuse deposits from them coming to their exchange, but they can't "null" some random addresses holdings.
- gruez 5y agoThe smart contract itself has a "blacklist" function[1], which presumably can be used to prevent those tokens from being moved. [1] https://etherscan.io/token/0xa0b86991c6218b36c1d19d4a2e9eb0ce3606eb48#writeProxyContract https://etherscan.io/token/0xa0b86991c6218b36c1d19d4a2e9eb0c...
- gruez 5y ago>Wait so USDC is linked to existing USD in a bank somewhere Yep, short of the fed issuing USD tokens directly that's always going to be how USD stablecoins work. >so what's stopping coinbase from just nulling the locked usdc and minting 262MM new ones Nothing, other than that they have zero incentive to do it. I doubt whatever goodwill they get will come close to the $262 million that they don't have to pay back.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Yep, short of the fed issuing USD tokens directly that's always going to be how USD stablecoins work. Or... you could just lie about the USD and issue a stablecoin anyway.
- runbathtime 5y agoUSDC represents a claim on USD, but why would Circle want to help out this contract and lose 262 million? If a stablecoin issuer like USDC can make arbitrary decisions to null any USDC token and they use that power, that is a good argument for the point that they are not following aml/kyc on every hop or transaction of USDC, even though they are allowing the transfer of dollars behind it. USDC can be charged with violating money transmission / bsa / aml/ kyc requirements.
- ganzuul 5y ago> but why would Circle want to help out this contract and lose 262 million? Probably a rhetorical question, but they might decide that it's a price they can pay for trust in their system. Not sure if I understood where the real value currently is though.
- runbathtime 5y agoUSDC's system didn't fail. The money transmitter (smart contract- IRON/TRON) failed, if the USDC is indeed 'locked' or not able to be transmitted. USDC can't be compelled by anyone to 'fix' this. If USDC can revoke any p2p transaction of USDC, that means that they can revoke the transmission of movement of dollars/reserves that USDC token represents. Implicit in that, means they have ultimate control or authority of all p2p transactions or transmissions, and they are not doing kyc/aml on all p2p transactions, thus in violation of money transmitter laws.
- easrng 5y agoI don't remember if there's a way to lock a specific token but I've read the contract and 1. It's behind an UpgradabilityProxy so it can be changed and 2. It includes functions to blacklist addresses and even temporarily pause all transactions.
- tornato7 5y agoCircle can in fact ban addresses from transacting USDC and has done so working with law enforcement: https://www.coindesk.com/circle-confirms-freezing-100k-in-usdc-at-law-enforcements-request https://www.coindesk.com/circle-confirms-freezing-100k-in-us...
- marton78 5y agoWhy should they? Suddenly they're over-collateralized by 262 millions, they might just as well spend that money.
- tluyben2 5y agoAs I get older, I do not understand how known scammers, especially the ones that raise millions over and over, get support time and time again. If not in jail, why do they still get jobs. I know some who just told me in my face that they were scammers of millions (or simply were happy screwing people even with viable ways out) and they raise money again, screw people again etc. People do use Google right? Due diligence?
- Semaphor 5y agoI can recommend checking out Reddit’s /r/cryptocurrency and branching out to smaller altcoint subreddits. Read the comments. There are thousands of people just looking for that one weird trick to get rich. As a sidenote, I almost always got out just before a crash by when I was playing with altcoins by waiting for people to get over the top enthusiastic in their subreddit and then selling everything. Might as well have been luck though, so don’t try it ;)
- ramesh31 5y ago>There are thousands of people just looking for that one weird trick to get rich. Increasingly I think they're the smart ones. I'm sitting here working my butt off for a few thousand dollars a month, while these guys raised hundreds of millions of dollars without even being able to grammar check a sentence. Who's the real sucker?
- Semaphor 5y agoI was talking about the users giving them money, not the scammers/con artists.
- tluyben2 5y agoWell, most these talks are marketcap for their coin or token. That is not actual value. Some of the biggest ICOs got only a fraction out of them or nothing at all. They still get a lot for free scamming others. Just do not think that a 100m$ ICO means they raised that. They cannot get anything close to that out.
- perl4ever 5y agoI can't say I would've done my research and learned things like this, if I had heard of them before the blow-up. But now that I've looked at their website, I think I can say that the writing just has a low budget BS-y tone to it. I'm not claiming to have an infallible BS detector. But this thing in particular gives me an overwhelming sense of they're trying to sound intelligent to people like me who don't understand a word. They sound very like the writers of spammy financial news that clogs Google search results for public companies these days. The ones that aren't actually bots, I mean. "Market shocks provide the best stress tests for stablecoin pegs, and IRON’s strong peg retention should go a long way to grow trust in our community. IRON has shown itself to be a shock-proof stablecoin, and the stabilizing protocol is now battle-hardened."