3 ms·
This is what I don't understand about the cryptocurrency security model. How I it possible to keep a private key private, if you have to use 3rd party hardware
by lupire 5y ago
This is what I don't understand about the cryptocurrency security model.
How I it possible to keep a private key private, if you have to use 3rd party hardware and software (no one builds their own computer components), to use the key?
- nickik 5y agoAre you equating, your money is at a bank and controlled by the government with 'somebody might make a supply chain attack against my hardware'. That seems silly.
- FlacoJones 5y agoThe Ledger Co-Founder talked about their security model here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ledgerwallet/comments/4xgi2t/does_ledger_know_your_private_keys/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ledgerwallet/comments/4xgi2t/does_l...
- FlacoJones 5y ago"We don't upload a private key in the device , we ask the device to generate a key pair - the private key stays onboard. Then we sign the associated public key during the manufacturing process to prove that we issued that device. This protects against attackers that would produce a clone looking like the real device but not behaving like it." - Ledger Co-Founder
- ramesh31 5y ago>How is it possible to keep a private key private, if you have to use 3rd party hardware and software (no one builds their own computer components), to use the key? It isn't. And this is the fundamental problem with using crypto for its' (professed, intended) use of a trustless currency. In order to actually do that, you need to run a full node on your own hardware. However no one wants to do that, so we've literally just reinvented the existing trust based banking system on top of it all, with the added benefit of zero transparency or regulation.
- superkuh 5y agoNo finance or speculator people want to. Plenty of tech people that actually use the blockchains instead of just using off-chain financial markets do. But people that actually use cryptocurrency instead of just trade it off-chain are in a minority now.
- runeks 5y agoAre you suggesting that it's necessary to write your own software and build your own hardware in order for it to securely store a private key?
- thebean11 5y agoNot even big tech companies build their own server hardware, that doesn't make them incapable of storing secrets.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bondarchuk 5y ago"cryptocurrency security model" -> "hardware wallet security model". Hardware wallets make no sense, they are about as secure as just using a third party custodian.
- zikduruqe 5y agoIt is just simple math. You can hand build your own keys. https://estudiobitcoin.com/do-you-trust-your-seed-dont-generate-it-yourself/ https://estudiobitcoin.com/do-you-trust-your-seed-dont-gener...
- Scoundreller 5y agoDo hardware wallets support that? Seems like they create a single key and then derive a key for each coin from that (hopefully well!). In effect, there are two keys that control each coin: the one for the coin and the device one that derives it and others.