9 ms·
Thailand bans meme coin and NFT: “no clear objective or substance or underlying”
- haskellandchill 5y agoWay to go Thai SEC.
- nkellenicki 5y agoI find this funny - Dogecoin has as much value as Bitcoin. It still takes energy (and therefore money) to mine, and the resulting "coin" has value - that being how much someone is willing to sell it for, and how much someone is willing to buy for it, driven by factors such as mining cost as well as speculation. The only real difference being the name of the coin. If they're worried about price influence by social media influencers, this is also a problem for other coins. Elon tweets, and the price of BTC varies. It's not just "meme coins" that's susceptible to this. The logic that's been applied here is highly suspect to me.
- haskellandchill 5y ago> Dogecoin has as much value as Bitcoin Correct, and that is zero (or really negative) value. I see crypto as a plague on productive society. People think they can just get rich by investing in currency. It's insane. Value is being destroyed with all the attention wasted in the space. Governments need to step in and protect their citizens from this nonsense.
- marsrover 5y ago> Governments need to step in and protect their citizens from this nonsense. Because citizens are being forced against their will to participate right? I don't know about the rest of you but I know I've held a gun to people's heads before and made them buy Bitcoin. Edit: love the downvotes, fuck this place. Go ahead and hell ban me or something.
- mehlmao 5y agoWhat about encrypting their files, threatening to leak documents with PII, and making them buy Bitcoin?
- marsrover 5y agoAnother good tactic.
- dogecoinbase 5y agoObviously not, rather because of the significant negative externalities that remain unaddressed after over a decade.
- marsrover 5y agoIf we want to address significant negative externalities that have remain unaddressed for over a decade maybe we should look into how many people we bomb on a frequent basis. Or healthcare. Or corruption in politics. Or our crumbling society.
- zenron 5y agoSpeaking as an US Citizen: Why is it you think the government should be involved in this when they are demonstrably incompetents in keeping our basic Credit Cards and Checking Accounts safe from scammers and fraudulent attacks? Especially not keeping our elderly population safe. They can't even keep public emails safe from a certain Secretary of State. They can't keep a single man in a Prison safe from 'suiciding' while waiting for the court case of the century. They can't even keep the phone companies accountable to the Do Not Call list for spam calls. They cannot keep telco and cable companies from price gauging consumers for internet while at the same time enforcing lock downs that keep people at home- with children- that require internet access and lots of bandwidth. Many states holding the state residents hostage from any sort of options of providers. If the crypto rush is the new gold rush and it is a burgeoning market, why should - or how could, the government save people from their personal decisions. Crypto itself is not fraud. We have laws against fraud if one specific instance is found to be fraudulent. Why should we make new laws to save people from their bad decisions? Honestly, those bad decisions started with the elected officials that aren't held accountable to the public as it is. So we're going to let incompetents govern incompetently for what exists and ask them to govern competently for NEW things? How peculiar.
- nitrogen 5y agoSo we're going to let incompetents govern incompetently for what exists and ask them to govern competently for NEW things? How peculiar. Believing the government to be incompetent is a self-fulfilling prophecy: - Only the incompetent or apathetic will choose to work for government and take the hit to their personal reputation. - Underfunding leads to underperformance which leads to perceptions of incompetence which leads to underfunding. - True incompetence, corruption, etc. start getting ignored as just "that's how the government is," so nobody tries to fix anything. - Those who have a financial interest in reducing the capabilities of government will "starve the beast" and make it progressively more incompetent. There are many functions of government that, though they could always do better, make the world better than it would be in their absence: fire departments, paramedics, infrastructure management (in areas where this is actually done reasonably well), utilities, financial crimes enforcement, agricultural and pharmaceutical quality enforcement, etc. We're already pretty far down this road of destruction of competence, so I'm not sure how to turn things around, but that doesn't mean we have to keep driving forward into the land of feudalistic anarchocapitalism.
- mdorazio 5y ago> People think they can just get rich by investing in currency. It's insane. Here's the problem - replace [currency] with any of many other things and the statement is still valid. You need to explain why crypto specifically deserves more hate than, say, Forex or options trading.
- spicybright 5y agoI'm guessing you as an individual would have no problem trading coins though, right? Even if they firewall the country, all you need is any vpn to make transactions.
- haskellandchill 5y agoIt's a false equivalency. Crypto is different than the other things, which are regulated. Crypto exchanges need regulation. That is all.
- tmn 5y agoExplain how it's a plague please
- haskellandchill 5y agoI could write an essay and it would not change a soul. Figure it out, or don't. Enjoy your life either way.
- tmn 5y agoI mean this is a uncommon opinion. I'd appreciate a few sentences because I was curious. But whatever, I won't lose sleep. I don't know if you think it's because of the energy waste, or invoking speculative rampage, or something else.. It's the something else I'm more curious about.
- haskellandchill 5y agoI see smart people watching charts like pornography addicts instead of engaging in productive business activities, that is all. I see money that could be invested in the community going into scams like Chainlink.
- tmn 5y agoFair point. I was addicted the chart watching for a few months the 2017 run. I would put this under the speculative rampage.
- cwkoss 5y agoA quick check of the price charts demonstrates that millions of people disagree that the value is zero. If you feel strongly about it, you should short Bitcoin. I wouldn't recommend doing so, but if that is your conviction you have the option to put your money where your mouth is.
- mym1990 5y agoBased on my light understanding of crypto related things, I think Bitcoin very obviously has a purpose and a mission while Dogecoin was literally created as a joke and happened to take off...that would be understanding of their “objectives” as referenced in the article.
- kube-system 5y agoI personally think dogecoin is dumb, but I also don't think originalism is very useful to judge most creations. Plenty of creations take on a life that is nothing like the originator intended.
- mym1990 5y agoMaybe, but it’s not like Bitcoin had a mission and it’s now completely different, it still pursues a more decentralized world view. In similar light, it’s not like Dogecoin is now any less of a joke than it was when it was created, it’s just speculated upon more.
- lvs 5y agoThe developers who made the joke are no longer associated with any ongoing development. And just because something is unserious does not mean it lacks value or objectives.
- lawn 5y agoA thing doesn't derive it's value or purpose from the intent of their creator, but how it's used going forward. Bitcoin for example was created to be electronic cash, but today most people treat is as a "digital gold" and a store of value, but not as something to be used in regular day-to-day transactions. And Dogecoin was indeed created as a joke, but it doesn't stop it from being used to buy things (3% of all BitPay purchases[1]), and in contrast to Bitcoin the community wants to keep it affordable. So in a way, you can argue that Dogecoin follows Satoshi's vision more than even Bitcoin does. [1]: https://bitpay.com/stats/ https://bitpay.com/stats/
- 5y ago
- wyager 5y agoCost is not driven by mining cost. Labor theory of value is tempting but wrong here and anywhere else. You have your causality backwards. Mining cost is driven by value.
- imNotTheProb 5y agoDogecoin has no cap. It's like Fiat currency. Bitcoin is more similar to Gold in scarcity.
- ziml77 5y agoDoes it have as much value? It is designed to constantly inflate while bitcoin is designed to have a hard limit on the number of coins mined.
- randomopining 5y agoHow exactly can you ban it without shutting down the interwebz?
- marsrover 5y agoIf I had to guess: leftist death squads.
- Afforess 5y agoPreventing legitimate institutions from allowing transactions involved with the purchase of the coin effectively bans it. It doesn't matter if consumers can still use it, if businesses can not.
- beiller 5y agoHow will they prevent transmitting it to brother Pichai in another country who can convert it to cash and send it back? Or how will they prevent exchanging it for goods, or even exchanging it directly for cash? They will have to ban cash.
- lumost 5y agoThis moves it into a niche for criminal activity, rampant speculators, and gamblers. The purpose of banning a type of financial transaction is to avoid stories where a retiree, or other vulnerable person loses their life savings because they got hooked into a get rich quick scheme. These bans only make sense when it's deemed utterly irrational to participate in the transaction for either all buyers or all sellers. It's pretty easy to understand why someone who has a modest nest egg/retirement portfolio could be pushed into a bet the house situation if they don't understand what they are buying and aren't particularly financially literate.
- beiller 5y agoYeah I totally understand where you are coming from. But to be fair, there is a little uncertainty everywhere today wouldn't you say? Who is to say that the stock market / housing / bond market is the only "allowed investments"? The government of Thailand I guess! But isn't there a bit of a conflicted interest? If you ban everything except for stocks, guess what happens to stocks? They go up cause a bunch of people are now forced to switch over. I am actually all for what they have done, but it still looks a bit like kicking it while its down. DOGE ain't so hot today and this isn't the reason.
- ffggvv 5y agokinda sad that the US has a useless SEC while china and thailand actually protect their citizens.
- marsrover 5y agoEven more sad that we have so many boot licking bitches in the US.
- impostervt 5y agoThis is one of those ideas that may sound good in theory, but will be impossible to apply fairly. There are many "meme" coins that are now dedicating a portion of each transaction towards charity - saving apes, funding animal shelters, etc. Is that enough utility? And there are plenty of ERC20 tokens that are not meme coins that, debatable, serve no real purpose except to enrich their creators and early investors. And while I'm no fan of NFTs, they seem as to have as much inherit value as any piece of art (whatever someone is willing to pay).
- munk-a 5y agoIn the US it's illegal to print your own currency and use it for commercial purposes. This doesn't preclude the ability to legally exchange goods in a foreign currency because, while there may be a whole lot of potential currencies, it's not that difficult to create an allowlist of approved currencies. I personally think this is a pretty stupid decision, but iit should be pretty easy to fairly apply so long as the Thai SEC lays out clear guidelines on which currencies are approved. And, I am avoiding making any sort of comment on whether currencies are worthy of being on that approved list. It's Thailand and the sovereign government has the right to make currency regulation decisions as arbitrarily as it wants.
- kahirsch 5y ago> In the US it's illegal to print your own currency and use it for commercial purposes. You can't make people accept your own currency, but you can print it and use it for commercial purposes if people want to accept it.
- cdumler 5y agoThere are plenty of private currencies in the U.S [1]. Printing them and using them are just fine as along as A) you do not attempt to pass it off as Federal currency and B) you do not refused to accept renumeration in Federal currency (the "for all debts, public and private" part) without pre-stated agreement. We agree you will mow my lawn and I will pay you 50 Disney Dollars, that is fair and legal. That said, the person doing the mowing the law owes income tax on the fair market value of the Disney Dollars. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_community_currencies_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_community_currencies_i...
- young_unixer 5y agoBy that logic, they should also shut down Tik Tok and most social media.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoPeople won't deposit their life savings in Tik Tok.
- HugoDaniel 5y agoJust their life
- NicoJuicy 5y agoAnd before internet, you wrote letters to your parents to let them know how "camp" was. Or to your friends when you moved away or vacation letters when you're travelling or send a postcard to wish happy birthday. It just got easier and quicker. But in general, people won't put their private life on display, just what they want to share and "impress" with or nag about. If you want to see damage to lives where things get shared in public, it's something like revenge p** where the government will protect the victim through the legal system and their actual private life was shared by harmful actors.
- heckerhut 5y agoHave an upvote
- jobigoud 5y agoNFT are conflated with their dubious use in art but they can be used for other stuff. In particular membership proof between unrelated entities.
- cwkoss 5y agoWhoever makes the first 'secure enough' (for IP industry lobby) DRM solution that uses NFTs for access management of digital content is going to make a ton of money. The hard part isn't the tech (DRM can't be perfect, but it doesn't stop other solutions from being sold), its getting buy-in from the IP industry lobby. They probably cringe at the idea of digital access rights being resold or traded as it erodes their monopoly pricing power. Being able to trade movies and songs at release sounds fun, and I'm sure wallstreetbets style traders would pile in if the ecosystem develops enough confidence. Would also allow content creators to recoup investment much faster at the expense of long tail royalty type earnings - which some may find very attractive.
- kderbyma 5y agoNFTs by definition shouldn't be banned....I get the bullshit being peddled is little more than garbage, but obviously the underlying purpose is better akin to things like deeds and ownership of physical properties via certificate.
- ToFab123 5y agoThe only Thai crypto exchange was closed about 2 years ago so it puzzle me how they will enforce this ban. https://www.livebitcoinnews.com/crypto-exchange-in-thailand-to-close-its-doors/ https://www.livebitcoinnews.com/crypto-exchange-in-thailand-...