7 ms·
The fact that offering an idea that's better than what's already being done is seen as rebellious at all, as opposed to being the entire job of an engineer, or
by whatshisface 5y ago
The fact that offering an idea that's better than what's already being done is seen as rebellious at all, as opposed to being the entire job of an engineer, or the definition of what engineers do, is not a good sign for any organization.
Next they'll be talking about rebellious accountants who have recorded more numbers by the end of the day than were in the spreadsheet at the beginning, or subversive lawyers who review contracts that had not already been reviewed. Before long it will take a fifth-column delivery driver to move a pizza to a location it's never been before.
- shoto_io 5y agoI absolutely agree, and at the same time it’s how large and (!) mid-sized companies often work. And it’s not only management that behaves like that but many employees as well. When I was a manager in a mid-sized companies I was a strong proponent of what I called “The dictatorship of ideas”. Let’s not care where the idea is coming from but try to create better and better ideas all the time. Not everyone liked it.
- lifeisstillgood 5y ago>>> Let’s not care where the idea is coming from but try to create better and better ideas all the time. Not everyone liked it. Not everyone liked it because it was improving the company without changing the political status quo. It's a bit like Washington and Franklin saying 'Hey we want Representation and Taxation" and King George saying "Ok, but you stay as subjects" Lots of small ideas can improve an organisation, but sometime big ideas imply 'regime change'
- shoto_io 5y agoYeah, thanks for the reminder. I realized that a bit too late. But: In a company it's also way more difficult to identify who is American and who is British ;)
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoIts easy: We Brits swear waaay more!
- rantwasp 5y agoit’s one thing to offer an idea or point out something could be done in a different, better way. completely different when you’re told it’s not gonna be done that way but you go ahead and do it anyway. the “rebellious” attitude also comes with you sinking in more time (you need to do your “dayjob” on top of this, right?) and with the real consequences if what you’re doing rubs people the wrong way/is seen as wasting time.
- gopalv 5y ago> The fact that offering an idea that's better than what's already being done is seen as rebellious at all, as opposed to being the entire job of an engineer, or the definition of what engineers do, is not a good sign for any organization. That is exactly what happens, but not because your management isn't listening. The sacrifice of good ideas is done in the name of predictability or viability. I've been witness to and driven a few of these sorts of moves and what has struck me is that successful "by-pass of management" rebellion costs time, effort and most importantly is a test of active leadership skills. There was a system which I was working on which absolutely sucked (for me personally, because I worked on performance and it couldn't be improved without changing the architecture). There was a way to rewrite about 25% of the system under different assumptions which would fix the performance issues, but the system that was in production already had several other issues which needed to be prioritized over performance. For a manager in front of a customer, of course, we're absolutely committed to fixing whatever is broken. That goes back into engineering, where the rewrite wouldn't have half the bugs we have, but it looks like Dunkirk when it fails. The manager has no way to actually approve the rewrite, when they're trying to hire immediately to just do the work that's already on the plan. Anyway, long story short, there was an intern for the summer who did the rewrite and get it working to the point where the next generation system was almost entirely built out by a single uninterrupted intern over two months (& his code is still in prod today). The methods needed to break rules and succeed are often just the same qualities needed to "just succeed", except the breaking of rules is necessary to prevent the regression to mean. And if you don't succeed, being disavowed like this means worse results than following orders. There's something to be said about the motivation of a team after burning their boats. I'm gearing up to do one of those off-the-books project right now. And the tolerance for risk is clearly something I'm having less of each year. That said, surviving failure does more for your confidence than clutch, but definitely would like less red in the ledger.
- endymi0n 5y agoPretty much spot on. The very best engineers often have a mix of technical excellence, courage / nonconformism and loyalty / optimism. Take out any of those and you get either nothing or a disaster. But if all come together, you will have someone on your team who doesn't just recognize that missed opportunity the other excellent other engineers already realized, but actively go against the plans of at least one level of management in order to do what's right for the company. They tend to create a lot of friction, but can often save a project. I personally love working with these kinds of people as I was formerly one of them — and they can and often do make the best managers later on (funnily enough, I've heard similar stories in the bio of almost any technology leader I respect). Having made the mistake more than one time of accidentally enabling people who didn't have the loyalty / optimism or technical excellence parts though, I get why these kinds of people are usually held in place in large organizations. The resulting friction, bickering and havoc can as well break teams and companies.
- wisty 5y agoI think this part of the answer to the Theory of the firm (this weird thing where companies seem to do better than work from home gig economies). On the one hands, if people just do what they want, it's total chaos. Everyone thinks they know best. Everyone wants to be a creative genius (ok, maybe not everybody, but a lot of people). Management needs to make things actually productive (exploit rather than explore). On the other hand, sometimes someone really is onto a good thing. Ideally, they'd instantly be recognised for this, and given a team and support staff, but managers aren't gods, they're just human beings. Here's an adaptive solution internal "risk taking" innovation is discouraged, but not usually a firing offense (depending on the time / resources spent, and whether you're keeping up with the rest of your work), because occasionally there is a big win that comes out of this.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoRisk taking is only a problem if it demands resources that would starve other known-good projects. Sometimes even that doesn't make it a problem, because the company may decided top-to-bottom that New Project X is a good idea, even when it's extremely risky. This can create spectacular success when it works and catastrophic failure when it doesn't. Either way, this kind of strategic risk should go through the C-suite. Smaller tactical projects are what Fridays are for. Throw some nominal resources at engineers, give them some free time, and see what happens. If they can produce a working proof of concept - not just a cloud of PowerPoint and meetings - you may have something to run with.
- rukuu001 5y agoThe status-quo is 'the work'. It's what's measured to determine how effective employees are. New ideas are a threat to that.
- 4gotunameagain 5y agoWe are also talking about space, a notoriously risk averse sector, where innovation is allowed to exist only where absolutely necessary, or in technology demonstration missions. Unfortunately when failure is not an option, taking risks is even more risky..
- Fordec 5y agoInteresting fact, 80% of satellites are now built outside the US. A surprising number of cubesats are built in the UK for example. The US regulatory framework, which has decades of legacy and history working with the likes of Lockheed has frozen the industry in the risk aversion. Only in the last five years have satellites been removed from the munitions list. Have fun with all the legal paperwork to hire an immigrant to work on a space project. Most of the work is now done elsewhere in places that don't have a space legacy, because of this exact risk aversion.
- ramraj07 5y agoThere are two types of ideas, one is the practical improvement that can and should be heard and considered seriously, and then there are the “great ideas” which a lot of engineers are happy to spew out, but are often unable to follow through because they think more highly of themselves than they ought to. The reality is that software fields are brimming with people who’ve been paid exorbitant sums for mediocre work from people who wouldn’t otherwise even qualify as above average in general intelligence. If the teams don’t listen to engineers often it’s at least partly because of such past experiences. A good company will be a place where the engineers who are capable of following through with great ideas are being listened to while the remainder are kept at their place so to speak.
- afarrell 5y agoOr they are unable to follow through because engineering is a team activity and so they cannot follow through if people don’t listen enough to consider the idea.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _0ffh 5y agoOne of the drawbacks of managers who are not good engineers themselves is that they lack the ability and knowledge to distinguish between truly excellent talent and pretenders. That's an organisational deficiency.
- alex-mohr 5y agoFor a decent take on that organizational deficiency, Rickover wrote a 1.5 page memo in 1953 addressing similar issues for the nuclear US Navy. At some point, it's a failing of process and structure rather than people. [1] 1: http://ecolo.org/documents/documents_in_english/Rickover.pdf http://ecolo.org/documents/documents_in_english/Rickover.pdf
- 5y ago
- peterkelly 5y agoMy thoughts exactly. This sentence really struck me as a strange thing to write: > Often these ‘rebels with a cause’ – also known as positive or constructive “deviants” – may be motivated because they care for the organisation and its mission, and feel psychological discomfort when they see that important capabilities clearly need improvement. If you don't feel that way about your work, then what the hell are you even doing there?
- throwaway87163 5y agoNot every job can be a passion. Sometimes people just need the money and are only there because of it.
- Dudeman112 5y agoWorking in a pleasant job for enough money to live comfortably, of course. Drink the Silicon Valley kool aid with moderation.
- mtberatwork 5y agoI can guarantee you the company does not feel the same way about the `rebel with a cause` as the rebel feels about the company, especially when times get critical. Unless you are the founder, it's best not to get too caught up in mission statements.
- DocTomoe 5y agoAnd even founders are not completely immune. See Steve Jobs, ca 1985
- Aeolun 5y ago> If you don't feel that way about your work, then what the hell are you even doing there? I think it’s possible to care about doing a good job without caring about the company.
- astura 5y agoUm... Working? Presumably.
- xwolfi 5y agoDepends what you call a better idea. You know surely as much as me that we engineer will propose maybe better concept but would lack possibly in sales acument, value production vs cost, market timing, optimal quality (sometimes a client really doesnt care about a quality increment at all, while you could have spent your time on something else more rewarding), etc. It's fine, company work as symbiotic systems, we create a certain tension, others focused on other dimensions will counter balance, and a good company will find ways to reach optimums rather than maximums.
- jakupovic 5y ago>Depends what you call a better idea. Proven idea is a better idea. That's what the article touches on but doesn't explore as their examples are all proven ideas. We don't hear much about non-proven or bad ideas by their own circumstances.
- goto11 5y agoIdeas are cheap. Investing in following a particular idea is costly and risky, especially since this also have to opportunity cost of not following a range of other ideas, given any business have limited resources. Such stories of course have a selection bias since everyone like a rebel pirate hero story but businesses and organization don't brag about failed projects. After all, the space shuttle blew up due to high risk engineering. In those case we blame the management. “we are always chasing after things other companies won’t touch”. - sounds great, unless you realize this also what CueCat did.
- jonplackett 5y agoThe other inertia is that companies are usually already doing something that is quite profitable. And all the people they’ve hired are good at doing the things that make the company profitable. It takes long-term thinking to see that it won’t last forever.
- coldtea 5y ago>is not a good sign for any organization On the other hand reality doesn't operate optimally.
- NoOneNew 5y agoThis isnt about proper management methodology. This is about better ways at redirecting blame away from leadership. "No, the project didnt fail because I micromanage, overwork my crew, create artificial roadblocks, drown in arbitrary meetings and in general am a cunt. No, no, no, my team just wasn't properly in the rebellion spectrum to accomplish the task. I need a pay raise and a bigger budget." Seriously, 80% of good leadership is someone doing honest self reflection after a decision, "if I was them, would I think I was a piece of shit?" Yes, in that language, because being crass is being honest. If so, alter the decision. If not, its probably an acceptable decision by the crew. A one page primer in terms of how not be an asshole as a leader is far more honest and effective than all these over intellectualize mental masturbation studies combined. Mutual respect and trust between leadership and the crew is what makes effective teams. But hey, that takes work, knowledge, compassion and fraternization. You know what doesn't take work and all that other hard stuff? Bullshit checklists. Then you can show how it's the plebs' fault, not yours.
- heywherelogingo 5y agoThis just sounds like the UK to me - anal retentive and compliant, so no surprise coming from the BBC. Short back and sides, suit, pointy shoes, don't stick your neck out.
- samjewell 5y agoI’ve worked my whole career in the UK (7 years software eng, plus a bit in other jobs). Sounds from your comment like you’ve had better experiences in other countries. Is that right? Which ones, and how?
- loudtieblahblah 5y agoit's this very fact, that bucking the normative or bucking the convention within an organization is why I've always argued for "assholes" or disruptive types who can back up their attitude with what they can bring to the office. People value cohesiveness, those who play ball. People will talk about the "constructive ways" to contribute but the reality is there becomes a lot of social and professional peer pressure to stay in line and often doing things hte "nice way" but continues the status quo and gets you ignored, overlooked, or worse - walked all over and ostracized. It takes someone not giving two shits, to change paradigms within a corporate culture. That means people hard to get a long with. It means someone who more rigid and conservative management types don't want to tolerate. It means the "everyone holds hands and get along" leftist hipsters don't want to tolerate them. Corporate culture enforces extreme compliancy to the group, in almost evey company. People who play nice and are competent are necessary for smooth operations, but disruptive types who may even be accused of being "toxic" (as long as they have skillsets, judgement and insight) are also necessary. A company can't be filled wikth these types. But filled with the polite hivemind? They're prone to stagnation.
- usgroup 5y agoWell, I like the extremity of your point, its instructive. However, I think challenging the majority usually comes with more baggage than just volunteering better ideas. I think being the my-ideas-are-better-than-yours guy, is having a better perspective that leads to conceptualising the whole problem differently. It can make everyone else feel inferior in a deep way. Being that guy is also hella frustrating, because doing things worse than they need to be done is frustrating. So you end up pissed at your colleagues or just thinking less of them. They pick up on it. Distance starts to grow. You end up in some little cliche in the office. Distance grows more. You end up being even more challenging. Distance grows more. And so on. It just has a whole human process around it. Its rarely about a trick or two here or there.
- xf1cf 5y agoYou have a very gracious view of engineers. At least by C-Suite standards. To the C-suite engineers are a cost center to be minimized. You are a robot, or better yet, a "resource" (to use the industry term) that consumes money and does some set of tasks. These tasks are tracked in JIRA. The KPI dashboard for the C-suite is like SCADA control but instead of big machines its a bunch of cogs. Like all good, functioning, and regimented engines wobbly cogs (the creative kind!) are removed expeditiously and replaced with more compliant and in-spec cogs. To everyone BUT engineers, engineers are just the minions that glue existing frameworks together. To challenge this idea is tantamount to heresy. Deviating from the norm costs even more money and considering they still have to figure out how to pay the CTO (most likely a "thought leader" and not an engineer) their extensive benefits this creative detour just ate into that budget. This is not some sign of a "bad org". It's every org of any significant size. Once you start having actual management creative freedom is just a fever dream. Creative freedom is reserved for an even more exclusive cost center called "Research and Development" which is often cut just before the rest of herd is culled to keep bonuses. Don't worry, none of us will ever see this. It's exclusive to engineers pulled from Top-5 FAANG-likes and the CEOs kids. The best strategy you can have as a engineer in all but the prime cut positions is to keep your head down, do your 8 hours, and leave. When you get tired of doing that at one place, go to another. Repeat this for 30 years. No MBA-style management strategy will ever optimize for your happiness, or your desire to actually make an impact. Why would you want to make waves anyway? When they hand you your termination papers all of that effort is wasted. There are better uses of your time, outside work, where you have actual control.
- Andy_G11 5y agoWhat is the point of articles like this? They are so disingenuous, pretending a faux-surprise that innovation has to work against immense resistance in the workplace (and life in general). You have to be hopelessly naive and indoctrinated by ivory tower institutionalism to be surprised at the way real life works. The next time you are on a management course which asks 'How do you foster innovation in the workplace?' or 'Do you see yourself as a rebel?' just write the obligatory guff and think of how you, the boss and your mates can have a few beers and work out how to shut down Bob, Sue or Jo because 'He / she's bright, sure, but his / her people skills could use a bit of work.'