11 ms·
Solana has an interesting technology. It's sort of a modernized Ethereum. High transaction rate, low transaction cost, more scalable, and proof of stake. Featur
by Animats 5y ago
Solana has an interesting technology. It's sort of a modernized Ethereum. High transaction rate, low transaction cost, more scalable, and proof of stake. Features Ethereum was supposed to have by now, but still doesn't.
Programs can be stored on the blockchain. They're written in, of all things, Berkeley Packet Filter bytecode. (No, they don't run inside the Linux kernel. I hope.) Programs can be written in Rust and compiled. How secure this will turn out to be for their "smart contracts" is an open question at this time.
So far, I can't find any working applications for Solana that do something outside the crypto space. Like, say, replacing domain registrars. There's some kind of identity service, but it seems to be tied to Twitter. There's The Media Network, but it doesn't work yet. ("The Media Network is an open source, decentralized and censorship-resistant live streaming hosting protocol. More coming soon.")
Not seeing "AirBnB for Solana", or "Uber for Solana", or "offshore realty for Solana",
or even "concert ticket scalping for Solana". This is a problem. It doesn't really do anything yet.
- JauntyHatAngle 5y ago>Etherium You mean ethereum right?
- kaspern 5y agoAudius is one such example: https://medium.com/audius/audius-selects-solana-to-scale-community-owned-music-streaming-8a868db644eb https://medium.com/audius/audius-selects-solana-to-scale-com...
- Animats 5y agoThat deal was announced last October, but does not seem to be working yet. Or even in test. Searching the Audius API docs returns zero references to Solana.
- Clewza313 5y agoWhy would you even need Airbnb or Uber for Solana? What problem does either solve? This remains a fundamental problem with crypto: we're 13 years in and the only practical use cases remain speculation and money laundering. Even DeFi seems to consistent mostly of navel gazing (crypto derivatives etc) and leverage.
- hestefisk 5y agoHave a look at areas of banking where you have a lot of paper and lot of a actors / intermediaries —- eg trade finance, post-trade asset servicing. Here blockchain is seeing a pretty good adoption, although mostly in private networks.
- lalaland1125 5y agoIf it's just a private network, why even call it a blockchain instead of a database? It's not even decentralized.
- ejstronge 5y agoI agree with your comment. Perhaps the GP is also considering the use of smart contracts (see ref 1 for an example) 1. https://www.forbes.com/sites/philippsandner/2020/12/02/will-blockchain-replace-clearinghouses-a-case-of-dvp-post-trade-settlement/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/philippsandner/2020/12/02/will-...
- ineptech 5y agoSmart contracts are amazing, as long as its a contract between two crypto people doing crypto stuff. But (and please, someone correct me if I'm wrong) the oracle problem still stops them from using anything in the real world as an input; I think this is what GP meant by naval gazing.
- ejstronge 5y agoThe example contract in the link I posted doesn't rely on third-party data sources (with the exception, perhaps, of time). Does the oracle problem still apply?
- Grustaf 5y agoIt would seem that by definition, if you want smart contracts or anything "on the blockchain" to interact with the real world, you will need to find intermediaries you trust. Meaning you're back to square one if you want to cross the crypto-real world membrane.
- wyxuan 5y agoWell a plus is that if it's done in solidity, people can just fork existing stuff on ethereum and push it on to Solana, with the exception of Uniswap and a few others that have explicitly disallowed it in their licenses
- nradov 5y agoIs there a "Chinese currency control evasion for Solana"? That's generally the most viable use case for most cryptocurrency systems.
- tikwidd 5y agoI had a little play with Solana to see if it would be appropriate for a game I'm building, to use as an (after)marketplace for players to trade in-game items. It's quite easy to install the Solana command line tools, create a wallet and create your own fungible or non fungible tokens with a few simple commands (and some Sol). The reason I was looking at Solana was because the transaction costs are extremely low (and if the marketing is to be believed, should stay that low even if Solana had the market cap of bitcoin). However you can't add any metadata to non fungible tokens at present (some dev told me on discord that this feature was coming very soon), which limits its usefulness. Also a reliable and user friendly marketplace for Solana tokens is still lacking (startup opportunity for someone?)
- Grustaf 5y agoTo be fair, AirBnB for Solana would be pretty pointless, the interesting thing is if they can come up with something that wasn't possible before crypto. The disruptive potential of the internet was clear even as we sat on dial-up connections, crypto is way past that point but still hasn't produced anything useful. Making ETH a bit better will not fundamentally change that.