3 ms·
It's actually about capability inflation. You can counter any tech but new tech makes old tech obsolete. An army consisting exclusively of F-35 vs old generati
by imtringued 5y ago
It's actually about capability inflation. You can counter any tech but new tech makes old tech obsolete.
An army consisting exclusively of F-35 vs old generation jets could decimate all enemy jets without losing a single F-35.
It's the same with modern tank vs old tanks. Those old tanks can't penetrate the armor of modern tanks.
- belter 5y agoYou sure about that ? Because at least in dogfights the 40 year old F16 seems to win.. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/07/disastrous-f-35-vs-f-16-face-off-was-also-a-battle-of-philosophies/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/07/disas...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wil421 5y agoThe F22 would probably be the one engaging F16s. Regardless if you are dogfighting in an F22 or F35 something else has gone wrong. The stealth planes sneak in and shoot enemy planes from far away.
- belter 5y agoI am afraid they tried that also.The F22 lost against German pilots on the Eurofighter Typhoon: https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2012/07/f-22-fighter-loses-79-billion-advantage-in-dogfights-report https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2012/07/f-22-fighter-...
- wil421 5y agoThe article hits on my point about dogfighting. I don’t think most US modern planes except the F16 were designed for it. IIRC they weren’t even going to include guns on the F22. > while the planes own the skies at modern long-range air combat
- gpderetta 5y agoAny scenario in which American F22s would participate in combat action against European Eurofighters is far fetched, dogfighting or not. In fact I would say if such an encounter were ever to happen, due to rule of engagements, a dogfight would be more likely than a BVR engagement (and likely to end without a single shot fired).
- knowaveragejoe 5y ago"Old school dogfighting" is just that - a thing of the past.
- elygre 5y agoThe premise was "consisting exclusively of F-35". you might have wanted F22s, but they are not available in the scenario.
- stouset 5y agoThis is irrelevant. The exercise was dogfighting, a phase which the F-16 would never be able to reach against an F-35 in combat without a multitude of things going wrong. The F-35 can see and shoot down the F-16 with radar-guided missiles in BVR well before the latter is even aware the F-35 is in the area. Dogfighting is minimally relevant to modern air combat for nuclear-armed nations. Things would have to be going extraordinarily badly in a war for the brass to start deciding to send their exceedingly expensive fifth-gen stealth fighters into dogfight coin tosses. Hell, even an A-10 is a surprisingly effective dogfighter against modern fighters. The fighters have speed but the Warthog has an extremely tight turning radius and far better low-speed maneuverability, both of which allow it to stay inside the opponent’s “bubble” (the area inside which a turning jet can’t ever manage to point its nose). If the A-10 can keep it to a one-circle fight it will win handily. A fighter will often have to rely on a “boom and zoom” tactic (where it disengages, gains distance, and turns back around for a guns pass) but that can be quite low probability of kill and still be relatively risky if the A-10 has friendlies in the area feeling it location information. But just like the situation already being discussed, this is for all practical purposes completely irrelevant. A flight of F-16s would engage and destroy a flight of A-10s from miles away with AMRAAMs and it would never have a chance to transition to an up-close dogfight.
- valec 5y ago> The F-35 can see and shoot down the F-16 with radar-guided missiles in BVR well before the latter is even aware the F-35 is in the area. what's stopping the f-16 from turning around and going cold as soon as it hears a lock or senses enemy radar?
- wearywanderer 5y agoThe rules of the wargame, which are invariably rigged for the most expensive toy.
- tynpeddler 5y agoThe linked article is out of date and cites "War is Boring" which is notoriously anti f35. Here's something a bit more recent. The english translation is at the botom: https://nettsteder.regjeringen.no/kampfly/fagprat/f-35-i-naerkamp-hva-har-jeg-laert-sa-langt-the-f-35-in-a-dogfight-what-have-i-learned-so-far/ https://nettsteder.regjeringen.no/kampfly/fagprat/f-35-i-nae....
- sandworm101 5y ago>> An army consisting exclusively of F-35 vs old generation jets could decimate all enemy jets without losing a single F-35. Maybe ... in the air ... if the numbers are the same ... if all of those F-35s are able to fly ... if the other side doesn't have a significant SAM capability ... if if if. In a realworld battle between armies the air-to-air capacity of fighters is a small part of the battle. Most will try to defeat the other's aircraft using ground assets, missiles/manpad. Ideally you take out aircraft in their hangars. A single well-placed artillery shell can take out a dozen F-35s in a hangar. A single frogfoot can destroy any F-35 that is low on fuel/ammo/speed after engaging a couple flankers. Realworld combat is messy. A pack of crows can take down an eagle.