4 ms·
So, looks like contacts and internal knowledge are much more important for a PHD than it is for most professions, but the situation is still much better than fo
by marcosdumay 5y ago
So, looks like contacts and internal knowledge are much more important for a PHD than it is for most professions, but the situation is still much better than for politicians.
I'd say that means the PHD job market has a large problem. When politicians are the ones you can compare yourself to look good, it's because things are not good at all.
- the-lazy-guy 5y agoThat is one interpretation. Another interpretation is that in pursuing academic career requires a certain attitude towards studying which people growing in a family of academics are a lot more likely to have. In STEM it makes a lot more sense financially to enter the workforce after graduation so staying in university for another 5+ years requires some real love for science. In my experience people with parents in academia are more likely to get financial and moral from their family while they are doing phd.
- hackinthebochs 5y agoNot to mention shared genes for educational attainment and interests.
- sleeper_service 5y agoIs there a proven role of genetics here or is this pseudoscientific determinism?
- hackinthebochs 5y agoIt is pretty well established that educational attainment is significantly heritable [1]. Although less studied, there is evidence of significant heritability of interests as well [2] [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-017-0005-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-017-0005-6 [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8407707/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8407707/
- bsanr2 5y agoHeritability is not necessarily genetic, which is probably what he was getting at. Behavioral genetics is fairly controversial for being an entire field which begs the question. https://www.wichita.edu/academics/fairmount_college_of_liberal_arts_and_sciences/psychology/documents/MisbehavingScienceReview.pdf https://www.wichita.edu/academics/fairmount_college_of_liber... https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/my-problem-with-e2809ctabooe2809d-behavioral-genetics-the-science-stinks/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/my-problem-...
- hackinthebochs 5y agoTwin studies, adoption studies, and now GWAS studies are quickly putting an end to the idea of some significant but elusive environmental effect that accounts for heritability measures in exclusion to genes. Regarding the articles, I don't find them compelling. The author of the first one identifies himself as an emergentist, which is conceptually vacuous. The critique in the second article doesn't target the strongest of heritability studies regarding IQ, educational attainment, etc, which have been widely replicated.
- bsanr2 5y agoAll behavioral genetic studies heretofore rely on statistical analysis to draw correlations from datasets. Even ones that identiy specific SNPs are often unable to identify the physiological mechanism by which, say, Gene X influences intelligence. Without that, it's impossible to conclude that expression of Gene X isn't environmentally-influenced, and only has positive effects on intelligence when a certain diet is consumed, or sleep schedule kept, or common childhood illness avoided, for example. Another trait influenced by complex genetic and environmental factors, variability in adult height, has similarly been held to be highly heritable based on flawed studies with flawed construction, methodology, and assumptions, despite the fact that the average in many countries has changed on a time scale incompatible with a purely or even highly genetic basis. And height is easy to measure: get a ruler. Models of intelligence have shifted over the years because, speaking frankly, we don't really know how to measure it objectively. Your objection to the first is ad hominem, to the second erroneous. Belief in genetic determinism, as we conceive it, is at odds with the principles of skepticism and scientific inquiry. Like eugenics before it, it really, really wants to find a scientific basis to justify the state of the world we live in even as that state shifts under us. There are massive holes in both the execution of studies and the underlying rationale, and it's impossible to speak in good faith on the topic without acknowledging that.
- jvvw 5y agoHmm. My mother was a university lecturer in mathematics and I don't think contacts etc helped at all with my PhD in maths and academia. What did help was the enthusiasm she passed in for her subject when I was young and the encouragement she gave me. Our house was full of mathematics books. My sister on the other hand had no interest in mathematics whatsoever!
- mirker 5y agoWhat’s the difference between a senior faculty and a politician? In both cases, you’re more of an icon than and individual contributor. The difference gets even smaller if faculty become dean.