17 ms·
Twice in my education, once in middle school and once in college (my instructor did a very dramatic read of William Jennings Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech), I
by cratermoon 5y ago
Twice in my education, once in middle school and once in college (my instructor did a very dramatic read of William Jennings Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech), I encountered the Free Silver movement in history classes. I never understood it then and to this day I still don't understand what the kerfuffle was about. It seems like a religious doctrinal difference rather than one that would have any real economic effect.
Somewhat before I cared about money, in 1971, Nixon decoupled the dollar from gold, and although I do recall hearing about the accompanying wage/price freeze, I don't think it's ever mattered to me whether or not I could exchange my paper for gold.
- billytetrud 5y agoYou couldn't exchange your paper for gold since 1931. Maybe that's why it felt like nothing changed to you. However, institutions could. Since 1971, unfettered monetary inflation has been used to siphon wealth from the people for the benefit of a segment of rich elites close with the federal reserve. It's no coincidence that real wages haven't increased significantly since that Nixon administration. https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/15558/productivity-vs-real-earnings-in-the-us-what-happened-ca-1974 https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/15558/producti... Requiring backing for dollars was a real limiter on inflation and government spending. Inflation fuels an ever increasing debt cycle that is incredibly harmful for the economy, but great for banks and financial institutions.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> Requiring backing for dollars was a real limiter on inflation Which directly leads to instability when the value of the backing changes. I'm not aware of any mainstream movement amongst orthodox economists to revert to pre-Nixon policies.
- dnautics 5y agoThat's understandable. The value of stability seems to be doctrinal in orthodox economics (it is the orthodoxy, after all) Like any other metric, stability comes at a cost (and it also comes with baked-in assumptions). I wish there were more rigorous discussion of what the social cost of stability is (is it worth it to have stability if that means siphoning money from the poor?), who benefits from 'stability', what values our metrics for stability encode, and to what extent the Federal Reserve system is a victim of Goodheart's law in all of the goals it seeks, to include 'stability'.
- kube-system 5y agoIt is undoubtably the working classes who benefit from stability. The people who control businesses are not laying themselves off first, nor are they living paycheck-to-paycheck.
- billytetrud 5y agoThere is quite a lot of reason to doubt that is the case in the long run. What I think dnautics is saying is that stability is trading off short term gains for long term gains. What about the stagnated real wages in the last 50 years? Is that good for the poor? What about seigniorage? Is that good for the poor? When someone says something like "undoubtedly/obviously X" or "its commen sense that X" 99% of the time they haven't put much thought into it.
- kube-system 5y agoWe're not comparing equal "short term" and "long term" events though. The short term effects are much more severe in nature. And because they are severe, these "short term" economic effects end up causing long term financial impacts for the people they impact, even after the economy has recovered. Most non-high income people do not have huge rainy-day funds. If they lose their job, even for a short period of time, they will find themselves relying on debt that is a lot more expensive than 2% inflation. Stability has a high value, it is just hard to measure in dollars. > When someone says something like "undoubtedly/obviously X" or "its commen sense that X" 99% of the time they haven't put much thought into it. Or rather, it's an easy question to answer because we've seen the situation happen many times. Who suffers during economic downturns?
- billytetrud 5y agoWe should probably define what kind of stability we're talking about before we devolve into fisticuffs. Are we talking about a "stable" economy? A stable buying power of the currency? Something else?
- billytetrud 5y ago> Which directly leads to instability when the value of the backing changes. You're not correct. Instability leads to changes in the buying power of currency, not the other way around. Unless you're talking about monetary inflation. What mechanism do you think there is to change the value of gold in a gold-backed world? The mechanism is that when there are better places to put your money than keeping it in dollars (gold backed or otherwise) the value of those dollars goes down. And vice versa, when there are fewer better places to put your money, more wealth will be held as currency and push its price up (this is why deflation is seen as bad - beacause it generally coincides with an economy that has been invisibly failing for years). Monetary policy had been inflationary and insolvent, and rampant expansion of the money supply lead to high price inflation which of course ended in a crash. It was monetary expansion that lead to the problems in the 70s not mysterious changes to the value of gold.
- reedjosh 5y agoPretty sure the value of gold only truly fluctuates against fiat currencies. It's not the intrinsic value of gold that fluctuates. In Roman times the value of an ounce of gold would buy a handmade robe, belt, and shoes. At today's value $1800, you could do exactly the same.
- fuzzfactor 5y ago>I'm not aware of any mainstream movement amongst orthodox economists to revert to pre-Nixon policies. That's OK, mainstream orthodox economists have completely failed to yield anything resembling pre-Nixon prosperity ever since.
- mullingitover 5y ago> Since 1971, unfettered monetary inflation has been used to siphon wealth from the people for the benefit of a segment of rich elites close with the federal reserve. The median household debt is $90,460 in the US, and the median savings is significantly lower than that. So barring hyperinflation, some reasonable inflation is actually beneficial for 'the people.' It's diluting their debt. Meanwhile, the most common investment for working people is in their home, and real estate is one of the best inflation shelters. The parties most harmed by inflation are the ones sitting on huge amounts of cash without using it productively (so, not 'the people'), and those are exactly the parties who need a fire lit under them to prevent a deflation spiral.
- hpoe 5y agoHere's the problem I own a home I am not owning that home as an investment vehicle I didn't choose the home to make a return I got that home as a place to fricking live, I chose my home because it would be most comfortable for my wife and family. The "value of the home" is an imaginary number in a database somewhere that doesn't actually do me any good when I need to pay for a hospital visit, or need to buy a car or something like that. In fact the more of my "value" is locked up in my home the less I am able to access it. Besides even if I were to liquidate what should I do then, go live under a bridge, the problem is even if my home has increased in value so has everyone else's home so even if I liquidate I'll still be stuck having to roll all that value over into a new home anyway because no matter what happens I still need a place to live.
- mullingitover 5y ago> In fact the more of my "value" is locked up in my home the less I am able to access it. It's extremely easy to access the value of your home, home equity lines of credit are used all the time.
- billytetrud 5y agoWhen the only way to access the value of your property is to pay a rent (interest) to someone else, then that isn't really easy access, now is it?
- RC_ITR 5y agoYou think that centralizing the global economy around a metal that has limited intrinsic value, limited supply, relatively high density, random allocation below out earth’s surface, and extremely high storage costs is a good thing for poor people?
- billytetrud 5y agoI think strictly limiting the ability for central banks to inflate the monetary supply (and use that created money to their own ends) is good for poor people. If it requires centralizing the global economy on gold, I certinaly think it would be worth it. However, an alternative would be to simply renationalize the Fed and put legislated limits on dollar monetary inflation. There are a lot of options here that don't involve going back to a gold standard. It kind of sounds like your argument is "gold is expensive, so how could it be good for the poor". Is that.. really the argument you're trying make here?
- reedjosh 5y ago> simply renationalize the Fed and put legislated limits on dollar monetary inflation. Nothing simple about that though since the current system benefits the most powerful. This _is_ why bitcoiners treat it like a religion. There is no traditional political way to return to sane monetary standards. Moving to BTC removes the untrustworthy governmental control from the equation. Bitcoin's energy usage is only necessary as a hedge against powerful actors trying to kill it. Proof of stake currencies are great, but it's likely if bitcoin hadn't paved the way, any such system would have been killed by a state actor since it hurts their main source of finance.
- billytetrud 5y agoIndeed. I meant its a simple idea. It would be simple to write a lwa for it. But of course, it would be politically fraught. Similarly tho, it wouldn't be politically simple to switch back to gold-backing. But yes, hopefully bitcoin can save us from this mess one day.
- 5y ago
- torstenvl 5y agoMy intuition is the opposite of what you're saying. Inflation devalues debt and savings while increasing the nominal value of wages. The guy with hundreds of thousands in savings and bonds loses from inflation; the guy with $80,000 left on his mortgage working as a senior sales associate at Home Depot benefits from it. How does this siphon money from the people to the benefit of rich elites?
- hpoe 5y agoBecause the inflation grows in respect to the access to captial you had before. So our Senior Sales associate at Home Depot doesn't see any real increase because he doesn't have any assest to take advantage of it. Meanwhile those that have access to cheap money are able to move it to others sources that are inflation resistant, stocks, companies, real estate, etc, meaning that overtime he is still getting paid $80,000 and his house may have increased in value but everything he needs to live is outpacing his ability to buy. Meanwhile those involved in finance are now substantially richer because they got more of the new money being created by having easy accless to captial. EDIT: If I am wrong in something here somebody tell me why, because that basically seems to be what is happening with the feds inflationary money policies is that everyone that can is borrowing at low interest rates then plowing that into real estate and the stock market because those are increasing in value so much, precisely because interest rates are so low and inflation so high.
- treis 5y ago>IT: If I am wrong in something here somebody tell me why, Because wages rise with inflation too. A very simplistic explanation is that inflation hurts those that save/lend cash and helps those the own assets & borrow cash. It tends to be the poor that suffer because they save in cash & it's easier to suffer as a poor person.
- stx 5y agoThe reality is that wages have not kept up with inflation. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us...
- Aunche 5y ago>Since 1971, unfettered monetary inflation has been used to siphon wealth from the people for the benefit of a segment of rich elites close with the federal reserve. Not deciding to arbitrarily tying the dollar to a random commodity makes the dollar more efficient. I can see how the wealthy disproportionately capture this benefit. However, it doesn't follow that people close to the Fed benefit more than anyone else does. Private equity and venture capitalists are further from the fed than banks, but have grown even faster. Also, if you wanted to stop inflation, why not just do it another way like forcing a debt ceiling or limiting how much money can be created to a rate similar to that which gold is mined? Tying your money to a volatile commodity seems like the worst way to do it.
- billytetrud 5y ago> Not deciding to arbitrarily tying the dollar to a random commodity makes the dollar more efficient. How so? > it doesn't follow that people close to the Fed benefit more than anyone else does Its a well established fact that this is the case. Its called Seigniorage. Its called the Cantillion Effect. This isn't controversial in any way. > Private equity and venture capitalists are further from the fed than banks, but have grown even faster. Do you have a source for that? Banks are regulated in a way that limits the risks they can take, and therefore the return they can get, so it wouldn't be surprising that banks growth is smaller, especially over short time spans (eg years vs decades). Private equity and venture capitalists are often very close to banks too, so the difference is likely negligible. And I would have to imagine that people who own private equity firms are a lot more likely to also have equity in banks. > why not just do it another way like forcing a debt ceiling or limiting how much money can be created to a rate similar to that which gold is mined Yes, why not? I don't think I ever advocated that going back to a gold-backed dollar is the only solution. What was important about the gold standard was that it was a widely agreed upon culture of limited monetary supply. Any way that leads us back to that kind of culture where people undertand the importance of a limited money supply and fight to preserve it is a way out of our predicament.
- Aunche 5y agoI'm not an economist, but I do think my intuition about money is correct. >How so? Money is supposed to be medium for the exchange of goods and services. At first, gold acted as a perfectly acceptable medium. However, as the economy grows, the supply of gold does not at the same rate, hence why money slowly became less and less tied to gold. First came fractional reserve banking and then the end of the gold standard. As long as the dollar is tied to gold, you always need to factor in the opportunity cost of holding gold into making an investment or a loan. For the decades following WWII, the American government could ignore this effect because the Bretton Woods system basically allowed the American government to pass that opportunity cost onto the Europeans and Japanese who were desperate for economic stability, but that wasn't sustainable forever. The wealth the American government got from essentially renting out dollars trickled down to the people, which is why I think many people reminisce the gold standard. >Its called the Cantillion Effect... Private equity and venture capitalists are often very close to banks too So can you define what you mean by being "close to the Fed"? I think the Cantillon effect just describes how the rich asymmetrically benefit from monetary expansion. The rich and poor can both take advantage of cheaper debt, but only the rich can afford to use that to grow their wealth. I don't think that this is enough reason to stop monetary intervention though. I'd much prefer our status quo to another Great Depression. The problem isn't that the Fed expands the money supply when the velocity of money falls. The problem is that they are unable to shrink the money supply when the economy recovers because with the rest of the federal government is required to issue $1 trillion in debt every year to operate. In theory, returning to a gold standard would incentivize Congress to be better at fiscal policy, but I'm pretty sure that they would just instantly become bankrupt.
- egh 5y agoThis is a great comment because while it's completely wrong empirically, it also completely misses the point of the good question about free silver. Like the question of what was the US civil war about (slavery) the question of what silver v gold was about has been completely obscured by interested parties seeking to complicate the issue in such a way that nobody understands it any more. There are complications, which I don't really understand, but all you need to know is that silver vs gold was about inflation vs deflation. The free silver people were farmers (who are always debtors) and they supported inflation, because inflation is good for debtors. The supporters of gold were creditors, and the supported deflation, because creditors like deflation. It's that simple. The author of the above comment apparently thinks the populist farmers were completely wrong and they should have been against inflation. This may be true (it's not, but let's stipulate) but the commenter prefers to obfuscate the issue rather than confront the clear fact that free silver populists supported it BECAUSE it was inflationary.
- billytetrud 5y ago> completely misses the point of the good question about free silver Oh the irony... talking about missing the point. I didn't miss the point. I just had nothing to say about that point.
- kaminar 5y agoYou're a psycho.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou have causality backwards. Accumulating debt tends to drive inflation. Inflation is disliked by banks, as it reduces the value of any currency-denominated assets (loans, debt, insurance premiums, etc.). Inflation aids creditors. The question of how money is injected into the financial system is independent of whether or not inflation occurs. Direct injection to consumers ("helicopter drops") would be least injurious to inequality. The fact that the financial sector engineers monetary supply increases to be in their favour is a problem of the wealth-power connection.
- billytetrud 5y ago> Accumulating debt tends to drive inflation. Well, its kind of a chicken and egg situation. I agree that moneatry (and price) inflation incentivizes more debt. However, the fact is that the mechanism by which monetary inflation happens is generally by creating debt. So if you were to pin whether the egg or the chicken came first, the answer would be that they happened at the same time. > Inflation is disliked by banks Mmm, no. Banks gain seigniorage from monetary inflation. So no they don't dislike it. > Inflation aids creditors. Devaluation of the currency aids creditors. However, monetary inflation does more than just currency devaluation. It also reallocates weath (seigniorage) and manipulates the market. Banks can simply loan out whatever money they want, so an inflating currency doesn't matter to them. They take that inflation into account already. What does matter is unexpected inflation. That's why uproar happens when inflation rates change significantly (either high inflation or deflation). > Direct injection to consumers ("helicopter drops") would be least injurious to inequality I agree. Still economically harmful, but less harmful than traditional seigniorage.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf inflation increases effective demand by consumers (that is, increases effective income and wealth of the poorest sector of society), then debt relative to total economic activity should decrease. The problem with debt is that it is a manifestation of an underlying contradiction. One or more of: - The expectation that those not paid sufficiently to survive can. E.g., increasing wealth inequality. - That past obligations take precedence over current survival. - Past consumption patterns or expectations of future consumption exceeding actual production capacities. At some point, something has to give. Debt can be inflated away, debt can be discharged (bankruptcy, jubilee, expiry, default). Or the social order under which the debts are recognised can itself be dissolved (revolution). Your #2 is false. Seigniorage is gain on minting money, not inflation. I have no idea what term you're confusing it with.
- dmckeon 5y agoThe key issue for “Free Silver” is not paper certificates, nor unlimited coinage, but the fixed exchange rate between silver and gold, in which the two metals were considered primarily as money, and not as commodities with separately varying supply and demand patterns. Imagine briefly a market in which APPL and TSLA common stock were subject to a fixed price ratio. Crazy idea, yes? But a 16:1 ratio for silver:gold makes just as much sense from a market point of view. For the consumer, investor, banker, a fixed ratio is a nice convenience, but if the supply or demand for either gold or silver were to change significantly, opportunities for arbitrage could become very profitable. Now think of the California gold rush, the Comstock silver lode, and the hundreds of other mining booms between 1850 and 1896. Who benefited, and who paid? Were WJ Bryan and other orators and politicians champions of the masses or tools of the robber barons?
- skak 5y agoUltimately, WJ Bryan was both a tool of capital and a champion of the masses, but the free silver effort was an the exceptional issue for the reasons you explained. I think farmers loans are worth mentioning specifically. The fixed ratio was terrible for farmers who had to seasonally borrow money and pay it back with interest.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoCould you expand on that a bit? Why did the fixed ratio hurt farmers (or anyone who had to borrow)? Or, how would a float between silver and gold have helped them? It's not like a bank is going to lend you gold dollars and accept being paid back in silver dollars (or vice versa) if the ratio between them isn't fixed... [Edit: Never mind, ffggvv answered this question below.]
- cratermoon 5y agoOh, there's the gap in my history class. We never learned about the economics and the fixed exchange ratio. I always looked back and presumed they were independently trading commodities the way they are today. To answer your question, Bryan was a champion of the masses in the same way the prior occupant of the Oval Office was a champion of the masses.
- Gibbon1 5y agoOne thing I read about. Before the great depression mortgages were much different than they are after the New Deal Reforms. Loans were usually interest only. You had to either pay or refinance the principle at the end of the term. Which might be five or ten years. If you defaulted the lender would take the collateral, all of it. Critically loans were denominated in both dollars and gold. And could be called in often at any time to be repaid in dollars or gold, which ever was highest. You can easily see how these could be abused by banks. If you were a small time farmer during a downturn the price your crops fetch drops, the value of your farm drops. But the price of gold goes up which increases the amount you owe. The bank would then call in your loan and because you can't pay in gold take your farm. Leaving you with zilch. The above is why FDR closed the banks when he took office. Because banks were strategically destroying the economy.
- ffggvv 5y agoas far as i can tell (correct me if im wrong) Farmers had massive loans that were gold denominated. (dollar backed by gold). The currency was deflationary, and the massive debts were breaking the back of farmers/rural areas. Adding silver as backing of dollar essentially increases supply of the backing of the currency, creating inflation. which relieves the farmers debts. (pay back less real money) so the farmers and WJB basically just wanted inflation to relieve their debt load. (and silver interests also obviously backed the idea)
- cratermoon 5y agoI get it now, thanks to you and another reply. I was never taught the economic technical details, just the socio-political history.
- nickik 5y agoThis is mostly correct. I added some context in my answer that you might be interested in. I think it would be more correct to say that adding silver would mostly cause increase liquidity it unlikely silver would have caused significant inflation. In general I would argue the issue with silver was way overblown, if silver or not would not have changed the fundamental problem. The people who opposed silver predicted over the top results and those who were pro silver overestimated the actual effect it would have. The US monetary system had far more important issues related to unit banking, reserve pyramids and note issue.
- nickik 5y agoSo let me maybe explain this. This is a issue that is really not understood at all even by most economists. History of economics and banking history is not really tough much beyond some broad interdiction as far as I know. There are some good economic historians that have done great work on this. I'm gone try not to go to far back, but it does require a little bit of background to understand of banking and bank regulation in the 19th century US. The first thing to understand is that banks would issue private bank notes in this period. Think of these like checking accounts. So a checking account is a IOU the bank has towards you, and for the privilege of you lending them money, they pay you interest. Now a bank note is basically the same thing, just that the interest actually goes to the bank. This is basically the economic driver behind bank notes in the first place. Every bank wants to have as wide and large a distribution as possible because that is basically money that was lent to them but they don't have to pay interest. This is a fine enough system and worked well in many places around the world for quite a long time, earliest accounts going back to China 1200 century. So the idea is that if people want to hold a lot of cash, the bank prints more notes because there is less demand for there reserves, higher cash preference. However if people prefer to have more money in their checking account, they equally have to reduce the amount of notes otherwise they are in danger of gold reserves being drained to other banks who did reduce their circulation. Other banks usually realize that you are losing gold faster then you are getting it so they start to blacklist you and then you are basically done. In practice this is very evident because the amount of notes in circulation would spike up in the summer when you had to pay workers and do a lot of transaction, and many fewer notes were in circulation in the winter because there was just less reason to carry cash. Remember that much of the economy was still driven by farming and the harvest. To earn interest the bank has to use money to make loans or buy stocks or obligation. In some system like Canada at the time there was little restriction put on the bank what they should use to 'back' these notes. The banks basically just had to made sure they are liquid enough reserves to cover incoming IOU from costumers or more likely other banks who had accumulated many of your notes and wanted to settle. (Little aside, these settlements were done periodically 1:1 with each bank you have accumulated notes off. Better developed such system eventually developed private clearing houses that would do this arbitration for banks and what banks lost or gained reserves, either simply moving them from one account to another on its own ledger or ordering one bank to send another the gold reserves) The US has a somewhat different history, once state governments allowed competitive banks at all, they required notes to be treated differently then checking accounts. And take a guess what states wanted as a backing asset for notes. Good old state government debt obligation. This is not so much different from many historical kingdoms where the king would basically force the banks to loan money to him. This caused a lot of problems because it would mean some banks would be highly leveraged with state debt and states in that period were not very not very reliable. So if a state defaulted the bank might just collapse at the same time. This was not the main issue with banking in the US and the problems caused were mostly limited and localized. Now because of the Civil War spending requirements changed and they now started to allow 'national banks' (National Bank System). And if you think the reason behind this is that these new federally regulated banks were required to buy federal debt, rather then state debt. You would be correct. This was a reasonable measure to pay for the war as far as these things go. People continued to use state bank currency in many cases anyway so eventually those banks were hit with a significant tax and that meant that you either became a national bank or stopped issuing currency. The problem however came when the Republican government after the Civil War basically had a major policy of debt reduction. See in this nice chart: https://cdn.theatlantic.com/assets/media/img/3rdparty/2012/11/debt-and-gdp-03.png https://cdn.theatlantic.com/assets/media/img/3rdparty/2012/1... You can now understand what this means. Basically the government did what we would now call 'monetary policy' but instead of having some kind of actual goal, they simply did it without realizing the implications on banking. Now put the "Cross of Gold" speech on that timeline and it makes more sense. If you are only allowed to print notes if you have federal debt and the federal debt is being reduced year over year then the amount of notes banks can actually issue is reduced. This is effectively caused two issues, one is that it is mildly deflationary (nothing like Great Depression but still not great) but the most significant impact is that there simply wasn't liquidity as banks were no longer responsive to note demand. By 1890 virtually all government debt was bound up to back notes, even if one bank wanted to issue more notes, they had to buy these papers from other banks who in turn had to reduce their amount of notes. So instead, banks just were not responsive. Silver was basically seen as an alternative more liquid currency. In my opinion they correctly identified the problem but the solution wasn't really the right one (not that I think silver as currency would have caused meaningful problems). The solution was to simply stop forcing banks to back their notes with ever reducing federal debt. You could go back and allow state and federal debt or allow a limited broader set of 'good assets', or simply bank what they would accept from other banks. However, William Jennings Bryan himself used all his power to prevent exactly that solution, starting as a congress men around 1890 he basically believed such a solution would basically give power to the banks. He virulently oppose currency and bank reforms for the next 20 years even during major liquidity crisis. As leader of the progressive wing we was very powerful person in the opposition to these reforms. His opposition were point to Canada that had non of the US issues, neither bank failures nor liquidity restrictions and had exactly such an 'Asset Currency'. There are nice graphs that I can't find anymore you can see how the currency in Canada is very responsive to the seasonal cycles. These reforms would have fixed 'some' of the other issue in the US system as well but they were not politically viable. They had some powerful support, specially from some 'Mid' sized banks but were opposed by the large New York bank, the powerful rural banks. So one could say Bryan was one of the major blockers of solving the actual problem and used the resulting crisis to make himself incredibly popular and powerful. To be clear, I'm not saying he knowingly did that, but this is what happened. This is of course also how the initial version of the Fed was created a few years later. The Federal Reserve System is basically 12 new banks that don't suffer from the same regulation, so they can issue notes for assets, as Rick (from Rick and Morty) would say "That is just Asset Currencies with extra steps". So instead of just having assets and printing bank notes backed by those assets, you take the very same assets to the Fed and they would give you federal notes. This was more viable because for the Bryan's because while these Federal Reserve Banks were theoretically private, they were regulated by the government to a stronger degree. Seems to me it would have been far easier to simply have additional regulation on banks and regulators publish a list of viable assets that existing banks had to follow rather then creating a whole new layer of banks on top. Now, I should say, the this is only one not 'the' major cause of the increase number of banking panics and runs that happen towards that period. The US Banking System had a number of sub-optimal policies that all acted together to cause panics in this period. I hope this helps. I left out a lot of stuff but this post is to long already.