7 ms·
The U.S. Military Emits More CO2 Than Many Industrialized Nations (2019)
- wait_a_minute 5y agoIt also has most of the free world as its customer and if it didn’t exist then China or Russia would be determining what you can post on here.
- Santosh83 5y agoI would say the less authoritarian world. No place is truly free until all of us are free. We still have a long way to go.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoI’m definitely free and my immigrant parents and grandparents who fled to the USA from an authoritarian Soviet Union shithole are also free. So no, I will go ahead and boldly and proudly say it’s the free world. Don’t make the perfect the enemy of the good.
- onion2k 5y agoDon't let good be the enemy of great.
- fsflover 5y ago> if it didn’t exist then China or Russia would be determining what you can post on here. This is FUD and strawman. US military could probably be decreased by >50% without any negative consequences.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoAccording to who? You? I’ll go ahead and defer to the generals and admirals and the elected officials to determine true budgeting needs for the dangers abroad.
- InitialLastName 5y agoDo you also let the bear tell you how big your honey stockpile should be?
- wait_a_minute 5y agoYou have no argument.
- kajecounterhack 5y agoUh this is actually a really good argument. Put another way, do you let kids decide how much candy they get to eat? These things are analogous. The way organizations like the military are set up, they always will want more money, more expansion, more autonomy. Hell, give me one example of an organization that won't ask for more money every year given the opportunity. Usually you have to provide value for money, but the military gets away with handwaving about security. Another analogous situation is infosec. I used to work in that space, and a big problem companies have is trying to figure out how much money to sink into their infosec teams. Good orgs invest in infosec, but they also don't just give all their profits to those teams. The value proposition of security in general is just hard to measure; that said organizations have a tendency to either massively overinvest (because fear, and it's hard to measure) or underinvest (because you don't need it until something goes wrong). A lot of times they start out underinvested, something bad happens, and then suddenly they're overinvested because they are afraid of bad thing happening again. I think this last description is very apt for the US.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoReasoning by analogy rather than by principles means someone has no argument. The analogy just restates the original premise without actually contending for the premise.
- kajecounterhack 5y agoThat's not correct. Analogies are a good way to help someone you're talking to understand where you're coming from. The post that originally drew the analogy for you was succinctly explaining why unequivocal support for an organization's budget, particularly one like the US military, is not a good idea. It was quite successful at conveying that point, you're just calling it invalid. Doesn't make it so.
- alexfromapex 5y agoThe military should not be playing world police but having a large enough military to counter rivals is the only thing maintaining the sovereignty of the U.S. and other free nations.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoIt’s really by necessity, because we all saw what happened to Hong Kong and Ukraine and what they’d like to happen to Taiwan and south Korea and basically as much territory as possible. If the US military vanished today, Russia or China would be the world police.
- wruza 5y agoI see why China, but Russia spends amounts similar to many nations. Why do you focus on Russia and not Saudi, India or a potential France/Germany union? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_militar...
- scoopertrooper 5y agoBecause Russia just recently launched a war of territorial aggression against Ukraine?
- fsflover 5y agoBut does it mean that the US needs a huge army to fight them?
- scoopertrooper 5y agoRussia actually has a pretty huge army still and they're rapidly modernising. They could get pretty deep into Europe if they set their minds to it. The raw reported spending numbers are a bit misleading because the Russian state is somewhat opaque and you need to adjust for purchasing power.
- orange_joe 5y agonot exactly FUD when China already actively exerts control over out TV and Movies without military supremacy. Also the majority of the military budget goes to salary, so you couldn't reduce budget by 50% without serious consequences to our capability. The Russians and the Chinese barely spend any money at all on salaries comparatively. with each soldier costing a fraction of a single US private. [1]. Moreover, the Chinese defense budget is increasing faster than their GDP, around 8-9% per year. https://www.csis.org/analysis/understanding-chinas-2021-defense-budget https://www.csis.org/analysis/understanding-chinas-2021-defe...
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat’s a good theory, now see what happens if your democratically elected government tries to loosen copyright restrictions. The US regularly flexes it’s might over friend and neutral country alike in order to protect its perceived economic interests. This means that you’re only free in so much as you’re already aligned with what the US wants. Better than China, sure. But not great.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoI must have forgotten about that time America sent its gun boats in to depose a democratically elected government over a disagreement about copyright law.
- ashtonkem 5y agoDon’t be silly; there are multiple ways to strong arm another country well and short of full invasion. My point is more a response to the world being free because of America. America acts like an imperial power over the rest of the world. It strong arms allies into complying with its economic wishes, and it regularly overthrows weaker neutral governments for similar reasons. Someone in South America would openly laugh at the idea that they’re free because of America, given how many democratically elected governments we’ve overthrown down there.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoThe only time America really throws its economic weight around these days is when it enforces sanctions. The countries targeted by these sanctions are not generally regarded as beacons of freedom. > regularly overthrows weaker neutral governments for similar reasons. Name one neutral democratically elected government deposed by America since the conclusion of the cold war. > Someone in South America would openly laugh at the idea that they’re free because of America, given how many democratically elected governments we’ve overthrown down there. South America has had many leftist governments with a hostile foreign policy towards America over the past several decades. They generally seem to be getting on okay. Edit: down vote if you must, but counter arguments would be welcome!
- williesleg 5y agoNot more than China and India. Get with it China bots. Try harder next time.
- ekianjo 5y agoOnly if you naively cherry pick nations to make a clickbait title.
- becquerel 5y agoHow is it clickbait? Nations like Morocco, Switzerland and Sweden are all industrialized nations, and not tiny enclaves no Westerner has ever heard of.
- boringg 5y agoThey are tiny in their population size and I wouldn't say Morocco is a heavily industrialized nation (even though they have 30M people @ 3000 GDP/pp). That said I believe the US military is moving towards a greener future where possible. They have invested in renewables since the aughts and are constantly looking at new technologies in the space. Actually a bit of a coveted buyer of tech if you can prove that your product is viable.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoHow much are they spending on defense and will they with their current defenses be able to resist China or Russia if the US military is not around?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dionian 5y agoHow does China compare? They are building tons of coal plants as we speak
- CraigJPerry 5y agoAbout half of the US currently. China - ~7 tons CO2 per capita US - ~15 tons CO2 per capita You have to discount the China figure further though because of the balance of goods made in China (and thus CO2 produced) and shipped to the US. I.e. the 15 tons per capita hides the outsourced emissions. Or you could go for the simpler analysis - which country has huge swathes of it’s population running AC, heating, huge cars and a “disposable” approach to manufactured goods consumption.
- swader999 5y agoPer capita doesn't really matter to the temp.
- bgee 5y agoYou are correct that per capita doesn't matter to the global climate but it's only relevant because regulations are enforced on a nation-based fashion. As a Chinese national living in the U.S., I would like my fellow countryperson to have the same standard of living as an average American does. Unfortunately this view is not shared by many Americans, including Obama [0]. [0] "...if over a billion Chinese citizens have the same living patterns as Australians and Americans do right now then all of us are in for a very miserable time, the planet just can't sustain it": https://www.abc.net.au/7.30/face-to-face-with-obama/2673356 https://www.abc.net.au/7.30/face-to-face-with-obama/2673356
- ahelwer 5y agoOur objective is to support the most humans with the least environmental impact, so yeah it does matter - unless you believe certain lives worldwide have more of a right to exist than others?
- 5y ago
- ashtonkem 5y agoI did the math on this a while ago, and I think it came out to the US Army alone consuming 1% of the world’s oil production in just oil. This was just straight oil into vehicle gas tanks, and didn’t even include whatever fossil fuels might be used to produce all the electricity that they also use.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoPlease submit it to peer review along with your comparisons of Chinese and Russian spend and the consequences of either of those being the new world police if the USA just stopped doing its thing because of needing to consume 1% of the oil production.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI believe you’ve just made up an argument you thought I was making. This is quite annoying, please stop.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoI did not make up anything. I asked you kindly to provide your incredible findings on US military oil expenditures, and the relevant comparisons with other nations like Russia and China, ideally for peer review in a qualified journal or a public blog.
- jdmoreira 5y agoare you asking an HN commenter to publish a peer review paper on the basis of his back of the envelope calculations just because you got somehow offended with the possibility of his calculations being true? That’s really sad.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> I did not make up anything. I asked you kindly to provide your incredible findings This is called 'sealioning'. It’s a documented harassment technique. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning
- egberts 5y agoMy bullshit detector is off the chart.
- tristor 5y agoThis doesn't surprise me in the least. The DoD and all of its sub-departments, is exempt from EPA regulations. There is no driving force to make more efficient and less polluting military equipment other than the desire to improve logistics or reduce costs. Considering that the military gets preferential pricing on its fuel purchases compared to typical civilian markets, it doesn't have any of the standard market or regulatory pressures to contend with which motivate innovations focused on energy efficiency. When a contractor is designing a new weapons platform, they focus exclusively on other factors of design, energy efficiency essentially isn't even a consideration as long as it can be refueled mid-mission. But really, if we want to discuss the US military and the environment, their carbon footprint is the least of my concerns. A bigger concern for me is how they've improperly handled and disposed of MASSIVE quantities of toxic waste over the years and continue to do so. One report I read concluded that nearly half of all PFOAs and PFOSs in the water systems in the continental US originated from military base runoff from them simply dumping expired/excess firefighting chemicals on the ground into open trenches. Basically every US military base inside the US is a superfund site the moment it is fully decommissioned and turned over to non-DoD control. That should tell you something. Carbon footprints aren't meaningless, but they're nearly so, compared to the far worse forms of pollution the US military does routinely that directly impacts everyone that lives nearby (I live in "Military City, USA", ask me about water quality here...).
- mandmandam 5y ago> The DoD and all of its sub-departments, is exempt from EPA regulations Ho-ly shit. I mean I know blatant corruption is basically under ever political rock ever everywhere, but that is... wow.
- abduhl 5y agoThis is not corruption, this is as designed. The DoD's mission is national security and Congress has determined that national security trumps environmental protections which, to be quite honest, are mostly procedural hurdles put in place to slow down innovation and progress. The question is whether or not we should hinder our ability to protect ourselves from external (and internal at this point) enemies in order to (possibly) protect the environment. Congress has decided that we shouldn't. You can, of course, come to a different conclusion, but I doubt Congress ever will.
- swader999 5y agoHey but at least it keeps the oil lanes open to all those authoritarian regimes we prop up. Especially when we deny our neighbors to the north a pipe.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]