3 ms·
Just a reminder that Robinhood didn't prevent this. Automatic increases to clearing house collateral requirements prevented this. If Robinhood allowed those tra
by vkou 5y ago
Just a reminder that Robinhood didn't prevent this. Automatic increases to clearing house collateral requirements prevented this. If Robinhood allowed those trades to go through, they'd have been cut off from the clearing houses, and none of their customers would have been able to perform any trades.
Unfortunately, due to the low level of public understanding of how stock trades actually settle, the conspiracy narrative you're presenting was the one that made it into the public consciousness.
There's no such thing as an instant stock trade. Retail brokerages are a leaky abstraction over what is actually an incredibly messy settlement layer. This abstraction holds when everything is normal, and leaks when stock prices become too volatile.
- jw1224 5y agoNo, Robinhood’s collateral requirements were increased by their clearing house only because their clearing house were on the hook to lose billions to retail investors during January’s short squeezes. The same clearing house used by Robinhood were the same people illegally naked-shorting GME. This is collusion, plain and simple. No part of this is representative of the “free” market.
- vkou 5y agoNonsense. Clearing houses don't lose anything during a short squeeze, as long as funds committed to a trade actually clear. They aren't the ones on the hook for a short exploding. They raise their collateral requirements during a period of high volatility. As it turns out, when you run a zero-fee brokerage, you don't just have a couple of extra billions of dollars lying around that you can put up as collateral on a moment's notice. > illegally naked-shorting GME. You don't understand how shorts work. You don't need anyone doing a naked short for a stock to exceed 100% short. This has been explained hundreds of times, both here, and on Reddit.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jw1224 5y ago> The only people allowed to naked short are market makers The SEC made naked short selling illegal after the 2008 financial crisis. Market makers are not allowed to naked short. > Clearing houses don't lose anything during a short squeeze, as long as funds committed to a trade actually clear Exactly my point — as long as funds clear, which they were at risk of not doing, thus putting clearing houses like the DTCC on the hook, in the event of a margin call. Let me break it down: - Melvin Capital were aggressively shorting GME - Retail investors used Robinhood to take advantage of a short squeeze opportunity - During the short squeeze, Citadel (who partly own Melvin Capital) bailed-out Melvin with a $2.8bn investment - Citadel is Robinhood's prime brokerage, paying them for preferential order flow - Citadel's global Head of Operations is on the board of the DTCC, the clearing house responsible for increasing collateral requirements - As a market maker, Citadel care a huge amount about GME exploding, because if Melvin Capital were margin-called, Citadel end up holding the bag - If Citadel are margin-called themselves, the DTCC clearing house end up holding the bag. This is really just the tip of the iceberg. I'm consistently surprised at how defensive comments on HN seem to be towards hedge funds and the whole short-squeeze debacle — which is still very much ongoing. I can happily point anyone with an open mind in the direction of excellent research summarising the ongoing situation, and there's mounds of evidence indicating hedge funds never actually covered in January. Not to mention the math on vote tallies in GME's latest 8-K filing from 2 days ago clearly proves more GME shares exist than should be mathematically possible, enabled only by naked short sellers who never covered. Oh, and whilst I'm at it, their 8-K also disclosed that they've been working with the SEC since May to assist them with an active investigation in to market manipulation. Doesn't get much more obvious than that, does it? But if it's easier to turn a blind eye, then each to their own.
- ahtihn 5y ago> Not to mention the math on vote tallies in GME's latest 8-K filing from 2 days ago clearly proves more GME shares exist than should be mathematically possible, enabled only by naked short sellers who never covered. You mean the 8-K that showed 55M votes out of 70M shares outstanding? How does that prove anything? Maybe you're confusing shares outstanding with the float.
- flefto 5y agoIf so, why doesn’t this happen all the time? In fact, when has it EVER happened before, or since? If it was normal wouldn’t there regularly be stocks that can’t be bought but can be sold?
- vkou 5y agoBecause stocks valuations don't jump by 2000%, with volumes up 3000% 'all the time'. And when they do, they aren't solely driven by retail investor mania pig-piling the exact same brokerage. And, uh, particular brokerages have stopped uni-directional trades for volatile stocks in the past, for the exact same reason. You may notice that no retail brokerage makes any guarantees to its customers that they will be able to trade anything, anytime they want. They don't carry a collateral that can meet any such guarantee.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rokobobo 5y agoI’m not a fan of Robinhood, but everything that vkou has been saying is true. My understanding is that Robinhood is self-clearing, not that Citadel is its prime brokerage. The clearing margin requirement came from NSCC. Clearing margins CANNOT be satisfied using client funds. So it’s Robinhood’s own capital—and whatever credit lines they’ve negotiated—that would need to meet those requirements. If I deposit 100k into Robinhood and keep it there as cash for 2 years, then one day I plunk all of it into GME, then until all my trades settle two days later, Robinhood will have increased clearing margin requirements based on the VaR of my unsettled trades. (Unless, my trade offsets someone else’s from within Robinhood, in which case I believe RH’s margin would reduce—but I’m not sure about this part.) And if one day after my trades, GME’s stock goes up 10x, the VaR goes up roughly 10x as well. Even though I would have a claim to a lot higher value in my account once everything is settled, until the trades are settled, it’s a major cash crunch for RH. The fact of the matter is that RH was not under-capitalized or have disproportionately small credit lines as a portion of their AUM, as compared to other brokerages. It’s just that their users were the ones that acted in a most coordinated way on a stock whose VaR was going through the roof.
- Miner49er 5y ago> Automatic increases to clearing house collateral requirements prevented this. I don't think they were automatic? They were raised way more then what was standard.
- tl 5y agoRobinhood implemented restrictions before any other platform though they were not the only ones to do so, held restrictions longer than any of their competitors, used restrictions (sell only) in a way that was unique to Robinhood and falsely made public claims (later to be retracted) that they had chosen to do some or all of this "for the public good." I would not trust them with a single dollar.
- vkou 5y agoThat's because Robinhood had the bulk of the retail mania, and were thus the most affected brokerage. Other retail brokerages, that were less popular with the WSB crowd never even stopped purchases of GME, because GME is was a small fraction of their trade volume - and thus, their collateral obligations did not grow much. You are correct for not wanting to use them to trade, for two reasons. 1. If you are actively trading, you are almost certainly throwing away money. Don't actively trade. Just buy an index fund and forget about it. 2. If you are actively trading, and you are a serious, informed individual (which already excludes the overwhelming majority of people who were buying GME), and you want 24/7 uptime, you shouldn't use a discount zero-fee brokerage that's popular on WSB. They won't be able to guarantee that uptime when WSB decides to take one side of a huge trade.