11 ms·
A US socialite who gave it all up to become a Carmelite nun
- rmk 5y agoWhat a remarkable, long-lived life! It's common to turn one's attention to spiritual pursuits in one's old age, but a full third of one's life is very long and unusual indeed. An excellent human interest story!
- akudha 5y agoIt is amazing that she could do such a radical change overnight, that too at an older age. Like, how can one go from luxurious lifestyle to sleeping on the floor overnight? Most people would have trouble giving up their luxuries for a couple of days. Incredible!
- susiecambria 5y agoIn action it was overnight, but she was drawn to being a nun from an early age. I'm sure that this idea, this dream was always in the back of her mind. But I do take your point. Dropping everything. Heck, I can't miss a coffee in the morning! But it does show internal (and external) fortitude.
- tw04 5y agoNot to downplay her commitment, but given she joined immediately after her husband died, perhaps she wasn’t thinking it was going to be for a full third of her life when she started.
- rmk 5y agoNo doubt that is almost certainly true, but if you read the article, you will find that she was intending to become a nun when she fell in love and started a family. It sounds like she practically postponed her dream of becoming a nun and got the family responsibilities over with before heading to the cloister.
- Thorrez 5y ago>On her 61st birthday [...] [s]he told her guests she had devoted her first 30 years of life to herself, the second 30 to her children and that the last third of her life would be dedicated to God. Even if it was just a joke, she probably at least knew it was a possibility.
- lurquer 5y agoReminds me of that Nun who gave it all up to become an Austrian socialite. Van Trap something?
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_von_Trapp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_von_Trapp
- astrange 5y agoNot a very flattering picture.
- geerlingguy 5y agoIn her case, I think she was still a 'postulate', basically in preparation to become a nun, and the 'Mother Superior' or whatever the head nun was at her convent told her she should marry Captain Avon Trapp. Sometimes reality is stranger than fiction!
- iammisc 5y agoI don't think she gave it up to be a socialite. She gave it up to be with the children. Her biography is very interesting
- dragonwriter 5y agoShe “gave it up” because she was directed by her religious superior to do so, and was initially unhappy about it. (As well as shifting timing related to external political events, the popular musical retelling changes this, because it makes a less simplistically charming narrative.)
- TMWNN 5y agoDolores Hart (<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolores_Hart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolores_Hart>) left Hollywood to become a Benedictine nun.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- neom 5y agoI watched this movie a few years ago, I highly recommend it: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1613092/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1613092/ Anyway, it features a guy who left his well paid finance job to go dedicate his life to working at the Kalighat Home for the Dying. The whole movie is inspiring, but that particular section stuck with me. It's stories like this article and the one in the movie I mentioned that make me excited for later life. Although, sometimes I think I should do it today...
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoYou should check out Katie Davis Majors'[1] story for someone who took the plunge early, and never regretted it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katie_Davis_(missionary) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katie_Davis_(missionary)
- pstuart 5y ago> make me excited for later life The trick is to be excited for today. Of course that's much easier said than done ;-)
- cortesoft 5y agoI am torn on this. On one hand I applaud someone who follows their dream in spite of societal pressures. On the other hand, she only saw her son twice in 30 years. I would be pretty upset at my mom if she did that, and I can’t imagine doing that to my kids. Not meeting my grandkids, even though I am still alive? That is unimaginable to me.
- xwolfi 5y agoBah god is more important than your whiny grandkids, and by spending all this time in prayer she's surely helping them. Religion is an ideological cancer: no need to be torn, this person followed an obsessive sickness, not a dream.
- narrator 5y agoEdit: You actually got canceled. I retract my comment.
- chairmanwow1 5y agoYeah, I think this fact shifts this story out of laudable territory for me. I think this is a really sad story.
- canadianfella 5y ago> she only saw her son twice in 30 years. She is a piece of shit and religion needs to be criticized more often.
- tssva 5y agoIt sounds like you probably have a fairly healthy and loving relationship with your mother. Not all family relationships are that way whether at the fault of the parents, children or both. I recommend not projecting your family history on to others and judging them based upon it. Some parents and some children don't deserve to be seen more than twice in 30 years. Some children should never suffer being exposed to their grandparents.
- 5y ago
- FounderBurr 5y agoSo she gave them all her money and they kept her behind bars for the rest of her life. How is this not a cult?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 5y ago> they kept her behind bars for the rest of her life You are assuming she had no choice to leave.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- draw_down 5y agoWell, what’s a cult? A cult is a group you don’t like.
- jollybean 5y agoA religion is the embodiment of spiritual principle. A cult is an institution which exists to empower and enrich leadership structure of the cult. Given the infallibility of humans, there can be lot of cultishness in religion. Paradoxically, a lot of cult members are actually true believers, often trying to - and doing - quite some good, meaning there can in many cases be some good 'conscientious externalizations' of even some otherwise crappy cults. This is harder to grasp but it's real. There are many otherwise secular groups that exist in this sphere especially among 1) ideologically oriented groups - and 2) corporations. My personal exposure to these kinds of environments triggers that 'weird feeling' whenever I visit such-and-such campus, in the Silicon Valley and elsewhere. There are political organizations, even 'nice ones' in 'nice countries' that take children, not even teens, off in isolation to places like 'camps on islands' to 'teach them their values'. Because of the lack of obvious religious artifacts, it doesn't set of the usual triggers, but when taking a more holistic view ... it seems a bit unhealthy. Even more meta, it seems to me that cultures that have very deep and complex behavioural patterns, idioms, norms, language structure etc. exhibit a lot of the same attributes. You could go so far as to point at many 'major cultures' ... but to be a little less controversial, my experience with both Amish and Mennonite community certainly has elements of this. But I reserve judgment. It's complicated. And also they are some of the most inconceivably kind people on the planet. FYI they are effectively pacifists, as 'God's Children should not take up arms against one another' etc. - they won't join the Army. Edit: from a purely secular perspective, where the notion of 'there being a god or not' or where 'beliefs' etc. irrelevant ... than really what is the difference between the Soviet Union, for example, and a cult? They exhibit all of the same artifacts. The only difference being, in some cults, there might be some kind of supernatural extra beliefs to go along with it. Stalin used (perverted?) a secular ideology in the same way as a cult would use their own system of beliefs. 99% of the resulting systematic and authoritarian externalizations have nothing to do with the 'core beliefs' in both cases. Edit 2: whether 'core principles' are ideological, spiritual, corporatist, nationalist, or even cultural, you get a lot of the same type of group dynamics forming.
- DavidPeiffer 5y agoHere's a similar, more recent story about a banker turned nun. Good listen if you have some time. https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/deathsexmoney/episodes/banker-called-to-convent-nun-death-sex-money https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/deathsexmoney/episodes/...
- user3939382 5y agoThe Jesuit Guide to Almost Everything by James Martin is autobiographical and tells about his experience going from a Wharton MBA, accountant at GE making a lot of money to becoming a priest; sitting in a hot room in Haiti with bugs inside to take care of the sick and poor. It really hit home with me because it was my dream to get a Wharton MBA. Then he says his balance would be higher at the ATM every week but it felt very meaningless. There’s also an interesting side story about the psychopaths (my word) in management at GE.
- nautilus12 5y agoAlot of these comments seem to be some form of trying to justify her decision as not being unique or spiritually inspired. I would encourage you to let things be what they are and not over analyze them
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- premium-komodo 5y agoFrom what I understand, the Carmelites differ from some other Christians because they do long contemplations. I often wonder if their contemplations are basically the same thing as my (Buddhist) meditation. I suspect they are, but that we just have different metaphors about what's happening. Anyone interested in this possible overlap between Christianity and Buddhism might check out the videos of John Butler, an English man who has contemplated/meditated for decades.
- pyuser583 5y agoA very different San Francisco. I’ve had dinner at that Hilton several times.
- VoodooJuJu 5y agoI think she had her priorities a little mixed up. When you have a son, your duty, your number one priority, is him. Abandoning your child is a crime against humanity.
- personlurking 5y agoI think the problem could have been avoided if she had entered a less strict convent/order (I imagine such a thing exists). That way she could devote her life to it yet still have visiting rights under normal conditions. As an anecdote/aside, I have a long time friend who - when we met - wasn't religious or spiritual in any outwardly noticeable way. She had a handful of interests, enjoyed discussing many life topics, and had a well-paying sales job with a good company. As the years went on, she had three kids from unhealthy romantic relationships, became more and more spiritual and gave up her job to start a part-time, new age micro business. Not only did her income go way, way down to the point that she constantly struggles to pay her bills, but everything she says is spiritually-motivated. In a real sense, she stopped being a person and became a mouth-piece of her spiritual beliefs. I recently realized she's no different than a monk or a nun (whose beliefs are weaved into everything they say), only she still lives in the real world. As a result of all this, our deep and diverse weekly discussions became less and less frequent (to the point of being almost non-existent), not to mention extremely unidimensional. She might as well have gone to live in a convent because I lost my friend all the same. Am I happy she's happy doing what she loves? Sure, but I also mourn the almost complete loss of the person I knew.
- codingdave 5y ago> no different than a monk or a nun (whose beliefs are weaved into everything they say) How many monks or nuns have you know? I grew up going to Catholic schools, and can assure you that monks, nun, and priests are real people who have real conversation. Maybe not the ones who choose to join the specific order the woman from the article joined, but in general, yes. I can sympathize that your friend grew apart from you. I've had friends do the same. But that is life. It would be short-sighted to write off entire groups of people because of one person's experience.
- personlurking 5y ago>I grew up going to Catholic schools Me, too. Church every Sunday and Bible studies every week (for many years), plus Catholic school (for a year). I'm not saying they are one-dimentional. I'm saying their views on many subjects tend to be filtered through their religious belief. Different from a plumber, a banker or a teacher who wouldn't filter their perspectives on many subjects through their vocation.
- weinzierl 5y agoI had a Déjà vu reading this BBC article because it is so close to the original Twitter thread, which appeared on my timeline a few days ago, that in my opinion it is borderline plagiarism. At least the BBC had the decency to link to the original source which most other newspapers never do nowadays. To save you the detour to the BBC website here is the original: https://twitter.com/4t9ner/status/1401458601462403077?s=21 https://twitter.com/4t9ner/status/1401458601462403077?s=21
- imwillofficial 5y agoI mean at 60, that’s a ton of socialite living she got done. She only gave up a retirement.
- agomez314 5y agoI wish the article delved more into the rich spiritual life that these people have. The article dwells on the material goods and lavish lifestyle and abruptly shoves up the fact that she abandoned it all - almost as if the author can't believe it herself! Recently I passed the Philadelphia downtown and noticed an amish family selling flowers from their truck. A large crowd gathered and wondered at the sight of the industrious family in 19th century garb. It's a sight unlike many city-dwellers, especially young people, get to see: chastity, family, religious devotion. People of today are so used to living in a culture that tells them owning more, having sex and expressing "your identity" is the path to happiness that many become stumped when shown this amish family doing business in a world so totally different than their own. I love it. This is diversity of thought and lifestyle. In comparison, modern culture is extremely homogeneous and boring. I appreciate the witness of Ann Russel as a person who shows us that there's more to life than what we can see and touch, and that there's great joy in seeking spiritual union with God.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dangus 5y agoYour views remind me of this article I read a while back: https://thefederalist.com/2019/10/18/gender-studies-professor-calls-twerking-with-lizzo-an-act-of-political-defiance/ https://thefederalist.com/2019/10/18/gender-studies-professo... I find the concept of pleasure oppression to be interesting. Essentially, the idea is that puritanical roots teach us that things that are pleasurable must be sinful and wrong, and that the oppression is felt most strongly by marginalized groups. Your positive manifestation of the simple life is living like the Amish. What you’ve omitted is the fact that the Amish/Mennonite societies run as authoritarian patriarchies, where the bishop figure and head of household (the husband) have the final word. I think there is a misconception that religious people have about the non-religious where they assume non-religious people are living a life of consumerism and materialism in lieu of God. Ultimately, those concepts aren’t related: believing in a particular brand of God isn’t a prerequisite to helping one another and living a life of service to others. The non-religious just don’t accept biblical stories as fact, and they might believe that any sort of afterlife is not a realistic expectation. The religious and non-religious alike live within a wide spectrum of materialism. There are certainly materialistic Christians and materialistic atheists, but there are also the opposite. Locking yourself in a self-imposed religious prison for 30 years is on the extreme end of the spectrum. The reason it’s a news article is because it’s an incredibly rare, strange thing to do. In my opinion, this reputation of strangeness is rightfully deserved.
- bobthechef 5y agoReminds me of Dolores Hart (who is now an abbess, IIRC). I can't say the comments here shock me, exactly, but they certainly are revealing. Specifically, so many of them pass judgement on this woman as if she had done something terrible and project their own categories onto her, characterizing this, without the slightest shred of evidence, as somehow sad. How lost one must be to claim such a thing! Sister Mary Joseph had only chosen to be a Carmelite nun after her husband had died and her children had grown up. She had no dependents or husbands for whom or to whom she was responsible anymore. She was not a single mother who had somehow abandoned her children. Would she miss her children? Probably, but she found a higher calling for which she sacrificed such contact and there is no higher calling than the religious life. In her case, she clearly felt called to devote herself in this particular way. I have no reason to presume that she didn't know what she was getting herself into (besides, religious orders do not simply let anybody in who isn't serious or even qualified in basic ways). Do her children miss her? Arguably, yes, but if they remain in the faith and see the world through a Catholic lens, they are likely to be joyful about having pursued this calling. There is nothing sad about it. It is a very joyful and wonderful thing. It is inspiring. Catholics (not of the cafeteria variety, anyway) find happiness in sacrificing lesser goods for higher goods and in the sanctification that comes with the suffering life will inevitably inflict on us. So let's just say she didn't join the order to be comfortable, but to grow spiritually in a particularly austere order. If you aren't Catholic, this may not make much sense to you. Someone who is a slave to comfort and whose horizons are severely limited and parochial will think this is downright crazy. But the Catholic understanding of reality, of Man, and of God imparts a vertical dimension and a breadth that is absent otherwise. Catholic anthropology is not reductive, and Man, after all, does not live by bread alone.
- dctoedt 5y agoI feel a little bit sorry for the woman's kids and grandkids, because having nearby grandparents, and specifically grandmothers, in your life seems to confer certain advantages in natural selection. [0] Just this morning my wife and I were talking, almost excitedly, about what our last "job" will be: Helping to raise our grandkids, if and when we have any (in the not-too-distant future, perhaps). - In the grandkids' infancy: Doing lots of playing, talking, laughing, reading to them, and other interaction with the little buggers, to help their brains develop. - From their births onward: Being sources of patient, calm, unqualified love, taking delight in their mere existence (but always deferring to their parents). Giving their parents a break in childcare duties from time to time. And of course your own kids are your kids forever. My parents and in-laws are long gone, yet even now I sometimes catch myself thinking, hmm, I should ask Mom and Dad about that. My wife has said much the same thing. We both want to be around for our own kids for as long as we're able and not a burden. We're both really looking forward to being grandparents. It gives us a(nother) reason to continue eating right and getting lots of exercise to stay in shape: We want to be physically up to the task for as long as we can manage it. [0] https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2019/02/07/692088371/living-near-your-grandmother-has-evolutionary-benefits https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2019/02/07/6920883...