6 ms·
> "The problem is that, in the past half century, a different type of food processing has been developed," says Fernanda Rauber, a nutritional epidemiologist at
by crazygringo 5y ago
> "The problem is that, in the past half century, a different type of food processing has been developed," says Fernanda Rauber, a nutritional epidemiologist at the University of São Paulo, Brazil, about what we now call "“ultra-processed foods”. "These substances would not be found in our kitchen. Usually, they contain little to no proportion of real foods."
This is ridiculous. Processed (or "ultra-processed") foods are mainly flour (wheat, corn, etc.), sugar (sugarcane, sugar beet), and refined oils (soy, canola). All of these are found in the kitchen and are very much "real foods".
Yes, processed foods include small amounts of ingredients like emulsifiers and natural flavors, but by weight they're a tiny proportion. The idea that they make up most or all of a product by weight is utterly ludicrous.
It's fine and good to be aware that processed food doesn't contain the "antioxidants and phytochemicals" found in unprocessed foods, and they may be calorie-dense and low in fiber. But it's unhelpful and utterly dishonest when nutritionists or scientists make absurd claims about processed foods being made mostly out of ingredients not found in our own kitchens.
- creamynebula 5y ago> Processed (or "ultra-processed") foods are mainly flour (wheat, corn, etc.), sugar (sugarcane, sugar beet), and refined oils (soy, canola). All of these are found in the kitchen and are very much "real foods" I wouldn't say so, sugar and the oils don't exist in nature on their own, and primates can't really eat wheat, corn and other grains.
- dilap 5y agoRefined seed oils contain polyunsaturated fats (and more specifically, omega-6 polyunsaturated fats, and more specifically yet, linoleic acid) in far higher concentrations than traditional foods. I believe this is the main thing that makes processed food unhealthy, and, indeed, is the main driver of the epidemic of the so-called "diseases of civilization" (obesity, diabetes, cancer, etc) that most of the world is experiencing. This series of blog posts does an excellent job of summarizing the evidence: https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/what-causes-chronic-disease https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/what-causes-chronic-disease
- bumby 5y agoWhat are the main causal hypotheses regarding why seed oils lead to obesity? I didn’t see much in the article regarding the mechanism that links the two. I know Catherine Shanahan has written about this link and talks about how easily seed oils cause inflammation through free radicals. But how do we get from inflammation to obesity?
- resoluteteeth 5y agoA lot of research on these topics assumes the existence of metabolic syndrome / syndrome x, which is a hypothetical syndrome that is the supposed to be the common cause of obesity, diabetes, etc. Metabolic syndrome used to be very mainstream but I'm not sure it's taken quite as seriously in the scientific community recently. However, if you do assume the existence of metabolic syndrome, you can pretty much justify a link between anything that could potentially be its cause and obesity. For example, if seed oils cause some sort of metabolic dysfunction resulting in metabolic syndrome, then that would then result in obesity. Obviously, if you assume that obesity is just caused by excess consumption of calories, and that obesity is then the cause of diabetes, and that there is no separate metabolic syndrome it becomes harder to justify this kind of theory. That link doesn't explicitly use the terms "metabolic syndrome" or "syndrome x" but it seems like it is probably implicitly assuming its existence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dilap 5y agoThe million dollar question! No one really knows. There are some theories. One thing is linoleic acid converts into endocannabinoids, which stimulate appetite. Too much n6, too much appetite, obesity, is the theory. If you google around on e.g. pubmeb you can find various papers proposing this. But there's probably more to it than that; there are pig and mouse studies where the animals are fed isocaloric diets, but the animals eating high LA get fat. So that strongly suggests that it's not just a appetite-based overeating thing. The blog hyperlipid proposed a theory involving ROS signaling at a cellular level; my knowledge of biology and metabolism is sadly minimal, but at a very high level I think the theory is something like, "having too much linoleic acid in the diet signals cells to remain unnaturally insulin-sensitive and accumulate fat". See also: the blog Fire in a Bottle, which tries to summarize the hyperlipid theory at a less low-level, technical level. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27350414/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27350414/ https://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2013/08/protons-so-far-some-sort-of-summary.html https://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2013/08/protons-so-f... https://fireinabottle.net/the-ros-theory-of-obesity/ https://fireinabottle.net/the-ros-theory-of-obesity/
- c54 5y agoI think this retort is sorta factually correct but missing the author's point. Totally true that by mass the preservatives aren't a lot, but that doesn't mean the refined products of naturally occurring plants are 'real foods' in the sense the author intends it. One way to think of this is that a food which is refined moves further and further away from the original 'real food' as it naturally occurs. ~80% of a wheat 'corn' is the white part, ~20% of a soy bean is oil, and 15-20% of a beet is sugar. Similarly, one apple yields about 1/3c of juice. Drinking 2c worth of juice (in an hour?) is fairly common but nobody ever eats 6 apples in an hour
- crazygringo 5y agoThe quoted epidemiologist says "These substances would not be found in our kitchen." I'm not disagreeing at all about refinement or the health. I'm just saying these refined substances are absolutely found in our kitchen, and used in quantity. They're nothing special or unique to processed foods. If you bake bread or cake or brownies, for basic recipes it's nutritionally virtually identical to processed crackers, cookies, and bars.
- drewcoo 5y agoThis is the other half of that quote, if we want to take it in context: "Usually, they contain little to no proportion of real foods." And those sentences were likely in a larger context but chosen by the author as a way to say something the reader could relate to.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoSimple truth - anything made with flour and sugar is literally poisoning you, whether quickly or slowly. Doesn't matter how much love your Nana added to the cookies; they still give you diabetes.
- germinalphrase 5y agoThey potentially give you diabetes.
- bsder 5y agoMostly the problem isn't the processed food but the sheer density of calories. It's quite hard to eat 3500 calories of steak. It's really easy to eat 3500 calories of snack chips.
- worik 5y agoPossibly. But probably the biggest problem for westerners like me is that we know so little about nutrition, despite studying it for decades. Turns out living organisms are extremely complicated. In our intellectual tradition we take that little knowledge and use it as if it were a solid and complete set of facts. Truly: A little knowledge is a dangerous thing
- codingdave 5y agoJust because a food came from a vegetable does not mean that it still retains the same nutrition. Corn syrup does not have the same value as corn, just as the first most obvious example. Nobody is worried about their source material "by weight". People are worried about whether there is any actual nutrition value in the food.
- klodolph 5y agoWe can worry about that without saying, "These substances would not be found in our kitchen." It's either false or misleading. I'm guessing these quotes are taken so far out of context that they've become meaningless. It's possible the speaker was referring to something specific with "these substances", but we'll never know by reading the article.
- worik 5y agoIt depends if you classify highly processed fine ground, bleached, and sieved flour as a "real food" Same goes for the sugars. The hydrogenated fats. Those "flours", sugars, and fats make up the bulk of that food. The hippies were right: Eat food, mostly plants, mostly raw, and make it taste nice.
- Angostura 5y agoYou seem to be using 'ultra-processed' and 'processed' as synonymns, in this case they are not. You are giving examples of processed culinary ingredients https://www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/what_is_ultra-processed_food https://www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/what_is_ultra-processed_... or https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5986467/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5986467/ From the linked article above: The most commonly eaten ultra-processed foods in the UK are: Industrialised bread (11 per cent) Pre-packaged meals (7.7 per cent) Breakfast cereals (4.4 per cent) Sausages and other reconstituted meat products (3.8 per cent)
- crazygringo 5y agoNo. I'm just using "processed" as a shorthand for "ultra-processed". All of the "ultra-processed" examples you give are exactly what I'm talking about -- industrialized bread and breakfast cereals are made of precisely the flour, sugar and oil I'm referring to.
- Angostura 5y agoJust as long as you are clear that the terms have precise meanings which you are using incorrectly
- crazygringo 5y agoJust as long as you are clear that nothing I said was incorrect, even though I was using both terms.
- Angostura 5y agoWell its incorrect to the extent that the post is specifically about issues concerning things like pre-made meals an sausages, and your rebuttal is that these concerns don't effect things like flour or sugar as ingredients. It's rather like me saying gun control is an issue and you pointing out that iron ore seldom kills anyone.