4 ms·
The weirdly tribal support for nuclear kind of confuses me. Like, 10 years ago I thought nuclear was an essential part of the future energy mix, just as a sens
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
The weirdly tribal support for nuclear kind of confuses me.
Like, 10 years ago I thought nuclear was an essential part of the future energy mix, just as a sensible hedge against other things not working out. It's maybe been 5 years since that became obviously unnecessary as renewables continue to progress.
My opinion on nuclear hasn't really shifted in absolute terms. It's still much better than coal for example. But the possibility and now near certainty of solar, wind and batteries being better and cheaper has put them way ahead in relative terms. It's renewables that I've been getting new information or confirmation of old information which was speculative in that time frame. Nuclear hasn't really changed.
The people who remain loudly pro-nuclear, then seem in fact to be super pessimistic about renewables compared with me, rather than super positive about nuclear.
As you kind of confirm with your edits, you think solar is inadequate, when I think it is one of the most astonishly successful power technologies ever conceived by man.
How did we end up with such divergent views on renewables if we're broadly in tune about nuclear?
- hocuspocus 5y ago> But the possibility and now near certainty of solar, wind and batteries being better and cheaper has put them way ahead in relative terms. Cheaper, most certainly, but better, according to what metric exactly? PV has a higher carbon footprint than nuclear. Same for wind if you add storage. Both require at least one order of magnitude more raw materials (mostly extracted using fossil fuels). Land use is also an issue with wind turbines, not all countries can put them offshore. And then there's the geopolitical angle and the huge dependence on China. I know that the nuclear fuel supply chain has its own issues as well, but again the amount of raw materials is relatively small and fuel can be stockpiled. It's not about being for or against renewables. They have a very real environmental footprint and we're past the point where we can simply disregard that.
- bildung 5y ago> PV has a higher carbon footprint than nuclear. Not inherently, though. This is only because the current energy production is 90% non-renewable globally. See e.g. here, page 11: https://group.vattenfall.com/de/siteassets/de/verantwortung/klima--umwelt/nachhaltigkeit/life-cycle-assessment---2019--lca.pdf https://group.vattenfall.com/de/siteassets/de/verantwortung/...
- jfengel 5y agoThe answer, of course, is "oil". The oil industry funds anti-renewable but pro-nuclear efforts[1]. That might seem counterintuitive, since nuclear also competes with fossil fuels, but the fossil fuel industry knows that nuclear plants take a very long time to build. During that time, more fossil fuel plants get built, and the renewables industry struggles and possibly withers. That creates a stripe of Internet commenter convinced that nuclear plants are the solution and renewables are terrible. They all use the same lines of reasoning, and it doesn't really matter how many times they're refuted because... well, because this is a playbook that has been used many times over. [1] https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-solar-kochs-20140420-story.html#ixzz30OY6i8BG https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-solar-kochs-20140420-st...
- Dylan16807 5y ago> That creates a stripe of Internet commenter convinced that nuclear plants are the solution and renewables are terrible. I can't recall ever seeing one of those. I hope you're not filing everyone that wants a high nuclear:battery ratio into that box!
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI would put anyone who thought that in that box. The very odd belief that nuclear power does not rely on storage and peaking capacity to deliver electricity when people actually want it, at a price they can afford, and without carbon externalities is one of the key things that indicates to me that nuclear support is an irrational tribal thing. You could easily think nuclear fans live in a parallel dimension where electricity demand is entirely flat and unchanging, so focused are they on the mythical "baseload" to the exclusion of everything else.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> The very odd belief that nuclear power does not rely on storage and peaking capacity to deliver electricity when people actually want it A desire to only have a day's worth of storage is not a belief that storage is unnecessary. > I would put anyone who thought that in that box. > You could easily think nuclear fans live in a parallel dimension where electricity demand is entirely flat and unchanging, so focused are they on the mythical "baseload" to the exclusion of everything else. You're going out of your way to strawman.
- pydry 5y agoNuclear funds a lot of propaganda. More than the carbon lobby, I think.
- elihu 5y agoThe downside of solar is that you'd either need a lot of storage to get through the night, or you'd need geographically-distributed power generation and the ability to move large amounts of power to the other side of the Earth. I'm kind of surprised we aren't already well on our way to building the latter, considering the potential benefits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_grid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_grid
- Dylan16807 5y ago> How did we end up with such divergent views on renewables if we're broadly in tune about nuclear? A big reason is that the price effectiveness of solar and the price effectiveness of solar+batteries are wildly different values.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSo I fully agree with the factual statement you've made here, and disagree with your unstated implication. Storage is much more expensive,yes. So much so that building extra solar (and or wind) and just wasting some of the energy when it's above the demand is cheaper overall then storing every drop of generation with batteries. But how does that impact nuclear vs renewables? Solar plus batteries is cheaper than fossil fuels (without carbon fees!) in many markets and use cases. And continues to get cheaper. That's an amazing thing that we should celebrate. It pretty much guarantees a solution to climate change even if sensible regulation doesn't get implemented. Is nuclear cheaper than fossil if you don't include the carbon and pollution externalities? I don't think it is. So the only hope for it (if we assume renewables all stop working tomorrow and we need a plan B) is widespread government intervention.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> Solar plus batteries is cheaper than fossil fuels (without carbon fees!) in many markets and use cases. Even if you're building out for the worst case scenario? > Is nuclear cheaper than fossil if you don't include the carbon and pollution externalities? I don't think it is. It can be if we stop using NASA-style one-off engineering methods.
- melling 5y agoBill Gates is now part of the tribe https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/11/bill-gates-bullish-on-using-nuclear-power-to-fight-climate-change.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/11/bill-gates-bullish-on-using-...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoBill Gates has been fairly vocally pro-nuclear and down on renewables for a while. He sometimes credits Vaclav Smil with inspiring this opinion. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/03/meet-vaclav-smil-man-who-has-quietly-shaped-how-world-thinks-about-energy https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/03/meet-vaclav-smil-man... I've never really found what he argues particularly compelling. His December 2017 piece, Electric Vehicles: not so fast, seems kind of wrong in retrospect but also pretty empty of intellectual heft.