4 ms·
Germany warns: AI arms race already underway
- z5h 5y agoWhen someone finally rules the world, what will they do next?
- randomopining 5y agoTighten control, extract wealth and live the best life, direct humanity towards what it thinks are valuable endeavors.
- mc32 5y agoI think what tends to happen is what we saw happen in Soviet Russia and Maoist China. "They," at the top, think they know what's best for people (hoi polloi) and start "designing" for that "utopian" society, history be damned.
- chewz 5y agoMake prols vanish underground and enjoy empty beaches, clean air and unspoiled nature. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Penultimate_Truth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Penultimate_Truth
- officialjunk 5y agosolar system
- mirker 5y agoIs there a non-vacuous example of AI being used in this context? Is it matrix multiplication, linear regression, same old control theory, or deep learning?
- ergot_vacation 5y agoIf you want sense of what real AI warfare will look like, look at Cambridge Analytica. Extremely primitive, but still highly effective. The key concept is the ability to sift through vast piles of data, find previously unknown patterns, and then exploit them. Humans have to make one ad for the whole nation. AI can micro-target hundreds or thousands of communities with custom propaganda, often even contradicting itself, achieving a much more powerful result. Now apply this approach to broader conflicts.
- randcraw 5y agoYeah, I think the point of China's term "Informationized Warfare" is to manipulate information flow and content to serve your interests more than your enemy's. If you can distort the perspective of an opponent country's decision makers or twist popular opinion there to foment internal dissent (as Russia famously has done in the US in the past decade w/o using any AI, so far), then you win. I also believe this strategy is not only about conducting occasional violent hot wars but very much about conducting a non-violent day-to-day cold war which is largely invisible to the public (both China's and the US's). China has been waging such a "cold war" in the US for over a decade in their many break-ins onto US computers to steal IP, especially from high-tech and military/intelligence sources. In the last 5 years, they more active in international PR initiatives to promote their economic and political interests. China's AI and data-driven social engineering techniques will surely play an increasing role in daily practices like these. Info-based warfare isn't about killing the enemy as much as weakening them, as Sun Tzu famously wrote, and I believe that's a view that China embraces. If you're patient, you don't need physical war. You can win simply by helping your enemy become more of a dysfunctional loser.
- kevinventullo 5y agoWas Cambridge Analytica highly effective? My understanding was that it was only used by Cruz in the 2016 primaries. In the main election, the Trump campaign found RNC’s data to be more useful than CA’s.
- tpush 5y agoCambridge Analytica was largely a nothing burger [0]. [0] https://twitter.com/nickconfessore/status/1313853996168351747 https://twitter.com/nickconfessore/status/131385399616835174...
- nradov 5y agoThere is no evidence that Cambridge Analytica was "highly effective". How many voters did they convince to change their votes? Please provide a number backed by reliable data.
- not_jd_salinger 5y agoI've worked in Ad Tech for awhile now at many different places. While the data and privacy issues that abound are mind blowing, this process: > sift through vast piles of data, find previously unknown patterns, and then exploit them. is much harder to pull of sucessfuly than you think. Having worked in the weeds with many projects of this nature, in practice these models are wildly less useful and powerful than the people buying the output from them believe. For an individual case, you can exploit this data pretty well to find out shocking amount of personal information about a person. Doing this at scale in a way that doesn't converge into noise is much harder.
- ergot_vacation 5y agoThe interesting (and sinister) thing to consider is how wild this will look if fully built out. We're not just talking about some machine intelligence shuffling troops around in lieu of a general. The advantage of a computer is its vision: it can see the "playing field," the reality it's fighting in, much more broadly and deeply than a human can. It can hold more things in its mind at once. AI warfare isn't computers flying some drones or robotic tanks. AI warfare probably looks like a bunch of small, odd occurrences as both sides probe each other's weaknesses in economics, infrastructure and politics, circling each other like two knife fighters. A bunch of weird, disjointed bursts of propaganda crop up across various media channels, fragmented and often seemingly incoherent, but perfectly targeted. Small, isolated incidents of problems at important institutions start cropping up, shutting them down for weeks or months: Hospitals, minor government agencies, oil pipelines, food processing. Never enough to look like a coherent attack. Knife jabs and dodges, the fighters probing, learning, a/b testing. And then one day it isn't a test anymore. The real strike comes. It isn't a nuke or an invasion. There's no need. Those things are as outdated as tying sharp stones to sticks. The AI knows just where to hit, in just the right way, and like a Vulcan death grip one pinch sets the whole system collapsing on itself. It will take humans a decade to even fully understand what happened. If they have that luxury. The atom bomb changed warfare via incomprehensible destruction. AI will change warfare via incomprehensible strategy.
- viciousvoxel 5y agoI would read this novel.
- Retric 5y agoThinking of AI like this is completely misunderstanding complexity. AI isn’t going to be able to predict the weather 2 weeks from now let alone society at the level your suggesting. It’s going to use the same old tools at best significantly more efficiently.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoWatching superhuman AI play games doesn’t look like this. They just look like people that are really stupid in some ways and really good in others.
- wegwe33 5y agoHaha. EU will not be able to compete in the AI-area at all, because they cannot collect any data due to their GDPR laws. No data = no machine learning. Nice shooting to the own leg :D
- lokimedes 5y agoIt’s data on the enemy you need for warfare. Only dictators need to collect data on its own citizens to win war.
- dzonga 5y agoI think in general fighting over territory is a lost cause these days. since the best resources are people. first world nations, have realized that. now they plunder people instead. Unlike extractible natural resources, which can be in abundance, brain drain is close to irreversible. Syria, will never regain it's lost skilled people. And likewise different African countries. In that sense the best AI war you can fight is disinformation and sow distrust.