8 ms·
National Geographic now recognizes The Southern Ocean
- eesmith 5y ago> it is the only ocean to touch three others and to completely embrace a continent rather than being embraced by them. Doesn't the Indian Ocean also touch three others? The map shows it touches the Atlantic, Pacific, and Southern, and it doesn't touch the Arctic. The Atlantic and Pacific both touch four other oceans.
- orangepanda 5y agoIndian Ocean, at best, embraces only Madagascar
- eesmith 5y agoSure, but why not write simply "it is the only ocean to completely embrace a continent rather than being embraced by them", and leave out the first qualification? It's always possible to add more qualifications, like "it is the only penguin-containing ocean completely south of the Equator to touch three others and to completely embrace a continent rather than being embraced by them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kjakm 5y agoCould somebody who understands this stuff explain it for me? I'm pretty sure I've heard of the Southern Ocean before. It also seems a little fishy that this is being heavily promoted by the magazine that (presumably) these 'Nat Geo cartographers' work for. Is this a PR stunt? Is there an official body that classifies oceans? Edit: I guess this bit of the article explains it. There is no new ocean, it's been recognised for a while. "'The Southern Ocean has long been recognized by scientists, but because there was never agreement internationally, we never officially recognized it,' says National Geographic Society Geographer Alex Tait. "
- skissane 5y ago> Is this a PR stunt? Is there an official body that classifies oceans? The International Hydrographic Organization (IHO) is the official body which defines the world's oceans. It is an intergovernmental international organization whose members are 94 countries, including all the world's major seagoing powers. IHO hasn't officially recognised the existence of the Southern Ocean yet, but it is planning to. Part of the hold-up is a dispute with Australia over the boundaries of the Southern Ocean – the IHO wants to put its northern boundary at the 60th parallel south, the Australian government wants to put its northern boundary as the southern Australian coast (which reflects Australian cultural understandings of it.) The other part of the hold-up, is the process of updating the boundaries of the world's oceans is being delayed by some unrelated political issues, such as the "Sea of Japan" naming dispute between Japan and Korea. But, unlike recognised international bodies such as the IHO, or even national government bodies, National Geographic magazine, or the National Geographic Society, has no formal authority to decide the boundaries of anything, including the world's oceans. So yeah, this is pretty much just PR.
- riffraff 5y agoI'm very curious to know what most of the IHO's work looks like. I'm imagining they have a yearly conference and they have an agenda like * check if there are new oceans * check if older oceans have gone away * should we rename the oceans? * snacks
- mikro2nd 5y agoFrom their website (https://iho.int/ https://iho.int/): "IHO works to ensure that all the world's seas, oceans and navigable waters are surveyed and charted, thereby supporting safety of navigation and the protection of the marine environment. It coordinates the activities of national hydrographic offices and sets standards in order to promote uniformity in nautical charts and documents. It issues survey best practices and provides guidelines to maximize the use of hydrographic information." Lest you think this merely a paper-shuffling exercise, if there's a shipping accident, a huge amount of legal liability rides on the accuracy and up-to-date information in the charts. What these guys do underpins a huge amount of maritime law and international shipping. Definitely one of the really important, useful international orgs.
- oefrha 5y ago> Anyone who has been there will struggle to explain what's so mesmerizing about it, but they'll all agree that the glaciers are bluer, the air colder, the mountains more intimidating, and the landscapes more captivating than anywhere else you can go. I was hoping to see a photo of those blue glaciers, intimidating mountains, and captivating landscapes. And there’s none. (Yes, I know how to Google images of blue glaciers.) I hope more editors ask the question: based on article text, what photos would a reader likely want to see?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- a3n 5y ago> I hope more editors ask the question: based on article text, what photos would a reader likely want to see? I often have this same thought. "Where's the pictures." Especially maddening when the headline implies (to me) that there will be pictures that I'll want to see.
- fnord77 5y agoespecially from natgeo
- falcor84 5y agoI did get a Rolex ad on that page with a nice photo of the ocean, so I have that going for me ...
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y agoI think one still photo can't really communicate what it's like. It's main characteristics are constant strong winds and large waves, along with being very cold of course. It's a miserably unforgiving and isolated place.
- samizdis 5y agoThere's a decent Wikipedia entry [1] on the Southern Ocean that provides a "Definitions and use" section listing how the ocean's been defined/redifined over time, and as by Australia: Pre-20th century, 1928 delineation, 1937 delineation, 1953 delineation, 2002 draft delineation, Australian standpoint. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Ocean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Ocean
- andrewingram 5y agoI was taught there was an Antarctic Ocean when I was in school (UK, born 1984), so I find this article both surprising and interesting.
- dataflow 5y agoDo you remember if you learned it in a science class or a geography class?
- andrewingram 5y agoFrom my recollection, this would've been at either infant or primary school, so before I had discrete subject classes. But I don't recall there being any scientific underpinning, it was just one of those lists of things we learned, like the planets and the continents.
- dkarl 5y agoMe, too, US born 1977. I learned about it when I was very young, and for some reason the fact that there were "five oceans" really stuck in my head. I have no idea what source I got it from, whether from school or some ancient children's science book from decades before I was born (definitely a possibility.) When I was older I would get stuck trying to name all five oceans before I remembered that there were only four now. It never sounded right to me that there were four, so this finally restores balance to my brain.
- 627467 5y agoI was thaught of 5 oceans: Indian, Atlantic, Pacific, Artic and Antarctic... So not sure what is new here. Is this similar to how in Latin world America is counted as a single continent while it's counted as 2 continents in the Anglo world?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- squiggleblaz 5y agoWell, the article is about National Geographic labelling the waters south of 60 degrees South as the Southern Ocean. There isn't an international consensus about whether to count the Southern Ocean as an ocean, and if so, where its boundary should be: in particular, Australia has always considered itself to be surrounded by the Indian Ocean to its west, the Southern Ocean to its south, the Pacific Ocean to the east and the seas that divide the continent from maritime southeast Asia to the north. Since this description is so natural from an Australian perspective, Australia has usually pushed back on adopting a Southern Ocean with some other definition. So yes, probably, this is very much like the difference between North and South America vs a unitary American continent. These distinctions seem academic to some but they're about identity and the placement of a community in the world to others.
- silicon2401 5y ago> in Latin world America is counted as a single continent while it's counted as 2 continents in the Anglo world? I thought in Latin America they say there are 3 Americas: north, central, and south.
- nrki 5y agoI grew up with the Southern Ocean being a thing. It was always marked on Australian maps.
- brabel 5y agoBut I think that in Australia, it's usually shown touching the whole extent of the mainland's southern coast? By NG definition, that would be incorrect as the "edges" of the ocean at defined as being at 60 degrees South, far away from Australia.
- simonh 5y ago60 degrees might make sense from a South American perspective, but for them anything much further North could put it next to much of Argentina and Chile. I think a boundary based on continental features makes more sense. So a boundary on great circles from, roughly, Windy Harbour Australia, to Cape Town, to Isla Hermite, then back to Tasmania.
- dwd 5y agoGrowing up in Warrnambool we were taught that the only thing separating us from Antarctica was the Southern Ocean. Bass Strait and the Tasman Sea began a bit further east and the Great Australian Bight wrapped the coast from WA to SA: The Southern Ocean was considered to be all the water beyond that to the south with the Indian Ocean west of the WA coast. It was never thought to be touching the Tasmanian coast ~4000km further east.
- atomicbeanie 5y agoSailors have referred to this region as the Southern Ocean for hundreds of years if I’m not mistaken.
- patwolf 5y agoMy child came home from kindergarten this year and told me that there were five oceans. I only knew four. I quickly pulled up Wikipedia and confirmed that the Southern Ocean was a thing. That was the first case of something my child learning contradicting my own outdated education. I'm sure there will be plenty more to come.
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago"No dad/mom, yeet is NOT a thing anymore!"
- hellojason 5y agoHave you heard about Pluto yet? My very eager mother just served us nachos.
- prepend 5y agoMy very eager mother just served us? Nein!
- jkingsbery 5y agoMy very eager mother just served us nine pickles.
- flycaliguy 5y agoThey also renamed Brontosaurus to Apatosaurus.
- silicon2401 5y agoThis is a lot older; I remember hearing about this back in the 2000s.
- JadeNB 5y agoI was born in the early '80s, and I remember learning both names in my dinosaur-obsessive phase, so I'm not sure it's a new thing.
- 5y ago
- LinAGKar 5y agoWasn't there supposed to be seven?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoSeven seas, not seven oceans. But much like the twelve Olympians or the seven wonders of the world, there have always been more individual seas than the collective count would imply. In real terms, drawing a line through the middle of the ocean and calling the ocean by different names according to what side of the line it's on is pretty ridiculous. You want to name regions that are different in some important way from other regions.
- tedk-42 5y agoOceans lie in-between continents. Another Aussie here letting you all know we've been calling in the southern ocean since before I can remember :)
- peanut_worm 5y agoWhen I went to school it was called the “Antarctic Ocean”
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.md/9HsRE https://archive.md/9HsRE
- fasteddie31003 5y agoWorded another way: A human taxonomy construct arbitrarily changes.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoAs a side note, I really hate how NatGeo's website forces me to enter an email address to read the article. So naturally, I put a fake email in and continued. I really wish there was a way to kill the newsletter modal - it's the return of popup windows but more annoying.
- chlodwig 5y agoI got past it by disabling javascript (using ublock) and reloading the page. This works on a lot of websites, but not all websites.