4 ms·
Senator Herb Kohl: But you do recognize that in the words that are used and antitrust kind of oversight, your market share constitutes monopoly, dominant -- spe
by tyingq 5y ago
Senator Herb Kohl: But you do recognize that in the words that are used and antitrust kind of oversight, your market share constitutes monopoly, dominant -- special power dominant for a monopoly firm. You recognize you're in that area?
Eric Shmidt: I would agree, sir, that we’re in that area....I'm not a lawyer, but my understanding of monopoly findings is this is a judicial process.
From: https://www.businessinsider.com/is-google-a-monopoly-were-in-that-area-admits-schmidt-2011-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/is-google-a-monopoly-were-in...
Also, the FTC's initial memo from 2012 that somebody higher up in the food chain quashed is pretty interesting: http://graphics.wsj.com/google-ftc-report/ http://graphics.wsj.com/google-ftc-report/
In short, dominant market share in web search. Though I think you could argue other things, like dominance in affordable smart phones. Android is effectively a monopoly for people that can't afford an iPhone.
- bananabreakfast 5y agoGoogle would argue that web search is not their market. They are in the business of online advertising in which they most definitely do not have dominant market share.
- tyingq 5y agoI can't say for sure whether they have a monopoly, but it's interesting that Eric Schmidt can't either.
- croes 5y agoYeah, that's why to google something means advertising and not searching for something on the internet. No, wait ...
- sneak 5y agoGoogle also doesn't have a monopoly on search.
- minsc__and__boo 5y agoBeing popular != Monopoly Having Market Share Dominance != Monopoly Being a monopoly means having sole control over the supply of a market (conversely, Monopsony is demand). When people say Bing, Baidu, DDG, Yahoo, DDG, etc. are all a click a way, that means Google does not control the market supply. Just because the majority of people choose to use something on an open market doesn't mean that thing has a monopoly.
- tyingq 5y agoSchmidt seems concerned they are in that territory. Also, the document I linked to, presumably written by people with deep expertise on the topic, has several relevant sections. One excerpt: === A. GOOGLE HAS MONOPOLY POWER IN RELEVANT MARKETS A firm is a monopolist if it can profitably raise prices substantially above the competitive level. [M]onopoly power may be inferred from a firm's possesion of a dominant share of a relevant market that is protected by entry barriers. Google has monopoly power in one or more properly defined markets...Staff has identified three relevant antitrust markets... === I think it's at least fair to say that some people with expertise in the space feel like Google could have monopoly control over one or more markets.
- minsc__and__boo 5y agoEric Schmidt is not Google. Also, a half-redacted document written by an anonymous person that was accidentally released almost a decade ago does not change the definition of a monopoly. Yes, you can assume that it's written by someone who knows what they're talking about, just as much as you can also presume they were wrong because it was squashed. That's a moot argument. None of that changes the fact that being popular does not make something a monopoly.
- tyingq 5y ago"popular does not make something a monopoly" I didn't say that, though, or anything like that. I did mention market share dominance. But that's often related to things like "A firm is a monopolist if it can profitably raise prices substantially above the competitive level.".