5 ms·
You’re not actually talking about the “moderately wealthy.” Just because billionaires are insanely wealthy doesn’t change the fact that a household making $500,
by dangus 5y ago
You’re not actually talking about the “moderately wealthy.” Just because billionaires are insanely wealthy doesn’t change the fact that a household making $500,000 is still incredibly wealthy.
There’s already an exemption for capital gains tax on the sale of primary homes. $500,000 for married couples, and you can remove the cost basis and cost of improvements from the equation.
In other words, almost nobody is taxed on the sale of their primary home.
A household that makes $500k on a good year is actually in the 1% statistically. They have left the working class long ago. They could work for about 7-10 years in their career and retire with an above-median salary (withdrawing following the 4% rule) in perpetuity. That is by definition not the working class: that family barely has to work in order to secure a lifetime of comfortable living if they don’t inflate their lifestyle.
In my view, your comment acts as an implication of support for regressive tax policy that hurts the actual working class. No, moderately wealthy people do not need help. No, we are not temporarily embarrassed millionaires held back from generational wealthy only by government tax policy – that’s a farce sold to us by the very billionaires that want to avoid being taxed. They want us to think that taxes hurt us more than they hurt them, which is mathematically not true.
They want us to think that “if only our taxes were cut, we could go back to affording a middle class lifestyle.” It’s not true.
- dhd415 5y ago>>A household that makes $500k on a good year is actually in the 1% statistically. They have left the working class long ago. They could work for about 7-10 years in their career and retire with an above-median salary (withdrawing following the 4% rule) in perpetuity. That is by definition not the working class: that family barely has to work in order to secure a lifetime of comfortable living.<< The "in a good year" qualifier in both your comment and the parent comment means that your conclusion that this person has left the "working class" is untrue. It's not uncommon to get a windfall (stock option vesting cliff, inheritance, capital gains, etc.) that boosts income in a single year to many multiples of one's typical income. Such an occurrence does not boost the recipient out of the working class. Managed carefully, it can change their life (buy a house, turbo-charge retirement savings, etc.) but no one's buying a private island with a single year of $500k income.
- dangus 5y agoOf course it does. The working class doesn’t get stock options, vesting cliffs, inheritance, or capital gains! Or much of a savings account or 401k, for that matter. The option to stop working for more than a few weeks or months takes you squarely out of the working class. Basically, what I’m trying to say is that the parent comment to ours is attempting to advocate for taxing just the billionaires and not to tax the moderately wealthy so much. I think that’s a flawed argument, because the moderately wealthy don’t need help, and are perhaps even more wealthy than they realize.
- chrisseaton 5y agoPlenty of normal working class people get options if they work at a tech company.
- frockington1 5y agoWhen I worked at Home depot as a lot boy I got stock options
- WalterBright 5y ago> The working class doesn’t get stock options, vesting cliffs, inheritance, or capital gains! robinhood.com would beg to differ. Anyone can invest in the stock market and get capital gains.
- HWR_14 5y agoNot at the 500k level most of them aren't getting capital gains. Or is this "anyone can be a multimillionaire - just play the lottery and get lucky" level of technically true?
- WalterBright 5y agoThey're getting capital gains any time they sell a stock for more than they paid. There's no magic threshhold of $500k.