4 ms·
If we fix everything except for aircraft, we will have done enough. At that point aircraft can keep using fossil fuels for a while longer. Cars, trucks, buses,
by oblio 5y ago
If we fix everything except for aircraft, we will have done enough. At that point aircraft can keep using fossil fuels for a while longer.
Cars, trucks, buses, trains, HVAC, factories are what needs to be electrified ASAP.
- amelius 5y agoIf every industry thinks like that ...
- legutierr 5y agoIs there another industry that is facing similar physical constraints that would hamper a transition? I understand that reducing the carbon output in concrete production is difficult to the point of being nearly economically infeasible. Other than that?
- scotty79 5y agoThere are some ideas about cement industry: [pdf] https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://awsassets.panda.org/downloads/englishsummary__lr_pdf.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwiS7pXs1ofxAhVQrIsKHcVbCAI4ChAWMAR6BAgEEAI&usg=AOvVaw1cHvI0mPvO8597FtnA6QFu https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/...
- oblio 5y agoI can drive a car that's 20% heavier due to batteries. Nobody's going to fly a commercial plane that's 40% heavier due to batteries. Some places, current batteries just don't cut it.
- dublin 5y agoThe requirements for fairly large power margins for safe operation at takeoff and landing generally prevent electric airplanes from making sense and achieving FAA approval, especially for commercial applications. We are decades away from viable electric commercial aviation. Even turbine-electric series hybrids weigh and pollute more than their native kerosene-burning equivalents.
- harperlee 5y agoAnd boats!
- oblio 5y agoOh, forgot boats, right. Boats should definitely be on my list.
- andai 5y agoAre there any electric boats yet? Especially curious about the feasibility for shipping boats. The density seems to be less of a concern there.
- ajuc 5y agohttps://solarimpulse.com/efficient-solutions/solar-electric-boats# https://solarimpulse.com/efficient-solutions/solar-electric-...
- czierleyn 5y agoI read about the Candela C7 boat last week. See https://candelaspeedboat.com/ https://candelaspeedboat.com/
- Symbiote 5y agoThere are several electric ferries in use in Norway and Denmark. Example https://www.visitaeroe.com/ellen https://www.visitaeroe.com/ellen
- throwawayaab 5y agoThese guys are doing some great things here in Seattle: http://purewatercraft.com http://purewatercraft.com
- jiofih 5y agoRecreational boats, yes, a ton.
- ncmncm 5y agoIntercontinental shipping is more likely to move to electrically-synthesized ammonia than to batteries. Big aircraft are more likely to move to liquified hydrogen, synthesized on demand at major airports; initially burning it in turbines, eventually using fuel cells and electric drive. Ammonia will be pretty easy to switch to; the main impediment today is just raw production capacity, which needs to be scaled up by three orders of magnitude. Ships can be retrofitted in place with new, bigger pressure-vessel fuel tankage and more complicated fuel piping. The changeover will need to be driven by regulation. LH2 is quite a bit harder, but the rewards for success are huge. It might need entirely new turbojet engines, and maybe new airframes with room for bigger tankage. It certainly needs truly huge scale-ups in both methods and raw capacity to synthesize LH2, and in production of cheap aerogels to insulate the LH2 tanks. The first usable LH2 transport aircraft will have an absolutely crushing advantage over kerosene-fueled craft anywhere they compete. Kerosene craft will gradually be pushed out to shorter routes and smaller airports. How fast this happens will depend mostly on how fast LH2 production can be scaled, and how fast new airframes can be approved and then delivered.
- _Microft 5y agoIf batteries do not make progress fast enough, synthetic fuels might be a temporary(?) solution. With these we can have the advantage of the high energy-density of hydrocarbon fuels for use cases like airplanes without having the climate effect of fossil fuels. Remember that the problem with fossil fuels is that they increase the amount of carbon in (short term) circulation which is what leads to further accumulation in the atmosphere or oceans. Producing synthetic fuels would remove carbon from the environment before releasing it on use again, leading to a net-zero effect.
- ganafagol 5y agoSynthetic fuels scale up even worse than battery density.
- mgoetzke 5y agoI doubt there is enough electricity available to also power the generation of synthetic fuels in high mass. Maybe for limited use cases (percentage wise)
- pjc50 5y agoWell, what energy where and at what cost? It's possible that there will be renewable overbuild to the extent that there are enough times of cheap or negative energy prices, especially in sunny locations, that can be used for fuel creation. (The downside I must mention is that high capital cost low utilization low running cost => still high cost) The USN have a solution in their back pocket: https://www.zmescience.com/research/us-navy-synthetic-jet-fuel-seawater-0423432/ https://www.zmescience.com/research/us-navy-synthetic-jet-fu... , presumably for at-sea refuelling using surplus energy from the reactors of carriers.
- 127 5y agoAbout biofuels... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OpEB6hCpIGM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OpEB6hCpIGM
- mxschumacher 5y ago
- cm2187 5y agoDo factories require batteries?
- oblio 5y agoI imagine factories can have customer arrangements with power suppliers (imagine an aluminum making factory), they could have their own batteries. Especially if the price for electricity varies, factories could charge their batteries when electricity is cheap, to save money. To be honest, I don't know what they could use batteries for, but I also can't imagine that some aspects of factory work will be completely untouched by the upcoming battery revolution.
- jokteur 5y agoTrains can already be electrified without the need for batteries. For the case of buses, I think there is an elegant solution that they have begun to use in my city. Historically, they already have been electric cables around the city for pantograph buses. However, it is expensive to run electric cables around the city, so they are only a handfull of lines using this technology. Now they are introducing hybrid battery / pantographs buses. Which I think a good compromise because you only need to equip a fraction of the line with electric cables, and the battery takes care of the rest. Because of that, you don't need a huge battery for the bus to be able to run all day. It can recharge periodically on the line with the pantograph. Concerning trucks and cars, yes that shit needs to be electrified ASAP.
- mymythisisthis 5y agoOne big mistake Toronto, Canada, did was getting rid of its trolley buses in the 1990s https://transittoronto.ca/trolleybus/9503.shtml https://transittoronto.ca/trolleybus/9503.shtml
- ratsforhorses 5y agoWhy not replace plane travel with hyperloop? Airplanes are high polluters, pay little taxes (none on fuel) , require massive bailouts and the only US civilian airplane maker is a soon to be anachronism... On the other hand...the infrastructure requirements for a cross coast hyperloop venture...especially if impulsed by government would resolve a lot of things...besides couldn't it be used for cargo..Amazon might be interested ...and imagine the billboard/advertising opportunities.. https://www.bbc.com/reel/video/p09jszr6/are-floating-pods-the-future-of-transport- https://www.bbc.com/reel/video/p09jszr6/are-floating-pods-th...
- f6v 5y ago> Why not replace plane travel with hyperloop? You can’t replace a reliable mode of transportation with something that doesn’t exist yet. Even when it’s ready, it’d take decades. Political powers are reluctant to commit to something that’s going to take longer than their careers. Then again, you don’t even need hyperloop. Germany has 250 km/h trains, those are more than enough for many routes.
- robin_reala 5y agoLots of countries have 330 km/h trains, and Japan is hoping to open the Chūō shinkansen within the decade, running at up to 500 km/h.
- bagacrap 5y agoare ACs not already electric? I guess furnaces are still largely gas, oil or wood burning... that doesn't seem like a technological problem though.
- dublin 5y agoGas furnaces are FAR more efficient than their electric resistance heating or even heat pump counterparts. Not to mention that a simple gas burner works with no moving parts (other than the solenoid valve) for decades with no maintenance, while heat pumps, in my experience, are far more troublesome than regular HVAC units, and still have to fall back to grossly inefficient resistance heating (even in a normal central Texas winter!) when temps dip below freezing. (One great thing about my parents moving several years back was leaving their $400-1000 annual heat pump repair bills behind. It wasn't just a bad unit - it was the third heat pump they'd had, and all (even from different mfrs!) were similarly troublesome, esp. for heating.)