6 ms·
If musk is to believed, (and I think he's on point with this), $50/kWh will likely come within the next 5 years. So next 9 years? My expectation is beyond Tes
by cogman10 5y ago
If musk is to believed, (and I think he's on point with this), $50/kWh will likely come within the next 5 years.
So next 9 years? My expectation is beyond Tesla, the rest of the industry will have hit on that sub $50/kwh price point. That is going to make a lot of things really interesting. $2000 for a 30kWh home battery backup? Who wouldn't get one?
To further this, with climate change leading to more and more extreme weather, I'm expecting that power outages are going to be semi-common (assuming the grid doesn't invest in battery backup).
- ben_w 5y ago> $2000 for a 30kWh home battery backup? Who wouldn't get one? Very few of the people that would currently benefit from a domestic backup battery could afford $2k, and most of the people who do have $2k to spare don’t live in places with unreliable electricity. The overlap isn’t zero, but… for example, I visited Kenya with an ex of mine, we met a local friend of hers, that friend would’ve benefited from a more reliable electricity bill, but her monthly rent and utility bills combined was equivalent to about $85 and she couldn’t afford to move.
- cogman10 5y ago> Very few of the people that would currently benefit from a domestic backup battery could afford $2k, and most of the people who do have $2k to spare don’t live in places with unreliable electricity. My expectation is that with climate change, unreliable electricity is going to affect a lot more places. The polar vortex that knocked out the Texas grid is likely to be a more frequent and more extreme event. ACs running more frequently will likely lead to more brown outs. Assuming our grids don't get major updates (I'm pretty pessimistic about this), we are looking at more and more outages in the future. It's certainly possible that smart grids could significantly reduce outages, but that will take too many actors working together to ever really fly. For example, if the grid could coordinate with your heating and cooling, you could distribute AC usage to avoid tripping the grid. Barring such a grid, homes having batteries would allow owners to skate through brown outs. Further couple that with solar and they could survive even major outages (hours or even days). > The overlap isn’t zero, but… for example, I visited Kenya with an ex of mine, we met a local friend of hers, that friend would’ve benefited from a more reliable electricity bill, but her monthly rent and utility bills combined was equivalent to about $85 and she couldn’t afford to move. A 1kwh battery would probably be a pretty positive impact. Add on a 300W solar panel and you'd have something that would extend the amount of electricity the have. That'd come in at ~$400 (assuming $50/kwh). Not enough to run an AC, but enough to keep the lights on and maybe run a fridge. Otherwise... yeah... not much good news for places that can't afford such batteries.
- jtbayly 5y ago> For example, if the grid could coordinate with your heating and cooling, you could distribute AC usage to avoid tripping the grid. This is already done. It’s a blunt system, but it is done. I was offered $5/month off my electric bill to add a device to my AC unit that would be able to turn it off for up to 15 minutes per hour. (I declined, because my AC at that time was not able to keep up even running constantly.)
- Johnythree 5y agoA 1KWh battery is affordable now using off-the-shelf lead acid batteries. There is no advantage using Lithium batteries (at present) as size and/or weight is not critical for domestic applications. The whole point of the discussion is that Lithium is still not cheaper than Lead acid.
- MrRadar 5y agoLead acid batteries suck for more reasons than just their size and weight. One major disadvantage is that the faster you discharge them the less of their charge you will actually recover[1]. Additionally, discharging them below 50% capacity significantly reduces their life in terms of total cycles (even for cells rated for "deep cycle" operation)[2][3] so you need to oversize your battery system to get the same effective capacity if you want your cells to last. Lithium batteries suffer from neither of those drawbacks. If those weren't enough, even when treated well (not discharged too deeply) lead-acid batteries don't last for as many discharge cycles as lithium iron phosphate cells. If you do the math, for batteries cycled daily modern LiFePo batteries are about the same TCO as lead-acid despite the higher up-front costs because the lithium batteries will last significantly longer and you don't need to buy as much absolute capacity for the same effective capacity. Here's a good presentation on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRqRDZh74F0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRqRDZh74F0 [1] http://omahamakergroup.org/2015/05/14/battery-derating-and-chemistry-comparison/ http://omahamakergroup.org/2015/05/14/battery-derating-and-c... [2] https://www.pveducation.org/pvcdrom/lead-acid-batteries/characteristics-of-lead-acid-batteries https://www.pveducation.org/pvcdrom/lead-acid-batteries/char... [3] https://www.solar-electric.com/media/wysiwyg/cyclelife2.gif https://www.solar-electric.com/media/wysiwyg/cyclelife2.gif (Graph shows cycles (y-axis) vs average depth of discharge (x-axis) for a typical "deep cycle" lead-acid battery. Note the y-axis is logarithmic.)
- reissbaker 5y ago> Very few of the people that would currently benefit from a domestic backup battery could afford $2k California, a state of 40 million people, would disagree with you ;) Not just referencing the blackouts we had last summer: CA also is heavily invested in solar power, and as a result, power is much cheaper during the day than at night (assuming you opt into time of use pricing). A battery for $2k would pay for itself in California quickly, because you can charge it when power is cheap during the day and run off battery when power is expensive at night. Plenty of other US states have had blackouts as well; my parents in PA now own a generator due to repeated blackouts last year. If they could have bought a battery for $2k, they probably would have: generators are loud and dirty. And Texans certainly had a bad time with blackouts recently as well.
- justinator 5y ago> California, a state of 40 million people, would disagree with you ;) How explode-y is this battery? I hear California also has this problem with forest fires and it seems a fire and giant batteries all over the place would be two flavors that do not go well with each other.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoProbably less explody than a propane tank. Turns out that pretty much any form of energy storage can release a bunch of energy in a short time if pushed hard enough.
- oblio 5y agoI was thinking the same thing until someone pointed out that lard stores a ton of energy but you can't really make it explode. I hope.
- branko_d 5y agoBut you can make it burn! https://madison.com/wsj/huge-grease-fire-was-a-hot-mess/article_acfce336-15d1-11e0-ba15-001cc4c002e0.html https://madison.com/wsj/huge-grease-fire-was-a-hot-mess/arti... > With so much oil-rich food on hand, including lard, cheese and more than 10 million pounds of surplus butter stored by the federal government, the fire was a hot mess — fast-moving, destructive and difficult to put out.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- int_19h 5y agoThere are plenty of places in US where electricity is not entirely reliable, and that includes some fairly wealthy suburbs. FWIW I'd get such a thing for myself even though we see outages maybe once a year - it's less hassle than a generator to keep the fridge running.
- alvah 5y ago"most of the people who do have $2k to spare don’t live in places with unreliable electricity" Increasing the mix of renewables in the electricity networks will mean most people live in places with unreliable electricity going forward. The proposed $2k 30kWh home battery backup could well be the adaptation many of us have to make.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoum, no, we are not going to have unreliable electricity because people's lives depends on it. We will have grid scale batteries, and the grid will charge you more or less depending on when you are using energy. it does not make sence to have such essential equipment randomly distributed through the population where I have to fight my landlord to repair the damn thing or have it not cause a house fire, while the guy is out of the country on holiday and couldn't give a rat's ass
- alvah 5y agoum, yes, it's happening already in areas where intermittent supplies make up a sufficient percentage of the energy mix (e.g. South Australia). In an ideal world we'd keep the rollout of intermittent sources below the level at which they cause instability until grid scale batteries are invented, however that's not the world we live in.
- jrek 5y agoMy understanding is that neither of the major outages in SA in recent times have been related to intermittent supply issues (i.e. the first major incident was related to trips caused by weather, the second was related to a gas using supplier failing to increase supply due to some market regulation minutiae that was subsequently changed).
- alvah 5y agoRegardless of the realities in SA (I’m not convinced by the offical explanation of the first outage at least, there are credible alternative theories), it’s well understood that beyond a certain level, introducing intermittent suppliers into a network designed for baseload generation will cause instability. I don’t have the figures to hand but IIRC more than very low double figures as a percentage starts causing trouble.
- SilverRed 5y ago> and most of the people who do have $2k to spare don’t live in places with unreliable electricity. A home battery in many places is basically free money. Renewables mean there is an extreme oversupply at some times and an undersupply at others. Owning a battery hooked up to the grid means you buy power at oversupply times where the power goes in to negative pricing and then sell it back at other times in the same day where it is very expensive. Reusing old car batteries for this purpose might become the next bitcoin mining with warehouses full of repurposed batteries buying and selling power.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> A home battery in many places is basically free money. Only if its a free battery. Otherwise, its an income stream with an up front cost.
- SilverRed 5y agoWhich is why its not common, but with battery prices coming down and dirt cheap second hand batteries on the horizon, this is going to become a big industry. An old tesla battery with only 50% capacity remaining is still perfectly good for this kind of use even if not so great for driving.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Which is why its not common, but with battery prices coming down and dirt cheap second hand batteries on the horizon, this is going to become a big industry. Maybe briefly, especially where retail customers with some installed renewable generating capacity can leverage the latter to take advantage of net metering laws designed to bring renewable capacity to the grid, because otherwise their stuck buying at retail and, if allowed to sell back at all, selling at wholesale. Bur cheaper batteries mean proper utility players (e.g., a joint operation of PG&E and Tesla) are building large, purpose-built storage facilities, often colocated with generation facilities, with lower marginal costs for real estate and interconnection than separate facilities and better access to financing than small operators. Storage is going to be a big industry going forward, but the period where home storage (or storage by anyone but major utility players) is a viable financial hack rather than just a backup plan for grid failure will probably be brief unless artificially subsidized to encourage distributed storage.
- mschuster91 5y ago$2k maybe not but you can grab some chinesium 1 kW generator pack for well under 200$ these days, and fuel it with distilled alcohol. Good enough for a grid backup to keep the refrigerator and lights running.
- mac01021 5y ago1. Here in CT with our abundance of trees, a large fraction of the state loses power for the better part of a week every couple of years when a windstorm comes up the coast. 2. Batteries need not just be for power outages. Net metering, granular demand-based energy pricing, etc are all reasons to get a battery for your house.
- ben_w 5y agoValue for money is not my argument. I’m just saying loads of people for whom it would provide benefit don’t have $2k spare money to invest. To put a different spin on it: the price point for the cheapest consumer unit should be way lower than that… unless you force landlords to install it at their own cost (as a landlord myself: a $2k legally mandated expense would not be happy fun times, but I could and would suck it up). And even then, you’re still thinking in terms of the richest economies, and first quartile incomes in developing nations would struggle with $25 backup batteries let alone $2000. One belief of mine which is shifting from all the replies I’ve been getting, is that I’m increasingly surprised how bad everyone’s telling me that America’s fundamental infrastructure is.
- mac01021 5y agoI understand your point. I don't think of the infrastructure here as _bad_, though. We do have the occasional outage after a storm, as I described. But, even if the uptime were as low as 99%, which it is not, I would not want to pay the cost of making the grid significantly more resilient than it is.
- ben_w 5y agoMy electricity uptime has never been as low as 99%. South coast UK for the first 18 years of my life, total downtime would’ve been at most half a day, in 30-60 minute fragments, ~99.992% uptime. Never once failed when I was back there for 7 months to help provide care for my mum. Likewise Sheffield for about a year, and that place had an annoying prepay electricity meter. Rural Wales for 3.5 years? 30 minutes of downtime total, ~99.998% uptime. Similar total downtime in Cambridge, but I was there 8.5 years, so 99.9993% uptime. I don’t think it’s ever failed me here in Berlin. That in particular is why I’m saying here that American infrastructure looks bad. It’s not the only way, TBH, but it is so in a new and relevant way I wasn’t previously expecting.
- quickthrowman 5y agoI would rather spend a few thousand more for a natural gas generator, it will run indefinitely as long as you have natural gas.
- cogman10 5y agohttps://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/16/natural-gas-power-storm/ https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/16/natural-gas-power-st... If the whole grid goes down, your gas likely won't be there. If you add solar, then you could indefinitely run in most circumstances.
- quickthrowman 5y agoI don’t live in Texas, I live somewhere that the natural gas doesn’t go out because people will die if it does, so our infrastructure is winterized and maintained. We get some -30F every winter and the natural gas service is always there. You could swap out the NG generator for a diesel one with a day tank and then you don’t have to worry about NG service :) A 30kwH battery wall is going to last 6-12 hours at most anyways. I can’t recall NG service disruptions on a large scale in my state, and I’m 37.
- cogman10 5y ago60kWh for 4k then? What about 120kWh for 8k? Point being you could target your outage range based on what you want to prep for at a fairly low cost (assuming $50/kWh). Add on a solar system to any of these and you'd have indefinite power without a reliance on surrounding infrastructure. For my home, 30kWh would give me ~24hr of power. Even if you want a fossil fuel generator, you could have an auto switch to battery for the short outages so you don't have to go crank on the generator.
- brianwawok 5y agoMy whole house generator runs on natural gas. Indiana natural supply gas is stable and afaik never stopped in the last 20 years. It automatically fires up 6 seconds after power goes out and runs my entire house including EV charger. It’s fairly quiet, cannot hear with windows closed. Cost like 5k and 2K install. Really hard to beat that in the near term with battery. No it doesn’t do the demand shift part of a battery, but it’s pretty clearly better as an emergency solution, at least for my needs.
- bcrosby95 5y ago> $2000 for a 30kWh home battery backup? Who wouldn't get one? Because it would be a lot more than $2k to get put it in your home. If you do the math on a Tesla powerwall, the raw cost of the battery should be right around $2k too. But it actually costs more like $8k per powerwall.
- cogman10 5y agoThat's for a few reasons. Competition is low. There are only a few players in the home battery space and they are similarly priced. Demand is high. Even with the higher price, the wait list to get a powerwall is more than a year out. My expectation is a few things happen over the next 9 years. I expect that battery production ramps up to a high degree. I expect that the EV market will eventually be saturated With those two things, I expect that EV manufactures and the likes of tesla will end up with more batteries than than demand. When that happens, you can expect that the cost of battery products will start to tumble as everyone that manufactures batteries starts to try and sell them for whatever application will buy them. Things that could spoil my assumptions? Power companies might decide now is the time to really buy batteries. That could keep demand outpacing supply. We could see new applications of batteries that aren't currently on the table, such as battery powered trains. The EV market could not saturate. This could be due to battery production capacity severely lagging EV demand. This could be due to anything from manufacturing plants running into major issues to supply chain problems. But, I'm an optimist. I expect to see battery tech and manufacturing continuing to build out at a fast pace. Oh, and eventually the expensive part of a battery system won't be the batteries but rather the install cost.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoBattery powered trains seem really unlikely to me. It's hard to imagine a situation where it's cheaper to do a battery powered train than a train track that supplies power (aka how most subways work).
- silly-silly 5y agoThe rest of the world doesn't live in high density built up areas. Many small crops farming trains in rural areas can not and will not be allowed to run power through the tracks in above ground situations.