9 ms·
This is really cool, but could anyone familiar with the domain estimate how far we are along the S-curve? I.e. it took a long time for things to ramp up, then
by oblio 5y ago
This is really cool, but could anyone familiar with the domain estimate how far we are along the S-curve?
I.e. it took a long time for things to ramp up, then they accelerate really quickly and then they slow down again. Think Moore's Law, which is dead now.
What would be the price estimate for 2030, for example. I think we're now around $100 per kwh (or something like that), what should we expect for 2030? $60? $20?
- eloff 5y ago> Think Moore's Law, which is dead now. Look again. Moore's law in terms of single threaded performance is dead. In literal terms of number of transistors on a wafer, it's still increasing exponentially, just slower. And in terms of what mattered when people cited Moore's law, the decrease in price/performance, it's still exponential, just slower and multi core. It will end, as all exponential trends must end lest they consume the universe, but the end is not yet in sight. Recently chips have started to go multi chip and three dimensional. So even when we finally hit that scaling limit, we haven't quite reached the end of exponential progress.
- bin_bash 5y agohasn't it always referred to transistor count and not performance?
- eloff 5y agoDid you read the whole comment? I edited it, but that part was in there from the beginning, just in different words.
- bin_bash 5y agoI agree with you, I just think you weren't making your case strongly enough by implying that Moore's Law referred to more than just transistor count.
- jeffbee 5y agoIt has always referred to the minimum of the cost-complexity curve for integrated circuits. The progress of Moore's Actual Law has never stopped. The thing people mean when they are talking about the deceleration of single-threaded CPU performance is actually Dennard scaling. Dennard said that density and power efficiency were complementary in such a way as to keep areal power constant. That was true until it suddenly stopped being true. If Dennard scaling had continued you'd be using a 20GHz CPU right now.
- sova 5y agoOxford Dictionary says: "the principle that the speed and capability of computers can be expected to double every two years, as a result of increases in the number of transistors a microchip can contain." Which notably mentions performance. I have often interpreted Moore's Law to be the fact that doubling improvements in performance will continue roughly every 16-18 months, but not always directly proportionally to transistor count -- other ways to squeeze out doubling performance gains arise and often in unexpected places.
- epistasis 5y agoSingle threaded performance and overall performance are quite different. But I'm not sure that Oxford is the most authoritative source here, as they are talking about a "computer" which is an awfully vague term. Wikipedia uses transistor count of an IC, which is much more specific: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore's_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore's_law Would be interested to know if the process inside Oxford's is as precise to distinguish, or if they intentionally dumbed it down.
- IncRnd 5y agoOxford Dictionary doesn't know what Moore's law is, then. Moore's law was an observation by Gordon Moore, co-founder of Intel, relating to the doubling of transistors per densely integrated circuit chip every 24 months. Originally, it was every 12 months, then every 24 months, etc. Moore's second law, which isn't as well known, relates to the exponentially increasing capital cost of manufacturing ICs.
- lanstin 5y agoI am sure there is some sci fi novel where species compete for neutron stars because they are a very dense compute substrate.
- Hjfrf 5y agoAsimov's "The Last Question" is close, though the focus is on entropy rather than any kind of space wars.
- arthurcolle 5y agoIsn't Three Body Problem kinda like this?
- mgoetzke 5y agoIs that book worth reading ? I am half-way through and I still don't see the point ;)
- lovemenot 5y agoI read all three books. The first was a couple of years ago. But from memory, half-way through the first should be enough to tell. If you haven't seen anything worthwhile yet, you won't by continuing.
- kevml 5y agoNot neutron stars specifically, but Accelerando by Charles Stross covers this.
- eloff 5y agoThat was a good book, it challenged many of my assumptions.
- Isinlor 5y agoIn the Perfect Imperfection by Jacek Dukaj [0] has something called "Remy's curve" [1]. On the curve you can find: - Ultimate Computer is the computer using the best hardware as allowed by the physical constants of our universe. See also physics of computation. - Inclusions are in essence 'pocket universes'. They are created for specific entities to run hardware in a dedicated universe with physical constants different from ours, allowing for better performance than those in our universe - Ultimate Inclusion is the inclusion with the best possible set of physical constants in the entire multiverse Seth Lloyd wrote a paper "Ultimate physical limits to computation" [2]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_Imperfection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_Imperfection [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_Imperfection#/media/File:Jacek_Dukaj_Perfekcyjna_wykres_REMY.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_Imperfection#/media/Fi... [2] https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9908043 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9908043
- cogman10 5y agoWith the current silicon manufacturing processes, I'd say the end is in sight. Every node shrink is taking longer and longer and getting more and more expensive to fabricate. We've been reliant on node shrinks to push things further. That hard limit is 0.2nm (silicon atom size) we are at ~2nm gate features. It remains to be seen if we can get to that 0.2nm size, I honestly don't think we can push much further past the 2nm size (I'd imagine 0.5nm will be the limit). That, to me, is very much being "in sight".
- holoduke 5y ago3d chips. Imagine current size with 1 million layers. Sure it will start with just a few layers. And many obstacles to be overcome like temp and delay. But one day our cpus will look like little cubes. Moore's law can continue for at least another 30 years
- cogman10 5y agoCouple of problems. First, how do you cool such a chip? Sure, you could add a bunch of transistors but the thermal costs per transistor will stay the same. Assuming similar design but adding 20 layers, how would you account for your CPU now consuming 600W? Second, The tech doesn't exist. The problem we have is that layering chips today is basically growing crystals in a controlled fashion. Defects in lower layers spoil upper layers. Today that's already a problem (CPUs today have ~7 or 8 layers). Can you imagine the problem of 20 or 30 layers? Who knows, maybe we'll come up with solutions to both problems, but that's a big maybe. My bet is that instead we focus on architecture designs. We revisit old but deemed too expensive concepts like an async CPU.
- eloff 5y agoThis is real, shipping technology. See 3d nand flash cells, see stacked cache and HBM memory. All the usual characters are working on it. Intel, AMD (TSMC), Samsung. Cooling is an issue, but there are solutions.
- 5y ago
- coderintherye 5y agoNREL has a great report on that, although it is focused on utility-scale battery storage: https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy20osti/75385.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy20osti/75385.pdf
- ortusdux 5y agoIt looks like $156 in 2019 & $137 in 2020. Estimates are $100/kwh by 2023-24 and $58/kwh by 2030. I do wonder how a dramatic shift towards Li powered cars will effect the price. We may see demand outpace supply for a decade or more. I hope it is the other way around because cheap lithium batteries flooding the market would have many positive implications. https://about.bnef.com/blog/battery-pack-prices-cited-below-100-kwh-for-the-first-time-in-2020-while-market-average-sits-at-137-kwh/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/battery-pack-prices-cited-below-...
- maxerickson 5y agoIt's very unlikely that large companies would leave that much money on the table (they will invest in supply).
- lovemenot 5y agoThere is no doubt that energy storage will be huge and worth investment at massive scale. As to Li-ion, well the future is good, but not so certain.
- cogman10 5y agoIf musk is to believed, (and I think he's on point with this), $50/kWh will likely come within the next 5 years. So next 9 years? My expectation is beyond Tesla, the rest of the industry will have hit on that sub $50/kwh price point. That is going to make a lot of things really interesting. $2000 for a 30kWh home battery backup? Who wouldn't get one? To further this, with climate change leading to more and more extreme weather, I'm expecting that power outages are going to be semi-common (assuming the grid doesn't invest in battery backup).
- ben_w 5y ago> $2000 for a 30kWh home battery backup? Who wouldn't get one? Very few of the people that would currently benefit from a domestic backup battery could afford $2k, and most of the people who do have $2k to spare don’t live in places with unreliable electricity. The overlap isn’t zero, but… for example, I visited Kenya with an ex of mine, we met a local friend of hers, that friend would’ve benefited from a more reliable electricity bill, but her monthly rent and utility bills combined was equivalent to about $85 and she couldn’t afford to move.
- cogman10 5y ago> Very few of the people that would currently benefit from a domestic backup battery could afford $2k, and most of the people who do have $2k to spare don’t live in places with unreliable electricity. My expectation is that with climate change, unreliable electricity is going to affect a lot more places. The polar vortex that knocked out the Texas grid is likely to be a more frequent and more extreme event. ACs running more frequently will likely lead to more brown outs. Assuming our grids don't get major updates (I'm pretty pessimistic about this), we are looking at more and more outages in the future. It's certainly possible that smart grids could significantly reduce outages, but that will take too many actors working together to ever really fly. For example, if the grid could coordinate with your heating and cooling, you could distribute AC usage to avoid tripping the grid. Barring such a grid, homes having batteries would allow owners to skate through brown outs. Further couple that with solar and they could survive even major outages (hours or even days). > The overlap isn’t zero, but… for example, I visited Kenya with an ex of mine, we met a local friend of hers, that friend would’ve benefited from a more reliable electricity bill, but her monthly rent and utility bills combined was equivalent to about $85 and she couldn’t afford to move. A 1kwh battery would probably be a pretty positive impact. Add on a 300W solar panel and you'd have something that would extend the amount of electricity the have. That'd come in at ~$400 (assuming $50/kwh). Not enough to run an AC, but enough to keep the lights on and maybe run a fridge. Otherwise... yeah... not much good news for places that can't afford such batteries.
- xorfish 5y agoMoores law isn't dead: https://ourworldindata.org/technological-progress https://ourworldindata.org/technological-progress You probably mean Dennard scaling is dead. The breakdown was around 2006. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennard_scaling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennard_scaling