21 ms·
ST3000DM001
- rektide 5y agoI could have sworn it was a similar 1.5TB drive that most infamous. Ah well.
- qbasic_forever 5y agoThe IBM Deskstar drives from the early 2000's are the most infamous to me. I remember having to put one in the freezer for a bit in a last ditch attempt to get one more boot out of it and copy data off before it was lost for good. Early 2000's computer hardware in general was a total nightmare at times.
- Lammy 5y agoYou're probably thinking of the Barracuda 7200.11's event-log suicide-roulette firmware bug. It was the first time I ever had to update the firmware of a fixed disk, and I remember it being a huge pain since the revised "SD1A" firmware came with a brand new bug and had to immediately updated again: - https://msfn.org/board/topic/128807-the-solution-for-seagate-720011-hdds/ https://msfn.org/board/topic/128807-the-solution-for-seagate... - https://www.anandtech.com/show/3482 https://www.anandtech.com/show/3482 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seagate_Barracuda#Firmware_bug_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seagate_Barracuda#Firmware_bug...
- AussieWog93 5y agoThat's what I assumed the article would be about too. Happened just as I started seriously getting into PC building. Haven't trusted Seagate since.
- Scramblejams 5y agoMe too. I missed the 3TB debacle because my Seagate 750GBs and 1.5TBs had all croaked, so Seagate had lost me as a customer by the time the bigger drives came into my price range. Silver lining, I guess. I've had great luck with Hitachis and Toshibas.
- tbyehl 5y agoI got bit by the Samsung Spinpoint F4EG data loss bug on two 1.5TB drives. https://www.smartmontools.org/wiki/SamsungF4EGBadBlocks https://www.smartmontools.org/wiki/SamsungF4EGBadBlocks
- shric 5y agoYeah, I bought 8 of these back in the day for two RAID servers. I have one left that I haven't had to replace since.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoI also remember the IBM Deskstar 75GXP, which was so unreliable it earned the nickname "Deathstar".
- geocrasher 5y agoI worked at a small web hosting company back then, and we used a bunch of IBM Deathstar's. They certainly lived up to their name! I disassembled one just to see what went wrong, and I found the cause (of that drive's failure, at least). Here's a list of terms for reference: http://data-recovery-tips.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/hard-disk-data-recovery-tips-450.jpg http://data-recovery-tips.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/h... At some point, the bearing that serves as the pivot that the actuator arm and actuator attach to, is attached to the chassis of the hard drive with a bolt on the bottom of the drive. At that time, most drives also had a bolt that went through the cover. The Deathstar did not. It was only attached to the chassis. Which was fine, and that's the method commonly used since then. This particular drive had no thread lock on the bolt, and it had come loose, leading to a catastrophic head crash. I don't know if other Deathstar's suffered the same fate for the same reason. The Wikipedia article on the subject says it was due to the magnetic coating of the platters coming off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deskstar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deskstar
- opheliate 5y agoAh man, there’s something about reading about physical hard drive failure that really makes me cringe. Really beautifully intricate technology, but man, when things come out of place…
- bombcar 5y agoHard drives are one of those pieces of precision engineering that we encounter on a regular basis - it's quite amazing they work at all given the conditions we submit them to.
- r1ch 5y agoI have a recording from one of my drives which I believe was a failing Deathstar. Not a pleasant sound to experience. https://r-1.ch/hdd.mp3 https://r-1.ch/hdd.mp3 (warning, loud)
- keanebean86 5y agoI like to think the flood was a cover for some government buying a mind boggling quantity of hard drives. All for some massive spying operation. Obviously I have zero proof or even the tiniest bit of evidence. Just my personal conspiracy theory.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fencepost 5y agoI like to think the flood was a cover for some government buying a mind boggling quantity of hard drives. No, it was a cover for massive flooding that killed more than 800 people and led to most of Thailand being designated as disaster areas.
- keanebean86 5y agoI see how my wording horrifyingly misrepresented the meaning. I only mean the resulting supply issues. Not the actual flood.
- Fnoord 5y agoHN is not the place for (personal) conspiracy theories.
- Justin_K 5y agoI still have my Amazon receipt for two of these where one failed within 2-3 years.
- Koiwai 5y agoDamn, I have a 12 disk RAID-Z2 with that, almost all of them failed in about 1~2 years, luckily because of Z2, I didn't lose any data. I'll never buy seagate again.
- geocrasher 5y agoI bought a 500GB WD Green drive in 2010, and in 2011 I needed a second 500GB disk in a hurry. I went to a local supplier and all I could get was a Seagate 500GB disk. Oh well, beggars can't be choosers. I retired them both earlier this year, replacing them with a single 2TB WD Blue drive to augment my SSD. They are both still fully functional, not so much as a SMART error. I chalk it up to two things: The first is an extremely low number of power cycles. The second is that I never moved the computer thy were in until after they'd finished spinning down.
- flyinghamster 5y agoI also generally tend to keep drives powered up, and they indeed tend to live long. Still, I have to be on alert for failing drives. I had four of the WD30EFRX together in a 2x2 pool (roughly equivalent to RAID10). One day, one of them began showing checksum errors after a scrub, and I replaced it with a Toshiba DT01ACA300. Once the bad drive was out of the pool, I ran a full self-test on it, which it failed. I did at least get five years of service out of it, but in any case, it's time for me to think about some newer hardware. For my next NAS, I'm kind of leaning towards using 2x8TB mirrored, with a third drive to be rotated into the mirror, splitting off the rotated-out drive as an offline backup.
- Koiwai 5y agoMine was in a home NAS server, almost never powered down, or moved, they die nonetheless, the replacement I bought, mostly TOSHIBA models, still works at this very moment, NONE of them failed.
- dheera 5y agoBack in the day I used IBM drives and they were super reliable. Too bad they stopped making hard drives and all the Maxtors, Seagates, Hitachis, and WDs came along with all their crap.
- sjaak 5y agoI remember these, zpool history provides a nice record here. First one failed within a year! zpool history tank | grep "zpool create\|replace" 2013-03-26.23:27:40 zpool create -fo cachefile=/var/tmp/zpool.cache -o altroot=/mnt tank raidz2 gpt/disk0.nop gpt/disk1.nop gpt/disk2.nop gpt/disk3.nop 2014-01-18.19:00:41 zpool replace tank /dev/gpt/disk3 2014-01-19.09:59:45 zpool replace tank /dev/gpt/disk1 2014-11-30.14:44:59 zpool replace tank /dev/gpt/disk2 2015-09-13.21:16:11 zpool replace tank /dev/gpt/disk1 2016-01-03.15:37:40 zpool replace tank gpt/disk0
- seabrookmx 5y ago> zpool history TIL this exists. Neat!
- segfaultbuserr 5y agoHa, it's one of the few HDDs that have their own Wikipedia pages [0], and even more so, it's one of the only two Seagate drives [1] - the other was the ST506/ST412, Seagate's first product! It just shows how infamous this 3 TB Seagate drive really is. Other HDDs on Wikipedia include: IBM Deskstar (equally infamous), and other historical milestones like the DEC RK05 (classic HDD for PDP-8 and PDP-11). I just hope the upcoming Heat-Assisted (Seagate) and Microwave-Assisted (Western Digital) Magnetic Recording drives won't repeat history. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Hard_disk_drives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Hard_disk_drives [1] Several Seagate product families have their Wikipedia article, but ST3000DM001 and ST506 are the only two specific models.
- larsla 5y agoI had a 75GB "Deathstar" at the time and was really worried that it would fail. I was a teenager and couldn't really afford replacing it, nor have good backup solutions. I accidentally pulled a power pin while removing the molex connector and had to solder on a modified power extension cable. The drive kept on living for many years and IIRC it never failed while in active use.
- DrAwdeOccarim 5y agoYep, I lost a ton of pictures from my early college years because of IBM "Death Star" failures. The stinging has yet to pass...
- techrat 5y agoHad a deathstar before the drives were known to be widely failing. Decided one day to consolidate my backups from CDR to DVDR. Copied CDRs, deduped the contents and could fit about 15 CDRs worth onto one DVDR. Satisfied, I cut the CDRs and rebooted my system to prepare for a DVD burn. The drive died on reboot. Ended up taking a sledgehammer to the drive to get the anger out of my system. https://i.imgur.com/Di9rQqu.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Di9rQqu.jpg https://i.imgur.com/zxrKyzE.jpg https://i.imgur.com/zxrKyzE.jpg Remarkably sturdy, that drive base was.
- hackburg 5y agoAre you in need of a professional hacker? We offer the following services and more... . Consulting services. . Email password retrieval. . Credit repair [revolving and installment tradelines}. . Phone hack. . Clearing of criminal records. . Recovery of lost funds on Binary Options and Capital investments. *. Database retrieval..e.t.c... Visit us to know more: Hackburg.blogspot.com
- NL807 5y agoI own a pair of those in RAID-1 mode, now retired. I upgraded the array start of this year, as one of the drives developed a fault. In all honesty, they operated continuously for 8 years without much of an issue, despite the reported flaws. They were pretty fast, too.
- walrus01 5y agoI had three of these that died within 1.5 years of being new. Ugh.
- e_y_ 5y agoLooking at my order history, I had one in my RAID and RMA'd it 1.6 years later. The replacement lasted until 2019 (4.5 years).
- atkbrah 5y agoAt my previous employer we had a 24 disk zfs storage server built using these disks (thanks to an external consultant who replaced enterprise grade disks because "they're basically the same"). While they were still under warranty we replaced 50% of them and after warranty 100% of them were replaced using another brand.
- beagle3 5y agoThis model was really bad, but he wasn’t wrong in general - while consumer drives have a higher failure rate, you can’t pretend the enterprise version can’t fail - and if you’ve built your system to withstand failure, whether 2 or 5 fail every year makes little difference if you have competent IT. I do make an effort to source them from as many different batches as possible, though - based on a DeskStar (“DeathStar”) experience a couple of decades ago. And there have been occasional bad batches for many models. (The iirc 500MB DeathStar and this 3TB seagate are special in having mostly bad batches)
- toast0 5y ago> I do make an effort to source them from as many different batches as possible, though If you can, also stagger the initial power ons. There's a history of disk firmware bugs that are triggered by runtime; if it makes sense, you want to have enough of a difference in power on time to do a lossless replacement on your first disk before your second disk hits the magic number of time on.
- beagle3 5y agoIndeed. Synology, which I’ve been using for the last 10 years or so when the project cannot afford NetApp/EMC class storage, does this out of the box. (I’m sure netapp and EMC do too, but it’s not my problem when the disks inside them fail)
- edward 5y agoIn 2012 I was working at the Internet Archive. I remember the 2011 Thailand floods restricted the supply of hard disks and pushed up prices. The best deal we could find was buying these Seagate hard disks as external drives at retail from Costco. We picked up a truck load. Then had somebody with a screw driver remove them all from the enclosures and install them in new servers. The error rate was high, the drives didn't last long in production.
- bigiain 5y agoDropbox (or maybe BackBlaze?) called that "shucking".
- LordDragonfang 5y agoIf you're thinking of the same article as I am, it was indeed Backblaze: https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze_drive_farming/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze_drive_farming/
- andruby 5y agoThat was BackBlaze https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze_drive_farming/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze_drive_farming/
- taylorfinley 5y agoI don't know if Backblaze's usage predates it becoming the common way to describe this practice, but it's definitely caught on. For example see any deal post on an external drive on reddit /r/datahoarder
- sbarre 5y agoI worked at an ISP in 1996, where we would buy external Boca 28.8k modems in bulk from retailers and take the boards out to put them in our racks because they were cheaper - yet identical - to the "ISP-grade" versions that Boca sold as just boards. Back then we referred to it as shucking the modems, so it's definitely not a new term in IT/computing (never mind the actual origin of the word).
- myrandomcomment 5y agoBack in the mid 90s I was working in IT at a midsized company. We used Compaq desktops (this is the Pentium Pro timeframe). The HD in the system where quantum fireball (IIRC). They failed at an amazing rate all in the first 3 months (30%). We called Compaq at one point and said, look we want replacement drives for all of our remaining systems. After much back and forth (stupid on their part as we had 1000+ machines over their complete line, including servers, so good customer) they refused to help saying “we will only replace them as they fail.” Fine, as you wish. A week later we called into support and reported the failure of 50 HD. They did not believe us. Sent 3 technicians. After they tested the 20th HD the look on their face was priceless. At some point one of the techs noticed the taser on the one of the other work benches in IT. An hour later we received a call from the sale rep telling us that they would replace all the current drives in every system with this model as long as there are no more “mass failures.”
- Lammy 5y agoWere they Fireball SE maybe? http://www.redhill.net.au/d/74.php http://www.redhill.net.au/d/74.php "In the case of the Fireball SE, the mounting of the [power] socket was so flimsy that it was all too easy to break the PCB and thus ruin the drive. (With most other drives, you would have to be a gorilla and a drunken one at that.)"
- grp000 5y agoI'm not familiar with data center tools or terminology. What is a tazer in this context?
- lloeki 5y agoIIUC the same as in other contexts, the subtext being that in face of their refusal to replace these doomed HDs before a failure has registered, the failures were made to prematurely happen with a gentle stream of electrons.
- myrandomcomment 5y agoCorrect. To the other comments. We where a good customer that experienced an amazing stupidly high failure rate in a part that others also reported the same issue. The cost of deploying these systems and having them fail randomly broke planning and wasted the teams time and impacted our IT cost metrics. The cost of the support ticket, time and replacing and re-imaging a system was not free. We of course tried very hard to be preemptive in sorting this once we ID’ the issue. The vendor did not care, so another path was taken in order to help express our unhappiness to the vendor which resolve the issue. We paid additional money by paying for a brand name vs for white box with the idea that we would prevent this type of failure.
- batmaniam 5y agoI remember this fiasco. There was a class action lawsuit that was filed. I got curious as to what happened with that, and it turns out... nothing. From the wiki: > On June 15, 2018, Judge Joseph Spero ruled that the class action plaintiffs must separate into multiple classes, as there was too much variability in failure rates to combine all claims a single class. In 2019, the plaintiffs were denied class certification a second time. So basically Seagate got away with it.
- rasz 5y agoFujitsu not being US corporation didnt get so lucky. Their 2005 annual report listed HDD litigation-related expenses at 10,220 mil yen = ~$100mil Mmmm Fujitsu, the sweet sweet smell of conifer forest. The flux they used on those drives smelled amazing! I worked at European Fujitsu distributor in late nineties. Absolutely the best non IBM(1) hard drives you could buy at the time. Cheap, fast, dead silent, super reliable. Then this happened: https://www.theregister.com/2002/11/05/fujitsu_admits_4_9_million/ https://www.theregister.com/2002/11/05/fujitsu_admits_4_9_mi... https://www.dataclinic.co.uk/fujitsu-hard-disk-recovery/ https://www.dataclinic.co.uk/fujitsu-hard-disk-recovery/ “blame was laid on the supplier of epoxy mould compound used in the manufacture of Cirrus’ Himalaya 2.0 and Numbur chips” Symptoms were drive not being detected, reporting as garbage corrupted strings, not spinning up or even clicking. The irony is they are 100% perfect mechanically. Btw I read somewhere swapping pcbs without making sure they have same firmware rev on board might result in service area corruption requiring actual specialist knowledge to recover (or running premade script in PC3000). (1) and we all know how IBM Deskstars turned out ;-( Amazing and fast drives, until the sad conclusion.
- uyt 5y agoRelated article from backblaze: https://www.backblaze.com/blog/3tb-hard-drive-failure/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/3tb-hard-drive-failure/
- edward 5y agoI just added a photo to the Wikipedia article: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ST3000DM001_as_external_hard_drives_in_retail_packaging_at_the_Internet_Archive.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:ST3000DM001_as_exter...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ficklepickle 5y agoThanks for the details! I just came here to post them, because I found them interesting. I certainly didn't realize that the image was just added nor that I would have the chance to thank the contributor.
- neweggrma 5y agoI knew that looked familiar... https://i.imgur.com/ITCFzeu.png https://i.imgur.com/ITCFzeu.png (order: middle, bottom, top). Lucky me (not sarcastic, DOA is far from worst-case scenario).
- TranquilMarmot 5y agoHey, I used to have one of these! To this date, the only hard drive I've ever had that just flat out failed on me.
- theospears 5y agoI was responsible for maintaining some large glusterfs clusters built on top of these drives, and they certainly added excitement to the experience. 1) At one point we were experiencing disk failures often enough that we wrote a cronjob to detect drive failures via smartctl and automatically send an email to our hosting company requesting them replace the drive. This saved engineering time, and more importantly reduced time to drive replacement, because 2) On at least one occasion, we had the third drive in a RAID6 array fail before we had rebuilt from the initial failure, leading to loss of the array. We think the increased load of the rebuild increased the chance of subsequent failures. Needless to say recovering from this destroyed all plans (and sleep) for the weekend it happened.
- dstick 5y agoThese things always happen in the weekend don't they? When I managed a large network of servers, it seems that all the outages happened during parties and/or the weekend.
- lostlogin 5y agoIssues seem to happen as you implement the long desired upgrade/fix/repair too. Things hold on for years then crap out right at the final moment.
- Operyl 5y agoThis makes sense though doesn’t it? Rebuilding an array is a very heavy load op, and putting components that have been around for a while under heavy load seems like a good and fast way to expose failing parts.
- spookthesunset 5y ago> These things always happen in the weekend don't they? Thats because servers know.... oh they know. Tuesday morning when you get into the office? Naw... that's too easy. Let's shit the bed on Christmas morning at 3:49am. That will let those stupid humans know who is boss around here.
- mountainpower 5y agoWow, what a coincidence. I did some maintenance on my NAS yesterday and finally removed one of my oldest hard drives, which I had unplugged a while ago because it was too noisy (it still worked when I unplugged it). I thought the name was familiar, I checked and yes, it is the very same model. I guess I was lucky not to lose any data on it, I wasn't very good with backups back when I first bought it.
- martijnvds 5y agoCraft Computing bought a bunch of those because they were cheap, and decided to replace them recently: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sFwiThZkfVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sFwiThZkfVo
- Yizahi 5y agoI had two of them, both failed over few years of super light use in a cooled case (with dedicated HDD fans). No Seagates for me after that.
- formerly_proven 5y agoI still have one of these and it has always been loosing a little bit of data here and there for the last seven or eight years. Maybe even from day one and it just took me some time to notice. You can write a bunch of data to it, check it, and it will be fine, but after a few months there are probably a few hundred or thousand new unreadable sectors. Oddly consistent.
- londons_explore 5y agoSo why did this drive fail? Has nobody dissected it to figure out exactly which component no longer functioned correctly?
- Scramblejams 5y agoEvery time a submission like this pops up I expect someone who worked at Seagate during that era to pipe up and explain what went wrong and why ... but I haven't seen it yet. Surprising.
- londons_explore 5y agoI think it's sad that the hacker/maker community doesn't have enough knowledge/skill/inclination to disassemble this kind of thing and figure it out for themselves. It's a bad sign when tech complexity gets out of the expertise of a hobbyist - I believe that's the start of a stagnation of that technology as new young engineers never get excited about disassembling and modding hard drives in their free time, and in turn it becomes paid engineers only who, I suspect, are less innovative. When was the last time you heard someone who had modded their hard drive to, for example, seek faster?
- tester34 5y agohaha, it's even better if you replace in your comment hard drives with CPUs
- londons_explore 5y agoBut people do mod CPU's... By overclocking, by hacking into SMM mode, by liquid nitrogen cooling... People also make their own toy CPU's for fun with quite some regularity - using FPGA's and other tools, the same as the pros. And people decap and reverse engineer new CPU's like Apples M1.
- tester34 5y ago
- neilv 5y agoOther infamous drives: Sun used the Quantum 105S for the main drive in SPARCstations, and that drive turned out to have a stiction problem (would stop spinning up). At a workstation ISV that was primarily Sun for its own workstations, on the rare occasion we had to power off large numbers of workstations, always at least one machine wouldn't come back. I vaguely recall slapping a drive, or dropping it and its caddy a short distance onto a desk, in the best tradition of "percussive maintenance". I also personally bought at least one Quantum 105S, and then later "nobody every got fired for buying IBM" personally bought an IBM Deathstar drive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deskstar#IBM_Deskstar_75GXP_failures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deskstar#IBM_Deskstar_75GXP_fa... Given my luck managing to find the worst lemon drives, for my subsequent home server, you can be sure that I intentionally used RAID mirroring of two different brands of drive. (Yes, it turned out that one make&model ran hot, while the other ran cool, and the hot one died.)
- cerved 5y agoI remember seeing a compiled list of hard drive failure rates for different models, I think it was backblaze. It was awesome
- Tempest1981 5y agoThe drive that taught people the importance of backups...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rollcat 5y ago> This particular drive model was reported to have unusually high failure rates, approximately 5.7 times higher fail rates in comparison to other 3 TB drives. Some anecdata: I have exactly two of these drives in my home NAS. The other two were WDC_WD30EZRX, one of them already failed, while the ST's are still going. All purchased in 2016.
- rincebrain 5y agoBefore the ST3000DM001, the ST31500341AS became infamous, both for its failure rate, and its firmware bug. The latter, if memory serves, was the bug where the drive had an internal event log that was a ring of 256 entries, and if it was at the last entry on boot, the hard drive's code on bootup for handling rolling back to 0 was (usually) broken, causing the hard drive to not start up any more. (I say usually because for this particular bug, regardless of whether I'm associating it with this model correctly, there were anecdotes of repeatedly power cycling the drives causing them to eventually boot normally, whereupon you could eventually apply the firmware update.) If you look up that model, you can find people commenting on stories about the ST3000DM001 asking "so when's the class action for the ST31500341AS?" edit: I see someone else in this discussion also remembers that family even better than I, because I forgot (or didn't update fast enough to encounter) the bug that was present in the first firmware update to fix this. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27419342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27419342
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoIn the late 1990s there were a slew of Connor hard drives with leaking seals. The outside of the platter would become corrupt and that would proceed inward. Seagate bought Connor in the middle of this and refused to honor the warranties. From what I recall a lawsuit followed and Seagate eventually capitulated.
- wilco4 5y ago> The lawsuit also pointed to user reviews of the hard disk drive on Newegg, which totaled more than 700 reviews with 2 or fewer stars. [5] Oh boy.
- dw-im-here 5y agoA wikipedia article with no context, really interesting
- andai 5y agoOne of the sources for this article is an interesting write-up by Backblaze about their experiences with these drives: https://www.backblaze.com/blog/3tb-hard-drive-failure/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/3tb-hard-drive-failure/
- donatj 5y agoI genuinely don’t know why anyone buys Seagate drives. Every single one I have owned with any decent level of usage since the mid-90s has died on me after a couple years. I actually bought a 4 Disk Seagate NAS and all 4 Seagate drives have since been replaced with HGST drives one by one.
- einpoklum 5y agoCongrats on what is possibly the least informative title I've seen on HN for years... seriously, can't something be done about titles for URLs?
- qualudeheart 5y agoI think it’s cute
- einpoklum 5y agoPerhaps that's because you know the model number? When people browse the list of titles on the front mpage, they should know what the story is about. So, in this case, something like: "ST3000DM001 - A disk model number that would live in infamy" or: "Seagate's infamous ST3000DM001" etc.
- qualudeheart 5y agoThere’s this aura of mystery and adventure to it. Who knows what it could be? It sounds like one of those sci fi wall-e tier robots.
- einpoklum 5y agoI once replaced all of my friend's filing box labels with new labels, whose cryptic text had an aura of mystery and adventure. Strangely, my friend did not enjoy the adventure I had set him upon. If you know what I mean.
- segfaultbuserr 5y agoUnfortunately, the HN rules say you can't do this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Please don't do things to make titles stand out, like using uppercase or exclamation points, or saying how great an article is. [...] please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize. Most of the time, this rule does more good than harm to prevent clickbaits, but it's not perfect and occasionally causes problem if the original title is not descriptive. In fact, there are multiple incidents that edited titles were reverted back by the mods, much to the complaints of the readers, I guess it's a small price to pay. Sometimes you can be sneaky so it won't be noticed, saying "Seagate's infamous ST3000DM001" is unacceptable, but the mods don't care if you say "Seagate ST3000DM001".
- mnw21cam 5y agoI won't buy Seagate hard drives unless I really can't avoid it. I missed this 3GB drive, but a while back I bought a Seagate 8TB SMR drive (ST8000AS0002) to store my backups on. It failed within months, so I got it replaced on warranty. The replacement failed within months, and I gave up on it. I was storing large files on it (just what it was designed for), each one with a par2 error correction file. Every now and again I would run the error correction, and it would usually find a few sectors that just returned the wrong data.
- elliebike 5y agoI guess I got lucky then! I've had one of these for quite a long time, maybe since 2013/14. A good number of those years it's been running 24/7, and I actually only recently replaced it
- Aerroon 5y agoI have this drive. It throws a "caution" in CrystalDiskInfo due to too many reallocated sectors. It has about 58,000 power on hours. I used it extensively for years for video recording. It held up well for me, but I don't really use it much since it threw that error. SSDs seem better for reliability these days - the TBW numbers are big.
- williesleg 5y agoIf I put all my data on these drives, the Chinese wouldn't have it right now.
- sega_sai 5y agoI had a backup JBOD with 36 of these drives. I thought since it was a backup machine that rarely will be used I could buy non-enterprise drives... Big mistake. There were 47 disk failures from 2013 to 2018.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoI had a a moment of "Well, that's weird, I recognize that name." I have one sitting in this very PC right now. Used it as a gaming drive until I was able to buy a 1TB SSD but it's still trucking along. I guess I'll want to replace that soon.
- HideousKojima 5y agoHard drives tend to fail early or after a long, long period of use, without much of an in-between. If it survived the first year of use then it should last as long as any other spinning disk drive.
- 509engr 5y agoI got three of these for a home NAS, not knowing any better. One failed within a day, the next failed within the first month, the third one lasted several years. For a long time, I didn't trust the NAS, making regular second backups (always a good idea) figuring it was the common point of failure, but the replacement drives were all working fine.
- GekkePrutser 5y ago> Paul Alcorn of Tom's Hardware argued that Backblaze used the drives in a manner that "far exceeded the warranty conditions" and questioned the "technical merits" of the lawsuit. I would question this. Backblaze knows what they're doing. And at least they provide a relative reliability index as they treat all drives the same.
- cosmin800 5y agoI don't know why anyone bothers to buy anything else than WD, seagate is making bad products for at least 10 years if not 15. Barracuda 7200.11 anyone? That was 12 years ago,I got a pair of Ironwolf 10TB, they failed in 6 months. How many seagates I saw failing? All - 30 - 50 God knows how many exactly. I have 10 years old WDs still running, actual powered on 6 years or so. I don't know why people are buying the same bad engineered products over and over again. Seagate should not exist anymore since long time ago.
- wil421 5y agoEvery seagate drive I’ve ever bought failed. After the 3rd failure on an external drive used for a multi-media PC I switched to WD. Still have 10+ year old WD drives that still work.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI use Seagate all the time, and while there are failures, I find the doom-saying about them to be greatly exaggerated. Moreover, because they are so much less expensive than the competition, and because I am using them in applications where redundancy is already a requirement, and because they have a warranty, everything has worked out.
- kstrauser 5y agoWD is temporarily dead to me after their shenanigans of selling Red drives that are SMR, which in my opinion is flat-out fraudulent. When WD pledges to stop selling SMR drives to NAS customers, I'll reconsider using them again. A Seagate may (or may not! see Backblaze stats) die sooner than a WD drive, but at least it's fit for purpose until then.
- rsync 5y agoWe buy a lot of seagate drives .... over the past few years in the 8, 10, 12 and now 16 tb capacities. I have never put any stock in this Ford vs. Chevy argument with hard drive manufacturers. Any of them are One model away from having a deathstar. We proof the drives fairly extensively and burn them in for long periods before deploying them. That has Worked out well.
- 5y ago
- juliansimioni 5y agoDoes anyone remember the DeskStar aka DeathStar drives? I had to look it up but apparently that was around 2001. As I recall that pretty much killed the IBM brand when it came to hard drives. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deskstar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deskstar
- fullstop 5y agoI had one that came in in a Macintosh G4 tower, and it died suddenly with a lot of photos that I wanted to save. I put the drive in the freezer in a plastic bag for about an hour and was able to boot the OS long enough to burn a DVD with the files that I wished to save. I'm much better about backing data up regularly now.
- ZeWaren 5y agoI remember using a bunch of Seagate 7200.12 HDDs around 10-15 years ago. After a couple years, I had multiple of them failing. Some of them were replaced by the shop I bought them at, some of them were replaced by Seagate directly. Every time, the data was lost. At some point, when the 5th drive failed, I realized that the failure was due to a firmware issue, that could be fixed by upgrading the firmware using a TTL connection and a serial console. I did exactly that, my data was accessible again, and the drive never failed again (it's still running now). I was very angry at Seagate and other vendors for sending replacement drives with the old firmware when it was known that the firmware would cause the problem again, while the new firmware was out and working correctly.
- voldacar 5y agoI would love to know what the specific physical difference is with Seagate drives in general that makes them less reliable compared to WD, toshiba, etc. Nobody ever seems to describe that other than saying vaguely that they use cheaper parts.
- wazoox 5y agoThe 1TB Barracuda ES.2 was hardly better. Around 2009-2010, I've set up 3000 of them. 1800 had to be replaced under warranty. After that we switched to HGST and never looked back. For the thousands of Helium HGST/WD drives I've set up since 2014, I had to replace only a handful of them overall. In fact my support account generally needs a password reset because it's been sitting unused for 1 year straight... Contrast that with the awful time when I was spending half my days replacing Seagate drives, and the other half asking for RMAs...
- joshstrange 5y agoI have 1 of these still in an array and my second to last one died a few weeks ago. They had high failure rates for sure but some of them held on for a good 5+ years for me. All of these drives came from shucking and a little over a year ago I moved from Seagate externals to WD externals and my pain increased 10-fold. Not only did I have to deal with the 3.3V pin issue but I've had drives die in under a year. Since then I dropped externals for internals (and the warranty that comes with it) and I went back to Seagate (Exos). Of course now buying a hard drive is insane with the prices where they are (easily $100 over what I paid before the price spike).
- seabrookmx 5y ago> I have 1 of these still in an array and my second to last one died a few weeks ago Exact same story here. With the exception of one of the Seagates that did die really early (< 1 year) the rest of them had the same lifetime as my 2TB WD Reds. I certainly wouldn't recommend them given their track record but it does seem this issue is a tad overblown.