7 ms·
Many hourly jobs love to schedule people at seemingly random times, so they'll never know from one week to the next what times they'll have free and can't make
by h2odragon 5y ago
Many hourly jobs love to schedule people at seemingly random times, so they'll never know from one week to the next what times they'll have free and can't make commitments outside of work.
Very few employers seem interested in hiring "part time" workers with higher priority commitments that may interfere with their desired schedule. This extends to "can't work on $holy_days" and things that have legal backing; hourly employees aren't likely to pursue the theoretical means of redress they have for those incidents.
Then add the other layers of suck jobs have now. Instead of being an expert in "what plumbing stuff our store has and where"; a clerk is now expected to meet credit card signup metrics, first, foremost, and only. A retired plumber who wanted to work at the home improvement store has what incentive to put up with this? Serving the community is great but those people have been eliminated as too old and crunchy and too hard for HR to deal with.
- johnrgrace 5y agoJobs are about more than a wage rate. To have unstable hours that you can't plan for makes some employers look terrible.
- nerdponx 5y agoThose employers don't care. I suspect it's deliberate. If you can't plan your life, you are a slave to work.
- gruez 5y ago> Those employers don't care. I think parent's point is that employees care. Employers probably don't care that they're paying employees minimum wage, but if other places pay higher than that the the employees (who do care) would switch to the other jobs. >I suspect it's deliberate. If you can't plan your life, you are a slave to work. Are you suggesting they're deliberately doing this so "you are a slave to work"? How does the employer benefit from this?
- grecy 5y ago> How does the employer benefit from this? The workers can't do things like go to school or do anything productive, so they're stuck at that job for a much longer time than if they could better their circumstance.
- lovich 5y agoIt also gives the employers the ability to point towards any deviations from being available on short notice as a reason to legally fire people. You either give up your life to your low level job or you provide ammo for them to remove all of your legal protections because you aren't being fired for a legally protected reason, but because you violated policy or weren't flexible enough
- wccrawford 5y agoWhen I worked in those situations, it was never about "enslaving" the workers. It was a simple calculation made by the manager to make their lives easier. First, scheduling was always hard. So they did everything they could to make it easier for themselves, including last-minute changes that they didn't even tell you about. You were expected to somehow check the physical schedule in the store right before the new week started, even if you weren't scheduled that day. Second, they'd get sick of the complainers, so the worst complainers would get preferential treatment. The best workers ended up with the worst shifts, too, because they were less likely to just call in sick or quit. I feel like there were more lessons I learned about scheduling back then, but it's been quite a while now. It was always all about the managers avoiding personal hardship, and very little about the company itself.
- heymijo 5y ago> * Many hourly jobs love to schedule people at seemingly random times, so they'll never know from one week to the next what times they'll have free and can't make commitments outside of work.* A number of years ago I heard Reid Hoffmann on a podcast discussing how algorithms would replace management. How could technology replace the human demands of management? I couldn’t wrap my head around it. Now I see that this type of thing is what Hoffman meant. The human aspect would be removed. A faceless, nameless algorithm would take over. Scheduling some of the most vulnerable workers in our society to ensure they don’t cross over the 40-hour per week threshold for work that would require benefits or overtime but also to ensure they don’t get paid to work an extra minute when there may be a bit of downtime.
- gavanm 5y agoThere's a book that takes this general idea in a direction. It's definitely intended as a commentary on society and the future, but you might enjoy reading it. https://marshallbrain.com/manna1 https://marshallbrain.com/manna1
- heymijo 5y agoThanks for sharing that gavanm. Skimming it shows that others have thought about this much more than me. I look forward to reading it.
- I-M-S 5y agoIf you want to see a more optimistic (?) implementation of this idea in fiction, you might be interested in my podcast The Program audio series.
- mastersummoner 5y agoI read this a year or so ago. I remember finding the vision of the Utopian future absolutely fascinating, but I always find the sort of dystopia he described happening before that unrealistic. For me at least, it's hard to imagine there not being enormous pushback before society could get nearly that bad. I'm definitely a bit of a utopianist, but in my mind the power of consumers versus profit driven business people always is cyclical. I find it much more likely that the technology to autonomously create houses, grow and harvest food, and generally automate a sane, healthy life for a person will advance significantly, and some philanthropist trillionaire will buy up vast swathes of currently uninhabited land and turn it into a utopia.
- enraged_camel 5y ago>>Many hourly jobs love to schedule people at seemingly random times, so they'll never know from one week to the next what times they'll have free and can't make commitments outside of work. Some employers do this on purpose because they don't want their employees getting second or even third jobs that might leave them exhausted by the time they arrive for their shifts at the first job.
- nostrademons 5y agoIt does make me wonder if anyone's ever tried "stochastic employment". Instead of having one (or even 2 or 3) jobs, have like ten. Show up whenever they call you in for your shift. If there's a conflict, just don't show up and see how long it takes for them to fire you. If they fire you, no big deal, you've got 9 other jobs. Periodically add more jobs to your collection when you start getting low on work. Basically invest the same amount of emotional energy in each job as they invest in you as a worker.
- svaha1728 5y agoMight work, but the none of these jobs are offering health care. The perks would be working nonstop for years of your life, and maybe free fast food.. not a great haul for gaming the system
- nickthemagicman 5y agoThey mark you forever. They can do a background check and find out why you were fired. I requested a copy of a job background check from TransUnion and it was creepy the amount of info that had been collected on me. There are big brother lists to track you.
- xbar 5y agoThe Right to Be Forgotten leads to some interesting thought experiments.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI love this idea; you could use software to automatically auction your various skills and time to create bidding wars. You wake up and have no idea what job you are doing in the morning versus the afternoon, and you could see stats on what skills are making the most money to find training or shadowing opportunities.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoOne of the benefits for people working at Chick-fil-a is that they always know they'll have Sunday off. Even five years in the future you can commit to doing something on a random Sunday. Unless you're in management or work at HQ, hopefully you're not still working there five years later but if you are, you always know you have that day off.
- JMTQp8lwXL 5y agoYour point on religious days intrigued me. I wonder if there's a more than casual relationship between "on demand" workers (which is often the case with part-time workers given random schedules week-to-week) and declining religious affiliation. If you don't know if you'll be working on Saturday or Sunday or not, you cannot regularly attend church/synagogue/mosque/etc. It's another barrier to friction, and surprisingly simple things can shift behavior.
- raincom 5y agoFry's electronics used to schedule their workers like this. - Either Saturday or Sunday off - No consecutive days are off - two openings (start around 7 or 8 am, end by 3 or 4 pm) - two closings (start around 2 pm, end by 10 pm or so) - one normal day (start around 9:30 am) This was how they used to 'enslave' their workers: by ruining their sleep patterns (two opening vs two closing); by not doing any productive work on their own (by not giving two successive days off); by preventing people from going to school (through different start times).
- kaidon 5y agoThis sounds like my hours at a restaraunt while doing my BSc. I have no idea how I made it... but it was worth it, becase I was making $7/hr...
- brandmeyer 5y agoA schedule like that isn't about enslaving workers. Its cross-training them and ensuring that nobody gets preferential treatment.
- imtringued 5y agoHonestly, how is this supposed to work? From the employer's perspective you are basically scraping at the bottom of the labor market and the only reason your business model works is that there is a lot of pond scum (not in the sense that these people are worthless) to scrape off at the bottom of the bucket. From an economic perspective this is highly inefficient. The free market isn't about propping up nonviable business models, it's about getting rid of them. If you can just fire your employees for arbitrary reasons it tells a lot about your business, it means you actually don't need those employees and as soon as another business pops up that needs them you don't care about losing them. In other words: You don't deserve them. Just think about it, where is productivity growth supposed to come from if you treat each employee like a slave? If you need to grow your business your strategy is to just get more slaves. You're never going to think about making sure your employees can perform to the best of their ability. You're also never going to use labor efficiently because all "business problems" can be solved by hiring another employee that doesn't complain. None of this makes sense. Cheap labor was a mistake to begin with, just because corporations got addicted to cheap labor doesn't mean we have to continue that trend.
- killtimeatwork 5y agoCapitalism is about providing value to consumers at lowest possible prices, not about maximizing some abstract (i.e. non-monetary) efficiency. If destitute workers are cheaper than robo arms, then the company will obviously have no reason to invest into those arms, and will exactly grow the business via "just getting more slaves" - see Foxconn and other similar empires.
- LocalH 5y agoMost large-scale employers expect even the lowest paid workers to treat the job like it is the most important thing in their life. This is inhumane, and leads to almost every mistreatment of employees. Unabashed capitalism at work.