3 ms·
So what are the city people going to eat if it has to be local? My perspective is that there are simply too many people and they are leading an increasingly mo
by giantg2 5y ago
So what are the city people going to eat if it has to be local?
My perspective is that there are simply too many people and they are leading an increasingly modern (high consumption) lifestyle.
- tharkun__ 5y agoI would tend to agree. Cities breed lots of problems. Social, economic, environmental, every kind you can imagine. And it creates very very small communities outside those cities which comes with its own problems too (think small town sheriff's tyranny type stuff - yes there's racial profiling etc in big cities as well, didn't say it was a unique problem). Bigger numbers do have an advantage but there is definitely a number that is too large. I would advocate for lots of intermediate size cities but that doesn't seem to be what anyone in power wants. Also, are you advocating for Thanos like mercy here? ;)
- giantg2 5y agoNot just that the settlement size is not right, but that the planet can only support so many people. Sure, they estimate it can support up to 11 billion. But that assumes increases in technology and commercial agricultural as well as consumer changes (like little meat). This also doesn't take into account it being sustainable or not. We need a shrinking population and less consumerism. We are not currently sustainable (and unlikely to become so anytime soon).
- BurningFrog 5y ago> the planet can only support so many people I think this is a big, and very sad misunderstanding. Back in humanity's hunter gatherer days, we truly lived off what the planet spontaneously produces, and that sustained world population of something like 50 million people. The we invented farming, and all sorts of technology, and now we're 7000 million. So how do those 6950 extra millions survive? I think the best way to think of it is that they (we) produce their (our) own food! Each mouth to feed also comes with two hands to produce food. The planet doesn't have to do the work. We make our own food.
- shmageggy 5y agoThis is wrong. By this logic the planet could support infinite people, which is clearly impossible. > The planet doesn't have to do the work. We make our own food. We don't just conjure food from the ether, it requires space and resources, both of which are finite. We're already using half of the world's habitable land for farming, and we need to retain some wild spaces to perform all of the ecological functions that farmland can't. There's a limited amount of fresh water, etc. And food isn't the only bottleneck. If the current population all lived a modern western lifestyle, we'd be emitting an even more unsustainable amount of carbon. The planet is a closed, finite system, so by definition there must be some upper limit to what it can support.
- giantg2 5y agoSo why do the experts estimate the planet can support between 8 and 11 billion people? 2 hands to produce it? No. Modern agriculture relies on machines for most things. The high yield monocrop pattern is how we feed so many already. I firmly believe that increasing people will decrease suitability.
- TheGigaChad 5y agoI would advocate for you to hang yourself.
- rab-the-goat 5y agoIf they have such a high population and low production that they have to steal other peoples food sources, they're an existential threat to everyone else. What they will eat has been determined, and it's not likely to make the transition to local. So other people's starvation and the mass destruction of habitat will continue to be their externalities.
- giantg2 5y agoMuch of the fish in the US is imported from China. So it's not just what "they" are eating.
- adventured 5y agoDo me a favor and post the latest figures on US domestic fish vs imports, where the imports break out to on a country-by-country basis, along with separating out US domestic fish that are exported to and then imported from China in a processing loop (used for cheaper processing, not actually caught or farmed by China). That way we can better analyze the context of what "much" actually means.
- giantg2 5y agoYou can do that if you'd like. It's supposed to be 30% of seafood is actual Chinese imports.