4 ms·
Your analogy is flawed because you seem to be assuming that the people with execution authority are the ones who reached an agreement in principle. You’d expect
by rayiner 5y ago
Your analogy is flawed because you seem to be assuming that the people with execution authority are the ones who reached an agreement in principle. You’d expect them to succeed in papering it up.
That’s not the case here. The agreement in principle was reached by someone who has no power to do anything with regards to corporate taxes. Congress sets U.S. tax law and agrees to treaties. To do that, you need 60% or 66% of the Senate. It’s like the CFOs reaching an “agreement in principle” to something that requires Board approval—and a big chunk of the Board is hostile to management.
- lukeschlather 5y ago> The agreement in principle was reached by someone who has no power to do anything with regards to corporate taxes I think you are considerably understating the power of the G7 finance ministers including the US Secretary of the Treasury. Sure, they can't ratify a treaty without the cooperation of congress. They're still extraordinarily powerful individuals and have loads of direct authority to shape tax policy.
- kortilla 5y agoThey can certainly shape implementation details not defined by laws, but they can’t create laws or change existing ones.
- ncallaway 5y agoMy analogy is really just a reference to what "reached a deal" colloquially means. "reached a deal" doesn't mean the deal absolutely 100% will be implemented. It means, the referenced parties have reached an agreement to something. In this case, the leaders of the G7 countries have reached an agreement among themselves to have a minimum corporate tax rate. Note that the United States has no obligation according to this deal—only Joe Biden has agreed the deal. And Joe Biden has no legal obligation under the deal, he merely has a reputational one. Since the agreed minimum corporate tax rate is 15%, and the United States corporate tax rate is 21% there's literally nothing Joe Biden needs to do in order to meet the terms of the deal he made with the other G7 leaders. If they want to turn this into an international treaty, absolutely, GOP Senate votes will be needed (though, given that the treaty would create a floor that's 6 percentage points below our current tax rate, I would imagine those would be attainable votes—if the GOP created a global floor that was lower than our tax rate, they could use it to argue for lowering our corporate tax rate).
- mistermann 5y agoTyler Cowan seems unimpressed: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/06/the-new-proposal-on-corporate-tax-synchronization.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/06/th... More smoke and mirrors perhaps?
- gscott 5y agoIt should be more of an alternative minimum tax. The corp ends up paying 0% due to tax write-offs the AMT kicks in and charges 5% or something.
- occamrazor 5y agoThere are actually many steps. In this case: 1. The finance ministers reach an agreement. This is what has happened. 2. A treaty is written and signed, normally by the head of state, but sometimes by the head of government (for the US in both cases the President). At this point the treaty in not yet legally binding, although according to international law the signatory country has an obligation "to refrain, in good faith, from acts that would defeat the object and the purpose of the treaty."[1] 3. The parliament (for the US the Senate) ratifies the treaty, making it binding. 4. The parliament (House and Senate in the US) creates the necessary national legislation to implement the provisions of the treaty. 5. The government creates the secondary legislation for the application of the national legislation created at 4. Usually after 2. the other steps follow more or less smoothly, but there are some high profile cases where the ratification never happened (e.g. the Kyoto protocol). [0] https://treaties.un.org/pages/overview.aspx?path=overview/glossary/page1_en.xml#signaturesubject https://treaties.un.org/pages/overview.aspx?path=overview/gl...
- skissane 5y ago> 3. The parliament (for the US the Senate) ratifies the treaty, making it binding. Under international law, ratification happens when a state’s international representatives (head of state, ministers, ambassadors) formally lodge instruments of ratification with the depositary. (See Article 2(1)(b), Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.) When the US Senate "ratifies" a treaty, that is not ratification under international law, that is a domestic legislative procedure which confusingly happens to have the same name. Under international law, legislatures are not involved in ratification, only the state's international representatives are (which almost universally belong to its executive). Domestic law may require those representatives to consult or seek approval from the legislature, but international law mostly (but not entirely) doesn't care about those requirements.
- tormeh 5y agoInternational law is very much a gentlemen's agreement, though. It's not like domestic law. Domestic law always wins.