3 ms·
It's not common sense, contesting your priors and verifying your assumptions is one of the hardest and most important parts of doing data-driven science. It's
by marcosdumay 5y ago
It's not common sense, contesting your priors and verifying your assumptions is one of the hardest and most important parts of doing data-driven science.
It's also not surprising that when you take a set of random people without science training, they'll just cargo-cult the most visible parts and forget about the hidden, essential ones. It should also not surprise anybody what part they forget about, since the calgo-cult speech is literally about this exact problem, but with trained scientists (did I say it was hard?) instead of random people.
- Griffinsauce 5y agoI think our thoughts aren't mutually exclusive. Good science > intuition/experience/best practices etc > bad science. I suspect we agree that a lot of product development is based on bad science. Yes doing good science would be best, but let's at least stop doing bad science.
- marcosdumay 5y agoOh, the problem is that it's not as simple as intuition/experience/etc being better than bad science. Often enough your intuition is just wrong, and bad science is just right. A better way is dealing with confidence values with your intuition, and changing the required quality of science based on the confidence of the priors you are trying to verify. But then, this is hard too. The real problem here is that, as you complained, those people aren't just competent enough on the work they are doing. I guess my point is only that this shouldn't be surprising, as it's a hard job.