7 ms·
I frequently walk my dogs without leash. They follow my command, don't disturb other people or dogs unless both parties engage and generally I don't do anything
by diggan 5y ago
I frequently walk my dogs without leash. They follow my command, don't disturb other people or dogs unless both parties engage and generally I don't do anything that someone who has a leash wouldn't be doing. They also walk side-by-side with me when off-leash. This is very common in the city I live and surrounding area (Barcelona, Spain and Catalunya). Both me and others without leashes are indistinctive from people who are using leashes.
How is inconsiderate if the dogs themselves are behaving? Maybe there is something I'm missing, and I'd like to understand your point of view. I could understand you think it's inconsiderate if people don't have control on their dogs and they annoy others while the owners do nothing, then I agree with you. But just because of being off-leash? Not sure I understand that line of reasoning.
Edit: Just to clarify further, if I did meet someone who asks me to leash my dog I would obviously do so without hostility or violence. In my ~6 years of having dogs in Barcelona, that has yet to happen even once.
- tomjen3 5y agoThe wast majority of dogs that aren't leashed should be. If I encounter your dogs I can't know if they are one of the handful out of a hundred who are totally safe to keep off leash, or not. I can also not know if they are mostly fine off leash but react badly to bicyclists, other dogs or whatever. So when I encounter them I have to assume you are not a reponsible dog owner.
- blamazon 5y ago> How is it inconsiderate if the dogs themselves are behaving? This is the problem right here. We have no idea whether your dogs are properly trained or not. There is no certification or regulation for having a dog off leash. We have no idea if they’re going to suddenly snap and, in the worst case scenario, viciously attack a baby, something they are biologically quite capable of. It is probably different in collectivist societies where folks consider proper training a prerequisite to going off-leash, but where I’m from we have a scourge of ignorant owners who are not in control of their dogs. They ruin it for everybody.
- diggan 5y ago> We have no idea whether your dogs are properly trained or not I think the assumption is, at least from mine and others like me, is that if your dog is off-leash, you can handle your dog off-leash. The same if you bring friends to some social event, you wouldn't bring them if you can't handle them and they can behave in public. I'm not afraid they are gonna attack me, although sometimes humans do attack other humans, most of them are fine so no need to worry in general. > but where I’m from we have a scourge of ignorant owners who are not in control of their dogs. They ruin it for everybody. Yes, I agree, it's terrible when owners have no control over their dogs. But that's not relevant to the leash itself, that's relevant to the expertise of the owner. Dogs on leashes misbehave as well, and can easily (if wanted and the owner is a terrible one) unleash themselves by either raw power or the owner not paying attention.
- TomVDB 5y ago> The same if you bring friends to some social event, you wouldn't bring them if you can't handle them and they can behave in public. No, this is not the same. You are legally responsible for the behavior of your dog.
- musingsole 5y agoThe legal responsibility angle of this all always leave my head spinning. If you let your dog off leash in a place where it is illegal to do so, congratulations: you've just lost the lawsuit. If anything remotely funny happens -- regardless of what -- the liability can and will fall on the dog-owner for their reckless behavior. The real sad part of this is when the dog gets put down for the stupid owner...but my point is the people who let their dogs off leash have also posted a big, red sign saying "I'm responsible for anything happening here" -- even though few of them seem aware of that fact. Liability only becomes a question again if there is another dog-owner with their dog off leash.
- wang_li 5y agoDogs should be treated like guns and other weapons. If a person gets a fine or jail time for shooting someone, a dog owner should get the same if their dog bites someone. If my gun would be taken away if I rubbed it in someone's crotch, then a dog should be taken away if it sticks its snout in someone's crotch. Perhaps one would say "it's not the owner's fault, the dog makes it's own decisions", well that makes it worse. my gun doesn't aim and fire itself. So maybe dogs should be regulated even more than guns.
- asimpletune 5y agoDo we just downvote people now who contradict the majority’s opinion? As far as I can say this adds to the discussion. Someone literally said people who don’t have their dogs on leashes are prone to violent confrontations. Then someone else retorted this is not the case for them and asked for elaboration to better understand their interlocutor’s point of view. We should not be abusing downvote privilegies by discouraging viewpoints that we disagree with, when these viewpoints are relevant to the discussion. In the long run that will be harmful to ths community here and the next generation of hackers will go to different forums, or, worse, learn from our example.
- randompwd 5y agoMeta comments do not belong.
- totalZero 5y agoI'm not the GP but I'd like to comment on this because it's an interesting question. Some people are afraid of dogs. Others come from cultures where dogs are considered ritually unclean. And no stranger can verify just by a glance that your dogs will behave themselves. To take the third point to its logical extreme, imagine a town where police wear street clothes and openly carry firearms. You, a visitor, cannot determine by observation alone that they are all highly trained officers of the law. You simply see people with firearms. That could be unsettling, despite the fact that the presence of those people actually makes you safer. I suppose that if everyone is walking their dogs without a leash, it's not really an issue because the culture has adapted to that practice.
- foobiekr 5y agoI have a friend whose pet dog killed one of his other pets, is known to growl at children, and to me seems genuinely dangerous. Friend insists that the dog is a good boy and wouldn’t ever hurt anything. Friend insists dog loves children. Friend is an intelligent, gregarious, kind hearted tech worker. He’s also completely delusional and in denial about his dangerous, demonstrably violent pit bull. Friend routinely takes dog off leash in places where that is not permitted. This is the problem.
- CJefferson 5y agoThe problem is I don't know your dogs are well controlled. I've been bitten twice over the last year by leashless dogs. This could of course be solved by introducing stiff penalties for owners of unleashed dogs who bite -- how about a fixed 10,000 dollar fine?
- ptr2voidStar 5y ago>introducing stiff penalties for owners of unleashed dogs who bite -- how about a fixed 10,000 dollar fine? If such a law were ever to be passed, something tells me a lot of people with "well behaved" dogs would suddenly start to leash their dogs "just in case". Humans are very predictable in that fashion.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- patcon 5y agoLaws are about enforceability, not individual outcomes. Your doing what you're doing stabilizes a culture where there can be no consequences for anyone in this domain, because there's no clear line of enforcement. What's a low-wage enforcement officer expected to do in this context you advocate, where people "mind their own dog's abilities" and only get fined when some clear violation occurs? Are they supposed to fine people only when they see dogs chasing birds, or scarring a fearful child, or jumping up on an elderly person, or any number of other things with unclear lines? No, you just outlaw dogs off-leash, and allow the $20/h enforcement officer to clearly execute their pro-social task. The anti-social behavior get fined.
- admax88q 5y agoSo basically the parties that are actually the problem are too hard to find, so we target everyone who fits into a similar category.
- bradleyjg 5y agoYes, because we don’t have infinite enforcement resources we need to decide if we are going to prioritize type I errors or type II. Given the balance of harms minimizing type II errors (i.e. requiring leashes where they aren’t necessary) seems the better choice.
- diggan 5y agoTo be fair, walking your dogs without a leash in the city of Barcelona is already illegal. You can walk past the police and they won't do anything though, unless your dog is not behaving, then they'll use the law to give you a fine for not having a leash. So while it's setup like you say it is, in theory, what you think cannot happen is what happens in practice. Same with public drinking and other laws. The police usually look the other way unless you are abusing it somehow, being too drunk, loud or otherwise annoying. Sitting in the park with a bottle of wine is fine and won't end up with you getting a ticket, even though it's illegal. At worst they'll tell you to stop whatever you're doing, and if you follow their command, that's the end of the situation. Maybe the big difference here between law officers in Spain (Barcelona at least) and wherever you're based, is how strict they actually enforce the laws. Here is maybe a bit laxer, which also fits in with the whole culture here, and it's represented in how law officers behave as well.
- dnh44 5y agoWalking dogs off lead is totally normal in the UK as well.
- giobox 5y agoDog attacks are common enough in the U.K. to be a topic you can subscribe to on the BBC news site. While it’s definitely pretty culturally acceptable to have a dog off leash there, I’m not so sure it should be, especially in places such as children’s parks or near livestock etc. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c9q9301541xt/dog-attacks https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c9q9301541xt/dog-attacks
- diggan 5y agoStrangely enough, most of those stories are about dogs attacking their own owners/families and seems to indicate the dogs were leashed in most stories.
- dnh44 5y agoCoincidentally a friend of mine was just attacked and bit by a large Alsatian. Luckily he is mostly okay! The dog was on the lead (or leash for you American English speakers) at the time of the attack though.
- wheels 5y agoThree things: - Laws are virtually never there to regulate the median case. They're there to reduce the risk of harm. The reason we don't let people have automatic weapons isn't because most people would go on a killing spree if they had one, it's that a tiny minority would, and that would be disastrous. - It's literally only been just yesterday that I watched someone's "well behaved" dog attack my friend's dog on a leash. He had to pull the (probably 3x larger) dog off of his. My brother had stitches on his face from being bitten as a kid by someone's "well behaved" dog. I have zero faith in dog owners' ability to self-regulate. - I'm sure you have the one dog in the world that doesn't chase birds. Most dogs do. This is specifically about that case.
- Enginerrrd 5y ago>- I'm sure you have the one dog in the world that doesn't chase birds. Most dogs do. This is specifically about that case. This really demonstrates your ignorance. Such dogs are not uncommon, particularly when well trained. My dog doesn't chase birds. She's a border collie that lives for frisbee and frisbee only. I taught her the herding maneuvers, but she does it lackadaisically and it's hard to get her to give eye to chickens. She's just not into it, but she'll humor me if I tell her to do it. Frisbee though... she is. And she can be at a dead sprint after a frisbee in flight and if I say "Stop" she'll stop on a dime. If the frisbee drifts off the field and into the street, she'll simply stop on the edge of the grass or sidewalk and wait for my ok to go get it without me saying anything. And my dog really isn't special. Honestly, she has been a difficult to train dog from day one, but she has still been trained. Her mother though... man she's a true pleasure to work with. I usually walk her off leash as well. When people ask me to put her on leash, I do, and I hold it with a loose pinky finger since it's kind of a joke because of how unneeded it is.
- spicyramen 5y agoI have a toddler and I absolutely hate people doing this. I don't know you nor your dog. Sometimes I go to the park and people assume we can read minds and let stranger dogs come close to us. Please leash your dog
- smcl 5y agoStrange you're getting so downvoted. While I am a dog owner (and therefore may have a bias) I don't think you've said anything wrong or even controversial. I've seen a lot of US-based people who cannot fathom the idea of a well-behaved dog being completely fine off-leash, so maybe this is why? I must say that in this sort of situation - an area near a nesting site - I absolutely agree a dog shouldn't be free to run around. But I imagine there are signs specifically warning people against doing that. There are areas here where I have to do the same, for example near areas where people hunt deer (a lot nearby) or where there are bears (only seen warnings in Slovakia). But outside of those areas, with an conscientious owner and an attentive, trained dog who listens to their owner - there's no reason not to unless it's someone who hasn't bothered training their dog.
- asimpletune 5y agoIt is totally counter to HN ethos to downvote a opinion you don’t agree with, and I’m disappointed others don’t give pause and ask themselves why they’re doing it first. All the responses in this thread have been cordial and relevant, so it is disappointing to see some of them met with this kind of silent disapproval, which is reserved for non-sequitors, those acting in bad faith, or impolite speech.
- smcl 5y agoI'm particularly confused because this comment of mine is downvoted despite me agreeing with the idea that dogs should be leashed in these situations. But I understand - people get annoyed and irritated, and really it's just meaningless internet numbers at stake so it doesn't matter :)
- bradleyjg 5y agoThere are a lot of different dog cultures around the world and even within the US. In cities that have a lot of people from all over the country and world you end up with a lot of culture clashes. People do things that in the context they grew up in are totally reasonable and normal, but from someone else’s perspective seems uncomfortable or even dangerous. In theory municipal rules should harmonize, albeit with some people left unhappy, but it’s another American cultural quirk that some rules are widely ignored. But which ones is again a matter of geographic diversity.
- stephenhuey 5y agoYou’re in the minority - too many dog owners think their dogs are fine and when their dog runs dozens of yards away from their master to bound up to us th egg cheerfully call out, “It’s a friendly dog!” Then they go on their merry way and I have to attend to my 2 crying toddlers. Maybe they only kicked my kids’ faces but sometimes they knock them down. I grew up with dogs in the 20th century - mine could obey and do tricks but I still didn’t make assumptions and grabbed them if we were in a situation like that. I don’t live out in the middle of nowhere - we’re in one of the largest cities in the USA and it’s illegal but dog owners think it’s a suggestion the way speeders on the road often do!
- diggan 5y ago> You’re in the minority Yes, if I was in the USA maybe I would be in the minority. But where I actually live (Barcelona, Spain) I'm not, as mentioned before. Countless people walk their dogs without leashes here, and no one bats an eye. > too many dog owners think their dogs are fine and when their dog runs dozens of yards away from their master to bound up to us th egg cheerfully call out, “It’s a friendly dog!” Sure that might be a friendly dog but in no way is that a well-behaved dog, it wouldn't run away yards away unless the owner explicitly calls out for them to behave that way. Living in ~16th or something biggest city in Europe, you wouldn't have your dog stray that far away from you, easily within a yard of yourself at all time, otherwise I wouldn't call them well-behaved. So back to the original point: off-leash dogs that don't behave properly have inconsiderate owners, yes I agree with this. Are all owners who let their dogs be off-leash inconsiderate? No.
- varjag 5y agoIf they leave their dogs off leash in leash-only areas, YES, they are being inconsiderate.
- nanis 5y ago> They follow my command That's great, as it should be. However, the majority of dog owners I encounter are at the mercy of their dogs, they treat the dogs not as dogs but as humans and try to bargain with them. This is merely annoying when the dogs is a golden lab, but can be mortal when it is a "sweet" "rescue" pit. You are right though, it doesn't matter if the dog is on a leash because people also get these 30ft (10m) leashes and all of a sudden, out of nowhere, someone's dog is trying to "just show affection" to a toddler. So, the golden rule is not to get a dog if you can't be pack leader. A very bad proxy for a person being able to control a dog is the dog being on a "short leash"[1]. So, people go for that rule. Then you get the 100 lb jogger (45 kg) who attaches a Doberman with a breakaway clip to their shorts. [1]: https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/on+a+short+leash https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/on+a+short+leash
- ptr2voidStar 5y ago>the majority of dog owners I encounter are at the mercy of their dogs, they treat the dogs not as dogs but as humans and try to bargain with them. The crux of the problem.
- mbrameld 5y ago> Both me and others without leashes are indistinctive from people who are using leashes. If this is true then you should have no problem putting a leash on them where it's required. By your own admission it wouldn't affect your activity.
- diggan 5y agoIndeed, if I do end up in a situation where it's required, I'll do it, no questions asked. But for day-to-day walks, it's not so I don't, together with the rest of almost everyone we meet with dogs on our daily walks.
- vimax 5y agoTo me the issue isn't generally having a dog off the leash, but specifically having a dog off the leash at a wildlife reserve where they may be running around disturbing the wildlife. It isn't a dog park.
- nitrogen 5y agoIndeed, there are areas (such as some federal land, dog parks, etc.) that specifically do not require dogs to be leashed, by design and intent. People who want to avoid dogs should avoid those places, and people who want to walk dogs off-leash should favor them.
- glennpratt 5y agoAnecdata: ~ I've been bitten in the hand drawing blood by two different dogs (not mine). ~ My daughter had a large dog nipping her face while the owner laughed. ~ I have too different acquaintances that were mauled on their face pretty badly. All these dogs had owners nearby. I love dogs and have had one or more the majority of my life, but people are irresponsible and arrogant.
- diggan 5y agoThat's really bad and obviously badly behaved dogs you have interacted with. I hope in all cases they got fined properly for the disturbance and ill caused, and hopefully improved over time, although unlikely... > people are irresponsible and arrogant Agree! And it does harm that people are behaving that way, but that doesn't give me reason to limit people who are not irresponsible and arrogant. Yes, some things are dangerous to consume for example, and irresponsible people can make it worse for everyone by consuming those things, but I don't think we should outlaw those things just because of that.
- Bud 5y agoNot a good analogy at all. You're comparing inanimate objects that people consume, entirely by choice, to an animal that can maim or kill others? Find a different rhetorical device, I'd say.
- seattle_spring 5y agoI philosophically agree with you, but the reality on the ground on US trails is that many people (dog owners or not) do not observe rules or etiquette. Go on a hike near Seattle and you'll probably leave with a Drake song memorized from how many kids are blasting it on their Bluetooth speakers. The actual trail is sometimes indistinguishable from the switchback cuts people make. Even take some time looking at US centric comments on this site lately: even with respect to a global pandemic, people will vehemently put their own wants over the greater good of society or the environment. The only solution is heavy handed enforcement. It sucks but I don't see a better way.
- cratermoon 5y agoEvery stereotype of the off-leash dog owner on display here. Leash your dog. To do otherwise is selfish and rude.
- diggan 5y ago> Every stereotype of the off-leash dog owner on display here. The comment I responded to called me "extremely inconsiderate", "hostile" and "violent" while I'm neither of those things (well, "inconsiderate" when it comes to how I handle my dogs seems to be up for debate at least). Are those the stereotypes you mean are visible in my comment? > Leash your dog. To do otherwise is selfish and rude. Thank you for sharing your opinion but it does not help me understand WHY, which I why I made my initial comment in the first place. You have something to contribute, contribute. But re-iterating exactly the same piece of information as what I replied to without any sort of addition or effort does not help anyone in this discussion. If you want to explain why you feel that way, please do.
- cratermoon 5y agoAre you familiar with the term "sea-lioning"?
- diggan 5y agoI wasn't but now I am. It doesn't seem like something we should subject HN to, so if that's what you're doing you should probably stop sooner rather than later.
- Bud 5y agoThis comment basically drips with a fundamental inability to see this situation from the other person's perspective. Even to see the most basic thing, which is that other people have no oracular powers with which to discern whether you or your dog are well-behaved.
- diggan 5y ago> This comment basically drips with a fundamental inability to see this situation from the other person's perspective Well... I mean yeah, that's why I asked for more information in order to understand the other persons perspective, what do you think this discussion is about? In case you missed it, here is the part I explicitly call out that I don't understand their perspective but I would like to, so please educate me: > How is inconsiderate if the dogs themselves are behaving? Maybe there is something I'm missing, and I'd like to understand your point of view. I could understand you think it's inconsiderate if people don't have control on their dogs and they annoy others while the owners do nothing, then I agree with you. But just because of being off-leash? Not sure I understand that line of reasoning. If you have something to contribute that can further my understanding, I'd be most appreciative. > other people have no oracular powers with which to discern whether you or your dog are well-behaved. Yeah, this is true but applies in so many things in life. New friend introduced by my other friend? Not sure they are well-behaved or not, but I'll default to that they won't murder me, but if they give signs that they might want to kill me, I'd stay away or contact authorities. I think in general society is adjusting well to the possibility of judging things as they come along, instead of painting broad strokes like "people with dogs off-leash are extremely inconsiderate", at least where I live, not sure how things look where you live.
- foobiter 5y agoit’s inconsiderate because you’re forcing strangers to trust you in a situation where you could alternatively follow a simple rule… it also sets a bad example for people with poorly trained dogs. We live in a society, not everything is about you.
- capedape 5y agoThis and even if they are behaving that can change anytime, especially in nature. This is coming from someone who just broke an elbow because of off leash dogs on a trail. Trail allowed bikes and dogs on leash. Dogs were on the side of the trail sniffing, caught wind of something else and immediately jumped in front of bike. I was going slow and watching them like a hawk. Dodged one and couldn’t the other. Owners were on a jog and literally ran off after asking if I was ok once. If the trail says keep dogs on leash , there might be a good reason.
- badgley 5y agohttps://slco.org/parks/millcreek-canyon/ https://slco.org/parks/millcreek-canyon/ there's a great hike just outside Salt Lake City that solves this problem by allowing bikes on even numbered days and off-leash dogs on odd numbered days
- abandonliberty 5y agoWhy do you have to follow [law] if you don't cause a problem for others? Would you make the same reasonable question for driving double the speed limit, not wearing a seatbelt, or carrying a gun in public? "How is it inconsiderate if I carry a gun in public? I've never shot or threatened anyone! If I met someone who asked me to put my gun away, I would obviously do so." :) Societies work because we agree to give up a measure of our personal freedoms, even when it's sometimes a bit inconvenient for us.
- diggan 5y agoGenerally law officers here apply laws against civilians based on preventing harm to others. If you have a wine bottle in the park and a officer walks by, they most likely wouldn't do anything. If you're loud and obnoxious, they would do something as you're disturbing others. Seemingly the police here are of the view that most dogs don't pose a threat to others and are not annoying when off leash, as I haven't been confronted when walking next to them with my leashed dog. Carrying a gun would obviously not be OK here as it's strictly outlawed. If I went to the US, I would probably feel the same way that some feel against dogs here but regarding guns, so that's actually a good point, thank you.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI have to agree, here in Barcelona there's no issues with dogs in general. People and dogs are well behaved. There is an issue with the police though, killing dogs unnecessarily. https://english.elpais.com/elpais/2018/12/20/inenglish/1545303649_028656.html https://english.elpais.com/elpais/2018/12/20/inenglish/15453...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]