3 ms·
You're missing the point. This was not an opinion piece; it's just a description of what the author encountered while working in India. Any opinion you attrib
by jrockway 15y ago
You're missing the point. This was not an opinion piece; it's just a description of what the author encountered while working in India.
Any opinion you attribute to the author is most likely something you are imagining based on your own opinions.
- davidw 15y ago> This was not an opinion piece; it's just a description of what the author encountered while working in India. Just like anything in reason.org is bound to have a certain slant, things in Mother Jones are not going to get published if they don't have their own slant. > Any opinion you attribute to the author is most likely something you are imagining based on your own opinions. The same phrase he mentioned popped out at me too, and if you look at it, it carries a lot of opinion: "Free-market cheerleaders, conflating" First of all, "cheerleaders" certainly contains a sense of someone in favor of something in a sort of rah-rah, go-team way that is not entirely positive. "Conflating" means: "they're mistaken". That said, yeah, it's mostly his experiences, but it's sprinkled with stuff to make it "on-message" with where it's published.
- bh42222 15y agoWhat's sad about the attempts to make it "on-message" is how bad and shallow they are. India is a big and complicated place, and there is a lot to think about its economic development. Are big foreign companies favored over small and/or local ones? Why, what kind of dynamic is at play here? How does the new economic power of women affect the sex selection of infants? There's just two examples, right of the top of my head, that I think (hope!) would be of interest to the hard core mother jones readers. But that's not where this goes, instead we get the shallow, almost caricaturish, money isn't everything undertone. Mixed with not enough money undertone, the workers should be getting paid more, they work 30+ hours shifts and still have to have bunk mates. All this mixed with, life sure can be complicated in this modern ever changing world. And none of these issues are explored in depth, it's just "doesn't it suck how little they are paid, doesn't it suck that money doesn't make you happy, hey look a Marxists!" I guess I would mind "on-message" editorializing a lot less, if it was part of a really good article. And what's most disturbing is this sense I get that maybe there could have been a much better article, but then it wouldn't have been on message, and to make it on message some bad things had to be done to the writing.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>How does the new economic power of women affect the sex selection of infants? // It was an article not a book. Isn't the purpose to raise in your mind these sorts of questions? He presents his experience to enlarge your outlook and enable you to address such questions in a more informed way. He's surely not attempting to offer an exhaustive insight into Indian culture just a snapshot from a long visit.