6 ms·
Honestly stablecoins - specifically tether - is about the only thing about crypto that genuinely frightens me. Crypto rollercoaster - up down sideways and in c
by Havoc 5y ago
Honestly stablecoins - specifically tether - is about the only thing about crypto that genuinely frightens me.
Crypto rollercoaster - up down sideways and in circles - sure I'm game. Tether that is stable until it implodes...hell no. Even without direct exposure the blast radius worries me.
- tluyben2 5y agoI find it weird that any person 'hodls' any crypto. I pick the rallies (like the one last night) and ride them, then sell. I cannot, besides stress, understand why anyone would hold crypto currencies at this point. It is too young and Wild West. That's why riding waves is easy and if you trade half decent you can make fortunes. But it can be gone tomorrow; for instance if Tether gets called on it's bluff.
- jamesrom 5y agoI find it weird that people can't see how that attitude is exactly why it's a rollercoaster...
- tluyben2 5y agoYep, but I am not holding the burning bag of poo. So yes I know that but I am not going to be that religious person that does that first and I do not get why anyone would.
- tiku 5y agoYou HODL until you can get a good enough number to stop HODLing.
- randomhodler84 5y agoYou have not been playing long enough if this is your attitude. “Zoom out” is generally the quote on this.
- bordercases 5y agoIt's also irresponsible investing to hold anything without an exit strategy. Lord knows I've lost too much without this principle.
- tluyben2 5y agoWell, let us see in 10 years. You might be very rich or have $0 from crypto. I will have my money even if it tanks and be very rich if it does not. If you hodled, you lost on days like 19 may, I almost doubled up. I just don't get the religious part: if Biden 'takes on ransomware criminals', btc could drop to 0$ today and it will crash the rest with it. And it will not jump to 1m$ overnight, so buy low sell high is also generally the quote on this.
- miked85 5y agoPeople hold crypto for the same reason that someone would hold any investment, they believe it will go higher. Of course that could be wrong with crypto, but the same applies to any investment. Risk/Reward.
- anonytrary 5y agoThe frightening things are the most transformative. Decentralized stablecoins represent a huge class of use-cases for blockchain. You don't have to tether the value of a stablecoin to a fiat currency necessarily.
- bordercases 5y agoThe ask is not hard: introduce dollar reserves and swap lines into the ecosystem, and don't touch the principal. Yet no stablecoin has been able to make this guarantee. Other kinds of assets beyond the dollar are not relevant to retail traders the same way the majority of traders are unlikely to take want to take physical at the end of a futures commodity contract. In the end they will want the dollar amount.
- Tenoke 5y agoFor what is worth, there's a huge blast radius if any of the top 3 collapse, with Tether (as the 3rd) likely having the smallest one - think of what happens to everything else when bitcoin crashes or even dips significantly.
- Havoc 5y ago>think of what happens to everything else when bitcoin crashes or even dips significantly. No idea about the rest, but I'm buying. Conceptually I think this has gained critical mass. i.e. There are enough people with enough belief to make crash to zero unlikely
- SkyMarshal 5y agoBitcoin crashes and dips all the time. It's lost over 80% of its value at least four times since it launched, plus the recent big 50% drawdown. It slows the cryptoeconomy for a year or so, but doesn't stop it, and then there's another bubble again ~2yrs later. Bitcoin's high but natural volatility is not the same thing as the price collapsing due to the system itself fundamentally breaking. For example, the Global Financial Crisis was the result of the system itself fundamentally breaking, not natural volatility, and its blast radius was immense. Tether or other major stablecoin collapsing due to being exposed as a fraud, or a fractional reserve with no reserves, or similar, would be more analogous to the GFC. And the blast radius could be worse than any of Bitcoin's 80% drawdowns, both economically and wrt to regulatory and legal attention.
- BenoitEssiambre 5y ago
- bpodgursky 5y agoNot obvious to me that it would be catastrophic. There are other stablecoins even if Tether is a 75%-funded scam (and honestly, who in crypto _hasn't_ taken a 25% haircut at some point?) Some people holding cash* would get hit, but there's no real magic to starting a 1-1 backed stablecoin. Someone will fill the space, since it's obviously needed.
- duskwuff 5y agoThe suspicion is that Tether is much closer to 5% backed than 75%. A 95% "haircut" would be catastrophic.
- WanderPanda 5y agoWhy would that be the case? Can you elaborate?
- ac29 5y agoTethers own press release last month showed them as having around 5% cash and treasury bills (more or less as liquid and stable as cash). Most of the rest is unspecified "commercial paper" - if that is commercial paper from, say, Apple, no problem. If its a debt issued by unregulated, offshore, heavily leveraged crypto exchanges, it could be more or less worthless. The general consensus is that if it was the former, they'd say so, so its far more likely the latter.
- duskwuff 5y ago> The general consensus is that if it was the former, they'd say so, so its far more likely the latter. They specifically describe their loans as "secured loans (none to affiliated entities)". There's no such annotation on their "commercial paper", giving the impression that this category (which amounts to slightly under 50% of their overall holdings) may consist in large part of loans to other crypto exchanges, possibly in the form of Tether tokens.
- young_unixer 5y agoTether imploding would just mean a couple more years to stack up. People who don't understand the technology would flee, thinking it was just a fad, those that do understand it would stay, stack up and wait a few years.
- simias 5y agoAh yes, the "technology". Any day now. Won't know what hit them. Around the corner really, alongside cold fusion and the chewing gum that replaces toothbrushes.
- nexuist 5y agoYeah, like online shopping. Remember that fad? Luckily the .com crash showed us that the critics were right and nobody ever got rich from that dumb idea again.
- tinomaxgalvin 5y agoDon't remember anyone saying online shopping was a fad, just that a lot of companies were massively over valued.
- codyb 5y agoI’m certain I’ve seen examples akin to “people want to touch and see the products before they’ll consider buying them”. I think the difference with crypto is that over time as more people look under the veil the number of naysayers grow, whereas with online shopping the naysayers have gone extinct (maybe RMS uses only cash or something). Last night I stumbled across a group freestyle rapping and hung out for a bit. At one point one of the rappers talked about putting money into AMC and how it was a bumpy rollercoaster of a ride. It really put a face on the other side of a lot of these cryptos and meme stocks. It’s entirely possible the fellow was a savvy investor (he certainly could freestyle very well) however judging by how his posture went from exuberant and confident to deflated as soon as he mentioned AMC in his own freestyle I’m fairly confident he bought in at the top. And it certainly didn’t surprise me that at my local stomping grounds I’d be hearing the dismayed crewing of the fleeced.
- lhorie 5y agoHonest question. How's Tether imploding different from e.g. a public company suddenly shutting down and its stock price going to zero? I imagine the two scenarios being similar in the sense that anyone holding tether would eat a big loss, but aside from the event obviously affecting investor sentiment, wouldn't it just be more or less business as usual for other coins? As in, couldn't BTC/ETH/whatever people just use other stablecoins instead? I feel like the risk of full-on panic selling seems more and more unlikely as time goes by and more institutional investors get into crypto. And even if everyone did take out their money at the same time, isn't most of the value actually backed by the dollars of whoever was the biggest fool?
- Havoc 5y ago>I feel like the risk of full-on panic selling seems more and more unlikely as time goes by and more institutional investors get into crypto. Agreed. Tether is special though because it's very big and (imo) very sketchy. So it's more of a "too big to fail - banks" company goes down than some random company. Thankfully other stablecoins are gaining ground
- Marazan 5y agoBecause the majority of crypto trades are done in Tether.
- diab0lic 5y agoA large company going bust doesn't imply that demand for other public companies was somehow fabricated. The more apt comparison here would be something along the lines of the recent run up in TSLA being the result of purchasing from the infinite margin bug from Robinhood a while back. It would turn out the demand wasn't real, only there because it was free. The implications for Bitcoin and other crypto also purchased with Tether, or with Bitcoin are a lot bigger than you'd imagine.
- lubujackson 5y agoTether imploding isn't at all like a public company closing shop, because public companies are Real Things and have public data about sales, revenue, employees, business relationships, etc. And even the ones that implode go through bankruptcy court where their assets are doled out to debtors and shareholders. Tether imploding would be more like a bank run, where you can see YOUR MONEY as a number on the screen then when you go to cash out, you simply can no longer access your money. Or maybe you can withdraw $100 a day, but no more. If and when that happens (or threatens to happen), everyone freaks out and tries to get their money at once - which is exactly why the banking system in the U.S. is backed by the federal government so this doesn't happen. The higher risk is that a good swath of crypto investment is done on leverage, which can increase with the more money you have. So with $100MM and a bit of lying you can go invest 10x your money in crypto and get some fat returns - lets say you go all-in and put $1B in Tether and get an 8% return on your money - thanks to leverage you are actually making 80% return on your $100M (sample #s, but you get the idea). This works great until things blow up, because you don't just lose your $100M, the BANKS that gave you leverage ("margin") lose $900M too, so one idiot taking this gamble can have a massive impact on the banking system as a whole. This isn't just theory either, something akin to this happened about a month ago: https://www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking-news/section/2/168807/Nomura,-Credit-Suisse-take-US$9b-hit-from-Bill-Hwang%27s-Archegos-fund-meltdown https://www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking-news/section/2/16880... And that wasn't even fallout from a Ponzi scheme, but simply from: bad risk management + leverage + minimal oversight + lying. The real stupidity is that these banks have continued to provide margin loans at very low rates with loose oversight, which should remind you of "race-to-the-bottom" mortgage market that blew up housing around 15 years ago. Except now we are talking about hedge funds and billionaires and a billions of dollars being thrown into shitcoins and NFTs. So when this implodes there won't be any collateral at all to rely on.