3 ms·
nope but we also demand some due diligence from private entities. When you leave the garage, the windows and the front door open with a "here's the money" sign
by Barrin92 5y ago
nope but we also demand some due diligence from private entities. When you leave the garage, the windows and the front door open with a "here's the money" sign pointing at your safe you might have a problem if someone steals your customers stuff.
Company private security and protection against these attacks is more than abysmal. Just take the pipeline hack as an example. There should be no way at all that infrastructure critical to the nations security is getting shut down because of a corporate hack.
If the private sector wants to earn profit from these things they need to show they're competent enough to handle it.
- tracerbulletx 5y agoThat's fair. I'm sure there is a happy middle that can be found.
- jliptzin 5y agoI don’t think that’s a fair comparison. I think a fair comparison would be 80,000 companies buy the same vault door from supplier X. But suddenly one criminal group has found a universal key to the vault that no one else knows about, and can now access all 80,000 vaults nearly simultaneously and clandestinely even though they still look closed and secure from outside observers.
- Sebb767 5y ago... but this was 5 years ago and everyone and their dog knows it by now, the company just didn't bother to change that door. Also, the criminal group doesn't hit doors with cameras, but nobody bothered to install one. --- What you described is a zero day, which is very rarely used - most ransomware simply uses the absolutely low hanging fruit of companies lagging behind years in security updates combined with highly insufficient backups.
- beermonster 5y agoCompanies generally do not have a sufficient tested backup strategy and plan (though backups have only one part to play). Those same companies have probably never suffered any major consequences as a result - which might explain why it’s so usual for this to be a common gap. Sloppy/incomplete backups can probably wing/firefight the more common ‘single server dies’ ‘single directory needs recovering from accidental deletion on file server’ ‘need to restore database following botched upgrade’ type scenarios creating a false sense of security. In the same way companies do not have sufficient HA for their critical systems or processes. HA means being actively resistant to events impacting availability by having (typically automated) redundancy to remove SPoFs. It doesn’t mean HA owing to luck the server hasn’t died in 10 years owing to lack of/poor maintenance. But both with HA and backups companies can dodge bullets (until a real emergency) and maybe never even have a major incident. Ransomware kind of exploits this lack of organisation level sufficient backing up of all critical information assets. It really is as you say, low hanging fruit.
- blablabla123 5y agoThe backup thing is really weird, I think only very small non-startup companies care about them a lot because they just cannot afford not having them. In all other places when I bring up the topic everybody seems to be lightly surprised and the sense of urgency just isn't there. Personally I find this just puzzling, in my home folder I loose files at least once a year and I also lost whole partitions. So having no backup at all is no option for me at home. I cannot understand how no or unmaintained backups can be an option at companies.
- 542354234235 5y ago80,000 planes use the same bolts to secure the engine pylons to the wing. It is found that the bolt can sheer in cold weather due to a casting defect. This does not cause a catastrophic failure because the aircraft are designed in such a way that an individual compromise will not bring down the entire system. Bank vault doors don’t open to the street for a reason. If your entire system is relying on the security of that one vault door, you have already failed. If you are storing sensitive data on millions of users in plaintext, you have already failed.
- salawat 5y agoEven plaintext can be secure with the right other measures. Air gapped in a physically secured, access controlled location, with all egress/exit points covered by sufficiently rigorous security measures? You're fine. Encryption introduces it's own SPOF's. If you'very never had a power failure in the middle of a key rotation, you've never been bitten back by your attempt at securing everything with cryptography. Or worse, corrupted by sketchy hardware. Defense in depth, and proper threat modeling is key. There is also the very real question of "Do you really need that Internet connected anyway?"
- mlac 5y agoThe market doesn’t incentivize security until it is too late. A pipeline operator that passes security costs onto consumers will lose to one with lower security and lower costs. Serious, significant attacks might occur at year 5, when the company becomes a big enough target to make it worthwhile to attack. By this time, the company who did not invest as heavily in security has captured the market while the one that invested in security does not have strong market share or may have gone out of business. Or they invested, but not in the right areas, or there was a new attack through a zero day. They can be extremely competent in managing oil and gas (and the physical and operational safety that comes with it), but not be competent in Cybersecurity. It’s real, hard costs today for something that may or may not happen and paying for controls that might prevent an attack. In the best case, as a customer, nothing happens. Whether improving the likelihood that nothing happen is worth a $1 or $3 per barrel premium (or if that $2 is justified) is a hazy mess and hard to make a decision around.
- panny 5y ago>The market doesn’t incentivize security until it is too late. That's why you have government and law to require it. The free market solving everything is a myth, and the USA is lucky that all the pipeline hackers wanted was money. Imagine if that was a nation state trying to immobilize the military in preparation for an invasion. No ransoms, instead bombs start falling while you are paralyzed.
- User23 5y agoIf the goal was to disable the pipeline the attacker could just apply thermite somewhere along one of it's many unguarded miles. The reason that doesn't happen is because retribution for such an act would be striking to say the least. It's impossible to prevent all attacks, physical or cyber, so at some point one needs to either submit to an order where attackers act with impunity, or otherwise invest in retribution.
- mschuster91 5y ago> If the goal was to disable the pipeline the attacker could just apply thermite somewhere along one of it's many unguarded miles. The reason that doesn't happen is because retribution for such an act would be striking to say the least. For what it's worth, a couple weeks ago someone (according to a manifesto, an anarchist group) did exactly that in Munich - they set about 50 10 kV electricity cables that were laid bare due to construction works ablaze to strike against a military supplier and cut off about 20.000 households for over 36 hours until the utility managed to restore service: https://www.br.de/nachrichten/bayern/stromausfall-in-muenchen-bekennerschreiben-aufgetaucht,SYKlDag https://www.br.de/nachrichten/bayern/stromausfall-in-muenche... Sabotage or plain old theft against utilities is pretty common, but it's hard to do something physical that truly disrupts service for longer than a day or two - the networks are designed with reliability against all kinds of issues in mind. An IT-based attack leaves no traces if done well and can have a week to month long impact, simply because back when these networks were designed, IT threats were not existing.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe infrastructure wasn’t impacted. It was shut down because the billing system was. It’s also easy to assume that everyone is incompetent. That doesn’t make it true. Like any hostile situation, a defensive position can always be overcome, you have to have an active offense as well.
- lupire 5y agoIf the pipeline could run without corporate, why would corporate exist?