7 ms·
Major ISPs agree to "six strikes" copyright enforcement plan
- omouse 15y agoThis is why we should get rid of the copyright system completely and keep it that way or start from scratch and build a new system (I prefer the former...). Time to move over to some kind of fully encrypted Internet or something :/
- wmf 15y agoI wonder if copyright holders will file a lot more of these notices (100X? 1000X?) since they will presumably be cheaper and seen as less threatening.
- bediger 15y agoIndeed. Does a penalty for filing a false notice (accusation) of infringement exist? What's the process for adjudicating disputes?
- kijinbear 15y agoI don't think there's any penalty for false accusations of copyright infringement. Likewise, nobody needs to pay for falsely accusing you of anything unless you sue them for defamation. If your ISP actually cuts off your internet after 6 false accusations, you might want to take them to the courts. EFF will probably love to take on such a suit. Unfortunately, very few people have the financial means or guts to sue the RIAA/MPAA and follow through with it.
- blendergasket 15y agoI think judges can order the accuser to pay the legal fees of the accused at least.
- kijinbear 15y agoYou'll probably need to win the lawsuit before the judge can order something like that.
- joeybaker 15y agoAll of the ISPs involved also provide cable TV service. That's to say, they have a vested interest in seeing the business model of "copyright holders" continue so that they can receive their affiliate fees. It's little wonder that this deal was "voluntarily" agreed upon.
- jolan 15y agoMake sure to do all your copyright infringement on a disposable VPS.
- kevingadd 15y agoRegardless of whether you break the law on a regular basis, having a personal VPS is a very good idea these days. I still regularly run into problems with websites and applications related to geolocation, blacklisting, or routing, and being able to proxy stuff through my VPS enables me to keep getting things done. In particular, if you're a Comcast user a VPS is pretty essential since their routing and peering are awful. Being able to run sensitive traffic through an SSH tunnel when you're on public Wi-fi is also a nice perk.
- ComputerGuru 15y agoI'm considering purchasing Comcast internet for businesses (not the residential stuff), and am interested in your comments about bad routing and peering. Can you expand on that, please? EDIT: I'm talking about Chicagoland region. Didn't know it was geographic.
- wmf 15y agohttp://www.merit.edu/mail.archives/nanog/msg15068.html http://www.merit.edu/mail.archives/nanog/msg15068.html http://www.merit.edu/mail.archives/nanog/msg15911.html http://www.merit.edu/mail.archives/nanog/msg15911.html http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Claims-Resurface-Concerning-Congested-Comcast-TATA-Links-111818 http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Claims-Resurface-Concerni...
- matwood 15y agoI have had fine service with Comcast. The thing to remember is that Comcast is basically an umbrella over many companies generally separated by state. To further complicate things one area within a state may have better equipment than another area.
- nitrogen 15y ago
- navyrain 15y agoGiven that these ISPs often have exclusive markets, in which they have no direct competitors, this would effectively deny internet access to anyone who had the misfortune of getting a few of these notices. Lack of judicial oversight is obviously a problem. But furthermore, this really overstates the seriousness of copyright infringement, and understates the importance of internet access for all.
- kelnos 15y agoIf you read the article, you'd know that ISPs seem unwilling to cut off access entirely, even after 6 strikes. Agreed on the judicial issues. While the ISP is legally free to make any decision it wants as to who is allowed to use its network, and in what capacity, they're essentially making these determinations based on hearsay.
- click170 15y agoWhat tickles me in that special way is the way this 'conversation' has gone. Them: "We've got an awesome new idea, 3 strikes policies. 3 accusations, and your out." Us: "Um, well actually it's not fair to have your internet cut off based on unproven accusations." Them: "Well then... 6 strikes!" Us: "I don't think you understand the objection..."
- JoshTriplett 15y agoThat's a standard political tactic; a compromise is always considered OK, so you propose something ridiculous and end up with half of ridiculous. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_Window http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_Window http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation
- horser4dish 15y agoThat last point is my primary complaint about these systems. While yes, this is actually a quite reasonable series of warnings (the first four carry no penalties at all), it still bothers me that there is no real proof behind any of this. As far as I know, all the content owners have to say to the ISP is that such-and-such IP was uploading our content X, and then the warnings begin. There's no first- or third-party fact-checking (which, I admit, would be quite difficult with torrents anyway), it is, as you say, "hearsay." I'm not quite sure why, but the RIAA and other organizations now carry as much weight as our government regarding our internet access (can the state even shut down a customer's access at all? I have no idea, but if it can't, that's even worse).
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThis is a very sad state of affairs. We already have a system for judging evidence, determining guilt and for assigning punishment, it's called the courts. This seems to be yet another advancement in abandoning all of the institutions of civil society and rule of law in the online world, frequently to the detriment of individual liberty. We can only hope that eventually these assaults against our freedoms will eventually be rolled back.
- jff 15y agoThese courts have already been very effectively used... as a threat by copyright holders in an attempt to shake people down for out-of-court settlements.
- blendergasket 15y agoThe tide seems to be turning against the RIAA/MPAA, damages 100s of times the cost of legitimately downloading the song are being questioned, the ruling that an IP address != a person and other stuff that is making it less likely that the copyright groups will be able to mass litigate going forward so they are starting to look for extrajudicial means. The scariest thing to me about this article is this: This is basically a system of penalty, based on enforcing the government's laws (even though lobbied for by the RIAA et al), that is not dealt with in courts. In the US at least we have the idea that our judges/juries are either our peers or are elected by our peers. There is a sense that they act on behalf of the collective will in transparent ways and are always accountable in some sort of way. It's a way for the community to enforce its norms on its members (for better or worse). In the system propsed in this article there are consequences to the file sharers. And there is no accountable system for doling out these consequences. These are not our peers judging us. These are corporations who have very vested interests, which are not the interests of the populous it is enforcing them upon. I'm worried that this will become something of a precedent. I think another really good example of this in action is the Visa/Mastercard embargo on Wikileaks. Operating outside of any judicial framework they barred funds to Wikileaks and its host for months. Then as soon as they get sued, and there is the prospect of having to account for their actions based on real laws they cave in, implicitly acknowledging the illegality of their stance. It seems that however powerful this government/corporation blanket of control thinks it is it still fears having to account for itself in the courts. An independent judiciary is a great check to power. The RIAA/MPAA are attacking one of the few checks on power that still give me hope that the idea of government the USA stands for can be salvaged.
- floppydisk 15y agoAt some point, someone will probably sue -- after getting cutoff by this new policy or receive significant fines -- on the grounds this does constitute a conflict of interest on the part of the internet provider. In the ideal world, we'd allow for competition across the board and remove the monopolies through the introduction of new options. Those options could make a major dent by positioning themselves solely as pipe providers. In turn, this would put market pressure on the conglomerates to either compete or die, in the ideal world. In the realistic world, the options would be to force the companies to split into wholly owned subsidiaries of a parent corporation. IE: Comcast Internet, Comcast TV / Comcast Content and they would not receive preferential treatment from one another. Also, remove the monopolies and change the current regulatory structure to create incentives for new ISPs to spring up and challenge the conglomerates. Ideally, we would be able to solve this without having to involve the government bureaucracy which will end up creating more new rules and probably hurting as much as helping. Realistically, the only way people will go for is if there's a regulatory change.
- freejack 15y agoSo now ISP = "Internet Services Police"?
- ruby_on_rails 15y agoSo who will guard the guards? I fail to see any oversight whatsoever. Ohh and look who these 6 major ISPs are. TimeWarner Cable sounds like they may have a few copyrights laying around... Major conflicts of interest? You bet. And what does this mean for the thousands of coffee shops, book stores, and other wi-fi hotspots which dynamically assign ip addresses? Most likely: nothing pleasant. Its a fine day when not only do corporations wield ridiculous power of lawmakers, but can form agreements tantamount to monopoly power. Net neutrality? Good luck with that.
- Derbasti 15y agoCase in point: In some European countries (e.g. Germany), a wifi provider is liable for all the stuff that happens on his network. Which means that there are next to no public wifis. A shame, really. Another step from democracy towards corporate dictatorship. Sometimes I wonder if we are currently experiencing a fatal flaw in commercialism that will ultimately subvert democracy.
- lwat 15y agoWhy not also cut off their electricity if someone used it 6 times to copy music or movies?
- Adam503 15y agoI suspect the content owners are going to get a big load of IP addresses from the ISPs and file a big huge pile of criminal charges or civil lawsuits against the people who the ISPs finger. The ISPs will then pretend to act hurt when the content owners violate this agreement. Give your internet account to a fine business establishment who doesn't do something as ridiculous as trusting Time Warner or Comcast with confidential customer information.