5 ms·
>The use of the image has produced controversy because Playboy is "seen (by some) as being degrading to women That's pretty straightforward, from the link I po
by tyingq 5y ago
>The use of the image has produced controversy because Playboy is "seen (by some) as being degrading to women
That's pretty straightforward, from the link I posted, and not the same quote or person.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIt's straightforward but it's not the same argument. They didn't ask why not to use Lena, they were asking about that specific quote.
- tyingq 5y agoHeh. "How is Lenna's picture disturbing or suggestive?"
- Dylan16807 5y agoWhat heh? There is a big difference between "the association with playboy is disturbing" and "the picture is disturbing". The O'Leary quote seems to be talking entirely about the picture, the 512x512 one. You've given a lot of resources for the former, but they were asking about the latter. And while "suggestive" is pretty subjective, "woman with bare shoulder" is not self-evidently suggestive.
- tyingq 5y agoYou're being overly argumentative, hence the "Heh". For example, you said "If I was going to argue against using Lena, I'd say things about the context of the image" Then summarily dismissed a quote about the context of the image. It's funny.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI dismissed that quote because we're not arguing about whether Lena should be used or not. That was never the question in this entire chain of comments.
- tyingq 5y agoThe question is ""How is Lenna's picture disturbing or suggestive?" The context is relevant to that, as you said yourself. The wikipedia link gives some of that context. I provided one example. Cropping out the nudity doesn't change the context.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> The question is ""How is Lenna's picture disturbing or suggestive?" Right. Which is a subset of the possible reasons to not use it. Everything about playboy is outside that subset, and does not answer the question, despite being a reason not to use it. Much like "It's a violation of copyright" would also be a reason not to use the image that doesn't answer the question.