4 ms·
Hello from Europe, a graying continent. We have a massive problem here. Our welfare systems, generally one of the most generous on the planet, cannot cope with
by inglor_cz 5y ago
Hello from Europe, a graying continent.
We have a massive problem here. Our welfare systems, generally one of the most generous on the planet, cannot cope with the greying of the population.
We also seem to be attracting the "wrong" kind of immigration for that purpose. Highly qualified people tend to prefer the US, Canada or Australia with their lighter tax burden, while our borders are crossed by mostly uneducated young men from the Islamic world whose employability is limited. The resulting societal conflicts are nontrivial, both between the migrants and the natives, and the "refugees welcome" vs "fortress Europe" camps. The trend seems to be towards "fortress Europe", but that is not an easy objective either.
Having a child is extremely expensive if you are an urban professional, because prices of real estate have skyrocketed to insane, unprecedented heights. There is a talk of negative interest rates, slow abolition of cash and higher taxation of property, which would turn the middle class into rats racing for life, owning nothing. Impoverished middle class tends to vote for devils just to stop the pressure. Which usually does not work anyway.
And we are heavily indebted. To be precise, some countries are heavily indebted (Italy, France), with some others, called frugals, joining a common debt scheme after Covid, but with their populations hating it. The next generations will have to carry the debt burden somehow, and the cohorts are projected to be smaller.
Unless we have a real breakthrough in robotics and kind and universal robots start caring about us all for no remuneration, this won't be sustainable. Too much of our current system is based on the fiction of constant growth.
- lumost 5y agoHow much of the declining birth rate is due to lack of security? As an urbanite with their first kid I can say we only plan to have one. Even with 2 tech jobs childcare, housing, college and other expenses mean that having 2 kids would make us fret over bills and start to ignore retirement. All of these expenses share the same trait that they are influenced by interest rates and nominal prices.
- inglor_cz 5y agoFrankly, I do not know. Everyone has their favorite explanation. This bunch of effects is really hard to disentangle exactly. But having kids is very expensive in urban areas, not just in Europe, but in places like Tehran or Singapore. To some degree, the fertility problem is a problem of runaway urbanization. We might be witnessing the moment when urbanization hits its limits. Another interesting complication is natural fertility vs. length of education. Women get less fertile after 30 and much less fertile after 35. Long education pushes the age of first birth upwards, where it starts to hit against the biological limits. IVF is a huge business in Europe. (Undergoing IVF right now - yes, we were fools for waiting that long.)
- swagasaurus-rex 5y agoLand is one thing everybody competes with eachother for, either through rent prices or through housing prices. Everybody, not just the rich have been using land as an investment for decades. Many cities are priced out. This land burden becomes a weight on businesses and people. Businesses that need to be located in a central area must pay high rents and high wages. Declining birthrates absolutely make sense. We just don't have enough room for all of us, and it's clear in the prices.
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 5y agoEducation of women is known to be a cause of decline in birthrates. Likely very little of it has to do with lack of security or economic reasons. In fact it's quite the opposite, the poor on average have more children than the rich.
- mtnGoat 5y agocan you cite this claim? i would be interested to learn more about the relation between the education of woman and lowering birth rates.
- inglor_cz 5y agoNot the user you are reacting to, but the correlation of education with total fertility seems to be pretty strong across the world. https://wol.iza.org/uploads/articles/228/pdfs/female-education-and-its-impact-on-fertility.pdf https://wol.iza.org/uploads/articles/228/pdfs/female-educati... It seems that the gap in fertility between the "no education" and "8 years of basic education" cohorts is extra pronounced.
- mtnGoat 5y agoperfect, thank you.
- watwut 5y agoBasically, women who are educated and have enough power to plan the amount of kids have less of them. Women who dont get to make those decisions have more of them.
- ishjoh 5y ago> Having a child is extremely expensive if you are an urban professional, because prices of real estate have skyrocketed to insane, unprecedented heights. This has also happened in the US, even in what would be considered secondary cities like the one I live in. I have seen my house triple in value in 8 years. (My definition of a secondary city are those that are large cities that are not LA, San Francisco, NYC. For example: Salt Lake City, Houston, Dallas, Atlanta, Austin). Part of the issue is the percentage of population that lives in cities is higher than at any point in the past so competition for housing is fierce, and seemingly always increasing. I was hopeful that with folks being able to work from home due to the pandemic we might actually see a reversal of this, unfortunately that didn't really happen, although maybe it will require 5-10 years to really take hold and change buying patterns. I also think raising the interest rate is long overdue, the interest rate was finally raising a little bit until the pandemic hit and was slashed to effectively 0 again. A rising interest rate would likely also lower housing prices, the problem though is that there are likely a number of companies servicing lots of debt that if the interest rate were to rise would be in trouble.