5 ms·
>will be reassigned to a STEM research role Not fired, just reassigned. I'm ok with that as a policy. Presumably he isn't ok with those old statements and ca
by duxup 5y ago
>will be reassigned to a STEM research role
Not fired, just reassigned.
I'm ok with that as a policy. Presumably he isn't ok with those old statements and can move on.
At the same time the folks who need to post some general statements about a whole group of people, religion, or whatever ...
As far as I can remember I've never felt a reason to talk about a whole category of people and "insatiable appetite for war and killing“ or "increasing insensitivity to the suffering [of] others".
I don't get it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- megamindbrian2 5y agoHave you people ever met a Jew? They literally idolized "never again" which is what this guy's is talking about. They literally live by the principal that this guy was removed from his position over. And questioning any Jewish philosophy is labeled anti-Semitic and condemned. Write a story about being "God's chosen people" doesn't make you righteous, it just makes you last to do it.
- dang 5y agoYou can't make inflammatory generalizations about ethnic groups on HN. Also, "Have you people ever met a Jew" followed by weird grievances and generalizations is enough over the line that I'm banning this account. We don't need this here—as evidenced by the flamewar that it started.
- thereare5lights 5y agoThe stereotyping in this comment is so blatantly racist that I’m surprised you even posted it.
- joejoeshabadoo5 5y agoI have met plenty, and there is a great joke that comes to mind. What is worse than the holocaust? 6 million Jews.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- duxup 5y agoI've met Jews. I didn't get the impression that they have an "insatiable appetite for war and killing". Would you say the Jews I met have an "insatiable appetite for war and killing"?
- nojokes 5y agoI have met Jews (Israelis to be more precise), Russians and Americans. All have been very nice people. But I think it could be said about all of them as nations to have to some degree "insatiable appetite for war and killing" considering their recent history. Naturally the Russians would label me a russophobe for saying that. Not sure what Americans would label me. I also understand the position Israelis are in and I understand their actions. But they have made a critical mistake from the beginning and what they continue to make - not giving a fair compensation to the people they displace. I think most problems would not exists today if that had been followed from the beginning. Perhaps I am mistaken, so please enlighten me. I also envy Israelis that they can be in such position.
- whimsicalism 5y agoPeople != nations. Conflating the two is bad because you start blaming people for the sins of their nation and that is how you get to dehumanization.
- pxc 5y agoAlso it's in the interest of the Zionist state to identify 'Israel' with 'Jews' If you're opposed to Zionism or the state of Israel, you shouldn't grant them that identification. If you assume or assert that all Jews support Israel's settler-colonial project, you're also playing into the state of Israel's rhetorical strategies that conflate the survival and military supremacy of the Zionist state with Jewish safety, opposition of Zionism with hatred toward Jews, etc. Failing to distinguish between the people group and the nation-state that claims to represent or serve them is not only rude or dehumanizing or sloppy in this case, but counterproductive for anti-Zionism as a cause. Anti-imperialism is not served by racism.
- 5y ago
- pxc 5y ago> Have you people ever met a Jew? yes. My Jewish friends are anti-war and anti-imperialist.
- libria 5y ago> Not fired, just reassigned. I don't even get how that's gonna work. Inevitably, he'll work alongside/under/oversee Jewish colleagues. That'll be an awkward Hangouts meeting. "Oh hey there's the guy that thinks I'm violent, I wonder if he'll judge my work/team interaction impartially..."
- ehsankia 5y agoIt was a post from 14 years he's apologized for. I'm sure everyone has plenty of beliefs from 14 years ago that no longer fits their current beliefs.
- annexrichmond 5y agoTrue, but it seems like most aren't given a second chance like he was.
- ehsankia 5y ago> most aren't given a second chance like he was. Most are almost never put in a position where things they've done or said over a decade ago is put under a spotlight. You have to be in a specific position, and have people specific want to take you down in the first place. Why do you think this specific post from 14 years ago happens to have been brought up now?
- capableweb 5y agoBut if Google thought he was now benign, wouldn't he just remain at the post? Moving him to a different department seems to indicate that Google think he did wrong, but not that much wrong as to fire him. I'm not sure how to reconcile that.
- duxup 5y agoIsn't there space in the sense that "this role isn't right for you because you did a thing" and "let's try here"?
- datavirtue 5y agoReassigned? Lol. He was already on the roof.