3 ms·
> Revenue 100mln+ - you have to tax revenue So banks and oil companies, which are naturally lots of revenue with a tiny amount of profit, would disappear, or b
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
> Revenue 100mln+ - you have to tax revenue
So banks and oil companies, which are naturally lots of revenue with a tiny amount of profit, would disappear, or become very small?
- ed_balls 5y ago> If your company cannot pay 1% of the revenue you don't have a viable business. Average corporation spends more on accounting and consulting. Accounting costs banks and oil companies around 0.8%, so the will be fine. I don't remember the exact number.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoRevenue is simply what you earn regardless of your costs. If some kind of business generates lots of revenues but has costs that are similar, then...they are screwed. You are basically proposing taxing money that moves through any company, regardless of the amount of money that has to pass out of it. Many companies just couldn't afford to exist anymore, we'd go back to hunting and gathering because even farming would no longer be economically viable. Oil companies have huge capital costs to find and extract resources, if you look at what their profits are compared to their costs of doing business, then obviously taxing revenue isn't going to work.
- lloda 5y agoYou'd tax global profit based on the local revenue fraction. So if the corporation has global profits of 1M and the revenue is 90% in country A and 10% in country B, then country A taxes 0.9M of profit and country B taxes 0.1M of profit and neither has to care where the corporation is located 'for tax purposes'.