19 ms·
> I save money by spending less on food, drinks, and electricity. For those of us who have to commute, it's not exactly the norm to be saving money while commu
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> I save money by spending less on food, drinks, and electricity.
For those of us who have to commute, it's not exactly the norm to be saving money while commuting.
Commutes are responsible for a 10% drop in hourly wages[1], and the median commute time results in spending 10 full days commuting a year.
The average commuter in one of the largest metro areas in the country will spend over 13 full days commuting a year:
> In the area with the longest average commute (New York-Newark-Jersey City), commuters are spending an average of 13 days, 2 hours, and 26 minutes driving to and from work. That means that 14 vacation days a year are barely covering the time it takes to get to work every day. So in addition to dropping the average wage from $34.71 per hour to $30.15 per hour, in order to get 14 days of hanging with their family on a beach, New York commuters must be willing to spend nearly as much time sitting in a car.
[1] https://go.frontier.com/business/commute-calculator https://go.frontier.com/business/commute-calculator
- e_y_ 5y agoI think their calculations are based on 24 hour days (1 hour roundtrip * 260 days). Vacations and work are based on 8 hour days, however, so in reality it's more like 30 days (6 weeks) of vacation time. And 30 minutes each way is much closer than most of the places I've worked.
- gnicholas 5y agoThe food/drink part could be the most of it. A Google employee enjoying free food and drink could save $60/day versus buying prepared food ($10 for breakfast, $20 for lunch, and $30 for dinner). If you drink much coffee or other beverages, that could be another $15/day. If you weigh this against spending an extra hour or two commuting, then it looks like a lousy bargain. But if you are like many people, and ended up working more hours during the pandemic, [1] then that erases some/all of the gains of not commuting. 1: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/11/24/people-are-working-longer-hours-during-the-pandemic https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2020/11/24/people-a...
- InvaderFizz 5y ago> But if you are like many people, and ended up working more hours during the pandemic, [1] then that erases some/all of the gains of not commuting. Wow. I cut my hours down substantially due to WFH. Pre-COVID I was doing 70+ hrs per week due to commuting into the area during the week and having nothing to do. Now I put in maybe 40hrs per week, broken up into 1hr chunks here and there and I'm not spending over $1500/month just for a room/expenses in the area where work is. It's great! I'm not going back to the office, like, ever.
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoAre you working less because you save commute time, and work more efficiently at your home workstation? Or are you just clocking in less, also producing less?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoSometimes working less doesn’t mean producing less, or if it’s less it’s not necessarily linear. They said they used to work more “because they had nothing to do”. The extra hours may not be worth as much as a well rested mind.
- InvaderFizz 5y agoOh, my overall productivity is down quite a bit due to family distractions. Once the new house is built, my office will probably be in a separate guest house.
- mFixman 5y agoA Google Employee working from home could save $200/day versus getting a fancy limousine to go to work. Nobody buys prepared food every day, and the costs of food are negligible for a Google employee.
- whiddershins 5y ago> Nobody buys prepared food every day I get what you are trying to say, but empirically false
- calvinmorrison 5y agoI spend 150$+ per month on AC and heat because of the pandemic. I spent ~30$ in gas a month commuting. I could even walk if my bike didn't work. Personally I like the free AC. Once you optimize your job to be close to your home, many of the benefits of wfh disappear.
- lamontcg 5y agoIf you're paying rents/mortgages close to your work, those savings from AC probably disappear pretty quickly.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoFor people who like where they live that isn't necessarily a factor. Even if I was fully remote I don't think I'd move
- calvinmorrison 5y agoI live in a medium/low col city. Not everywhere is NYC or Cali
- insaneirish 5y ago> Once you optimize your job to be close to your home, many of the benefits of wfh disappear. LOL.
- bartvk 5y agoWhat's funny about parent's remark?
- heavyset_go 5y ago> I spend 150$+ per month on AC and heat because of the pandemic. I spent ~30$ in gas a month commuting. I could even walk if my bike didn't work. Work from home doesn't mean you have to literally work from home. There are plenty of places you can work from, ranging from free like libraries or parks, to paid like coffee shops and co-working spaces. You can get your employer to pay for the latter. > Once you optimize your job to be close to your home, many of the benefits of wfh disappear. Those optimizations become liabilities if you get a new job elsewhere.
- ashtonkem 5y agoCommutes also cost the one thing we can't get back; time.
- heavyset_go 5y agoSometimes people say they're making a time trade off for more money, and plan to use that money to buy more time. While money is fungible, time is not. You can't buy more time with your kids while they're young if they're already grown. You can't buy more time with someone who has passed away. And you can't buy your way out of missed opportunities in your personal life, once they've gone they're gone.
- warkdarrior 5y agoI would rather pay the maid to spend 5 hours to clean the whole house once a week, while I take the kids to the park or to the beach. Same thing applies to cooking, groceries, errands, etc.
- blevin 5y agoWe talk about the time-value of money; perhaps there’s also a time-value of time.
- EliRivers 5y agoChap at work (at his home,rather!) has spent the last 15 months making and eating breakfast with his children every day. He's not coming back to the office. No way, no how. He's seen a better life.
- mars009 5y agoThis. Also the time you are using when you are young or what you can do with your time when you are young != to the same time spent when you are old. I remember traveling abroad, spending the night at hostels, waking up at 5AM and hitting tons of museums and walking miles and miles per day to sight see, and visit everything. 65 years old will probably not be able to pull that off
- randomsearch 5y ago
- geodel 5y ago> The average commuter in one of the largest metro areas in the country will spend over 13 full days commuting a year: This might be technically correct. But realistically I'd count only working hours. 200 working days and roughly 2 hr commute for me a day. So it is about 400 hr commute to work/home i.e ~50 work days spent in commute.
- deanCommie 5y agoYou don't have to commute. You chose to commute. You maybe did it for a larger house. Or maybe for cheaper rent/mortgage. We're not talking here about folks on minimum wage who can only afford to live 2 hours outside of the city they are working in. The highly paid software engineers on hackernews could absolutely afford to live 5 minutes from the office, 30 minutes from the office, or 2 hours from the office. They could afford to move to a city with good transit where they can only afford an apartment, or to a city with no transit where they can afford a giant mansion.
- foepys 5y agoPlease remember that not everybody here works for FAANG or similar companies.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoNone the less people do seem to make poor decisions when it comes to commuting.
- bloqs 5y agoThis comment suggests you are from a generation where there was a choice
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoMostly it comes from having made poor decisions in the past. There is always a choice. Ten more miles equals one extra bedroom and so on.
- frockington1 5y agoWhich generation doesn't have a choice? I'm a millenial and don't understand if this generalization is at me, genx, boomers or those damn new kids the zoomers. When I bought a house I was able to buy anything that was on sale and fit my budget except for retirement communities with a 55+ age restriction
- ls15 5y agoPrivate transport is also one of the biggest sources of greenhouse gas emissions. Reducing daily commute seems like a good way to improve our carbon footprint. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200317-climate-change-cut-carbon-emissions-from-your-commute https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200317-climate-change-c...
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoOne of many, though; I'm really getting my hackles up with corporations making end users responsible for things like plastic, industrial farming and co2 emissions. Yes they're a part of the equation, but there's much bigger impact to be made if they work from the top down. Mind you, there are things like that going on (at least in my neck of the woods), with things like subsidies to consumers for going to battery powered cars and installing solar panels, and subsidies to e.g. energy producers for building wind farms out at sea.
- read_if_gay_ 5y ago> there's much bigger impact to be made if they work from the top down Exactly. Germany banning plastic straws while simultaneously funding a new natural gas pipeline feels very much like they just want it to seem like things are improving.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoPublic consciousness seems to lack the ability to prioritize issues. Disposable plastics are a problem first and foremost because they cause proliferation of microplastics in the biosphere. This is an issue, but it's not an important issue right now. It's likely harmful to biosphere and to us in the long run - but as of today, there's no noticeable harm being done that can be tied to microplastics, which suggests any negative effects are weak. Climate change, on the other hand, is a civilization-ending threat. We keep burning more fossil fuels, and it's quite likely our grandchildren will get to starve to death. Preventing this should be our absolute top priority. Microplastics can wait. It's like trying to administer first aid to an accident victim who has a nasty skin cut on their arm, and a leg that got cut off below the knee. Yes, that skin cut is painful and it needs treating to prevent infection, but it can wait - the first priority is to deal with the leg, before the victim bleeds out.
- Mauricebranagh 5y agoYou are assuming that salaries don't take that into account.
- enriquto 5y ago> Commutes are responsible for a 10% drop in hourly wages Maybe statistically, OK. But if you have a nice commute it may be likely the best part of your day. I have a mostly flat, 40 min bike ride in the woods every day, and it is my "me time" that I cherish and lets me unwind before and after work. Definitely not "lost time".
- teachingassist 5y agoIf you were given back those 40 mins, you could spend them on a 40 min bike ride in the woods. If that's the absolute best way you can imagine spending those 40 mins, you don't lose the option to do that.
- enriquto 5y agoI also spend about 30 min per day cooking for the kids. Would you say that I could "get back" these 30 minutes by hiring a personal cook? Well, maybe, but I really don't live like that. It's a mildly pleasurable activity, even if I'm able to imagine "better ways to spend my time".
- jiofih 5y agoReread that comment. He’s saying you would have the option of doing that 40m bike ride, which you don’t have today. For the majority of people that commute will not be a nice ride through the woods, and they can’t opt out.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI don't think a 40 minute bike ride is the kind of commute we're talking about. Most commuters are not doing so by biking through a nice woodland trail. I would love to ride to work, but it would take over twice as long as your commute in a climate that is inhospitably cold for biking for about 6 months of the year and often rains for the rest. > it is my "me time" that I cherish You have kids don't you? That seems to be a consistent feature of people I meet who espouse the virtues of going to work.
- globuous 5y agoI thought I would like commuting as I’d find time to read more, but commuting during rush out to and from work is the absolute worse. I don’t even have space to open a book. And the metros in Paris are every 2 minutes so you couldn’t safely increase this rate. And obviously you couldn’t really make the metros longer (you could first fill a half and then a second half, but come on, let’s be realistic here). If everyone remote worked half the week, I’d expect the metros to be half as full during rush hours. So it’s be a lot more enjoyable for everyone: space to sit and space to read a book. I think the best of both worlds would be working at the office on average 2 to 3 days a week (on average; so I’d like to be able to work remotely for a week or two at a time). This would also allow couples to alternate being home which would be nice for kids. If both parents work late at the office, who takes care of the kids, a nanny ? Expensive and doesn’t help the proximity between parents and their kids. My girlfriends mom stopped working when her kids started calling their nanny « mom ». That means that her career stopped. And that scares my girlfriend. Finally, remote working would reduce traffic jams and hence help with our whole global warming situation. So the 5 day at the office work week for everyone is: - not hygienic (metros more packed == greater chance of spreading the common cold, flu, stomachs etc == more money spend on healthcare == more sick leaves) - not green (why travel everyday when we do not have to) - not family friendly (who takes care of the kids when no one’s at home 60 hours a week?) - wastes everyone’s time (stand still doing nothing in the metro for an hour to work and back). I’m all for the partial work at the office for the reasons mentioned by the grandparent comment, but go to hell companies that will bring the five days at the office back !!
- dahfizz 5y agoWhenever the discussion of commuting comes up, the discussion revolves around worst case scenarios. We are software engineers! There is no reason for us to put up with a worst case or even an average case commute. If we want to go into the office, it's easy for us to move house or move job. Its not worth agonizing over a few bucks an hour, especially when going into the office has its own monetary benefits as OP mentioned. It would be a non-issue for most people here to just pay for an Uber back and forth to work, and not have to worry about driving at all.
- FuckButtons 5y agoExcept of course if where we live is a compromise between minimizing distance to other places like our spouses place of work or our kids school.
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoLive close to work? No! Move further away so you can create more emissions travelling there and have a bigger house to heat/cool. Then complain when politicians don't put your needs over the quality of life of the people who actually live and pay tax on your route. Finally, sleep soundly at night knowing the brake dust you make them breathe comes from a Tesla.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> Whenever the discussion of commuting comes up, the discussion revolves around worst case scenarios. The median and average commutes are not the worst case scenarios. > Its not worth agonizing over a few bucks an hour 10% of a software engineer's yearly salary is nothing to balk at. A year or two of that is easily the down payment amount for a modest home, and is more than what many people make in a year. > It would be a non-issue for most people here to just pay for an Uber back and forth to work, and not have to worry about driving at all. I just checked Uber, and a one way trip to my last employer is $40 without surge pricing, and to another employer, it would be over $60. Assuming there's about 260 work days per year, that's at least $20k - $31k a year on Uber rides alone. And it's not just about cost. It's also about time. Based on my last commute, I'd spend about two weeks straight just driving to work and back each year.
- _jal 5y ago> For those of us who have to commute, it's not exactly the norm to be saving money while commuting This is true. I choose to live within walking distance of my office, and it has vastly improved my life - prior to this job, I commuted 2.5 hours a day, and that was awful. These choices of course have complex tradeoffs, but you don't have to commute, it is a choice.
- johnmaguire 5y agoAre you not paying more to live near the office?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CobsterLock 5y agoI feel like this borders on the kind of insensitive comment that people get when they live paycheck to paycheck. Why don't you just save your money for a month? Why don't you just buy nicer shoes so you don't have to replace them every other month? I feel like the trade off isn't that complex. Walking to work is a luxury of having a well paying job in the city.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ck425 5y agoYou're not wrong, but you are discussing this in community full of largely well paid professionals. The majority of is have the financial ability to live within walking/cycling distance of the office, even if we choose not to.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> These choices of course have complex tradeoffs, but you don't have to commute, it is a choice. I have to live near disabled family members so I can help take care of them. It's either work at Walmart, commute or work remotely. I've done the latter for years, but before the pandemic, most non-remote-first employers' attitudes towards remote working was either simply "no", or there was the expectation that you were to spend a year or more working in the office before asking your employer to make a special case for you to work remotely.
- SomeHacker44 5y agoI commute at least 2 hours each day I go to the office. If the MTA is running smoothly. I would estimate I spend closer to 20 days commuting each year. Plus $1,800, which pales in comparison to the TVM of hundreds of hours commuting. I will not be happy to return to the office.
- HardwareLust 5y agoThat's one reason why I left Seattle. I was commuting 4 days/week, with a 1hr 15min commute in both directions, so I was spending 21.66 days a year in the car. Why so long? Affordable housing, of course. I took a small pay cut, moved the east coast and now spend 24 minutes a day commuting, which is infinitely better.