14 ms·
History of the Nautilus loudspeaker
- iampivot 5y agoOne thing is sure with Hi-Fi; there's always someone who thinks they know it all.
- wodenokoto 5y agoI get redirected to https://www.bowerswilkins.com/net/blog/products/history-of-nautilus https://www.bowerswilkins.com/net/blog/products/history-of-n... and the redirect hijacks my back button. Maybe this link is more ergonomic to other users as well.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoFor me the link works fine, I haven’t noticed troubles, but anyway thanks :-)
- alias_neo 5y agoDid the same to me on Firefox Android.
- bwang29 5y agoI used to work in boutique audio retail. One of the big challenges of the business is how big and heavy good speakers are. In the old days we would need to crate the speaker to customers’ house for audition as every room has a different acoustic, and try a few different speakers with more crates with a upfront fee/credit to purchase, but it doesn’t happen nearly as often anymore. Showrooms nowadays also mostly do not have the right environment and setup for the speakers to perform well as they were before. In fact most people do not have an opportunity to listen to half decent audio from a heavy passive speaker and the type of sound they could make relative to homepods is becoming more of a myth now. And the direct implication of this is speaker makers need to make more profit per sale and the price increase for Klipsch Heresy and Forte for each revision is bananas. There are still software company making solutions to emulate speaker sounds before a purchase calibrated to common headphone models, I don’t know how they function but every customer who’d tried one of those would walk away for almost certainty as it sounds crappy.
- ninjaoxygen 5y agoI work in high-end AV. Perceptually, in a good space, those fantastic speakers often do not make the sound people associate with "loud", no distortion, no top end becoming hissy, just the concert-level bass to clue you in to how loud it is. People who have paid a lot for their system want that "wow" factor that immediately makes anyone think it's loud. The other issue is that different listening material definitely needs different amplifier and processor settings - there is no setting that "just works". We find many customers do not wish to get engage with those settings these days.
- smichel17 5y agoAs a very, very casual audiophile, I don't personally feel the need for new models all that much. I don't go crazy trying to fit speakers to rooms — that's going to change over time! So I'd put the speaker in whatever location sounds the best in that house, and I'm happy with that. I like the sound of old 60's-70's acoustic suspension speakers with large (11-12") woofers. In particular, I find them to produce a much more satisfying deep bass when played at low volumes. I won't say they're "the best", since I haven't had the chance to listen to much modern high-end equipment, but certainly they're good enough for me to be happy with. Currently listening on a pair of 1970 Advents (OLA), for the curious. I appreciate that passive speakers are nice. I prefer listening on the Polk T15's I own over the desktop speakers I have, a logitech Z323 paired with the subwoofer from a Z-2300, despite the superior bass of the latter. Anyway, my point is that I don't personally need all that much (expensive) innovation; I'd be pretty satisfied if these companies wanted to produce product lines that already exist (or bring back older designs, which are increasingly more expensive/difficult to find, these days. I admit to ignorance here, and I get that solid wood is expensive, but I have difficulty understanding why this type of speaker can't be manufactured and sold at a couple hundred bucks a pop, vs several thousands for the models the grandparent comment mentioned.
- bayindirh 5y agoAs an audiophile (without the madness), I can understand you. On the other hand, with a pair of good speakers and a nice amplifier with bass, mid & treble knobs, you can almost dial the tone which's best for a genre. A 2x10 band eq is better, but I prefer to listen pure-flat instead. In my setup, only vinyl needs loudness + tone circuits, the rest is happy with pure flat. Of course music and sound is a subjective taste, but 90% of the road can be traveled with just basic, but good components IMHO.
- tcmb 5y agoI'm surprised there's no mention of the cochlea in this article... I always assumed the design was inspired by it. Surely there's some analogy in how the human ear breaks down frequencies in the cochlea and how a speaker produces them in a similar shape?
- duskwuff 5y ago> Surely there's some analogy in how the human ear breaks down frequencies in the cochlea and how a speaker produces them in a similar shape? A false analogy, at best. The sound is produced entirely by the speaker, which sits at the front of the speaker; the "nautilus" shape is simply a resonant chamber.
- yetihehe 5y ago> the "nautilus" shape is simply a resonant chamber. From what I've read, it's the opposite of a resonant chamber, it's filled with wool to absorb any sound which could be reflected from enclosure. It's special shape ensures that each frequency emitted by driver is absorbed at different place to ensure no harmonics, THE only sound emitted from this speaker is made by front of membrane.
- askvictor 5y agoNot necessarily; it's the (inverse) horn shape that is important here (see the higher-frequency speakers), and the woofer would simply be too long to be practical without coiling.
- te_chris 5y agoI haven't listened to the Nautilus but I have listened to the B&W 800 (RRP £23500) speakers and they really have to be experienced to be belived. I was listening in a studio environment that had just installed them, as an upgrade from the already very nice Quested setup they had. When we switched to the 800's the effect was profound. The speakers just disappeared leaving this seamless soundstage where noises just happened within it, rather than relative to the L/R points of the spectrum like most speakers. It was incredible. I'm a former audio engineer turned dev, still producing music. These babys rocketed to the top of my "if my options are ever worth anything" bucket list.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoYou can DIY high-end speakers, saving thousands. Sounds weird, but its true. Here is one example that is popular, there are others: http://www.donhighend.de/?page_id=3212 http://www.donhighend.de/?page_id=3212
- JohnBooty 5y agoThis is true. I'm going to make a vast oversimplification here, but a rule of thumb is that a lot of the well-regarded DIY kits on the market compare well with retail speakers that cost 2-3X as much. Some examples: https://www.parts-express.com/speaker-components/speaker-subwoofer-kits https://www.parts-express.com/speaker-components/speaker-sub... https://www.diysoundgroup.com/home-audio-speaker-kits/home-audio-series.html https://www.diysoundgroup.com/home-audio-speaker-kits/home-a... https://meniscusaudio.com/product-category/speaker-kits/ https://meniscusaudio.com/product-category/speaker-kits/ etc.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoAnd this is a conservative estimate, its more like 10-20x as much. Huge parts of the budget for high-end gear is marketing.
- KozmoNau7 5y agoWhat kind of bugs me is that there really aren't any kits and very few DIY designs that match the kind of speakers I really miss, at least not ones focused on home audio. Those speakers being the old-school big boxes with 12-15" woofers, sometimes multiple and usually 3-way designs, sometimes 4-way. Large, heavy, imposing and punchy, big speakers for big music. I know modern speaker drivers have come a long way, but you just can't get that from 6" or 8" drivers in the same way. DIY PA speaker designs do provide some of this, but I'll have to tweak the aesthetics more in a "living room-friendly" direction, because nobody seems to want big beefy speakers anymore.
- rorykoehler 5y agoNot a fan of how these look (subjective) but am generally a massive fan of B&W speakers. They are a class apart. Truly stunning sounding. You can listen for hours on end with zero fatigue. My bro has has pair of bookshelf (CDM1?) hooked up to Arcam pre and power amps and the sound is out of this world.
- qiqitori 5y agoI use Bowers & Wilkins P5 (series 1) headphones after having tested every other pair in the shop and found these to sound nicest. Really like the sound, but the discoloring is pretty bad (I got the white ones). (Could have something to do with the shop being a somewhat noisy environment and these being the only headphones without active noise cancelling that still shut out most noise, so YMMV.)
- maqp 5y agoThe P5 suffer from a disgusting design flaw: Under the magnetically connected ear pads, the headphones have a soft fiber-like material that's glued in. The glue will melt and leak between the contact points in a few months, which will stain white t-shirts etc.: https://imgur.com/a/W2i0pPa https://imgur.com/a/W2i0pPa The importer first claimed they fixed this issue mid-production, they did not. I went through FOUR pairs. Every. Single. Time. the glue melted. I wrote to B&W about them having a systematic problem in their manufacturing process, they advised me to contact the importer for a replacement pair. Then came the P5 series 2 which the importer said would fix it. Finally... Except, it did not. When I contacted the importer about the problem being still present, they flat out refused to replace the headphones, but instead offered a discount for PX headphones. I told them I would've annulled the purchase like the Finnish law allows me, had I been made aware it would never be fixed. I also told me I wouldn't pour another cent in B&W products. Also I found an entire site dedicated to the design flaw in the PX, which I alas, can't find now. To conclude: Do NOT buy B&W headphones / consumer loudspeakers. The company does still manufacture high-quality high-end loudspeakers, I've been satisfied with the CM1s and no complaints after 10 years of use.
- 5y ago
- senbarryobama 5y agoI recently made my own speaker box and it seemed shockingly easily. Are there a 3000% markup on these objects?
- mixedbit 5y agoPerhaps the primary goal of Nautilus as a product is to sell other B&W speakers. It is so extraordinary and easy to remember that it can be the reason for people to choose a pair of normal looking and affordable speakers from B&W. Nautilus was for sure how I have first encountered B&W.
- bayindirh 5y agoIt's a show of engineering prowess. It's like Nikon's f0.95/50mm lens. Almost perfect, but impractical for most. Moreover, these kind of show pieces allow technology creep to lower levels, allowing the know-how to practically improve other products down the road. I think it's necessary to have products like these.
- ants_a 5y agoA similar product could be produced reasonably cost effectively with injection molded plastics and doing the unit adapted crossover in digital domain. I think it has not been done because the story of it being painstakingly manually crafter, the tower of monoblock amplifiers needed and even the high price itself are the allure of this kind of product. Just like the selling point of a high end wristwatch is not about its capability to accurately tell time. Another important part is that the speaker itself is only a part of the overall acoustic system, the room that it is placed within forming the other part, equally capable of changing the sound. Very few people have the luxury of designing the listening room with as much consideration for acoustic performance as the speakers have.
- bayindirh 5y agoThe thing is, even the performance comes close, injection molded plastics won't have the same characteristics of the tuned fiberglass body with the tuned filling material. Also, to be able to create the same crossovers in the digital domain, you'd have to go pretty high end again, because, passing through a single DAC at the end of the chain is not same as a DAC -> ADC -> Crossover -> DAC chain at the end of the day. All in all, you'll come pretty close but you won't be able to create the exact same device at the end. Also, some stuff's (like good drivers built in small numbers) price doesn't come down that easily. Yes, dedication and tuning of a special room with 8x 500W mono amplifiers requires a hefty sum and these speakers are may not be expensive when all the price is factored in, but throwing in modern plastics and a couple of DSPs cannot replicate all that, all the time.
- em500 5y agoNever heard these myself, but I remember that Nautilus speakers were used in an MP3 listening test by the German c't magazine in 2000[1]. Conclusion: > In plain language, this means that our musically trained test listeners could reliably distinguish the poorer quality MP3s at 128kbps quite accurately from either of the other higher-quality samples. But when deciding between 256 kbps encoded MP3s and the original CD, no difference could be determined, on average, for all the pieces. The testers took the 256 kbps samples for the CD just as often as they took the original CD samples themselves. This article made me (1) never worry about "lossy audio encoding" again and (2) ignore everyone starting about "better equipment" wrt compressed audio. Granted, they used the cheaper Nautilus 803 rather than the 801 in the test. But they also had Sennheiser Orpheus available in the listening test. [1] https://hydrogenaud.io/index.php?topic=27324.0 https://hydrogenaud.io/index.php?topic=27324.0
- bayindirh 5y agoAfter a certain point, lossy compression doesn't create any perceptible loss in audio quality as long as the rip is done well (with a good encoder, etc.), and you don't know every part of the piece in question. e.g. in classical music, you can tell subtle differences if you've listened the piece live or performed it inside an orchestra. However, that's a pretty edge case. There are always differences if you know where to look for, otherwise it's pretty insignificant.
- stinos 5y agoe.g. in classical music, you can tell subtle differences if you've listened the piece live or performed it inside an orchestra Can you explain this a bit more? How is having heard a piece live, which by definition means a unique performance, going to affect whether or not you can pick out whether the recording of (likely) a different performance has been put through lossy compression? Or do you mean a recording of that same live performance? I mean I'm used to subtle differences coming and going depending on room/speakers/crappy compression, but only because I use the same source as reference (say, the same CD). Using a live performance as reference sounds strange, because there I would be able to here one of the musicians doing something different, but difference isn't there on another recording so not usable as cue for hearing differences in sound reproduction.
- e17 5y agoI once got to listen to a pair of these at Abbey Road studio in London as a teenager. They blew me away. I was already a burgeoning audiophile (working in a branch of Sevenoaks Sound & Vision if anyone knows) but these speakers really started a love affair with audio.
- robin_reala 5y agoAh, Sevenoaks. I got a very good set of separates from them in ’98 (Arcam, Myryad, and B&W speakers), but I did spend a lot more money than I’d originally planned as I was young and rather susceptible to hard-sell techniques. Ended up buying everything else from Richer, who were dramatically better in that regard.
- JohnBooty 5y agoOn one hand I like spare-no-expense halo products like this. They are fascinating, at least visually. On the other hand this is why the hi-fi hobby is dying. With products like this, we promote the idea that high fidelity audio requires all sorts of exotic equipment that few can afford. The happy reality is that excellent audio reproduction can be achieved without spending much money; certainly less than a modern game console. One example would be JBL's excellent entry level studio monitors. While they don't play super loud, they measure nearly impeccably and sometimes go on sale for as little as $200/pair. https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/jbl-lsr305p-mkii-and-control-1-pro-monitors-review.10811/ https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/j...
- bob1029 5y agoYou can get damn close to the performance of the halo products with stuff as humble as Polk Audio floorstanders and some Emotiva amps. Any dumbass with a table saw, glue and a bunch of clamps can make speakers that rival the highest end for pennies on the dollar. There are lots of online resources for this sort of thing. If you think this hobby is about the most precise listening experience (bit rates, conversion, etc), you would be wrong in my eyes. It's more about the presence/power you get from a system that can saturate a 20A circuit with transients. The effective dynamic range in a real world listening room. Having your walls rattle a bit when the depth charges explode is an experience. You don't get that with sound docks/bars, headphones, etc.
- JohnBooty 5y agoIf you think this hobby is about the most precise listening experience you would be wrong in my eyes. It's more about the presence/power you get from a system that can saturate a 20A circuit with transients. Both things are true and the best systems nail both. The research done by Floyd Toole and Sean Olive and others tells us that all other things being equal, listeners prefer speakers that accurately reproduce the input signal. https://www.amazon.com/Sound-Reproduction-Psychoacoustics-Loudspeakers-Engineering/dp/0240520092 https://www.amazon.com/Sound-Reproduction-Psychoacoustics-Lo... But, I also agree 100% that gobs of power and accurate reproduction of those transients is also key to listener enjoyment and that this is something that is currently (no pun intended) undervalued by the objective audiophile world. In a modestly sized room one can have their cake and eat it too, with regards to studio monitors. My den music room is about 200 ft^2 / 19 m^2. In this room I have studio monitors crossed over to a pair of subwoofers and it's able to push some very satisfying output levels.
- holri 5y agoBest high-end audio for at home: https://www.boesendorfer.com/en/pianos/disklavier-edition https://www.boesendorfer.com/en/pianos/disklavier-edition If you do not have the time and talent to play it yourself, you can listen to Horowitz or others playing live in your home on a real piano.
- blipmusic 5y ago:-) Also see Glenn Gould's Goldberg variations: https://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/12/arts/music/12conn.html https://www.prosoundnetwork.com/archives/yamaha-disklavier-and-zenph-restore-goulds-1955-igoldberg-variations https://www.classicstoday.com/review/review-13701/
- amelius 5y agoReminds me of the Henry Ford quote: “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.”
- bob1029 5y agoThe real deal is certainly unbeatable, but even then you could have the best concert grand installed in your house and it would still not sound nearly as good as the one sitting in the middle of a massive concert hall expressly designed for this purpose. I would have to wonder if a high quality recording of a piano in a proper setting would be more compelling to certain listeners than a live performance in a less ideal location. I have an upright piano at home that I play on occasion, but I much prefer how the full-size concert grands sound in the big concert halls. I certainly enjoy the act of reproducing music with my own hands more than listening to someone else do it, but from a purely acoustic standpoint there are tradeoffs.
- holri 5y agoMy Bösendorfer grand piano sounds much better than my B&W loudspeakers with high end project amplifier in the same living room. It is not even comparable.
- dave_sullivan 5y agoI am a big fan of B&W speakers. Cool to see this article. Someday hope to get some 803s.
- mrlambchop 5y agoA long time ago when I had younger ears, I heard these at an audio show in London, in a "sound proof room" and I will never forget the experience. I was working for TagMclaren at the time, having just left dCS Audio and I thought I had heard a lot of high end speakers by then, but these blew my socks off and left a lasting impression. I half believe it was the presentation - dramatic, but also extremely clever choice of SACD source content with some theatre thrown in for good measure. However, that 12 minutes in a room in conference hall in London with the Nautilus speakers was something I will never forget for a "this is what money buys you" experience. Warm, huge dynamic range, concert hall experience - comfy chair and dim lights helped as well :) At Tag, we built the "tag mclaren speakers f1" that had a lot of elements I feel borrowed from the B&W industrial design (but made F1 grade) - I used these daily for several years, but was never able to convince myself they were as good as that one time experience.
- teknopaul 5y agoI am a firm believer that you can get too hi-fi. Listening on B&W cans as we speak and they are undeniably hi-fi but not what you call meaty for drum & bass. There is no such thing as the sound of an electric guitar; the pick-ups amp and choice of speaker and cab are what makes it rock. Ortofon recently made this mistake with a full new range of carts and needles with higher range, volume and spec all round. Nobody likes them with their existing records because they don't sound "fat". Maybe new records will be produced that presume new needles but I ain't sure that any of this is progress over hitting your favourite tree trunk with your favourite stick. I have different speakers for different music, until B&W give these cabs out free to the yoot in Brixton there aint gonna be any good music to play one them. They will always be adequate speakers for the fabulously rich.
- ben7799 5y agoExcellent points... almost no hi-fi no matter how high end actually captures what instruments in the room sound like since instruments just don't act the same way. The recordings themselves don't capture a lot of that information or have it mastered out, so the loudspeakers can never put it back in. The soundboard of a piano or the top of an acoustic instrument for example just don't work like a loud speaker. Drums pack a ridiculous punch in the room that speakers rarely capture. Guitar amps do all kinds of strange things in the room due to purposely designed in imperfections that are often missing in the recordings.
- vstrien 5y agoIt makes me wonder, in an age of 3D printing.. has anyone ever tried to re-produce these things?
- louwrentius 5y agoIf you ever want a pair of decent speakers for next to nothing, look up high(er)-end models from 10+ years ago and buy them second-hand. I have a pair of B&W 683s, not even that fancy or anything but they are more than good enough for my 40+ year old ears.
- ben7799 5y agoMy father has had a pair of B&W 7xx loudspeakers for almost 30 years now. Once you get something like that there's no reason to ever look at anything else again unless you've got issues. I've spent a ton of time listening to them. They're really amazing. Funny thing is he spent so much money he never could figure out what to do about home theater when that became a fad. Now Home theater is pretty much gone but his setup is still fantastic for music.
- louwrentius 5y agoI can relate to that: my 85 year old aunt has Magnat speakers from the early eighties and they sound amazing to this day. Never have I owned a surround set, I really don’t care about that. The 683 were bought for the same price in euros I paid for my (not so great) 202i bookshelves 25 years ago in Dutch Guilders. Felt great.
- electrograv 5y agoI am surprised there aren’t more mentions here of AudioScienceReview.com For anyone interested in buying speakers (or other audio products), it’s a fantastic resource and an essential one to avoid getting ripped off with severely overpriced and underperforming products; sadly, the high fidelity speaker space is crowded with such products (many of which are borderline scams), using a ton of pseudoscientific marketing babble to push products ranging from “snake-oil” bunk, to mediocre garbage that still costs the price of an exotic car for no good reason. If you’re curious to cut through the garbage, and learn how to achieve the best sound quality for the best price with a no-nonsense approach, AudioScienceReview is the place to go. They have the highest quality objective measurements on many speakers (that goes far beyond frequency response, before you brush it off thinking that’s what I’m talking about) and tutorials on the well-established science of what makes a speaker sound better than others, and how we design and evaluate this. It turns out you can get sound quality ~90% as good as it gets for just a few hundred dollars, and ~95% as good as it gets for a few thousand dollars (obviously just rough numbers here). Beware of speakers sold for exorbitant prices and exotic visual designs that tout how they are built, rather than what measured performance they achieve objectively. B&W speakers are not bad, and I enjoyed mine very much when I had them. But there exist far better speakers at a fraction of the cost, and this includes their high end (like the Nautilus).
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoCan you list the far better speakers?
- electrograv 5y agoThe “Speaker Rankings” tab here is useful: https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?pages/SpeakerTestData/ https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?pages/Spe... Otherwise, let me know your price range and size constraints, and I’ll refer you to the best engineered (with subjective impressions that back it up) speaker you can get. Note that generally to get good bass response you need larger speakers due to the laws of physics, but more exotic construction can push these boundaries, albeit at the expense of greater cost and electrical power demands. If you want to know what is objectively far better (and subjectively according to most, as the science predicts), look to the Revel F328Be, Genelec 8351B + Genelec W371A, Kii Three + BXT, Dutch and Dutch 8C. These are very expensive, but even in the worst case they are half the price of the B&W Nautilus and perform far better according to what the state-of-the-art science tells us. And subjectively, this is easily confirmed.
- smoldesu 5y agoI'm probably in the minority here, but companies: please just call it the Nautilus. It's a product, not a person, and I don't care how much time or effort or personality was put into your product. I paid money for it, I own it now. It will be called "The iPad", not "iPad". It outright annoys me when companies try feigning familiarity like that.