13 ms·
Article mirrors my experience. For context I'm German, my wife's French and we've got family in Croatia who own a vineyard so I'm used to being around alcohol a
by Barrin92 5y ago
Article mirrors my experience. For context I'm German, my wife's French and we've got family in Croatia who own a vineyard so I'm used to being around alcohol and people drinking. My first impression when I spent time was in the US was indeed how bipolar drinking is compared to Europe.
We probably drink a hell of a lot more in raw terms than the average American does.Two glasses of wine for dinner, another one in the evening, maybe some cognac to wind down, and so on. But it's for the most part not about getting drunk or coping with stress. I've got no illusions about the physical effects but speaking about addiction or being dysfunctional I've seen very little of it despite some people I know drinking enough to stun a mule probably.
The things that I noted were different in the US is how solitary everyone is, overworked and how little time people take for preparing food and just sitting at a table having a drink over conversation. People seem to drink to cope more, use it as a medicine rather than for pleasure or to enhance meals, and I think that turns very badly very quick.
That said I don't think solitary drinking is necessarily as bad as the article makes it out to be all the time, but it takes a certain personality. When you take drugs alone, not just alcohol, you need to be more mindful about why you do it.
- fantod 5y agoNoticed this when I was in Germany/Austria as well. In America, if you go out drinking then that's the primary activity. It's what you're doing. But in central Europe socializing and seeing friends is the activity and you just happen to drink because that's what you do when you see your friends.
- vdnkh 5y agoThis makes no sense. Do you think that Americans go out drinking to get drunk arounds friends, but not to socialize with them?
- sidlls 5y agoI’ve noticed that any bad habits or behaviors Americans have tend to be misunderstood when they aren’t being misrepresented or exaggerated in order to pile on.
- C19is20 5y agoFrom my (not op) experiences, oh yes. Just last night I was talking to a potential bar investor and one of the huuuuge talking points was " how do we cater for the americans?"
- TameAntelope 5y agoI think Americans just aren't used to saying we're out to socialize. It's what's happening, but we're bad at it and we're not used to being explicit about it. As a member of this target demographic, I would say that catering to American drinkers would be to provide a pretext to be at your establishment. You don't have to actually provide all that much, but if you provide a reason for being there that isn't, "Socialize with others" I bet you'd attract more Americans. In America we do "brewery tours" for example, but it doesn't even have to be related to alcohol itself ("good" music, board games, axe throwing, bumper cars, pub quiz, karaoke, etc.). What matters is that you're plausibly not there to "socialize", even though that's actually why you're there.
- refurb 5y agoBy that statement these are Americans outside America? Seems like an unrepresentative slice of the country?
- ipaddr 5y agoWe went out to get drunk and socializing happened. Without the going out to get drunk part the socializing doesn't happen. Getting beer was always the event. Like going to a weekly bowling game. Socializing happens but you go there for bowling.
- elliekelly 5y agoIt definitely depends on the type of bar/club you’re at but a lot of them have music so loud it’s impossible to hold a conversation.
- CapricornNoble 5y agoAnecdote: we've had curfews/restrictions that prevented the American military from drinking alcohol at establishments in the local community, sometimes for over a year. Almost all of my peers at the time would rather sit at the Officers' Clubs on base and get drunk, as if it was their only option for socializing. My take (granted, I had quit drinking years prior): I know you guys can't drink off-base, but....that's where all the WOMEN are (the military officer ranks in our Service is ~94% males). I would expect your desire to get laid to exceed your desire to hide inside your alcohol-infused comfort zone.... My peers: Nah....if I can't drink alcohol I don't wanna go out to meet anyone. The people I hang out with (even to this day) go out to get laid, and if they get DRUNK that's just a side-effect. Most guys I know go out to get drunk, and if they get LAID, that's just a side-effect.
- watwut 5y ago> I would expect your desire to get laid to exceed your desire to hide inside your alcohol-infused comfort zone.... Honest question: what is his realistic chance to get laid with non-prostitute? How much money would it cost to pay sex worker? I also suspect that going around bars while not drinking looking for girl to have sex with might involve a lot of rejection and a lot of effort. > The people I hang out with (even to this day) go out to get laid, I honestly never socialized with people like that. I had always stable relationships and most my friends tended to form those too. Not everyone is for quick hookups.
- CapricornNoble 5y ago>>>Honest question: what is his realistic chance to get laid with non-prostitute? At the time, pretty high. The clubs and bars were very active, and "gaijin-hunter" Japanese women are notoriously easy. If you are halfway-attractive and at least a LITTLE charismatic, you should be able to snag a one-night stand or two, and then a girlfriend in.....6 weeks? That's assuming going out Friday/Saturday every weekend. If you aren't drinking alcohol, it's not that expensive either. If you end up with a relationship that lasts a few months or more, I consider that a pretty good ROI. >>>How much money would it cost to pay sex worker? Depending on service (incall/outcall) and location...$100-$300+. >>>I also suspect that going around bars while not drinking looking for girl to have sex with might involve a lot of rejection and a lot of effort. It does put you "not on the wavelength" of people when they are drunk, doubly so if they are kinda dumb too. You can overcome these hurdles by being attractive, and knowing the right conversational hooks to say in their native language to build rapport quickly and lazily. Building that skillset does take time, and brings other risks (PUA's call it "calibration"....in my experience, "calibrating" for Japanese women can over-fit your social skills for a small dataset, and then your Game suffers when you engage with women from different cultures). >>>I honestly never socialized with people like that. I had always stable relationships and most my friends tended to form those too. Not everyone is for quick hookups. 90% of my wingmen have been in stable relationships. That's never stopped any of us from adding to our harems. If you have a wife, get a mistress. If you have a mistress, get a side-chick. If you have a side-chick, get a fuck-buddy. If you have all four of those, bang all of them during the week, so on the weekend you can get some head in your car in the parking lot from a new girl, who might be a suitable replacement for any of the last 3 of your regulars (I don't recommend replacing your wife with a club-rat...). I had a roommate that kept his accountant side-chick for over 5 years, even after his wife found out. She paid his $20,000 bail when he was getting kicked out of the country, no questions asked. That said....those kind of reliable women are rarely found in bars/clubs, but if you never venture outside of your fortified American enclave because you can't consume alcohol in town, how would a guy ever find out either way?
- OminousWeapons 5y agoI disagree with this. Americans go out drinking with friends because alcohol helps you cut through the bullshit small talk and get to the real talk that everyone is afraid to initiate but eager to take part in. If we could all have perfectly candid conversations surrounding sensitive topics without alcohol, there would be no need for most bars to exist.
- bitexploder 5y agoIt’s kind of amusing when you think about it like a philosopher. I’m a bit older than the average HNer, probably, at 41 this year. It’s all the same fears and doubts. The human condition. Finding love, acceptance, belonging. Not facing down the human condition alone. That is what “big talk” is about to me.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoI don't drink but I agree it's the social drug. It makes you want to interact with others. Drinking alone makes you want to go out and tell people what's on your mind. I used to drink with friends and in that country there was a custom that bars close at a given time at night, and then we would go to someone's apartment to drink more. I remember on one occasion we were sitting around in someone's kitchen maybe 8 people. And at one point I realize everyone was talking at the same time. Everyone was talking so no-one was listening. Everyone wanted to get their point across.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThere are lots of philosophical debates about this. “Is your drunk self closer to the ‘real you’ than your sober self?” People defend both sides of this thesis often.
- qeternity 5y agoWhere in Germany? I find this surprising. As an American expat who has spent a lot of time in Germany, I’d agree that the German relationship with alcohol is less taboo, but Germany/UK have pretty big binging cultures. The Mediterraneans definitely do it more responsibly though.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoYes. Think about Octoberfest. It's all about drinking
- 9dev 5y agoYet, the Oktoberfest is such a small and insignificant detail of our culture. It’s a big party, mostly for tourists. After those two weeks, many people I know take a monthlong abstinence, and life carries on. Binge drinking happens, but it’s definitely nothing regular.
- lhorie 5y ago> to enhance meals Can you clarify what you mean here? I was under the impression european habits of alcohol pairing takes much more space under this umbrella than, say, whether an american associates junk foods (pizza, wings) with beer.
- vmception 5y agoWhat I got out of this was that you were around well-adjusted people in Europe and were around less well-adjusted people in the US. How do you even know about solitary drinking in the US? Why are you unaware of solitary drinking in France/Germany/Croatia? I have no way of quantifying any of your observations. I am aware of people with drinking problems in France, Germany and Croatia. It is easy for alcohol to periodically become a problem in people's lives. I'm not trying to defend American culture at all. These observations read kind of comically though.
- maya24 5y agoAlcohol is a harmful drug much worse than some of the other banned drugs on the market.
- jmcdl 5y agoThis is a common refrain but at the same time it seems to be the one substance commonly used across most of the world since ancient times. None of the other supposedly less harmful, banned drugs are so ubiquitous. Perhaps there's a good reason for this (besides varying availability of other substances)?
- gilbetron 5y agoIt's a really interesting question. Maybe the benefits of having something to drink that has alcohol to kill of pathogens outweigh the negatives?
- chitowneats 5y agoI'm sorry, which pathogens are killed by imbibing alcohol? I've never heard of such a thing, even historically. Edit: Next time I'll do a cursory googling before commenting. This is apparently an existing hypothesis for common types of bacteria such as e coli, salmonella, etc in the drink itself, not in the body.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoI wonder if they meant killing pathogens in the drink, before you drank it. Clean water is a modern thing.
- chitowneats 5y agoBingo. Edited my comment above.
- detaro 5y agoPathogens have a harder time living in alcoholic beverages, making the drink itself safer.
- k__ 5y agoI'm German, and I'd consider drinking 2-3 glasses of wine plus a glass cognac a day quite much. But I'd consider drinking daily or even weekly much.
- ashtonkem 5y ago> That said I don't think solitary drinking is necessarily as bad as the article makes it out to be all the time One of my great bugaboos is these cultural definitions of alcoholism that are independent from the actual amount of alcohol consumed. You know “you’re only an alcoholic if you drink alone” or “you’re only an alcoholic if you pour your own drinks” (apparently this is a meme in Japan?). Every culture that consumes alcohol seems to have these, and they’re all laughably naive and easily gamed. Alcoholics can and do drink heavily together, and they can pour each other drinks if that’s what it takes to sidestep some silly taboo. The only definition of this that’s meaningful is how much alcohol you drink and how often, nothing else.
- TacticalCoder 5y ago> "you’re only an alcoholic if you pour your own drinks” (apparently this is a meme in Japan?) (source: I've got family in Japan). It's polite in Japan to serve others and then let someone serve you. Otherwise it's "tejaku" (pooring oneself's drink). In, say, France/Belgium it's different: the one who serves from the bottle serves everybody and ends up serving himself. Now, obviously, when you're drinking alone there's nobody to serve you...
- ashtonkem 5y agoJust to be extra precise; I’m not trying to imply that there’s anything wrong with customs around how a good friend or polite host serves other people. I’m just railing against the “you’re only an alcoholic if you <behavior unrelated to amount consumed>“ tropes. I’ve never been to Japan, but I’d heard that “you’re only an alcoholic if you pour your own drinks” is a trope there. The question mark in my original post was to underscore my uncertainty.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThis trope needs to die. Europe doesn't have drinking "problems" because it mostly draws the line for "problems" in what would solidly be "functional alcoholic" territory in the US.
- tomnipotent 5y agoWait, what? From the WHO: https://www.euro.who.int/en/health-topics/disease-prevention/alcohol-use/data-and-statistics https://www.euro.who.int/en/health-topics/disease-prevention... "The WHO European Region has the highest proportion in the world of total ill health and premature death due to alcohol."
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoExactly. The numbers don't back up the narrative unless you do mental gymnastics to redefine Europe. HN often seems to forget that Europe extends south beyond the Alps and east beyond the Oder.
- pedrosorio 5y ago> HN often seems to forget that Europe extends south beyond the Alps Unclear what this is supposed to mean. Italy[0], Portugal[1] and Spain[2] all have lower prevalence of heavy episodic drinking than the EU average. Both Portugal ("south of the Alps") and France[3] ("north of the Alps") have higher alcohol consumption per capita than the EU average, which is largely due to a culture of moderate wine drinking with meals that has nothing to do with "functional alcoholism". [0] https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0016/402190/ACHP_FS_Italy.pdf https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0016/402190/... [1] https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/402198/ACHP_FS_Portugal.pdf https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/402198/... [2] https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/402202/ACHP_FS_Spain.pdf https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/402202/... [3] https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/402185/ACHP_FS_France.pdf https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/402185/...
- cm2012 5y agoFor what its worth it I looked up the data to disprove you but it actually backs you up. The data says that Germans drink more than Americans but have lower rates of alcoholism and liver disease. German data: https://www.who.int/substance_abuse/publications/global_alcohol_report/profiles/deu.pdf https://www.who.int/substance_abuse/publications/global_alco... US data: https://www.who.int/substance_abuse/publications/global_alcohol_report/profiles/usa.pdf https://www.who.int/substance_abuse/publications/global_alco...
- bnralt 5y agoWhen factoring in the alcohol-attributable fractions, it looks like German males have slightly higher rates of liver failure because of alcohol than American males, while German females have slightly less than American females. An this is with the U.S. population demographically being much more susceptible to alcohol liver disease than Germany[1]. Looking at the numbers, I think there's a real possibility that Germans and other Europeans have a problem with alcohol that's just as bad if not worse, but are possibly less willing to admit it. Just like how 70 years ago few in America would be willing to admit America's problems with alcohol and tobacco. [1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/02/150220190741.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/02/150220190741.h...
- np- 5y agoI'm surprised this is the top comment, what's the deal with Europeans tending to talk like they're the authoritative source on American culture based on a few people they've met and a few websites they've read? This seems like an absurd reductionist view of both European and American cultures. It honestly seems like the type of anecdotal content I would expect from a Reddit thread.
- jorblumesea 5y agoSpain would disagree. Many parts of Europe absolutely have binge drinking problems on par with the US or UK. Let's not even get started on Eastern Europe. You don't need to go far from Germany to find these problems. I would probably say that Germany isn't indicative of the Eurozone at all.
- flemhans 5y agoIn Eastern Europe it's lowly and indecent to get drunk, whereas in the "Binge Belt" it's a goal for the night for some. I'd sat the Binge Belt is US, UK, AU, DK, NO, IS, JP, KR
- User23 5y agoGermany has a drinking problem[1]. [1] https://movendi.ngo/news/2019/04/18/study-germany-has-an-alcohol-problem/ https://movendi.ngo/news/2019/04/18/study-germany-has-an-alc...
- plandis 5y agoI’ve lived in the US for 30-some years and could really only tell you the drinking habits of myself, my wife, and a few close friends with any kind of accuracy. Do you do research on drinking habits? How can you assume to know so much about the US’ drinking habits in general terms?
- myrandomcomment 5y agoI am an American. I drink 2 glasses at wine at dinner, maybe a cocktail before, and a whiskey or the like after. Dinner is an event for the family. We talk about the day. We take time to cook it for the most part. The other day we had the new neighbors over, cheese, meat and fish board, and lots of wine. Eating and drinking with friends and family is joy and happiness.
- brandonmenc 5y ago> My first impression when I spent time was in the US was indeed how bipolar drinking is compared to Europe. There are two possible relationships a person can have with alcohol - it is either primarily a food, or primarily a drug. Americans have a hard time treating it as food, although thankfully that seems to be changing.
- rorykoehler 5y agoWhy do we perpetuate these myths about European drinkers? If you’re not drinking to get intoxicated why are you drinking? I’ve seen addiction papered over with this nonsense on more occasions than not.
- JamesBarney 5y agoIt's my understanding the U.S. drinking culture is more similar to Iceland/Scandinavia/Japan/Korea/China. It seems that continental Europe is the outlier.
- gwbas1c 5y agoAs an American, I find that most people drink much less than that. The alcoholics are often around people who drink so much that they aren't aware that drinking multiple drinks a day is uncommon. I honestly get sick when I drink more than three drinks within three hours.
- gadf 5y agoAh, the European's old trope of knowing how to Enjoy Life more than the Americans. Funny, whenever I visit W Europe I find it pretty sad and people look pretty grumbling. America is a lot more lively. I think of this Eurostory as a EU coping mechanism.
- baby 5y agoWhen I moved to Canada, what really shocked me if that people would drink alone, or be the only one drinking at a table. Alcohol is something social in France.
- verst 5y agoI agree with you. It's not that Germans don't drink a lot - but it's just not as much in a single session and generally not for the purpose of getting drunk. Most people don't understand the concept of standard drink sizes (for medical purposes or blood alcohol calculation). Firstly the standard drink size in the US is larger than in the US, but even so it's still smaller than the typical size drink people actually receive. If there were more awareness around standard drink sizes we might discover that Americans drink more than statistics capture by a lot (though probably not more than Germans)! In Germany most of my friends in the US would be considered alcoholics. - shots are typically much larger in the US - about 2x-3x - the standard beer size (for beer on tap) is usually a pint in the US. In Germany it's about a half pint! (That's why Germans can have a lunch beer) - Canned wine is fairly popular in the US, but nobody realizes that this is essentially half of bottle of wine. On a related note: most people definitely drive under the influence (legally drunk) in the US! :( I grew up in Germany in the restaurant business (family business) and was a bar tender from a young age (albeit in a fancy restaurant with a few locals who'd sit at the bar). The most shots I've ever seen someone drink in an evening was 9 shots - my staff and I thought that person was a crazy alcoholic. Those shots are 2cl. When you compare that to the typical tequila shots in US bars it's basically ~3 shots (a little more), which people in their 20s and 30s tend to drink like it's no big deal. I have lived several places in the Midwest, in SF, Chicago and of course traveled lots of places in the US for business and vacation. Disclaimer: German in the US for 15+ years. I'm writing this right now whilst drinking my German Import Pilsener to wind down from work :D
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI've been to Europe many times. It's no better there than here. In the USA it's a bit of a regional thing as well, some states are much worse than others, but I don't think Europeans should feel like they have "superior drinking practices", they're just as bad.
- orange_joe 5y agoI don’t think France has a particularly healthy drinking culture. It’s worth pointing out that France has a far higher rate of alcohol deaths than the US, France has around 41K/year and the US 95K/year, which is shocking given the 5x population difference. Even if we assume there are accounting differences, France has a way higher rate of abuse at the extreme end (and thus likely indicates a higher rate of abuse more broadly)
- dantondwa 5y agoI think it is necessary to distinguish between generations, at least in Italy, but I’ve seen similar patterns in other countries I’ve lived. My generation in Italy (millennials) tends to drink a lot more and with the precise purpose of getting drunk. The way they/we do it resembles much more the American way than the way our parents used to drink. Of course, this is based on personal experience, but I’ve seen this pattern across different social classes and it seems to be mainly linked to age, more than education or economic condition.
- lordnacho 5y agoOne thing that comes to mind is the 21 year age restriction on the US, which seems to actually be enforced. Where I grew up in Europe there was an 18 year limit officially but not really, and you could get all the booze you wanted as an teenager. Cannabis too. I went to an international school, so we'd get American kids coming in and realising that they could drink before graduating into a dry university. At least one of my friends got his stomach pumped after a massive binge. I wonder whether the culture in the US encourages people to guzzle it all down at once to minimise the risk of getting caught. I noticed something similar in the UK, where they do seem to somewhat enforce the drinking age of 18, and so when I got to uni here my new friends would act like they'd just discovered alcohol and get incredibly drunk. Now it's not like kids in Europe never get drunk, but it's always available so not really seen as an alluring thing. On much of the continent it's also the kind of thing you might consume with your parents around, which is the ultimate excitement killer.
- vmception 5y agoI do see Americans as having stunted growth regarding some vices The night life hours being so few exacerbate that too
- ridethebike 5y agoI for one drink two bottles of wine while playing some slowly paced video game every Sunday night in anticipation of great new week in my hellscape of a project.