16 ms·
Avoid buying in HOA neighborhoods (2014)
- kyrra 5y agoI've lived in both. HOAs have their place, and really I think it depends on the person. Going into a home purchase, you have to sign the HOA agreement, so you know the rules they set forth. They keep the neighborhood looking a certain way, which is something some people want. I've met plenty of people that don't like HOAs and purposely avoid them, which is fine also. But be prepared for a much wider variation of look and style of a neighborhood. It makes it much easier for a house to get run-down as well. One thing not mentioned in this post is that HOAs can be dissolved. A friend had voted to dissolve his HOA (which was successful), due to too many problems. Common-land that the HOA owned becomes a problem, but it can all be worked out.
- lokar 5y agoYou know rules on the day you sign. They can change.
- ardit33 5y agoRules do change all the time. My Coop (in NYC) decided to impose a 2% transaction fee, which works out about 10k on a 500k apt. They also can raise then fees anytime. That’s why HOAs can be a problem if they have too much power. The fact is that most HOA board members/directors tend to be older folks that have more time on their hands than you do. And they set the agenda. Good luck with that.
- jacob2484 5y agoPeople vote for the co-op board members. Why not vote the people out?
- ardit33 5y agoI just want a place to live, not become a political campaigner. I just want to come home and chill dude. Not have to lobby all my neighbors, just not to get fleeced out of my money. The fact is that most HOA board members/directors tend to be older folks that have more time on their hands than you do. And they set the agenda. Good luck with that.
- shados 5y agoDon't join a club if you don't want to do club stuff. And most of the time, board members are "older folks" not because they have more time on their hands. It's because they got burnt enough and figure being part of the board is an easier way to deal with the bullshit. Hell, in the HOA I'm in, the board members are trying to give the spots away but no one want it. Unfortunately someone has to make sure the common elements get maintained, and even if you hire someone to do it, someone has to be accountable for making sure the person hired does their job.
- pixl97 5y agoYour first statement is no different than saying "I want to life in a safe democratic country, but dont want to dealing with all that politics and voting stuff" People complain about their governments all the time, few are willing to do anything.
- betwixthewires 5y agoNo, it's not the same thing. Participating in a system that controls a navy or decides if murderers get executed or not is not the same thing as having to play politics with busybody nosy neighbors with too much time on their hands telling you you can't build a camaro with your son in your driveway or put a leg lamp in your window.
- Kranar 5y agoThen why would you choose to live among a community of people who agree to live by a set of standards with respect to their property if all you want to do is go home and chill? HOAs exist mostly for those who want to live in a community of people where everyone else does care about one another, where there are common properties that are shared and taken care of, and where everyone has a responsibility to maintain their property. That is not for everyone, absolutely, but if it's not for you, then don't live there. From the way your post is written, it suggests you wanted the benefit of living in an HOA without contributing to any of the responsibilities.
- judge2020 5y agoIt becomes a small government. A lot of small governments are dysfunctional, but quite a lot more work for their community members.
- duncan-donuts 5y agoHow common are HOAs? I’ve lived in an urban area my entire adult life and I don’t think there are any HOAs. My parents lived in one tho in the suburbs and I don’t recall them liking it. Is there any reason to actually buy a home in one?
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoIn places where new communities are being developed HOA and CCRs (the actual rules) are extremely common. In fact in my area they’re required for all new home building communities.
- nine_k 5y agoWho requires them, and on what grounds?
- wearywanderer 5y agoHOAs are a kink, for people who like to be controlled or for people who like to control others. Being in a HOA is like being in a BDSM relationship. Some people like this sort of thing.
- fallinghawks 5y agoI guess if you're into living in a picture perfect neighborhood and don't want to have to look at anything especially weird or different, and have a "council" you can complain to if there's a problem, you'd buy into that. A lot of condo complexes have them as well. HOA fees also go to gardening and other people involved in exterior maintenance.
- blowski 5y agoHow much of a US-specific problem is this? Do similar entities exist in most countries, and do they work any better?
- chrisseaton 5y agoI lived in a village in the UK where windows and doors had to be painted a certain way, you couldn't have visible satellite dishes, you couldn't change the structure, and there were other rules about random things like no tents on front lawns (for some reason? nobody does anyway though.) I think it's pretty uncommon here. I liked it - mostly sensible rules designed to preserve heritage for everyone.
- blowski 5y agoYes, in the UK, most blocks and estates where they’re dominated by leaseholds (as opposed to freeholds) have a property management company that will outsource that to an agent. Conceptually, that sounds similar to these HOAs in the US, so I don’t get why the difference in attitude towards them.
- vinni2 5y agoIt’s pretty common in Scandinavia I don’t know about other European countries. But there are many advantages and disadvantages to HOA. They can negotiate collective deals on internet and tv etc but a lot of mandatory expenses are pushed on you.
- Zababa 5y agoIn France it's usually limited to a single building or a few building built at the same time, and usually called a "copropriété". People can have their vote if they own their appartment. They decide things like "don't hang dry your clothes on the balcony", "don't change the way window blinds look", "here are the trees that we're going to plant in the park", "this is how garbage is handled", "should we have an employee taking care of cleaning and garbage, or should we use an exterior service?". They usually work mostly fine. Edit: a sibling comment mentionned something about a village where you can't freely change the color of your blinds. We also have that, usually on the municipal level, to preserve heritage/the way a place look. For example, some communes from the "Pays des Pierres Dorées" have strict rules about this https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierres_dor%C3%A9es https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierres_dor%C3%A9es
- jimmyswimmy 5y agoYeah, nobody likes an HOA. We all want to be allowed to do whatever we want. That's why I live in a neighborhood without one. Leave the kids toys and trash cans out for a day? A week? Forever? No problem! But I can't complain about similar things my neighbors might do. Or, I can complain, directly to them. If I care enough. Neighbors replaced their roof a year ago. Left the old shingles on the lawn, for a year. Did I like it? No. Did I care enough to complain to them about it? Also no. That's the kind of neighborhood I want to live in though. You want a neighborhood where the houses are in perfect cookie cutter shape? You need an HOA neighborhood, and you get the pluses with the minuses. What I think most of us really want is to be able to do whatever we want, while also being able to tell others what to do. That doesn't work. You have to choose to either rely on your neighbors being decent, or suffer through life under an HOA.
- klohto 5y agoWhole (most of) Europe works without an HOA, why USA can’t?
- loeg 5y agoMost of the US isn't under HOA, either.
- nine_k 5y agoI wonder if it holds e.g. for Germany. Maybe it's not HOA but the town magistrate, etc?
- netrus 5y agoIf you want real HOA vibes in Germany, visit a Schrebergarten (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allotment_(gardening)#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allotment_(gardening)#Germany)!
- tannhaeuser 5y agoThere's no such thing in Germany apart from eg leasehold of holiday homes, rented garden houses (Kleingartenvereine) etc. but there are municipal usage restrictions according to Baunutzungverordnung to the effect you can't repurpose residential areas as a commercial space, and local zoning rules according to a Bebauungplan or equivalent for eg how many storeys are allowed, building lines, distances, materials to choose, a duty for at least an effort to gardening, etc., but it depends greatly where you live, ranging from very strict to everything goes. Edit: IANAL
- city41 5y agoWhat I find interesting about where I currently live is rules you'd expect at the HOA level are actually at the township level: how tall your grass can be before it must be cut, how many cars you can park outside and where, maintaining exterior structures like fences, etc. All are laws in the town I live in. I've never seen that before.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoI think the difference would be that with an HOA there is a resource of people eager to enforce these rules vs the township that probably can’t be bothered to?
- city41 5y agoI haven't lived here too long yet. But I have noticed several notices placed on lawns regarding the length of the grass. At first I assumed they were HOA notices, but upon closer inspection they were from the city. edit: here is one of the notices if curious: https://i.imgur.com/xJABpPf.jpg https://i.imgur.com/xJABpPf.jpg
- citrin_ru 5y agoThis grass look pretty good to me. I expect mowing grass almost to the ground and then watering and fertilizing so it would not die from such abuse is a huge waste of resources on a national scale. Obsession with low mowed lawns is something I just cannot understand.
- supertrope 5y agoHOAs allow townships to kick enforcement of these minor things down a level. They also get to dodge asking voters to approve a tax as it's now in the form of an HOA fee.
- shakezula 5y agoThis is exactly what they do - They're just another corporation with state backing that you have to pay to live. State capitalism.
- lopatin 5y agoI'm planning to buy an apartment in Chicago (Lincoln Park). All these apartment buildings have HOA fees from $500 to $1k per month, so it seems to be pretty unavoidable here. Does this mean I should just avoid buying in the city all together? Renting for a lifetime doesn't seem great either.
- cyberpunk 5y ago1k a month!? Why would anyone pay that? There must be some great facilities I guess (pool? gym?)
- jagger27 5y agoWhere on Earth do you have to pay $1000/mo for a gym membership? I find condo fees staggeringly hard to justify.
- sosborn 5y agoThose fees are for a lot more than gym membership. Take a large building - have you ever looked at the maintenance costs for something like that? If you haven't the good news is that annual budgets and statements for the past x number of years are publicly available for these associations (at least where I live that is true). Before you buy a place, a good realtor will walk you through the association's finances and give you an idea of how well the property is managed.
- pseudo0 5y agoOne issue is that developers will often set an attractive low rate to sell the initial units, and it doesn't get appropriately adjusted as the building ages. Then down the road, when expensive stuff (roof, elevators, etc) need to get fixed or replaced, there isn't enough capital banked and the fees spike dramatically.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoAt my complex, the majority of the HOA dues are going to elevator and roof repairs (or rather, going to replenish reserves that were depleted due to those repairs) Some of the money also goes to utilities (water, sewer, trash) which I suspect are cheaper to do communally than individually
- kull 5y agoUnfortunately, in some areas you just cannot find one without HOA.
- jschmitz28 5y agoI think there is a high variance in how involved different HOAs are, so it's hard to make a blanket statement that you should totally avoid considering buying a property that's in an HOA. My current house is in an HOA that's around ~$20 / month (which pays to keep some of the common spaces of the development maintained), has never gone up in ~4 years, and we've never been notified about anything needing to look better even when our lawn was in pretty rough shape the summer we moved in. We did some research and were pretty confident going into it that we weren't going to be dealing with an overbearing HOA, and I also like that the development and community areas (including a tennis court and basketball court) stay well maintained. In our case, it feels like we're getting a good deal for the cost.
- yabones 5y agoIs that any different from paying +$240/year in your property taxes? My small town in canada has those amenities as well, sans HOA. All municipal, and managed by the town's parks department.
- desert_boi 5y agoProperty taxes can go to _those people_ who can't afford to live in your burbclave.
- compiler-guy 5y agoThe difference is that you only need the local neighborhood to agree that it wants a well maintained park, not the city, which may have other priorities.
- sofixa 5y agoBut if the neighborhood can't afford a new park, there is no new park, while the city's priorities are(or should be) the wellbeing or its citizens.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoI’d love to see some national crackdown on HOA/CCR rules. In particular you should never be stopped from growing food on your own property. If covid taught us anything it’s that the food chain is fragile. The people who run these organizations would literally rather die than see a few corn stocks drying in the backyard of a neighbor.
- fortran77 5y agoI hate HOAs, but if all parties involved agreed to this "contract", the Government shouldn't tear it up and throw it away. Similarly, while I am for solar panels and flying the American flag, I don't like politicians who pass laws forcing HOAs to allow both: https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2011/720.304#:~:text=(2)(a)%20Any%20homeowner,Air%20Force%2C%20Marine%20Corps%2C%20or https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2011/720.304#:~:text=... and https://www.solarunitedneighbors.org/florida/learn-the-issues-in-florida/homeowners-associations-and-solar-access-in-florida/#:~:text=Florida%20Statute%20163.04%20forbids%20any,performance%20suffers%20as%20a%20result https://www.solarunitedneighbors.org/florida/learn-the-issue.... I feel if I was smart/savvy enough to buy a home where I'm allowed to fly a flag or have a solar panel, the people who agreed not to should have to suffer with the devalued property they chose to create.
- josephcsible 5y ago> if all parties involved agreed to this "contract" Imagine that your grandfather bought a house in an HOA, then he died and you inherited it. You're now bound by a "contract" that you never signed or agreed to. Actual contracts can't bind next of kin, only those who actually signed them.
- londons_explore 5y agoI guess you bound yourself to that contract by accepting your inheritance from your grandfather. Various other contracts can be passed on this way too. You always had the option to say no after all, and not take the house.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoHOAs could be studied as what happens with poor government models. If you ever thought you want single party rule, you might be able to look to HOAs as a cautionary tale. I’m biased, lived in one that a lemonade stand war that would have made Animal Farm seem like a lesson in good government. The sex scandal and the embezzlement didn’t help change my opinion later.
- tyingq 5y agoAlso note that some HOA's are "voluntary". Check with a realtor first to make sure that means they have no teeth with regard to covenants, etc. Basically, if they can't put a lien on your property, they have no teeth.
- entire-name 5y agoUnfortunately, in competitive markets like the Bay Area, HOA neighborhoods are the only option available to you in your price range for most people starting out. Your other options are to rent, or to move to a location far from where you work. (Or to live with your family if that is available to you, and all parties agree on it). Now, of course, if you can and prefer to permanently work remotely, then moving to a further location from where you work may be a good option for you. But then you will have to consider the risk of you being able to continue to have a job that allows permanent remote work.
- gnicholas 5y agoWhat competitive Bay Area markets are you referring to? We've bought here a couple times, and although we looked at a few properties that were part of a 3-5 unit "HOA", most of the homes we saw (and both of the ones we bought) were not anywhere near HOAs. In fact, we currently live on a street that is not a public road, but which is apparently maintained by neighbors without resorting to an official HOA. Where are the HOAs around here?
- entire-name 5y agoI guess it depends on what your price range is. For most people starting out, the price range is generally less than $1M. At that price, you will generally only have townhouses or condos available to you, which will generally have HOAs. It sounds like the properties you have been looking at are more akin to "multi-tenant" units in which it is much easier for all owners to collaborate. The properties I'm referring to are those with many more units, and in these communities, an official HOA is usually already set in place long before the first unit was purchased (agreement already set with the builders). That said, I should probably qualify my original comment with "Bay Area within 1 hour of typical office locations in the Bay Area on typical rush hour commute". Here, "typical office locations" will include San Francisco County, San Mateo County, and Santa Clara County. This then limits your property locations to San Francisco County, San Mateo County, Santa Clara County, and Alameda County. In _these_ locations, $1M can generally only get you a condo or townhouse with many units (at least the last time I checked).
- gedy 5y agoThis kind of reminds me of those for and against CoC (Code of Conducts). Some people find them unnecessary and insulting, others can't imagine working/contributing without them. Different strokes for different folks I suppose.
- void_mint 5y agoSuper interesting downvotes.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoUnfathomable downvoting is recently endemic. IDK why. I've been upvoting as I see cases of it.
- void_mint 5y agoI really wish HN would reapproach their strategy for downvoting. It seems like all too often users take the Reddit-esque "Downvote = Disagree" strategy, which is just absolutely terrible for cultivating legitimate conversation between people that might disagree (but are being respectful and have valid points like the post above).
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago>I really wish HN would reapproach their strategy for downvoting. Perhaps a cooling off period after 4 or so. Lately tho, I can't ascribe many DVs to anything - reasonable or not. It's fairly baffling.
- gambiting 5y agoWhat I find really interesting is that I keep hearing how Americans love their freedom and hate being told what to do and how to behave. Yet HOAs are such stereotypical American institution....I've lived in a few different countries and I can't think of anything as opressive to your homeowner rights as American HOAs. And people enter them willingly? Can someone explain why? Are the benefits of living in a managed neighbourhood really worth being told when to cut your grass and when you can take your bins out and what you can and cannot park in your own paid for driveway?
- db48x 5y agoDon’t forget that most people live in towns/cities, counties, states, etc. All levels can and have made idiotic rules. Does anyone really think that the FCC’s current interpretation of Title II of the Communications Act of 1934 is anything other than the droolings of a moron? The congress that wrote the act was apparently not firing on all cylinders either, but at least the act is pretty coherent. Also, don’t forget that not all HOAs make the stereotypical idiotic rules about grass length and garbage bins. Some of them have invented entirely novel classes of idiotic rules! And many of them are just boring and stick to maintaining common areas for the use of residents. Cleaning the neighborhood pool, mowing the median of an avenue or two, trimming the trees, and so on.
- void_mint 5y ago> And people enter them willingly? Can someone explain why? For some, the house they want happens to be in an HOA neighborhood, so they oblige. For others, they like the "order" that the HOA demands of the homeowners that live in that zone - grass and roofs and paints are all "approved" which definitely provides some semblance of consistency. In my experience, HOAs are exactly like this article describes. People that like power for power's sake becoming anal about the people they have control over, under the guise of "consistency" and "order".
- FPGAhacker 5y agoThis is a truism that extends to any governing body. But there are people that having lived under the tyranny of power mongering HOAs, work to keep the rules to a minimum.
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy are covenants allowed to run with the land? There's no other kind of ownership that can control people forever like it can. Regular contract law seems way more restrained in comparison. If there were a new blanket rule that covenants couldn't run with the land, wouldn't that completely and immediately defang every mandatory HOA (effectively turning them into the benign voluntary HOAs) with no other negative side effects?
- crooked-v 5y ago> with no other negative side effects Try that with townhomes with shared walls and ceilings and you'll see negative side effects pretty quick.
- philwelch 5y agoTownhomes with shared walls and ceilings are closer to condominiums.
- josephcsible 5y agoOkay, let me clarify/amend: keep condos and other cases of split ownership of a single building as they are now, but do what I said for single-family homes and other cases where every structure is wholly owned by a single person.
- shados 5y agoA large amount of HOAs are on land leases, so they ARE shared ownership. If you made the rule you suggest, all it would change is that new HOAs would all be on long term land leases (and you'd have a lot of chaos in the current ones that didn't do this because with existing laws it was not necessary).
- josephcsible 5y agoI said shared ownership of buildings and structures, not of land. Wouldn't that eliminate that loophole?
- andrewzah 5y agoI haven't had any issues with my HOA. There are bad HOAs, but I feel like for the average person they're fine. Beats having a neighbor that decides to put junk in the front yard, including a toilet. That happened to my parents, who don't live in an HOA neighborhood.
- dmitrygr 5y agoYou know what is worse than living with a HOA? Running one. I live in a small townhouse complex. Just a dozen units. Nobody wants to be HOA president but we legally need one. I've been de facto forced to run the HOA. It is a joyless thankless task. The number of times I've had to deal with improperly dumped furniture or the city inspector demanding fire extinguisher inspections in insane! My next house will be in a hoa-free area So i can avoid having to work for free.
- londons_explore 5y agoCan you just be HOA president and route all emails about it to the Trash? Postpone all HOA meetings indefinitely... Let all requests go to voicemail, etc... If anyone accosts you about HOA matters in the street say "I think that's best bought up after the next HOA presidential election"
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Nobody wants to be HOA president but we legally need one. Usually, there's a process to change the rules or extinguish the HOA by majority vote. If no one thinks it is important enough to be worth running, extinguishment sounds like a good idea. Not volunteering for the job would probably help move that process along. > My next house will be in a hoa-free area So i can avoid having to work for free. Most HOA’s have plenty of people willing to fill leadership positions (and then hire an HOA management company to do virtually all the actual work.)
- Aeolun 5y agoIt’s fine as long as they’re reasonable. I don’t want random people in my neighborhood to pain their house pink with yellow flowers either.
- ohazi 5y agoWhy not? People use "neighbors paint their house pink" as some sort of canonical example here, but I've lived in neighborhoods with pink houses and ugly houses and unkempt lawns and so-over-the-top-it-borders-on-creepy Christmas decorations and it has never bothered me enough to care. Why does it actually bother you?
- chickenpotpie 5y agoControlling paint color is a bit extreme IMO, but people like to decorate their home and it makes sense to me that the view from their home is part of that. I don't necessarily support it, but I understand the desire to have a nice home in all aspects.
- CyanLite2 5y agoBecause no one wants to buy a house next door to a pink house with the creepy year-round Christmas decorations. That directly affects the valuation on someone's biggest investment they may ever make in life.
- maxerickson 5y agoTreating housing as an investment is a horrible mistake. It's an expensive durable good, policy should be focused on making it cheaper over time. (while maintaining or increasing suitability/utility, not by letting it decay)
- jacob2484 5y agoTreating it like an investment IS the prudent thing to do. Is vs. what you want it to be theoretically are 2 different things.
- _wldu 5y agoHOAs are really just another form of government. You -> HOA -> City/Town -> State -> Federal You pay fees and taxes to all of them.
- josephcsible 5y agoSort of. They function just like another layer of government, but the problem is that they're not actually part of the government, so they don't have checks and balances and they're not held to the same standards.
- missedthecue 5y agoAnd in theory, HOA's compete with each other. One HOA with a $500 monthly fee will likely be outcompeted by a neighboring one with a $20 monthly fee (all else being equal)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- void_mint 5y agoSeeing lots of posts in this thread about "Americans" and "freedom", but these posters I think are forgetting that the only thing Americans love more than "freedom" (quotes intentional) are controlling other people, which HOAs allow.
- Clubber 5y agoMany like "freedom for me but not for thee." Not everybody though. It's more common that I feel comfortable with.
- del_operator 5y agoOh dang, I really like my HOA. I don’t hear much from them and it’s only $250 twice a year. However, it’s been helpful in rare cases where our neighbor had obnoxious election signs up til after February 2020. They are also helpful for managing the roads and nudging the community to install fiber.
- dheera 5y ago> it’s only $250 twice a year I'd rather $0 than your $250 > However, it’s been helpful in rare cases where our neighbor had obnoxious election signs up til after February 2020 Why do you care? It's their property, as long as they aren't putting election signs on your property or blasting noise that affects you, they have a right of free speech.
- enraged_camel 5y agoYeah. The parent post really drives home the point made in the article: HOAs are simply a mechanism to make other people conform to one's wishes.
- HPsquared 5y agoIn other words, they're a local form of government.
- enraged_camel 5y agoNot quite. No actual government will force people to remove political signs on people's front lawns, thanks to the First Amendment.
- ekerstein 5y agoYou’re missing the point. If the board makes a decision you don’t like, you can vote them out. They are elected officials meant to represent you so that the average homeowner doesn’t have to get into the minutia of contracts or managing common property.
- vincent-toups 5y agoThis guy's understanding of what constitutes "horror" is really high strung. Like yeah, this stuff might be irritating. Maybe you wanted pinker shutters. But who really cares? Imagine getting bent out of shape about the color of your shutters or having to put up curtains.
- nightfly 5y agoImagine caring that your neighbors have pinker shutters or don't have curtains? Imagine caring enough to fine them until they either comply or have to move out?
- rantwasp 5y agoyou’d be surprised. these people exist and are a PITA
- ack210 5y agoYup. My parents live in an HOA that used to have a woman (who had no official capacity with the HOA other than living in it) drive around in her golf cart every day with a clipboard to note down any violations she spotted. One of her favorite rules to enforce was one that indicated how long you could have your garage door open for (something like 20 mins). Like another commenter's experience above, she too had a ruler she would use to measure various shrubs etc. in hopes of finding a violation.
- rantwasp 5y agonot a fan of fighting back, but you need to fight back against these type of people. i would report suspicious activity both to the HOA board and the police. let’s see how they handle this.
- glitchcrab 5y agoYou're entirely missing the point. Yes, having to re-paint your shutters is an annoyance in the scheme of things, but why should you _have_ to? It's your house; why should you _have_ to do what a committee demands? And yes, you can say that he has to because he's signed the papers, but you'd still be missing the point.
- fortran77 5y agoIn many areas, the local government _requires_ an HOA for all new developments. It's an awful situation. I'll never live in an HOA neighborhood if I can help it!
- londons_explore 5y agoI wonder if HOA neighbourhoods are cheaper for the city? I could imagine costs of policing being lower and various kinds of complaints being dealt with by the HOA before it gets up to the city.
- rickspencer3 5y agoI like our HOA. They do a good job maintaining all of the common property, including the pool, the shuttle system, and the copious grassy areas and parks that are part of our neighborhood. There are rules here that are related to maintenance, but since there are so many common areas (and roofs and walls, there are a lot of town houses) one person's deferred maintenance can easily become costly for others. I don't find the HOA oppressive our violating my rights at all. I was completely free to not buy a home in this development, and the HOA documents were shared with us early and often in the buying process. I feel more like our HOA is about buying into the community, and getting the benefits of pooled resources. If that's not your thing, keep looking.
- jacob2484 5y agoExactly - I have 0 issues with mine either. I'd love to build a big garage in the yard, but I realize I can't for the better of the neighborhood aesthetics, and I'm fine with it.
- dheera 5y agoThe problem is HOAs are spreading across the country like a fungus, and it's becoming increasingly hard to find an area that isn't an HOA area. Mandatory HOAs should be outlawed, plain and simple. Optional participation in return for access to common areas (e.g. a gym/pool membership) is fine, but hell no they're not telling me how to decorate something I own. Tell them to look up what "own" means in the Oxford English Dictionary if they have a problem with it.
- jjeaff 5y agoSo you wouldn't have any problem with your neighbor decorating their house to look like some kind of brothel? Or your other neighbor using his front yard as an auto parts storage area? Or another letting their grass grow so high that it starts attracting wild animals and snakes that keep spilling over into your backyard? Something even as small as a bunch of junk in a yard that fills with rain water can bring a plague of mosquitos upon an entire neighborhood in certain areas.
- ryanmcbride 5y agoI grew up with an HOA and we'd always get letters about the halloween decorations (I've always done it big, ever since I was a kid) that alone made me anti HOA my whole life. Obviously not to mention how the goal of many HOAs just below the surface is to keep their neighborhood as white as possible.
- yona 5y agoI see this mentioned a lot but you know what? One of the best lawns in my neighborhood is owned by an African American family. Impeccable. The worst lawns are owned by white folks. Doesn’t this comment assume that “only white people mow their grass?” We’ve had issues with our HOA, and I wish they weren’t necessary, but some people won’t take care of their lawns unless they’re threatened with fines. Otherwise, they’ll let the jungle grow in their yards, and leave a couch by the sidewalk. On the topic of race, homeownership, I’ve heard, is usually one main way in which a family can build wealth; if we’re concerned (as we should be) about racial inequality (financial inequality being a sub portion of it), any self-governance that encourages homes to be well-maintained, lawns to be kept, trees and bushes trimmed, and junk vehicles not parked in the yard is a benefit to any family’s net worth, since a main concern of an HOA is preservation of property values. Real Estate is a supply/demand game. The nicer your home and neighborhood look, the higher the market value, which is of upmost concern if homeowner is trying to increase wealth.
- mikem170 5y ago> keep their neighborhood as white as possible I know that these same mechanisms were used to keep out minorities in the past. But I'd say now that they are more about forcing conformity to stereotypical average white middle class appearances than against minorities per say. Variety is not tolerated. It is ok to be a minority, as long as you don't ever act like one. I personally think that's oppressive, even scary, and not good for the culture over the long term. But some people are into that.
- caymanjim 5y agoIt always amuses me when people talk about "buying" a property under HOA control. You're not buying anything. You're agreeing to an indefinite lease with a majority share of profit upon transfer of the lease. If someone else can decide what color your house is, you don't own it.
- umanwizard 5y agoBy this argument nobody owns anything because there is always some level of state authority that can make rules about what you’re allowed to do with it. What’s the fundamental difference between an HOA and a small local government?
- the_local_host 5y agoNot the person you originally asked, but an HOA is an additional layer for a start. Moreover it tends to have more restrictions, of a kind that would seem ridiculous at the level of local government (e.g. what color your curtains can be, in the case of the condo I'm currently renting.)
- brailsafe 5y agoThat would piss me off even as a renter.
- sneak 5y ago> By this argument nobody owns anything because there is always some level of state authority that can make rules about what you’re allowed to do with it. You're right, and that's bad, too. If what you're doing isn't affecting anyone else, you should be free to do it.
- cartoonworld 5y agoThe color (and much more importantly the condition) of your house certainly does affect someone else.
- bachmeier 5y agoHOA is a broad term. The cost/requirements vary. I wouldn't want to try to sell my house if the guy next door parked an RV on the lawn. Things like a community swimming pool and fighting the wrong type of development are a definite plus.
- tomohawk 5y agoWe rented for a year in a town sized HOA that had pools, playgrounds, pools, and other ammenities. A seemingly very nice area in one of the top median income counties in the country. They ran a contest to see who had the most amazing yard. The first, second, and third place finishers all ended up with massive fines, and had to tear out tens of thousands of dollars worth of landscaping. It turns out that their wonderful yards had not complied with every policy and procedure of the HOA. We purposely have bought in non HOA areas now and almost every year hear horror stories from co-workers and friends that confirm our choice. Incidentally, when we moved out of the rental and bought our non HOA house, our car insurance dropped substantially. The crime in the HOA town was much higher.
- londons_explore 5y agoSounds like the HOA people were angry they didn't win...
- shados 5y agoHOAs hate is a fascinating topic to me. Not because I care/don't care about HOAs themselves, but because it really shows how loud a vocal minority can be. The usual narrative is the evil HOA trustees who enforce their selfish greedy wants on everyone else and rule with an iron fist. The reality though is that in most HOAs, they have very little discretionary power beyond what's in the bylaws. What's in the bylaws is agreed upon by the owners. If "everyone hates being told what to do", it's pretty simple to get the rules changed or to vote out the trustees. But it doesn't happen. Why? Generally one of three things A) The inhabitants aren't the owners and thus can't change the rules. Ok, fair enough if that's the situation, that's going to suck. B) People hate the rules, but they don't hate them ENOUGH to go through the trouble of changing them, and some people who likes the rules are enforcing them. IMO ignoring rules you don't like shouldn't be an option (and is why we have so many bad laws at all levels of governments. If everyone who hates them got together to change them, not even the super rich could prevent it from happening). C) The most common one from my experience: turns out a whole lot of people actually agree with the rules. All the talk of freedom, but that includes the right of consenting adults to come into a legal agreement about...stuff. As long as nothing they agree on is illegal to put in your contract, why shouldn't they be allowed? If a bunch of people want to sign an agreement to reach a global maximum instead of a bunch of local maxima that make everyone miserable, why not? Turns out not everyone is cool with the "I do whatever I want and you do whatever you want", and "let's get together and make a compromise so we can both be a little happier" is actually fairly popular too. And thus HOAs are a thing. But I hear the reply already: "In X area everything's governed by HOAs! We have no choice!". Well, either change the rules (after all, if they're THAT damn, it shouldn't be too hard to get enough votes to get them changed), or buy elsewhere. We're talking about buying here, so it implies a certain level of privilege, after all.
- Mountain_Skies 5y ago>buy elsewhere In my experience discussing the topic, the people who claim there are absolutely no properties anywhere not in an HOA are not very truthful. Similarly, they're also makes outlandish claims about how there is only one job they can do and it's only located in this one city so they have absolutely no choice in the matter. It is simply impossible for them to live anywhere else except in this one town that only has HOA properties. The reality is that they want to live in an HOA but they don't want any of the obligations that come with it. They want their neighbors all bound by the rules but they should be granted exceptions because they're special. Personally I would never live in an HOA with tons of rules and design standards but that's what some people like and are free to join. It's their choice. There are plenty of HOAs that just want you to keep your yard mowed twice a month and not keep junk cars and old appliances outside. It's a continuum but far too many want the surroundings of a strong intrusive HOA and the obligations on them of a weak or non-existent HOA.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoA couple of stories about one notorious Florida HOA Man jailed over brown sod: https://jonathanturley.org/2008/10/12/putting-the-prude-back-into-prudente-florida-man-jailed-for-failure-to-sod-lawn/ https://jonathanturley.org/2008/10/12/putting-the-prude-back... EMTs finish heart attack victim's sod job so he'll go to the ER: http://www.ccfj.net/HOAFLFirefFinLawnw.html http://www.ccfj.net/HOAFLFirefFinLawnw.html
- notdang 5y agoNot just jailed, but "in jail indefinitely".
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> Not just jailed, but "in jail indefinitely". A legendary HOA victory if there ever was one.
- betwixthewires 5y agoThat first one really tells you what this becomes: a layer of bureaucracy in between you and your neighbors. And that's just how the busybodies like it, because they're cowards. They don't care about you. Mandatory HOAs aren't about keeping a neighborhood a certain way, they're about taking control over other people's lives. They disconnect us all from each other, they become the go to replacement for neighborhood relationships. And they give the worst of us a cudgel to wield over our neighbors.
- tunesmith 5y agoHad a fun little exercise with our HOA recently. Seven member board, and each year half the seats are open for election. Over the years, two rules have come into tension. First, in order for a new candidate to be elected, they have to get a majority (not just a plurality) of the votes - 50% + 1. I think the original thought was that if a large number of candidates ran and no one got over 30% of the votes or something, they shouldn't be eligible for the board. If not enough new candidates get 50% support, then the incumbent can keep their seat, in order of votes. The second rule is that you can only vote for a number of candidates matching the number of openings. So if there are only three openings, and seven people are running, you can only vote for three of them. If you vote for more, your ballot gets thrown out. The board has had problems lately so we had a lot of candidates in a recent election. I remember liking five of them, but I could only vote for three. There were roughly 1000 votes, and the most popular "reform" candidates got around 490, 460, 450, 420 votes, so none of them made it in (they clearly had split the vote). The incumbents that retained their seats got vote totals like 350, 275 - one incumbent got the second lowest of all running candidates, but got to keep his seat. Obviously anti-democratic - as interest increases in replacing board members, it becomes less possible to do so. There are remedies such as Instant Runoff voting, but the way we vote and count is that you get your ballot in the mail, put a checkmark next to the names you want, and then counting teams count up the checkmarks (discarding the ballots with "too many" checkmarks). Manually counting IRV was deemed too onerous for our process. Another, and my favored solution for this sort of scenario, is Approval Voting, where you simply put a checkmark next to all the candidates you approve of, and then all the checkmarks are counted by the same counting teams, without discarding the ballots with "too many" checkmarks, since it's no longer possible for there to be "too many" checkmarks on a ballot. We gave presentations to the board, explained it as thoroughly as possible, made the case that what the elections were doing (due to the 50% rule) was measuring the level of support for each candidate, and that only Approval Voting was capable of measuring that accurately, subject to our other restrictions. It failed on a 4-3 vote. Of the votes against, one was "it's been working fine the way it is", another was "It sounds funny", one gave no explanation, and one indicated the lawyers were of the opinion it wasn't allowable. In the next election, the three "yes" votes chose not to run for re-election and were replaced.
- grosales 5y agoI pay around 15 bucks a month for my HOA. They take care of common land and also the 3 kids playgrounds in the neighborhood. They also have to approve any changes to the exterior of a house which can be annoying. One interesting thing they do is that for things like new decks or replaced ones, you need to submit an application for approval which should include a building permit by the county. It gives prospective home buyers assurance that certain things were done correctly. Before a house is sold, the seller needs to provide an HOA disclosure which triggers an inspection for which a seller needs to ensure all changes were made with the approval of the HOA. Our seller (an investment property management company) had to fix several things in our house to being them up to code to get those approvals, which helped me as a home buyer. Besides that, the HOA has been very responsive, we did replace our windows without their approval but it was relatively easy to fix given that they were similar windows.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 5y agoAs a brit I find these interesting. We don't have them. Planning law is a bit tighter. And there are laws about party walls. But HoAs just aren't a thing here...
- technick 5y agoYes and No, it could be worth it depending on the HOA board. I successfully penetrated my HOA board (24 years old with no experience) and in 2 years became the president. I then rewrote the HOA covenant to be more sensible and cut the fees by 50% with a plan to phase them out in 3-5 years. 98% of the neighborhood voted my changes in. I only put leans on houses that absolutely refused to cut their lawn for multiple months and pay their HOA dues.
- walterbell 5y agoCould you share a bit about your motivation and resources, tools or mentorship that helped with this achievement?
- technick 5y agoI was motivated to change some of the sillier rules that I knew could bite me in the butt, like the rules around putting up seasonal decorations and allowing garbage bins to be out for more than 24 hours. I had a friend who also sat on a completely different HOA board as president and he mentored and enabled my success in many ways (His neighborhood and board was over 2x the size of mine and offered many more benefits). My neighborhood was 238 households (single family homes), 2 playgrounds, 2 large common areas for cookouts, 2 entrances and a single pool. My HOA collected $450 dollars yearly from every household to maintain all of the above and threw 4 community parties yearly. That said, is there something specific you wanna chat about?
- walterbell 5y agoThanks for the additional detail. It's a rare success story among hundreds of negative stories. You might want to write it up, likely many outlets (both pro and anti HOA) would be interested in publishing, because it shows the system working as designed, and breaks the stereotype of older people monopolizing HOA boards. You could inspire an entire generation to take an interest in practical local governance :)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- upofadown 5y agoThose things were getting so obnoxious that the US federal government had to make a law that overrode the HOAs to allowe TV antennas and satellite dishes: * https://www.fcc.gov/media/over-air-reception-devices-rule https://www.fcc.gov/media/over-air-reception-devices-rule
- walterbell 5y agoHomeowners also have rights to financial reports, and to display the American flag, https://www.hoamanagement.com/homeowners-rights-against-hoa/ https://www.hoamanagement.com/homeowners-rights-against-hoa/
- etempleton 5y agoI used to feel very strongly against HOAs, but for the past year or so I have been dealing with a neighbor who puts out bulk trash improperly (basically a big pile of random trash) and doesn't call it for pickup so it sits for weeks if not months. This is more than an eyesore. It often includes glass and other items that kids (including theirs) break in the road where I walk my dog. He had a splinter of wood from their garbage pile go straight through his foot, but luckily is fine. A few houses down the bank owns a house that was a foreclosure three years ago that no one lives in and is falling apart. I guess they were not able to get any money at auction for it so now are just sitting on it until they can write it off as a total loss and sell the property for land value. Apparently no one can do anything about either problem.
- mikem170 5y agoEvery municipality I've lived in has laws on the books against putting out trash too early, and also about condemning property (which I am admittedly not as familiar with, but I assume priorities safety over aesthetics, which makes sense). Municipalities have code enforcement and city councils to enforce the above rules. I've seen municipalities that do a better job at these kind of things than HOAs. I've also seen HOAs that don't do a good job of enforcing their laws, seemingly falling apart. (I wonder if they can be sued in these cases?) For example, I've seen HOA neighborhoods with cars parked everywhere - driveways, street, blocking driveways, and on lawns, because the houses were unaffordable unless four or more working people lived there, and there was no way to get anywhere except via car.
- prirun 5y agoI think an important thing is that there is not much common property in the HOA's domain, which therefore limits the fees the can collect. When there are high fees, HOA's attract the worst of society. My HOA is $100/yr and the only common property are some pillars at the 2 entrances. We do have rules that I actually like, for example: - don't leave your trash cans visible from the street - no driveway basketball goals or other sports equipment - no motor homes or boats parked in driveways - no long-term parking on the street; guests for parties are fine - fences have to be approved. We have 5-6 different kinds that they accept, but not 30 - sheds and other detached storage buildings have to be approved. Anything attached to the house doesn't require approval These rules to me are to maintain property values of the neighborhood. It's not like the HOA's that insist you get a new roof every 10 years or paint your house every 5 years, or the HOA hires someone to do it and sends you the bill. My sister was in one of those in FL for a vacation home and she sold it, not just for that reason, but it was definitely a factor.
- dheera 5y ago> My HOA is $100/yr and the only common property are some pillars at the 2 entrances. Yeah well that's a lot of price to be paying for a couple of pillars. I'd rather pay $0. I'm not paying $100 to some random dude. They aren't the IRS. > We do have rules that I actually like, for example: That doesn't mean I have to like them. I shouldn't have to pay my $100 to be subject to restrictions. > - no driveway basketball goals or other sports equipment > - no motor homes or boats parked in driveways What? Why do you care? It's not your home, let them do what they want > - fences have to be approved. We have 5-6 different kinds that they accept, but not 30 I'll build my own damn fence. I'll build my fence how I like it. > - sheds and other detached storage buildings have to be approved. Anything attached to the house doesn't require approval I think this is a city building code issue for safety reasons, in any case the HOA should have no say over it. > These rules to me are to maintain property values of the neighborhood. I have ZERO responsibility to maintain YOUR property value. And if I truly own it (i.e. not under mortgage), I have ZERO responsibility to maintain my own property value. I only have responsibility to be a good citizen and not be a nuisance or public health hazard to you. A boat in my driveway does nothing to you, and it's not upto you to tell me where to put my boat.
- 5y ago
- kevin_nisbet 5y agoI've been president of my condo board for several years now, for a Condo corporation in Canada for a high-rise building. I'm seeing lots of comments around residential HOAs which might be a different story. From what I've observed from only one board, talking with various property managers, industry reading, and reading legal case summaries, I do believe there is a lot of variability in different areas and corporations. Which to a degree makes sense, these are basically small businesses government by a board of random strangers with no special qualifications and are managing $125 million in assets or more. In my building we need to find 5 boards members out of ~150 units. Sure, you hire a property management company and a property manager to do day to day operations, but ultimately the board is responsible for all financial and strategic decisions. It's especially tricky because many of those decisions are going to be based off of imperfect and limited information. Having done this for several years, I do believe many don't understand their requirements by purchasing a property government by a condo or HOA, and the notion that it's their own property they should be able to do what they want. I certainly did not understand my obligations when I bought my unit compared to several years on the board. With freehold it might be a different story, but in a highrise shared structure I think it's clear that we need some sort of contract that outlines the requirements, and that contract to be enforceable to the property owner. One of our lawyers explained it to me once in a way that really resonated. The Condominium Act (The legislation in Ontario that governs condos) is designed as consumer protection law. But it's not consumer protection law in the sense of a consumer vs the corporation, it's consumer protection law as a protection from having to bear costs created by your neighbors. So there are lots of rules in place on how you get a board, how you pass rules, how you manage disputes through tribunals or the courts, what types of liabilities the board can take, what types of expenses go to an individual unit owner (IE damage), with the ultimate outcome meant to protect owners from costs created by their neighbors. So the example of someone losing their job and not wanting to pay the maintenance fee's, well the structure of the contractor is everyone pays their share, if you don't, it means a neighbor would have to. Who would want to take on liabilities of shared spaces if their neighbors might be insolvent and the remaining are left holding the expenses. And yes, part of this bears the requirement to manage a community and disputes that may arise. Are their bad boards... definitely, there are plenty to go around. Are there ways for boards to create lots of hidden debt which will impact the owner... absolutely, I'd suspect mostly by deferring or not understand required maintenance, not paying attention to poor vendor performance and maintenance practices, and in some cases not understanding the differences in bids and picking the lowest bid from someone clearly going to cut corners. It's also happened to us once where all bids were so high that we couldn't understand, so we split up the project and rebid for 50% of the cost... other boards may have just accepted it. Are there board members who join to take advantage of the corporation to break the rules or take advantage of the decision making power, I'm sure there are plenty of example as well. But on average I would expect most people join the boards in a good faith effort to protect their own investments and the common interest of all owners. If living by this set of community rules isn't for you, then don't buy into a condo or HOA. But if you want the advantages of what a HOA/Condo provides, understand the risks, sometimes don't mind volunteering the work yourself (join the board), then a condo or HOA might be for you. And try and give those random strangers some credit, and understand that they're probably making the best decisions they can on the information they have available to them (doesn't mean be hands off or not to ask questions, just make a good faith effort). They might also be tackling significant problems, like a health crisis, or having to lobby the government to prevent a 39% increase in utility rates by reclassifying the common elements from residential to commercial utility rates.
- elzbardico 5y agoA lot of the appeal of HOAs como from the obsession americans have of seeing their homes as investments. An illusion conveniently fueled by the marketing of banks and realtors. Americans usually have this idea that a home is a valuing asset, because they mistake price inflation, fueled mostly by a constrained supply in some growing markets, with true asset valuation. It is not like something magic happened in the bay area and trillions of dollars have magically been added as true value for the existing house, it was just price inflation most of the time. When Detroit was an american economic power-house people probably thought that their properties would value indefinitelly. But the thing is, even if a local supply constraint is sustainable over time, either because of real space limits (like in Manhattan where the only way to build new space is by first demolishing something) or because of zoning restrictions, nothing guarantees that the demand will stay strong forever. And even if local demand stay strong, we can expect it to decrease globally some moment in the future, as we enter a demographic transition where population starts to actually shrink instead of grow. Take out the my-home-as-a-valuing-asset notion, and a lot of the drawbacks of this style of community (lack of privacy due to the absence of front yard fences/block walls, increasing fees, annoying restrictions) become more salient.
- LatteLazy 5y agoPlenty of people have made more money from home appreciation and downsizing than working. That's a problem imho, but you can't blame others for wanting to do the same thing... And of course, if you buy in such a market, you are all the more desperate (quite logically) to keep it that way.
- elzbardico 5y agoSure. Don't deny that. I just question the wisdom that on the long run this is healthy or sustainable to believe that houses are always appreaciating assets when usually gains come from asset price inflation not inherent value increase.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThe question is what we replace it with. One of the reasons we bailed everyone out in 2008 was because no one could convincingly sell a model other than keeping on the same as before...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]