6 ms·
What we lose when literary criticism ends
- Invictus0 5y agoI can barely read this with all the distractions and popups all over. I don't want to sign up for your newsletter!
- puipjqxrkubfcgq 5y agoBooks are a rather dry and old-fashioned way to experience a story. Text in general works best for reference works and non-fiction since it is so easily searchable. People quip that with podcasting and audiobooks society is returning to an oral tradition. I'm inclined to agree and can only encourage the development. Narration adds such a richness to a story. Most everyone subvocalizes when reading anyway.
- crooked-v 5y ago> Most everyone subvocalizes when reading anyway. That's a huge assumption to make. Did you not know that not everyone operates with an inner monologue?
- wussboy 5y agoHe did say "most", which isn't everyone. He still may be incorrect, however. I've never seen any data in this.
- nicoburns 5y agoThat is quite an individual thing I think. Personally I can quite easily lose myself in a book, but I struggle to keep my attention on an audio book.
- wussboy 5y agoYup, everyone's different. I like both reading and audiobooks, but I audiobook more because I can do it when I'm driving or walking the dog. Killer feature.
- tehnub 5y agoWith text in front of you, you have the freedom to vary your pace as you please. You can slow-read a critical section, or skim a paragraph of fluffy description.
- Zababa 5y agoI don't agree that books are dry. With books, lots of elements are left to my imagination, which helps put a part of myself in the story. I don't think I'm the only one that does that considering how people tend to dislike movie adaptations of books. > Narration adds such a richness to a story. Narration adds more elements, which can be a good or a bad thing.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoGo read House of Leaves and then see if you still have the same opinion. That is a story that can only be told in the form of a book.
- dqv 5y agoAnd after reading about it, I imagine it can’t be in ebook form either?
- mcguire 5y agoIt would lose something... :-)
- crooked-v 5y agoI'd be curious to hear how you'd do something like these pages in an ebook without just resorting to a static PDF: https://i.imgur.com/ZgHnjza.jpg https://i.imgur.com/ZgHnjza.jpg https://i.imgur.com/6LfLwAq.jpg https://i.imgur.com/6LfLwAq.jpg
- dqv 5y agoThat was my exact thought too. I was trying to imagine how it would be done in an ebook where it could be resized appropriately to the various screen sizes and couldn't really grok it.
- tqi 5y ago> The elevation of an undifferentiated mass of online voices has instead resulted in a large-scale manifestation of what American critic Elizabeth Hardwick, in 1959, referred to as “a sort of democratic euphoria that may do the light book a service but will hardly meet the needs of a serious book.” I'm not sorry that we no longer have a monoculture with a generally agreed upon definition of what a "serious book" is, bestowed upon us by "serious critics." I don't buy the idea that literary criticism accomplished anything except act as gate keepers that ensured only the right voices were celebrated.
- ska 5y agoAt it's worst, criticism (of any type) is mere gate keeping. At it's best though, it's intelligent informed contextualization. Which takes real work. Your odds of finding the latter by randomly sampling the mass opinion is approximately zero. But clearly it has value. So it's a quandary, how do you tear down the institutionalized gate keeping without reducing everything to superficial opinion? How do you find a better way to pull signal out of all that noise?
- username90 5y agoLiterary criticism isn't it though, the reason people don't care is that those critics doesn't laud the books people like. If they dug up new Harry Potters to take the world by storm people would care, but as is there is little value in their work. If you think that Harry Potter isn't good then you are one of the bad gate keepers since that kind of book is what people wants to read.
- retsibsi 5y agoTo speak sensibly about what is good, we have to define what we mean by 'good' in this context. You can define 'good' as 'popular' if you like, but I don't think that corresponds with how most people use the word, and nor is it particularly useful. (We already have a word for popular.) This doesn't mean that 'good' = 'lauded by highbrow critics', either. But it's okay to have a concept of literary quality that isn't reducible to popularity or pure entertainment value; it's okay to value things like psychological insight, or beautiful complexity, or the capacity of a book to broaden its readers' circle of empathy. We will never all agree on which qualities matter most or which books best exemplify them. Employing these unavoidably fuzzy and subjective concepts certainly opens the door for pretentious charlatans to barge in and do their thing. We should adopt a sceptical stance toward any and all cultural gatekeepers, and exercise our own judgment. But there's still no need to flatten our concept of literary quality down into something objectively measurable.
- medium_burrito 5y agoHonestly, for the stuff I read I totally care more about the opinion of "enthusiastic amateurs", so yeah, honey badger don't care. The more interesting part of the article is "In 2018, The Writers’ Union of Canada found that, after factoring in inflation, Canadian writers are making 78 percent less than they were in 1998", ie inflation ie a giant motherfucker, and thanks governments everywhere for fucking the younger generations out of a future.
- throwaway98797 5y agoinflation is good for the young since they are in debt. inflation hurts the old on fixed incomes.
- catlifeonmars 5y agoYou just said it was “after factoring for inflation”. How does it make sense to say this is due to inflation when you just said inflation was accounted for?
- coldtea 5y ago>With mainstream media uninterested in books coverage that doesn’t get clicks, writers and readers are being left out in the cold Literary criticism ended? Leisure reading is at an all-time low, and that's even worse. And most of the "reading" going on concerns self-help snake-oil crap, get-rich-quick books, and of course, heavy skimming.
- fedreserved 5y agoCome to thesopranos reddit thread. It's 9 part quotes, 1 part very serious literary criticism on the most complex tv show maybe film in existence imo (as it's essentially an 86 hour movie). A lot more noise, but a lot more insights overall then any literary critic can muster. The problem is it's a needle in a haystack, but it's not that bad when you still find enjoyment in most of the hay!
- offtop5 5y agoI had a starling Revelation today. People just don't read anymore, instead they buy a book so they can take some photos for Instagram and then shove it under a couch or something. The biggest problem with so much access to information, is it's simply impossible to absorb it all. You can read tweets from hundreds of people before you can get through the first chapter of Harry Potter. I fear this has caused a permanent dumbing down of society
- dghughes 5y agoWhen the Internet really took off in the mid 1990s I thought to myself with all the websites, IRC, email, blogs more people than ever are reading. Sure it's not books which are the crafted thoughts of writers instead the Internet is a million concepts.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoI would like to read the last 10 books I bought none of which I finished and only a couple of which I've started. Instead I find myself scrolling hacker news and Twitter. But at least I'm not on Facebook and Instagram!
- easton 5y agoTwitter isn’t really better than Facebook, it’s short content designed to provoke an emotional reaction. HN really isn't either, although the emotional reactions here are a lot fewer and far between. Pick up the book on the top of the stack and read the first chapter right now. You’ll be happy you did!
- dcolkitt 5y agoOne formula that works well for me is audiobooks + jogging. There's really no escape from the book for the next 30-45 minutes.
- germinalphrase 5y agoFunctional literary is quite high, but it is both a subject of research and social criticism that American culture is reverting to an oral - rather than literate - culture.
- Sophistifunk 5y agoThere are no book reviews any more. There are books that stir up the internet outrage machine, and books nobody knows about.
- Herodotus38 5y agoHas anybody read Martin Amis’s: The War Against Cliche? It’s been several years but the book is great and the title summarizes the work of a literary critic, at their best, in my opinion.
- ggm 5y agoI actually question the premise. The NYRB and LRB are alive and well afaik. I read reviews all the time in the Guardian. At a second tier, honest customer reviews exist in kindle. Sometimes they are dreck, but you can apply critical faculties to what people say. I agree in principle there is "less" than there used to be but there isn't "none" and I think I have bought at least three books recently purely on the strength of in-depth reviews I read online (they were Ross King: the Bookseller of Florence, Emma Southon: A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum and Geraldine Brooks: Year of Wonders And, the first two which I have read, had merits and issues, and the review highlighted both as I recall)
- karaterobot 5y agoMy takeaway from the article wasn't that there aren't people reviewing books anymore, but that fewer people today can make a living writing informed criticism about style and technique, as opposed to about how a book makes them feel, or how it fits into an ongoing cultural conversation.
- ggm 5y agoYea, maybe because I buy more non fiction i mistake review for literary criticism. I'm probably unaware of the change in eng. Lit. as a field. I always found other peoples take on a lyrical quality in somebody's writing as less useful than "it's a coherent narrative" -I know how Rushdie or Vikram seth write: i want to know how concretely plausible or accurate their story is regarding Indian social affairs of the time.