3 ms·
Signal is centralized and in no way can replace emails.
by ekianjo 5y ago
Signal is centralized and in no way can replace emails.
- tptacek 5y agoEmail is default plaintext, can't force encryption on groups, leaks --- in fact, gleefully publishes --- the most important dragnet surveillance metadata (even when ostensibly encrypted), creates long term archives of secrets, is built on long term secrets, and, to boot, is in the real world itself effectively centralized. It's hard to even imagine a secure messaging system less safe than email. Recommending encrypted email is simply malpractice.
- ekianjo 5y agoRecommending signal fails to realize that it can be compromised in many ways precisely because it is centralized. A false sense of security.
- 0xCMP 5y agoEmail clients and server instances are just as centralized in practice. Yet email servers almost always know everything about you in contrast to Signal. And you can prove this by reading their code and by the fact that they respond to subpoenas with as little info as they do. How would signal be compromised that email could not and which signal is not better prepared for?
- ekianjo 5y ago> Email clients and server instances are just as centralized in practice. I don't follow. Not everyone uses Gmail or the big email providers.
- kasey_junk 5y agoIf anyone on the communication thread uses GMail or the other big providers then the entire conversation is subject to the weaknesses of the protocol. Right now that sits at about a 1 in 5 chance for Gmail alone.