5 ms·
I forget where I read it (venture deals, perhaps?) but it has always stuck with me: founder stock should vest! Nobody should get any equity whatsoever until an
by sneak 5y ago
I forget where I read it (venture deals, perhaps?) but it has always stuck with me: founder stock should vest! Nobody should get any equity whatsoever until and unless they've been working full time on the project for a year or more, founders included!
That wouldn't have solved the problem here, however, where blowing up the whole company is the best outcome, as you don't want to be in business with greedy, dishonest people. Building inside of a crab bucket is a huge waste of time.
- redis_mlc 5y ago> founder stock should vest! That's not obviously true. An example when it doesn't make sense is if you already spent a significant amount of time, or got results. From an investor standpoint, they like founder vesting because they're essentially wiping out (zero-timing) whatever initial ownership you had, and getting cheap employees (founders) on an employment contract. Investors get a significant power advantage at founder expense. But hey, if you don't know any better, sign on the dotted line. For those who aren't sophisticated with business contracts, there's no such thing as a "standard contract." You can find out if the other party is flexible or not by saying, "I'll redline this and get back to you." If they refuse, then you know where you stand.
- lumost 5y agoThis is a pretty bad deal IMO. If I’m the technical cofounder the first months are basically me getting the (software) product to the point where it can be shown to customers. The next few months will see a sales founder get our first deal. Once the product is ready to launch, A bad technically founder could find a cheaper CEO. Once the first deals are in a bad CEO could find a cheaper technical founder. The vesting strategy encourages thinking about founders as employees that can be replaced rather than as partners.
- pedalpete 5y agoYes, but think about the other perspective. The CEO decides to leave after 2 months, and they hang on to 50%? The vesting keeps everyone honest and in for the long-haul.
- rkk3 5y agoOr in Facebook's case, no vesting agreement for co-founder with 20% of the company that didn't work out after a few months.
- jdsully 5y agoA startup is just so difficult that you really can't get away with stuff like that and survive. It's very rare you can fire your dev team and get away with it, your product will not be good enough for years on end while you learn and grow. On the flip side customers will wonder why their point of contact is now gone if you fire the main contact they were dealing with. Plus how are you going to get more of these customers now?
- rkk3 5y agoThere should be some sort of vesting schedule. If you really don't think a standard one is fair, It doesn't have to be over 4 years. It is also normal to have events that accelerate vesting (like an Acquisition) which in yours case could be the delivery of an MVP. Also if your co-founder thats doing sales can't close without a product, you should get someone who can that is a very bad sign.
- cweill 5y agoWhat about when some founders put in capital, say one founder puts in $100k? Do they still need to vest?
- sneak 5y agoPersonally, I'd say yes. Maybe a shorter overall vesting schedule, but at least a one year cliff.