3 ms·
Obvious (hard) question: How many deaths were prevented because of this overwork?
by BeetleB 5y ago
Obvious (hard) question: How many deaths were prevented because of this overwork?
- ornornor 5y agoI’d suspect not very many. Filing the TPS report by some made up arbitrary deadline, forcing the victims to work overtime so that a middle manager somewhere can feel important is very unlikely to save a life. When you think about it, most of the work most people do is utterly inconsequential and doesn’t matter much if at all. And even when it does, it’s really not so critical that the world will end if it’s a week or two late, making most overwork useless.
- nradov 5y agoThat makes no sense. If most work was truly inconsequential then a smart CEO would fire all the inconsequential workers to improve profit margins. Companies lay off redundant workers all the time.
- Noumenon72 5y agoAre you never grateful to your coworkers for all the things they do that make your life easier? And you aren't even there to see the things you do for your customer that make their life easier. If you got hired and it wasn't because someone made a law you had to be hired, you're probably doing something pretty consequential.
- ornornor 5y agoI should have qualified that I meant it in the context of overwork. Almost nothing we do is so crucial that sacrificing people’s lives to overwork so the deadline can be met is morally justifiable. There are very few mission critical, literally life saving exceptions. 99% of it all is not: if the TPS reports are done a week or two late, no one dies and nothing explodes.
- bserge 5y agoGee, I dunno, those extra 200 smartphones and 40 app features that will end up as trash and forgotten a year later sure saved a lot of people. Most of this overwork is for bullshit, mundane reasons that aren't even worth a rat's life.
- manquer 5y agoNot everyone works in software or builds apps, even if you don't find meaning in someone's work( or yours) it doesn't mean they don't find meaning in that themselves however trivial or useless it may seem to you. A job overworked or not gives a purpose, a lot of people get depressed if they loose a job because they lack the purpose. Also overwork makes sure there is not much time to think about anything else. I don't encourage overwork, however it can have both positive and negative impact on lives.
- Noumenon72 5y agoSmartphones are life changing! They freed me to travel anywhere (GPS), to take my pills on schedule, to Google what to do in emergencies. I bet each smartphone adds more quality to people's lives than the one who dies loses.
- bserge 5y agoI'm 100% with you there, but the current ~6 month cycle is ridiculous. And people actually buy a new phone every year, there's no practical reason for that. My 2018 phone is perfect, even my 2014 older phone still keeps up.
- Knufferlbert 5y agoMy sibling comments are a bit cynical. Considering the widely reported stress on health care workers during the pandemic I'd suspect that number may be higher than one would think despite the millions working on throwaway products. Obviously, society should incentivise that those professions that are overworked and useful to society hire/train more, so they are not that overworked.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoWell, so many life-saving physicians and other health care workers undergo periods of extreme work hours. If they wouldn't have been capable of accomplishing so much over as short a calendar period, I would estimate higher fatalities, especially during the pandemic but also over all the other decades. I expect there is an equation for this tragic number. It doesn't matter how many more life-savers you deploy, simply because there will never be enough of them, things will always be better if one or more of them put in a little extra time. Should also be equations for the positive-outcome/number-of-hours.