16 ms·
Court rules climate change “duty of care” to future generations exists
- Bluestein 5y agoSee also: - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/mar/02/a-duty-of-care-australian-teenagers-take-their-climate-crisis-plea-to-court https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/mar/02/a-duty-o... "Eight teenagers and an octogenarian nun head to an Australian court on Tuesday to launch what they hope will prove to be a landmark case – one that establishes the federal government’s duty of care in protecting future generations from a worsening climate crisis."
- pyuser583 5y agoWhy those eight teenagers and nun specifically? Will they get a large say in the process than anyone else?
- andrewclunn 5y agoYou owe it to the unborn to not use cheaply available fossil fuel, but not to avoid having them chopped up or chemically euthanized.
- tick_tock_tick 5y agoThe fact that these battle are being fought in the courts rather than the legislature shows how ridiculous judicial overreach has become.
- Bluestein 5y agoI am split on the "judicial overreach" issue ... ... if lawmakers / govt. is not doing it for you, and you are aggrieved, aren't courts just another available means at a citizen's disposal, to effect change?
- dominotw 5y ago> at a citizen's disposal sorry but how are courts at my disposal?
- Bluestein 5y ago... as in, you have them available to you?
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoProsecutors and regulators have discretion to ignore any harms you suffer. But you still have the right to file a lawsuit.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoThe purpose of various government bodies are not simply to all be equal tools for citizen desires. At least in the United States, each branch is "co-equal," and "checked and balanced." This is on purpose. A particular branch has the power to perform certain activities, while other branches don't.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cm2187 5y agoNo, courts aren't there to bypass the democratic process when the policy of the country doesn't fit your own politics. They are not elected, are usually pretty much unaccountable. They should not issue laws or make policy.
- Isinlor 5y agoAs far as I can see, the court is not doing here anything else than interpreting the law. Literally, the whole ruling is explaining pieces of the law step by step. > The objects of the EPBC Act include providing for the protection of the environment, especially those aspects of the environment that are matters of “national environmental significance”: s 3(1)(a). Section 3(1)(b) states that a further object is the promotion of “ecologically sustainable development” through the conservation and “ecologically sustainable use” of natural resources. > The following principles are principles of ecologically sustainable development: > (c) the principle of inter-generational equity—that the present generation should ensure that the health, diversity and productivity of the environment is maintained or enhanced for the benefit of future generations;
- teachingassist 5y agoYou could say the same sentence but replace 'judicial overreach' with 'legislative incompetence'. I suggest the problem is that the legislature is filled with cognitive dissonance on this issue, prepared to say one thing [in law] - for the votes - and do another - for the votes. That requires the judiciary to sort out the mess.
- rsj_hn 5y agoThat the legislature is not following your wishes does not mean that they are incompetent. They could be reacting to the wishes of the majority of the population, which simply does not view carbon emissions as being particularly important nor do they believe there is any crisis to address here.
- teachingassist 5y agoYou make a separate point. My point was that the legislature is writing law which is in conflict with itself. The quote "future generation" hasn't come from the judiciary - it is written into the law, for the judiciary to deal with the consequences.
- ska 5y agoSimilarly, 'judicial overreach' is (most?) often just used to mean 'I don't like the courts decision'. Especially in a common law country, this terminology is often off target.
- jbay808 5y agoUnfortunately, the majority of the population hasn't been born yet.
- glial 5y ago> They could be reacting to the wishes of the majority of the population Citation seriously needed.
- etrabroline 5y ago
- mikepurvis 5y agoI think it depends how you view the relationship between the judiciary and the rest of government. For example, the judiciary can be seen in part as the voice of the past— they're appointed by previous generations of politicians, part of their role is to apply and interpret the laws accumulated by previous governments, and they're free from having to pander to voters every election cycle. If the present day government has become ineffective or gridlocked, then it makes sense to me that the judiciary may have a role to play not in setting new policy, but at least in recognizing the intent of past leaders as encoded in existing laws.
- vkou 5y agoNo, what it shows is how incapable the legislature is of dealing with a crisis.
- Corazoor 5y agoThe ruling by the german constitutional court was definitely not judicial overreach. For one because rejecting laws on constitutional grounds is the main purpose of that court. But more importantly, the court started it's argument with the observation that the german goverment and parliament committed themselves to the goal of co2 reduction, by signing and ratifying the kyoto protocol. From that follows that it is quite unfair (unconstitutional even) to put the major portion of reductions towards the end of the deadline, effectively pushing the burden on younger generations. Measured by their own standards and all that...
- Isinlor 5y agoWhere do you exactly see the overreach? I'm reading the ruling and I see there only interpretation of the Australian law. Things like: 150 The objects of the EPBC Act include providing for the protection of the environment, especially those aspects of the environment that are matters of “national environmental significance”: s 3(1)(a). Section 3(1)(b) states that a further object is the promotion of “ecologically sustainable development” through the conservation and “ecologically sustainable use” of natural resources. Each of those terms used in s 3(1)(b) is defined. Section 528 provides the meaning of “ecologically sustained use” as the “use of the natural resources within their capacity to sustain natural processes while maintaining the life-support systems of nature and ensuring that the benefit of the use to the present generation does not diminish the potential to meet the needs and aspirations of future generations”. The principles of “ecologically sustainable development” are given meaning by s 3A which provides: Principles of ecologically sustainable development The following principles are principles of ecologically sustainable development: (a) decision-making processes should effectively integrate both long-term and short-term economic, environmental, social and equitable considerations; (b) if there are threats of serious or irreversible environmental damage, lack of full scientific certainty should not be used as a reason for postponing measures to prevent environmental degradation; (c) the principle of inter-generational equity—that the present generation should ensure that the health, diversity and productivity of the environment is maintained or enhanced for the benefit of future generations; (d) the conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity should be a fundamental consideration in decision-making; (e) improved valuation, pricing and incentive mechanisms should be promoted.
- wvenable 5y agoThese decisions can easily be legislated either way completely invaliding most "judicial overreach" after the fact. It's just the legislation branch in a lot of countries are quite happy to not be involved in these kind of big decisions.
- notanormalnerd 5y agoIf you watch close and have a look at the demografics of germany, than this is not judical overreach but a reminder for the baby boomer generation (over 40% of voters) that they indeed have to take care not to leave an unlivable planet. The young generations (below 35) have basically no real demografic power and are underrepresented in politics. You saw that with covid and who was impacted the most and who will pay at the end of the day.
- msrenee 5y agoOff topic: I love that you're using an "f" in the word demografic (standard spelling is demographic). I've been learning a lot about how all the weird spelling exceptions came into the English language and the fact that we still use "ph" to make an "f" sound is just super interesting to me. It's mostly present in words that came from Greek through Latin, which represents the sound of the Greek letter "phi" as "ph". Then, as far as I can understand, the spelling remained unchanged even after all those words began to be pronounced with our current "f" sound.
- casefields 5y agoSame stunt being pulled in American courts except getting slapped down. Speaking of future generations, imagine duty of care being applied to abortion policy...
- Daishiman 5y agoThe legal argument with regards to climate change has to do with lives that will be realized, not that lives that won't. For those who do live in the future, climate change will impact them. If a potential person does not exist in the future because it is aborted, it is not subject to suffering due to climate change.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoLife begins at conception.
- Daishiman 5y agoNon-sentient life that cannot suffer isn't something I care much about.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoAll human lives matter.
- dane-pgp 5y agoIf someone is in a medically-induced coma, should it be legal for their enemy to inject them with an overdose of morphine? Just because someone isn't currently fully aware of their surroundings doesn't mean they stop being human.
- analognoise 5y agoSo charge every woman who gets an abortion with murder. And miscarriages should be...what, second degree murder, I guess? Be consistent - how long should we jail women for, for terminating a pregnancy? Good luck trying to form your fascist theocracy.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI know it’s a controversial topic, but it is philosophically interesting that the court would rule about future generations and their rights but simultaneously pass on the rights of humans about to leave the womb (who are atomistically more real than ‘future generations’).
- Bluestein 5y ago> but it is philosophically interesting ... very.-
- Bluestein 5y agoI appreciate the downvote :) ... buy I for one find it interesting.-
- hobs 5y agoI think its fair to note, but its still consistent in my mind - existing people have rights, we acknolwedge virtual people have some rights, and that there's consequentially going to be a category of virtual people that are unrealizeable people due to rights we grant current people. That's consistent with the fact that we allow current people to use resources future people could possibly use, but we are trying to strive a balance between those who do and those who might exist.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThey aren’t scientifically unrealizable though, which is a flaw in this argument.
- Cerium 5y agoBoth situations can be seen as preserving the rights of the current generation. In one case the right is deciding to not have a child, in the other case the right is deciding to have a child (and the required environment for them). Not protecting the environment is taking away from the rights of those who wish to create future generations.
- ping_pong 5y agoI believe in strong environmental laws, but the idea that you have to protect people from "future harm" is absurd. How exactly do you do that? I understand that this is in Australia so their laws may be different, but the idea that you can sue someone because of possible future damage is legislating predicting the future. In SF, when the DA refuses to prosecute a criminal and that criminal goes on to kill another person, did that DA fail to protect that victim from future harm? How far does this protection from the future go on? The idea also seems to go in the face of abortion, because a fetus will grow into a human. So does that mean that you need to protect the fetus from harm now because it will be a person in the future? There are just too many absurd situations that this result opens up, I agree that we need strong environmental laws but this is going too far into prophecy and fortune telling and opens up a lot of unintended consequences of what it means to "protect the future".
- gotostatement 5y agowouldn't a philosophical/legal framework like "reckless endangerment" apply here? there's a line at which harm to future generations becomes reckless
- Bluestein 5y ago> philosophical/legal framework like "reckless endangerment" You are onto something here, I think. To avoid ridiculous situations very clearly codify a line, a threshold ...
- ping_pong 5y agoHow can you prove that expanding the mine actually caused any damages to the environment? With a chemical plant, if it leaks waste and poisons a nearby river, the damages are very real and easy to understand. Expanding a mine that doesn't directly cause damages but increases CO2 doesn't have direct damages that you measure because it's global. Even with something like Fukushima, you can measure the damage it did to Japan, but what about all the radioactive waste it is leaking into the Pacific? How do you measure that catastrophe? Can you even prove that it has done any damage, even though it's obvious?
- Sol- 5y agoVery intersting year for climate court cases. The German constitutional court recently issued a similar ruling, which caused quite the stir: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/29/historic-german-ruling-says-climate-goals-not-tough-enough https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/29/historic-germa... And of course there's the Shell case in the Netherlads that was recently discussed here as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27290508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27290508 Personally I think it's a good thing that the courts realize that countries and companies shouldn't be allowed externalize the costs their pollution onto future generations.
- hcurtiss 5y agoI think most people agree on the policy. The question in the US, at least, is whether unelected jurists with lifetime appointments are the ones who should be deciding those policies. Generally speaking, the reason for separating the two is that there's no political recourse for the judicial decision. That's how wars are started. In my mind, policy should be made by the legislative branch. These are not always bright lines, but at least in the present case, and what to do about those intergenerational externalities, they are in my mind very plainly matters of lawmaking, which is not the proper role of the US judiciary.
- Isinlor 5y agoIn this case it is just a fairly direct interpretation of the law. > The objects of the EPBC Act include providing for the protection of the environment, especially those aspects of the environment that are matters of “national environmental significance”: s 3(1)(a). Section 3(1)(b) states that a further object is the promotion of “ecologically sustainable development” through the conservation and “ecologically sustainable use” of natural resources. > The principles of “ecologically sustainable development” are given meaning by s 3A which provides: > (c) the principle of inter-generational equity—that the present generation should ensure that the health, diversity and productivity of the environment is maintained or enhanced for the benefit of future generations;
- kevingadd 5y ago
- golemiprague 5y agoI don't understand the meaning of it, can't whatever government just say that whatever their policies are the best for taking care of the future generations?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 5y agoI note that out of 8 threads responding to this topic, 4 of them attempt to dispute the outcome by referring to abortion policy, a rate which seems considerably higher than chance. I'd suggest that when you see red herring arguments that use a highly emotive (but often irrelevant) topic to redirect discussion, you simply don't take the bait.
- neonological 5y ago[redacted]
- dang 5y agoYou can't dox other users, or attack other users, on HN. I've banned this account. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27430579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27430579.
- Ancalagon 5y agoWow quite eerie levels of astroturfing considering how recent the post was made.
- KETpXDDzR 5y agoAs long as we don't have a world government which is enabled, countries will pollute the environment to improve their economy. Also, most politicians in power probably think they won't experience the consequences of destroying the only planet we have. Such rulings are all small drops in the sea and won't stop the inevitable end of humanity.
- JimTheMan 5y agoI have never seen so much... motivated manipulation of discussion in a hackernews thread before. Far out brussel sprout, can we get these people off of here?
- google234123 5y agoYou could justify a lot of suffering for people alive today if you weigh the almost uncountable future generations of people against the few people alive today.
- monkeydreams 5y agoQuite possibly, but this ruling relates to children already born.
- egypturnash 5y agoOh damn. Maybe we’ll get a Ministry For The Future earlier than the one in the KSR book of the same name.
- Proven 5y agoComplete, socialist nonsense. They can rule whatever they want - it doesn't mean it's true. Hey, how come no one uses the Communist Party of China for the huge number of coal power plants constructed since the 90's - tere's a ton of money to be made!
- anonymouswacker 5y agoHorrible idea to allow governments to have more power for this duty to “care” for future generations (as if they did any sort of a good job taking care of the present).