4 ms·

What baffles me is that huge portion of those small business websites have absolutely no need for Wordpress or any backend altogether. At best they need some st

What baffles me is that huge portion of those small business websites have absolutely no need for Wordpress or any backend altogether. At best they need some static site generator and a CI/CD pipeline maintained by the provider to rebuild the site if it is an actual blog, which is not that common.

pgsimp 5y ago
How are the small businesses supposed to update their websites, if there is no backend? You can't expect them to write HTML. Not sure if suitable WYIWYG editors are still around, or if Word exports to HTML have become usable.
- hutzlibu 5y ago
  " or if Word exports to HTML have become usable" I doubt there is beauty to be found. And websites are a lot about beauty.
- friendzis 5y ago
  Businesses, even very capable with web dev, update their websites very rarely. Businesses want to update the content, which is different. Static site generators are built exactly for that.
  - FalconSensei 5y ago
    Can I open an app on my phone to create/update a post? Can I Use my phone to create another user so a friend can guest-post on my blog? Can I send an email to a certain address to publish a new post? Nope
    - friendzis 5y ago
      Now you just take things a blogging platform can do and try to morph that into an argument against static site generators. The very point of static site generators is to drop a whole host of functionality. How often does a construction/handyman "online flyer" webpage need a change? Once a year, maybe. The primary point I am trying to make is that websites of a lot of small business (obviously ones that are not webshops) serve more or less static content and therefore have no need for a backend at all. You have a food blog where you publish recipes/reviews daily? Surely a blogging platform is a much better fit for you. You have a restaurant page where you publish contacts, coordinates and a menu which changes every second year? Well, maybe a static site generator is a better fit.
Cthulhu_ 5y ago
You say that, but what if they want to add GA? Or an image gallery? Or a chat box? Those are just some examples that with Wordpress, it's a click and pretty much plug and play. With the static site generator you're proposing, you quickly need to do coding yourself.
- friendzis 5y ago
  If you buy website development service you do not necessarily care whether the provider writes custom code for WP or static site generator. Why do you need a backend for GA or image gallery?
  - iamacyborg 5y ago
    Because you don't want to keep paying ongoing fees for new development when it could be as easy as installing a plugin.
    - friendzis 5y ago
      But image gallery does not need any "additional development". All it needs is frontend code to display the gallery nicely, some storage mechanism and a "manifest" of sorts with relevant metadata of the gallery. If that is a photo-sharing website, then yes, proper backend is needed. But for a portfolio website of a photographer, which gets updated once a month at best, static manifest will work wonders.
      - blizdiddy 5y ago
        I love the idea that "frontend code" is somehow not "additional development". Have fun with your "manifest" and "metadata".
        friendzis 5y ago
        I equally love the idea that hiring a web agency to build a wordpress template is somehow entirely different thing from hiring a web agency to build a not-wordpress template. The frontend code which eventually renders the image gallery does not care whether fetched image list is produced by PHP code or is served by http server directly from filesystem.
prower 5y ago
> At best they need some CI/CD pipeline maintained by the provider My business requires a what now?
- friendzis 5y ago
  Missed a part. A static site generator with build/deploy happening on provider's infra.
  - pembrook 5y ago
    > A static site generator with build/deploy happening on provider's infra. “Say what now? Where do I login to update a photo on the site?”
- throwaway77112 5y ago
  In software engineering, CI/CD or CICD is the combined practices of continuous integration and either continuous delivery or continuous deployment.[1] In short everything has to be continuous, otherwise you'll stall and die. Now go buy some CI/CD from the shop. [1] wikipedia
  - lethologica 5y ago
    Cool. Now imagine I’m a business owner that makes and sells my own socks and happen to need a website to do so. What you’re talking about would still make zero sense to me.
    - throwaway77112 5y ago
      I should have added it was sarcasm :(
IncRnd 5y ago
> At best they need some static site generator and a CI/CD pipeline maintained by the provider to rebuild the site if it is an actual blog, which is not that common. What most people want is to have something that works, where they can focus on their content and not on your tools. Wordpress works for people. If they get a CI/CD pipeline maintained by someone, how do they create pages, get updates, fix those pesky security issues, write a blog post on their mac that when saved automatically gets posted? How easy is it to apply a theme to your CI/CD pipeline? Your tools work for you, but are you going to maintain them with the same level of features as Wordpress? Oops, it's holiday time, will you write a greeting card plugin for your CI/CD pipeline for them to purchase cards on their website and send site-specific cards to their email list by Monday? No? Sorry, they just switched off of your CI/CD pipeline to Wordpress. When moving to a different hosting provider, people want to conduct business not learn a to use a new CI/CD pipeline to match the tools at the new hosting company. What about when you get tired of updating their site generator code for them? They will need to start over, and they won't pick another CI/CD tool that's unmaintained and is expected to get horribly outdated after a year. People go into business in order to conduct business.
- FalconSensei 5y ago
  And they will want to automatically publish to twitter/facebook, integrate shopify on the site, some forms, etc... Wordpress has 1 click install for all those things as plugins (or work out-of-the-box)
- friendzis 5y ago
  "Joe's porchbuilding" does not send automated greetings. They want a website that is discoverable on Google by new clients and can display their pitch, everything else is negotiated on phone or by email anyway. You only need to worry about security issues if you build such a site on top of a dynamic platform. The updates and security issues disappear if you serve factually static content as static content. Static site generators are bad for dynamic websites, but that does not mean you have to try and fit a whole dynamic platform into a static website. Different use cases, different tools.
  - 5y ago

pgsimp 5y ago

How are the small businesses supposed to update their websites, if there is no backend? You can't expect them to write HTML. Not sure if suitable WYIWYG editors are still around, or if Word exports to HTML have become usable.

hutzlibu 5y ago
" or if Word exports to HTML have become usable" I doubt there is beauty to be found. And websites are a lot about beauty.
friendzis 5y ago
Businesses, even very capable with web dev, update their websites very rarely. Businesses want to update the content, which is different. Static site generators are built exactly for that.
- FalconSensei 5y ago
  Can I open an app on my phone to create/update a post? Can I Use my phone to create another user so a friend can guest-post on my blog? Can I send an email to a certain address to publish a new post? Nope
  - friendzis 5y ago
    Now you just take things a blogging platform can do and try to morph that into an argument against static site generators. The very point of static site generators is to drop a whole host of functionality. How often does a construction/handyman "online flyer" webpage need a change? Once a year, maybe. The primary point I am trying to make is that websites of a lot of small business (obviously ones that are not webshops) serve more or less static content and therefore have no need for a backend at all. You have a food blog where you publish recipes/reviews daily? Surely a blogging platform is a much better fit for you. You have a restaurant page where you publish contacts, coordinates and a menu which changes every second year? Well, maybe a static site generator is a better fit.

Cthulhu_ 5y ago

You say that, but what if they want to add GA? Or an image gallery? Or a chat box? Those are just some examples that with Wordpress, it's a click and pretty much plug and play. With the static site generator you're proposing, you quickly need to do coding yourself.

friendzis 5y ago
If you buy website development service you do not necessarily care whether the provider writes custom code for WP or static site generator. Why do you need a backend for GA or image gallery?
- iamacyborg 5y ago
  Because you don't want to keep paying ongoing fees for new development when it could be as easy as installing a plugin.
  - friendzis 5y ago
    But image gallery does not need any "additional development". All it needs is frontend code to display the gallery nicely, some storage mechanism and a "manifest" of sorts with relevant metadata of the gallery. If that is a photo-sharing website, then yes, proper backend is needed. But for a portfolio website of a photographer, which gets updated once a month at best, static manifest will work wonders.
    - blizdiddy 5y ago
      I love the idea that "frontend code" is somehow not "additional development". Have fun with your "manifest" and "metadata".
      - friendzis 5y ago
        I equally love the idea that hiring a web agency to build a wordpress template is somehow entirely different thing from hiring a web agency to build a not-wordpress template. The frontend code which eventually renders the image gallery does not care whether fetched image list is produced by PHP code or is served by http server directly from filesystem.

prower 5y ago

> At best they need some CI/CD pipeline maintained by the provider My business requires a what now?

friendzis 5y ago
Missed a part. A static site generator with build/deploy happening on provider's infra.
- pembrook 5y ago
  > A static site generator with build/deploy happening on provider's infra. “Say what now? Where do I login to update a photo on the site?”
throwaway77112 5y ago
In software engineering, CI/CD or CICD is the combined practices of continuous integration and either continuous delivery or continuous deployment.[1] In short everything has to be continuous, otherwise you'll stall and die. Now go buy some CI/CD from the shop. [1] wikipedia
- lethologica 5y ago
  Cool. Now imagine I’m a business owner that makes and sells my own socks and happen to need a website to do so. What you’re talking about would still make zero sense to me.
  - throwaway77112 5y ago
    I should have added it was sarcasm :(

IncRnd 5y ago

> At best they need some static site generator and a CI/CD pipeline maintained by the provider to rebuild the site if it is an actual blog, which is not that common. What most people want is to have something that works, where they can focus on their content and not on your tools. Wordpress works for people. If they get a CI/CD pipeline maintained by someone, how do they create pages, get updates, fix those pesky security issues, write a blog post on their mac that when saved automatically gets posted? How easy is it to apply a theme to your CI/CD pipeline? Your tools work for you, but are you going to maintain them with the same level of features as Wordpress? Oops, it's holiday time, will you write a greeting card plugin for your CI/CD pipeline for them to purchase cards on their website and send site-specific cards to their email list by Monday? No? Sorry, they just switched off of your CI/CD pipeline to Wordpress. When moving to a different hosting provider, people want to conduct business not learn a to use a new CI/CD pipeline to match the tools at the new hosting company. What about when you get tired of updating their site generator code for them? They will need to start over, and they won't pick another CI/CD tool that's unmaintained and is expected to get horribly outdated after a year. People go into business in order to conduct business.

FalconSensei 5y ago
And they will want to automatically publish to twitter/facebook, integrate shopify on the site, some forms, etc... Wordpress has 1 click install for all those things as plugins (or work out-of-the-box)
friendzis 5y ago
"Joe's porchbuilding" does not send automated greetings. They want a website that is discoverable on Google by new clients and can display their pitch, everything else is negotiated on phone or by email anyway. You only need to worry about security issues if you build such a site on top of a dynamic platform. The updates and security issues disappear if you serve factually static content as static content. Static site generators are bad for dynamic websites, but that does not mean you have to try and fit a whole dynamic platform into a static website. Different use cases, different tools.
- 5y ago