7 ms·
Each site seemed to be funneling you into a single source of truth and way of not only thinking, but FEELING about an event. Which is a big problem. In the int
by Animats 5y ago
Each site seemed to be funneling you into a single source of truth and way of not only thinking, but FEELING about an event.
Which is a big problem. In the intelligence community, people are taught to distinguish between data items from different sources, which may indicate confirmation, and data items from the same source via different paths, which don't.
- fartcannon 5y agoI think this is a good place for authorship attribution AI's. A plugin that will identify text that resembles known PR and propaganda and links to the original source. Is this a real review or is this person writing their review from a script? Am I interacting with a real person or someone paid to sway the public opinion of something on a forum? Edit: Maybe we could prevent more influence by Satya @ MS and the like. "In fact, this morning, I was reading a news article in Hacker News, which is a community where we have been working hard to make sure that Azure is growing in popularity and I was pleasantly surprised to see that we have made a lot of progress..." https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/microsoft-corp-msft-q1-2019-005545657.html https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/microsoft-corp-msft-q1-201...
- potatoman22 5y agoCreepy
- eitland 5y ago> "In fact, this morning, I was reading a news article in Hacker News, which is a community where we have been working hard to make sure that Azure is growing in popularity and I was pleasantly surprised to see that we have made a lot of progress..." Wow! That was unexpectedly - what should I say - candid? And I actually appreciate you all being here : ) But please distinguish between - "helping customers where they are" which is a great idea and - secretly pushing an agenda. And if anyone wonders about how do you distinguish between those two here's a rule of thumb: in the first case if someone realizes you work for that company it feels good. In the second case it probably feels bad.
- crispyambulance 5y ago> A plugin that will identify text that resembles known PR and propaganda and links to the original source. Certainly such a tool might be useful to someone analyzing disinformation campaigns, but it only goes so far. If the intent with such plugins and other forms of human/AI moderation is merely identify the source of what looks like disinformation, you're going to disappointed to hear that those who are influenced by disinformation don't care what "the source" is. It's why meatheads on Fox News can blabber non-stop garbage and get the highest news media ratings in history. Dealing with this problem with "plugins", at best, is entering an infinite game of wack-a-mole. It's fundamentally not a technological problem. This kind of stuff has always existed, and yes, now it's hopped-up on internet speed and naive countermeasures now need AI to keep up. But it's still qualitatively the same thing as it was in the 1930's. It requires a long game to battle it involving leadership, an educated populace and a government that isn't grossly polarized and dysfunctional. Sadly, I don't think we're up to the challenge at least in the USA.
- fartcannon 5y agoAgreed about the whack-a-mole. Would be hard. Only a few people have the ability to lead projects that require so much mole whacking. I'm thinking of gorhill and ublock origin, for example.
- tekknik 5y ago> It's why meatheads on Fox News can blabber non-stop garbage and get the highest news media ratings in history. Interesting how you had to throw a right wing site in there with your underhanded attack. So you think the left is immune to this? Can you actually get through a CNN article without wanting to vomit? With that one statement you lost me entirely.
- crispyambulance 5y agoTo be honest, I do feel that CNN and MSNBC have fallen off a cliff as far as quality is concerned in the last 10+ years. All cable news is pretty much a wasteland. But there's a special place in hell reserved for Fox News. As bad as CNN can get with its cloying reductive stories, they at least try. Fox News is end-to-end garbage. Sorry.
- retox 5y agoThe site https://www.churnalism.com/ https://www.churnalism.com/ tried to do something like this before ML was accessible, but it seems to have died on the vine just a year later.
- ornxka 5y ago>Which is a big problem. Is it? What if the alternative is that people feel the wrong way about things?
- Natsu 5y agoI think they're saying that feeling the event instead of thinking about it is a problem. A lot of times the news is all on about something as an emergency that will do something terrible if you don't pay attention to it. There may be some seed of importance in there to lend it credibility, but a large portion of the time it's simple manipulation and I ignore it on principle for that reason. In other words, I usually tune it out because of that and instead go look for primary sources on whatever is making the news, instead, and even when I read the articles, I care only about the sources and whether I can verify them. I simply skip all the sections that are opinion.
- tekknik 5y agoThis 1000 times. Any news org trying to invoke an emotional response should be treated as toxic. Get what important details you can from the article and move on. I don’t want AI to tell me what’s true, I want AI to remove the author’s bias.
- rayiner 5y agoIf people agreed on what was the right and wrong way to interpret the world we wouldn't need democracy.
- moralestapia 5y ago>In the intelligence community What do you mean by this? And I'm not being snarky, really.
- dkislyuk 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Intelligence_Community https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Intelligence_Com...
- Animats 5y agoThe US "intelligence community" is the CIA, NSA, etc.[1] Intelligence analysis is the business of trying to extract useful info from of noisy and deceptive data. Here's an introduction to the field.[2] See especially section 4. 4-11. Analyst have found the following rules helpful in dealing with deception: - Avoid over-reliance on a single source of information. - Seek and heed the opinions of those closest to the reporting. - Be suspicious of human sources or sub-sources who have not been met with personally or for whom it is unclear how or from whom they obtained the information. - Be suspicious of information that appears to be too easy to collect and is too perfect of a picture. - Always look for material evidence (documents, reports, imagery) rather than relying exclusively upon what someone says. - Look for a pattern where a source’s information has seemed correct and accurate initially, but then proven to be false. - Generate and evaluate a full set of hypotheses at the outset of a task. - Know the limitations as well as the capabilities of collection assets, sources, and potential deceivers. This kind of analysis used to be needed only by intelligence specialists. Now this should probably be taught in schools. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Intelligence_Community https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Intelligence_Com... [2] https://info.publicintelligence.net/USArmy-IntelAnalysis.pdf https://info.publicintelligence.net/USArmy-IntelAnalysis.pdf
- pjc50 5y agoIf we're going to talk about the intelligence community, then the same criticism that gets used against the media needs to be brought up: the Iraq WMD.
- throwaway210222 5y ago> In the intelligence community, people are taught to distinguish between data items from different sources Where on earth do you get this from? In additional to the yellow cake fiasco, remember the pressure US and British intelligence came under find kompromat on UN security council members to bully them into voting for the Iraq invasion. Complete and utter lap dogs.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Where on earth do you get this from? From local cops to the CIA comparing the same information from multiple sources is SOP for everyone who deals with unreliable information.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoYou reminded me of this piece by Glenn Greenwald: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/how-do-big-media-outlets-so-often https://greenwald.substack.com/p/how-do-big-media-outlets-so... > what was most notable about this episode is that it was not just CNN which reported this fraudulent story. An hour or so after the network shook the political world with its graphics-and-music-shaped bombshell, other news networks — including MSNBC and CBS News — claimed that they had obtained what they called “independent confirmation” that the story was true. > All of this prompted the obvious question: how could MSNBC and CBS News have both purported to “independently confirm” a CNN bombshell that was completely false? The reason this matters is because the term “independently confirm” significantly bolsters the credibility of the initial report because it makes it appear that other credible-to-some news organizations have conducted their own investigation and found more evidence that proves it is true. That is the purpose of the exercise: to bolster the credibility of the story in the minds of the public. > But what actually happens is as deceitful as it is obvious. When a news outlet such as NBC News claims to have “independently corroborated” a report from another corporate outlet, they often do not mean that they searched for and acquired corroborating evidence for it. What they mean is much more tawdry: they called, or were called by, the same anonymous sources that fed CNN the false story in the first place, and were fed the same false story. > NBC News pretended they had obtained “independent confirmation” when all they had done was speak to the same sources that fed CNN.